Summary
Prince Myshkin returns home after his secret morning meeting with Aglaya, exhausted and seeking rest. Lebedeff arrives with disturbing news: 400 rubles have been stolen from his coat pocket during the previous night's festivities. As Lebedeff methodically eliminates suspects—the servant, his children, Keller (who was thoroughly searched), and Burdovsky—he builds a case against Ferdishenko, who mysteriously disappeared early that morning and left a suspiciously detailed forwarding address. The prince finds himself drawn into Lebedeff's investigation, despite his fatigue and desire for peace. Lebedeff's true motives gradually emerge: he wants to use this theft as leverage to monitor General Ivolgin, whom he suspects of visiting a certain widow. The conversation reveals Lebedeff's complex relationship with the general—part genuine affection, part manipulative control. He claims to want to help the general overcome his weaknesses through 'generous tenderness' and constant surveillance. The prince reluctantly agrees to help, but only if Lebedeff promises discretion. This chapter demonstrates how seemingly helpful people can exploit crises to advance their own agendas, and how the desire to help others can be twisted into a form of control. Lebedeff's investigation serves multiple purposes: solving the theft, controlling the general, and positioning himself as indispensable to both the prince and the Ivolgin family.
Coming Up in Chapter 38
The mystery deepens as new evidence emerges about the missing money, forcing the prince to confront uncomfortable truths about the people closest to him. Meanwhile, the consequences of his secret meeting with Aglaya begin to unfold in unexpected ways.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Arrived at her house, Lizabetha Prokofievna paused in the first room. She could go no farther, and subsided on to a couch quite exhausted; too feeble to remember so much as to ask the prince to take a seat. This was a large reception-room, full of flowers, and with a glass door leading into the garden. Alexandra and Adelaida came in almost immediately, and looked inquiringly at the prince and their mother. The girls generally rose at about nine in the morning in the country; Aglaya, of late, had been in the habit of getting up rather earlier and having a walk in the garden, but not at seven o’clock; about eight or a little later was her usual time. Lizabetha Prokofievna, who really had not slept all night, rose at about eight on purpose to meet Aglaya in the garden and walk with her; but she could not find her either in the garden or in her own room. This agitated the old lady considerably; and she awoke her other daughters. Next, she learned from the maid that Aglaya had gone into the park before seven o’clock. The sisters made a joke of Aglaya’s last freak, and told their mother that if she went into the park to look for her, Aglaya would probably be very angry with her, and that she was pretty sure to be sitting reading on the green bench that she had talked of two or three days since, and about which she had nearly quarrelled with Prince S., who did not see anything particularly lovely in it. Arrived at the rendezvous of the prince and her daughter, and hearing the strange words of the latter, Lizabetha Prokofievna had been dreadfully alarmed, for many reasons. However, now that she had dragged the prince home with her, she began to feel a little frightened at what she had undertaken. Why should not Aglaya meet the prince in the park and have a talk with him, even if such a meeting should be by appointment? “Don’t suppose, prince,” she began, bracing herself up for the effort, “don’t suppose that I have brought you here to ask questions. After last night, I assure you, I am not so exceedingly anxious to see you at all; I could have postponed the pleasure for a long while.” She paused. “But at the same time you would be very glad to know how I happened to meet Aglaya Ivanovna this morning?” The prince finished her speech for her with the utmost composure. “Well, what then? Supposing I should like to know?” cried Lizabetha Prokofievna, blushing. “I’m sure I am not afraid of plain speaking. I’m not offending anyone, and I never wish to, and—” “Pardon me, it is no offence to wish to know this; you are her mother. We met at the green bench this morning, punctually at seven o’clock,—according to an agreement made by Aglaya Ivanovna with myself yesterday. She said that she wished to see me and speak...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Helpful Control - When Help Becomes Manipulation
People who use others' problems as opportunities to gain ongoing influence and control while appearing generous and caring.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone uses your problems as an opportunity to gain control over your life.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's offer to help requires them to have ongoing access to your personal information or decision-making process.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Methodical elimination
The process of systematically ruling out suspects or possibilities one by one through logical reasoning. Lebedeff uses this technique to narrow down who could have stolen the money by examining each person's opportunity and behavior.
Modern Usage:
We see this in workplace investigations, insurance claims, or when trying to figure out who ate your lunch from the office fridge.
Forwarding address
Information left behind when someone moves or travels, supposedly so mail can reach them. In this chapter, Ferdishenko's overly detailed forwarding address actually makes him look more suspicious, not less.
Modern Usage:
Today this might be someone who ghosts you but leaves elaborate social media posts about where they're going - too much information often signals deception.
Generous tenderness
Lebedeff's term for his approach to helping General Ivolgin - claiming he wants to reform the general through kindness rather than harsh judgment. However, this 'tenderness' involves constant surveillance and control.
Modern Usage:
This is like helicopter parenting or controlling relationships disguised as caring - 'I'm only watching you because I love you.'
Leverage
Using one situation or piece of information to gain power or influence in another matter. Lebedeff wants to use the theft investigation to justify monitoring General Ivolgin's personal life.
Modern Usage:
Like using someone's mistake at work to get them to cover your shifts, or threatening to tell mom about something unless your sibling does what you want.
Circumstantial evidence
Proof that suggests someone is guilty based on circumstances rather than direct observation. Ferdishenko's suspicious departure timing makes him look guilty even though no one saw him steal.
Modern Usage:
When your coworker calls in sick the day after the big project fails, or when someone suddenly stops responding to texts after you lend them money.
Manipulation through crisis
Using an emergency or problem as an opportunity to gain control or advance your own agenda. Lebedeff turns a simple theft into a complex scheme to monitor the general.
Modern Usage:
Like family members who use every holiday drama to reorganize seating charts, or bosses who use budget cuts to eliminate people they don't like.
Characters in This Chapter
Prince Myshkin
Exhausted mediator
Returns home seeking rest but gets pulled into Lebedeff's investigation despite his fatigue. His willingness to help others makes him vulnerable to manipulation, even when he recognizes what's happening.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend everyone calls with their problems because they know you won't say no, even when you're overwhelmed
Lebedeff
Scheming investigator
Presents himself as a victim of theft but reveals his true agenda is controlling General Ivolgin. He methodically builds his case while manipulating the prince's good nature to get cooperation.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who turns every minor issue into a major investigation to advance their own office politics
Ferdishenko
Convenient scapegoat
Becomes the prime suspect because of his suspicious early departure and overly detailed forwarding address. His absence makes him an easy target for blame.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who leaves the group chat right before drama explodes and everyone assumes they're guilty
General Ivolgin
Absent target
Though not present, he's the real focus of Lebedeff's scheme. Lebedeff wants to use the theft investigation to justify monitoring the general's visits to a widow.
Modern Equivalent:
The relative whose personal life becomes everyone's business because family members claim they're 'worried' about them
Keller
Cleared suspect
Was thoroughly searched and cleared of suspicion, demonstrating Lebedeff's methodical approach to elimination. His clearance helps build the case against Ferdishenko.
Modern Equivalent:
The obvious suspect who gets ruled out early, making everyone look elsewhere
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I want to save him through generous tenderness, and by constant watching over him"
Context: Explaining his true motives for wanting to investigate the theft and monitor General Ivolgin
This reveals how people justify controlling behavior by framing it as care and concern. Lebedeff's 'generous tenderness' is actually surveillance and manipulation disguised as love.
In Today's Words:
I'm going to help him by never giving him any privacy and calling it love
"The whole thing has been got up, prince, to frighten me"
Context: Initially claiming the theft was orchestrated to intimidate him
Shows how people often see themselves as victims of elaborate plots when the reality is much simpler. This self-dramatization helps justify their subsequent manipulative actions.
In Today's Words:
Everyone's out to get me and this proves it
"But you must promise me that you will be absolutely silent"
Context: Getting the prince to agree to help while demanding secrecy
Manipulators often demand silence to prevent their schemes from being exposed. By making the prince complicit through secrecy, Lebedeff ensures cooperation.
In Today's Words:
You have to promise not to tell anyone what we're really doing here
Thematic Threads
Manipulation
In This Chapter
Lebedeff uses the theft investigation to justify monitoring and controlling General Ivolgin's behavior and relationships
Development
Evolved from earlier displays of Lebedeff's cunning into a clear system of using crises for personal advantage
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone offers help that comes with unexpected ongoing obligations or surveillance
Trust
In This Chapter
The prince reluctantly trusts Lebedeff despite recognizing his mixed motives and manipulative tendencies
Development
Continues the prince's pattern of giving people benefit of the doubt even when evidence suggests caution
In Your Life:
You might struggle with trusting people whose actions don't fully match their stated intentions
Class
In This Chapter
Lebedeff systematically eliminates suspects based on social position and perceived respectability rather than evidence
Development
Builds on earlier themes of how social status influences assumptions about character and behavior
In Your Life:
You might notice how people's backgrounds affect whether they're believed or suspected in workplace conflicts
Control
In This Chapter
Lebedeff frames his desire to monitor the general as 'generous tenderness' and moral guidance
Development
Introduced here as a sophisticated form of control disguised as care and protection
In Your Life:
You might encounter people who use your mistakes or weaknesses to justify ongoing oversight of your choices
Deception
In This Chapter
Ferdishenko's suspicious disappearance and overly detailed forwarding address suggest calculated deception
Development
Continues the theme of characters using elaborate lies and misdirection to achieve their goals
In Your Life:
You might notice that people who provide too much detail about their whereabouts or actions are often hiding something
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Lebedeff really want from investigating the theft, beyond just finding the stolen money?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Lebedeff use the phrase 'for his own good' to justify controlling General Ivolgin, and why is this reasoning problematic?
analysis • medium - 3
Think of someone in your life who offers help but seems to need ongoing involvement in your problems. What patterns do you notice in their behavior?
application • medium - 4
How can you tell the difference between someone who genuinely wants to help you become independent versus someone who wants to keep you dependent on their help?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how people can exploit our gratitude and turn our weaknesses into their opportunities for control?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Helper's True Agenda
Think of a recent situation where someone offered you help or where you offered help to someone else. Draw two columns: 'Stated Reasons' and 'Possible Hidden Benefits.' List what the helper claimed they wanted to achieve, then brainstorm what they might actually gain from the arrangement - information, control, gratitude, access, or ongoing involvement in your life.
Consider:
- •Consider what the helper learns about you through their involvement
- •Notice if the help creates ongoing dependency rather than independence
- •Pay attention to whether the helper seems to need your problems to continue
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you accepted help that came with unexpected strings attached. What warning signs did you miss, and how would you handle a similar situation differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 38: Letters from the Abyss
What lies ahead teaches us to recognize when someone's desperation is driving destructive choices, and shows us avoiding difficult conversations often makes situations worse. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.