Summary
The narrator finds himself trapped in a toxic dynamic with Polina, who treats him with contempt while keeping him available for her purposes. She's planning to gamble at roulette and wants him to play on her behalf, though her true motives remain mysterious. Meanwhile, the household buzzes with tension over an unanswered telegram from St. Petersburg about the General's mother - her potential death would solve his financial crisis. The General has fallen desperately in love with Mlle. Blanche, a calculating French woman who seems interested only in his money. The mysterious Frenchman holds power over the General through a 30,000 rouble debt, and everyone's behavior shifts based on perceived wealth and status. Mr. Astley, a shy Englishman who's clearly in love with Polina, lurks around their group but rarely speaks. The narrator observes all these power games with growing disgust, yet remains trapped because of his obsession with Polina. This chapter reveals how financial desperation creates a web of manipulation where everyone uses everyone else. The narrator sees through the games but can't escape them, showing how emotional attachment can blind us to toxic situations and keep us participating in our own degradation.
Coming Up in Chapter 4
The tension around the General's mother reaches a breaking point, while the narrator's observations of the power dynamics begin to reveal dangerous undercurrents that could destroy them all.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
On the morrow she said not a word to me about gambling. In fact, she purposely avoided me, although her old manner to me had not changed: the same serene coolness was hers on meeting me—a coolness that was mingled even with a spice of contempt and dislike. In short, she was at no pains to conceal her aversion to me. That I could see plainly. Also, she did not trouble to conceal from me the fact that I was necessary to her, and that she was keeping me for some end which she had in view. Consequently there became established between us relations which, to a large extent, were incomprehensible to me, considering her general pride and aloofness. For example, although she knew that I was madly in love with her, she allowed me to speak to her of my passion (though she could not well have showed her contempt for me more than by permitting me, unhindered and unrebuked, to mention to her my love). “You see,” her attitude expressed, “how little I regard your feelings, as well as how little I care for what you say to me, or for what you feel for me.” Likewise, though she spoke as before concerning her affairs, it was never with complete frankness. In her contempt for me there were refinements. Although she knew well that I was aware of a certain circumstance in her life of something which might one day cause her trouble, she would speak to me about her affairs (whenever she had need of me for a given end) as though I were a slave or a passing acquaintance—yet tell them me only in so far as one would need to know them if one were going to be made temporary use of. Had I not known the whole chain of events, or had she not seen how much I was pained and disturbed by her teasing insistency, she would never have thought it worthwhile to soothe me with this frankness—even though, since she not infrequently used me to execute commissions that were not only troublesome, but risky, she ought, in my opinion, to have been frank in _any_ case. But, forsooth, it was not worth her while to trouble about _my_ feelings—about the fact that _I_ was uneasy, and, perhaps, thrice as put about by her cares and misfortunes as she was herself! For three weeks I had known of her intention to take to roulette. She had even warned me that she would like me to play on her behalf, since it was unbecoming for her to play in person; and, from the tone of her words I had gathered that there was something on her mind besides a mere desire to win money. As if money could matter to _her!_ No, she had some end in view, and there were circumstances at which I could guess, but which I did not know for certain. True, the slavery and abasement in which she held...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Emotional Hostages - When Attachment Becomes Manipulation
When emotional attachment blinds us to mistreatment and keeps us participating in relationships that degrade us.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone uses your emotional investment against you to maintain control while offering nothing in return.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone asks for your time, energy, or loyalty while treating you poorly—then ask yourself if you're staying because it's genuinely good for you or because you're afraid to lose what you've already invested.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Contemptuous manipulation
When someone treats you badly while keeping you around because they need something from you. They make their disrespect obvious but still expect you to be available when they want something.
Modern Usage:
Like staying with someone who openly disrespects you but keeps you on the hook because you're useful to them.
Financial desperation
When money problems become so severe that they drive all your decisions and relationships. People start treating each other as means to solve their debt problems rather than as human beings.
Modern Usage:
When someone's drowning in debt and every relationship becomes about who might help them financially.
Status anxiety
The constant worry about your social position and how others perceive your wealth or importance. It makes people desperate to appear successful even when they're failing.
Modern Usage:
Like keeping up appearances on social media when you're actually struggling, or buying things you can't afford to look successful.
Emotional blackmail
Using someone's feelings against them to get what you want. The person knows you care about them and exploits those feelings to manipulate your behavior.
Modern Usage:
When someone uses your love or loyalty against you to make you do things that aren't good for you.
Gambling as escape
Using high-risk activities to avoid dealing with real problems or to chase a fantasy solution. It becomes a way to feel powerful when everything else feels hopeless.
Modern Usage:
Like day trading, lottery tickets, or any get-rich-quick scheme when you're facing serious financial problems.
Toxic loyalty
Staying devoted to someone who treats you poorly because you're emotionally attached. You can see the dysfunction clearly but can't break free from it.
Modern Usage:
Staying in a bad relationship because you love them, even when they consistently hurt or disrespect you.
Characters in This Chapter
Alexei Ivanovich (Narrator)
Protagonist
He's trapped in a humiliating relationship with Polina, knowing she despises him but unable to walk away. He sees through everyone's games but remains powerless to escape because of his obsession.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who knows his girlfriend is using him but can't leave
Polina
Manipulator
She openly shows contempt for the narrator while keeping him available for her gambling plans. She's mysterious about her true motives and treats him like a useful tool rather than a person.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who keeps you around for favors while making it clear they don't respect you
The General
Desperate debtor
He's waiting desperately for news of his mother's death to solve his financial crisis. Meanwhile, he's fallen for Mlle. Blanche, who's clearly only interested in his potential inheritance.
Modern Equivalent:
The older guy chasing a younger woman who's obviously after his money
Mlle. Blanche
Gold digger
A calculating French woman who has captured the General's heart but is clearly only interested in his financial prospects. She represents the transactional nature of relationships in their world.
Modern Equivalent:
The influencer dating someone for their wealth and connections
Mr. Astley
Silent observer
An English gentleman who's obviously in love with Polina but rarely speaks. He watches the drama unfold while keeping his feelings mostly hidden.
Modern Equivalent:
The quiet guy who's clearly interested but won't make a move
The Frenchman
Power broker
He holds financial power over the General through a massive debt and seems to control much of what happens in their social circle through his economic leverage.
Modern Equivalent:
The loan shark or creditor who owns you
Key Quotes & Analysis
"You see, how little I regard your feelings, as well as how little I care for what you say to me, or for what you feel for me."
Context: The narrator explains how Polina's behavior communicates her complete indifference to his feelings
This shows how some people will openly display their contempt while still expecting you to remain available to them. It's a particularly cruel form of manipulation because it's so honest about the disrespect.
In Today's Words:
I don't care about your feelings at all, and I'm not even going to pretend I do.
"Although she knew that I was madly in love with her, she allowed me to speak to her of my passion."
Context: Describing how Polina permits him to express his love while showing contempt for it
This reveals how toxic relationships can involve someone letting you be vulnerable while they use that vulnerability against you. The permission to speak becomes another form of humiliation.
In Today's Words:
She knew I was crazy about her and let me embarrass myself by talking about it.
"I was necessary to her, and that she was keeping me for some end which she had in view."
Context: Realizing that Polina keeps him around because she needs him for something
This shows the painful clarity that can come in toxic relationships - you can see exactly how you're being used but feel powerless to stop it. It's about being reduced to your utility rather than valued as a person.
In Today's Words:
She needed me for something and was keeping me around until she was ready to use me.
Thematic Threads
Toxic Power Dynamics
In This Chapter
Polina maintains control over the narrator through contempt mixed with just enough attention to keep him hoping
Development
Expanding from earlier hints about their relationship to show the full manipulative dynamic
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in relationships where someone keeps you off-balance with hot-and-cold treatment
Financial Desperation
In This Chapter
Everyone's behavior shifts based on money—the General's debt, waiting for his mother's death, Blanche's calculations
Development
Building on previous financial tensions to show how money corrupts all relationships in this world
In Your Life:
You see this when financial stress makes family members or coworkers treat each other as resources rather than people
Self-Deception
In This Chapter
The narrator believes he sees through everyone's games while remaining trapped in the worst one
Development
Introduced here as the narrator's particular blind spot
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself staying in bad situations while telling yourself you're 'choosing' to be there
Social Performance
In This Chapter
Everyone performs roles based on what they think others want—Blanche playing the sophisticated woman, the General playing the gentleman
Development
Continuing the theme of people as performers rather than authentic selves
In Your Life:
You see this in workplace dynamics where everyone performs their 'professional self' while hiding their real motivations
Unrequited Obsession
In This Chapter
Both the narrator with Polina and Mr. Astley with Polina show how one-sided attraction creates suffering
Development
Introduced here as a parallel pattern affecting multiple characters
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in your own past relationships where you invested more energy than you received back
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does the narrator stay with Polina even though he admits she treats him with contempt and uses him as a tool?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Polina maintain control over the narrator through her pattern of giving just enough attention mixed with poor treatment?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this same pattern of emotional hostage-taking in modern workplaces, relationships, or family dynamics?
application • medium - 4
What specific boundaries would you set if you found yourself in the narrator's position, and how would you enforce them even when it felt painful?
application • deep - 5
Why do people often find it harder to leave toxic situations the more they've already invested in them?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Investment vs. Treatment Ratio
Think of a relationship (work, personal, or family) where you feel frustrated or undervalued. Draw two columns: 'What I Give/Invest' and 'What I Receive/Get Back.' List everything honestly in each column. Then ask yourself: If a friend showed you this list about their situation, what would you advise them to do?
Consider:
- •Include emotional investment, not just time or money
- •Look at actual treatment received, not potential or promises
- •Consider whether you're staying because it's good or because you're afraid to lose what you've already put in
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you stayed in a situation longer than you should have because you'd already invested so much. What would you tell your past self now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 4: The Gambler's Delusion and Cultural Clash
Moving forward, we'll examine gambling addiction creates false patterns and justifications, and understand people double down on bad decisions when emotions run high. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.