Summary
Prince Myshkin finally reads the letters he's been dreading, and they reveal Nastasya Filippovna's complete psychological breakdown. Her words are both worshipful and terrifying—she sees him as perfect, untouchable, while describing herself as corrupted beyond redemption. She writes about wanting to unite him with Aglaya while revealing her own engagement to the dangerous Rogojin, who she believes will kill her. The letters read like fever dreams, mixing religious imagery with paranoid fantasies about hidden razors and buried corpses. After wandering in a daze, Myshkin encounters Nastasya in person for a final, devastating goodbye. She falls to her knees in the street, asking if he's happy, then disappears with Rogojin, who confirms her mental state while hinting at the violence to come. This chapter exposes how trauma and obsession can transform love into something toxic and destructive. Nastasya's letters show someone who has internalized so much shame that she can only conceive of herself as either a saint or a monster—nothing human in between. Her 'selfless' desire to unite Myshkin with Aglaya is actually a form of control, a way to remain central to his story while appearing to sacrifice herself. Meanwhile, Myshkin's passive response to her crisis demonstrates how good intentions without decisive action can enable tragedy. The chapter reveals that sometimes the most dangerous people are those who see themselves as beyond redemption.
Coming Up in Chapter 39
The consequences of this final meeting begin to unfold as the wedding day approaches, and the tensions that have been building throughout the novel reach their breaking point.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
The prince understood at last why he shivered with dread every time he thought of the three letters in his pocket, and why he had put off reading them until the evening. When he fell into a heavy sleep on the sofa on the verandah, without having had the courage to open a single one of the three envelopes, he again dreamed a painful dream, and once more that poor, “sinful” woman appeared to him. Again she gazed at him with tears sparkling on her long lashes, and beckoned him after her; and again he awoke, as before, with the picture of her face haunting him. He longed to get up and go to her at once—but he _could not_. At length, almost in despair, he unfolded the letters, and began to read them. These letters, too, were like a dream. We sometimes have strange, impossible dreams, contrary to all the laws of nature. When we awake we remember them and wonder at their strangeness. You remember, perhaps, that you were in full possession of your reason during this succession of fantastic images; even that you acted with extraordinary logic and cunning while surrounded by murderers who hid their intentions and made great demonstrations of friendship, while waiting for an opportunity to cut your throat. You remember how you escaped them by some ingenious stratagem; then you doubted if they were really deceived, or whether they were only pretending not to know your hiding-place; then you thought of another plan and hoodwinked them once again. You remember all this quite clearly, but how is it that your reason calmly accepted all the manifest absurdities and impossibilities that crowded into your dream? One of the murderers suddenly changed into a woman before your very eyes; then the woman was transformed into a hideous, cunning little dwarf; and you believed it, and accepted it all almost as a matter of course—while at the same time your intelligence seemed unusually keen, and accomplished miracles of cunning, sagacity, and logic! Why is it that when you awake to the world of realities you nearly always feel, sometimes very vividly, that the vanished dream has carried with it some enigma which you have failed to solve? You smile at the extravagance of your dream, and yet you feel that this tissue of absurdity contained some real idea, something that belongs to your true life,—something that exists, and has always existed, in your heart. You search your dream for some prophecy that you were expecting. It has left a deep impression upon you, joyful or cruel, but what it means, or what has been predicted to you in it, you can neither understand nor remember. The reading of these letters produced some such effect upon the prince. He felt, before he even opened the envelopes, that the very fact of their existence was like a nightmare. How could she ever have made up her mind to write to her? he asked himself. How could she write...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Toxic Martyrdom - When Self-Sacrifice Becomes Control
Using self-destruction and suffering as tools to control others while appearing selfless and noble.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone weaponizes their suffering to control others while appearing to sacrifice themselves.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's crisis consistently becomes your emergency, and practice responding with specific offers of help rather than open-ended emotional rescue.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Psychological breakdown
When someone's mental state deteriorates to the point where they can't think clearly or function normally. In Nastasya's letters, her thoughts jump between worship and self-hatred, showing how trauma can fragment a person's sense of reality.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who've experienced severe trauma or abuse - their thinking becomes distorted and they may alternate between extremes.
Internalized shame
When someone has absorbed so much negative judgment about themselves that they believe they're fundamentally flawed or worthless. Nastasya sees herself as irredeemably corrupted and beyond salvation.
Modern Usage:
This shows up in people who grew up with constant criticism or abuse - they become their own worst enemy, believing they don't deserve good things.
Martyrdom complex
When someone gets a sense of purpose or control from sacrificing themselves, often while making sure everyone knows about their sacrifice. Nastasya claims she's stepping aside for Myshkin's happiness, but it's really about staying central to his story.
Modern Usage:
Think of people who always play the victim or make dramatic sacrifices to get attention and maintain control over relationships.
Enabling behavior
When someone's passive or well-meaning responses actually make a bad situation worse by not setting boundaries or taking action. Myshkin's kindness toward Nastasya enables her destructive patterns.
Modern Usage:
We see this in families dealing with addiction or mental illness - trying to be supportive but actually making the problem worse by not enforcing consequences.
Fever dream narrative
A style of writing or thinking that feels disconnected from reality, jumping between images and ideas without clear logic. Dostoevsky uses this to show Nastasya's mental state through her letters.
Modern Usage:
This describes how people think and communicate when they're having a mental health crisis - their words might not make logical sense but reveal their emotional reality.
Russian Orthodox imagery
Religious symbols and concepts from Russian Christianity that emphasize suffering, redemption, and the struggle between sin and salvation. Nastasya uses this language to describe her relationship with Myshkin.
Modern Usage:
People still use religious language to make sense of guilt and worthiness, even when they're not particularly religious.
Characters in This Chapter
Prince Myshkin
Passive protagonist
He finally reads Nastasya's disturbing letters but remains paralyzed by indecision. His encounter with her in the street shows his inability to take decisive action even when someone desperately needs help.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who always means well but never actually does anything when you're in crisis
Nastasya Filippovna
Tragic figure in crisis
Her letters reveal complete psychological breakdown - she alternates between worshipping Myshkin and describing herself as irredeemably corrupt. Her final street encounter shows someone who has given up on herself entirely.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who's been through so much trauma they can only see themselves as either perfect or worthless
Rogojin
Dangerous obsessive lover
He appears with Nastasya, confirming her mental deterioration while hinting at the violence he's capable of. His presence represents the destructive path Nastasya has chosen.
Modern Equivalent:
The controlling, potentially violent partner who isolates someone from their support system
Aglaya
Absent but central figure
Though not physically present, she's central to Nastasya's letters as the 'pure' woman Nastasya wants to unite with Myshkin. This reveals Nastasya's black-and-white thinking about worthiness.
Modern Equivalent:
The person you compare yourself to and always come up short
Key Quotes & Analysis
"These letters, too, were like a dream. We sometimes have strange, impossible dreams, contrary to all the laws of nature."
Context: Describing Myshkin's experience reading Nastasya's disturbing letters
This sets up how trauma and mental breakdown can make reality feel surreal and disconnected. The letters don't follow normal logic because Nastasya's mind isn't functioning normally.
In Today's Words:
Her messages were so messed up they didn't even seem real
"Are you happy? That was all I wanted to ask you - are you happy now?"
Context: Her final words to Myshkin before disappearing with Rogojin
This question reveals her desperate need for meaning in her sacrifice. She's given up everything supposedly for his happiness, and needs confirmation that it was worth it.
In Today's Words:
I threw my life away for you - tell me it was worth something
"She is mad, quite mad!"
Context: Confirming Nastasya's mental state to Myshkin
Rogojin's blunt assessment shows he understands her condition but is still pursuing her. This reveals how some people are drawn to others' vulnerability and brokenness.
In Today's Words:
She's completely lost it, but I'm still going after her
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Nastasya can only conceive of herself in extremes—either pure saint or irredeemable sinner, with no middle ground for ordinary humanity
Development
Evolved from her earlier social masks to complete psychological fragmentation
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in your own all-or-nothing thinking about mistakes or failures.
Control
In This Chapter
Nastasya maintains control through apparent powerlessness, using her breakdown to orchestrate everyone else's choices
Development
Escalated from subtle manipulation to overt emotional terrorism
In Your Life:
You might see this in relationships where someone uses their problems to dictate family decisions.
Boundaries
In This Chapter
Myshkin's inability to set limits with Nastasya enables her destructive behavior while appearing compassionate
Development
His passive kindness has consistently failed to help anyone throughout the novel
In Your Life:
You might struggle with saying no to people in crisis, even when helping hurts them.
Shame
In This Chapter
Nastasya's internalized shame creates a worldview where redemption is impossible and destruction is inevitable
Development
Her shame has deepened from social embarrassment to complete self-hatred
In Your Life:
You might recognize how past mistakes can create a narrative that you're fundamentally flawed.
Communication
In This Chapter
The letters reveal how trauma can distort communication into fevered manipulation disguised as confession
Development
Communication has broken down from difficult but honest to completely delusional
In Your Life:
You might notice how stress makes your own communication become dramatic or manipulative.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Nastasya's behavior in her letters and final meeting reveal about how she sees herself and her relationship with Myshkin?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Nastasya push Myshkin toward Aglaya while simultaneously making herself the center of his emotional world?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen someone use their suffering or problems to control situations while appearing to be selfless?
application • medium - 4
How should you respond when someone repeatedly creates crises that demand your immediate attention and emotional energy?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about the difference between genuine self-sacrifice and using suffering as a form of manipulation?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Manipulation Pattern
Think of someone in your life who frequently has crises that require others to drop everything and help them. Write down their typical pattern: What triggers the crisis? How do they present it? What response do they expect? How do they react if you don't respond as expected? Then identify what they actually gain from this cycle.
Consider:
- •Look for how they frame themselves as the victim while making others responsible for fixing things
- •Notice if their crises tend to happen when attention is on someone else or during important events
- •Pay attention to whether they actually follow through on solutions offered or if they find reasons why nothing works
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you realized someone was using their problems to control your behavior. How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 39: The Weight of Ordinary Lives
Moving forward, we'll examine the desire to be 'original' can trap ordinary people in cycles of self-doubt and resentment, and understand accepting your limitations can be more liberating than constantly striving to be exceptional. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.