Summary
Cat and Mouse
Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky
The relationship with Sonia deepens in this pivotal chapter as she becomes the first person to truly understand his isolation. He visits her in her tiny room, and their conversation reveals two people living at society's margins for very different reasons. She's been forced into prostitution to support her family - a sacrifice she's made with full awareness of its cost. He's isolated himself through pride and his terrible crime. Their connection forms around shared suffering, but also around a fundamental difference: her degradation is imposed by circumstances, his is self-inflicted. The chapter explores how Sonia maintains her humanity despite being treated as less than human. She still has faith, still loves her family, still believes in goodness. In contrast, he's lost his moral compass entirely. She asks him to read the story of Lazarus from the Bible - the resurrection of the dead. The symbolism is clear: can someone who's spiritually dead be brought back to life? Sonia represents the possibility of redemption through faith and love. Her gentleness with him, despite barely knowing him, shows a capacity for compassion that stands in stark contrast to his intellectual theorizing about "extraordinary men." This scene sets up what will eventually become his path to redemption.
Coming Up in Chapter 17
Now that Raskolnikov has confessed to Sonia, she faces an impossible choice about what to do with this terrible knowledge. Meanwhile, someone else has been watching and listening, and Raskolnikov's secret may not be as safe as he thinks.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Razumihin waked up next morning at eight o’clock, troubled and serious. He found himself confronted with many new and unlooked-for perplexities. He had never expected that he would ever wake up feeling like that. He remembered every detail of the previous day and he knew that a perfectly novel experience had befallen him, that he had received an impression unlike anything he had known before. At the same time he recognised clearly that the dream which had fired his imagination was hopelessly unattainable--so unattainable that he felt positively ashamed of it, and he hastened to pass to the other more practical cares and difficulties bequeathed him by that “thrice accursed yesterday.” The most awful recollection of the previous day was the way he had shown himself “base and mean,” not only because he had been drunk, but because he had taken advantage of the young girl’s position to abuse her _fiancé_ in his stupid jealousy, knowing nothing of their mutual relations and obligations and next to nothing of the man himself. And what right had he to criticise him in that hasty and unguarded manner? Who had asked for his opinion? Was it thinkable that such a creature as Avdotya Romanovna would be marrying an unworthy man for money? So there must be something in him. The lodgings? But after all how could he know the character of the lodgings? He was furnishing a flat... Foo! how despicable it all was! And what justification was it that he was drunk? Such a stupid excuse was even more degrading! In wine is truth, and the truth had all come out, “that is, all the uncleanness of his coarse and envious heart”! And would such a dream ever be permissible to him, Razumihin? What was he beside such a girl--he, the drunken noisy braggart of last night? Was it possible to imagine so absurd and cynical a juxtaposition? Razumihin blushed desperately at the very idea and suddenly the recollection forced itself vividly upon him of how he had said last night on the stairs that the landlady would be jealous of Avdotya Romanovna... that was simply intolerable. He brought his fist down heavily on the kitchen stove, hurt his hand and sent one of the bricks flying. “Of course,” he muttered to himself a minute later with a feeling of self-abasement, “of course, all these infamies can never be wiped out or smoothed over... and so it’s useless even to think of it, and I must go to them in silence and do my duty... in silence, too... and not ask forgiveness, and say nothing... for all is lost now!” And yet as he dressed he examined his attire more carefully than usual. He hadn’t another suit--if he had had, perhaps he wouldn’t have put it on. “I would have made a point of not putting it on.” But in any case he could not remain a cynic and a dirty sloven; he had no right to offend the feelings of others,...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when keeping secrets is causing more damage than the original mistake, and how to break that cycle through careful confession.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Confession
In Russian Orthodox tradition, confession isn't just admitting wrongdoing - it's a spiritual act of reconnecting with God and community. For Dostoevsky, confession represents the first step toward redemption and healing.
Suffering as redemption
A central Russian Orthodox belief that suffering, when accepted with faith, can purify the soul and lead to spiritual growth. Sonia embodies this idea - her hardships haven't broken her but deepened her compassion.
Moral isolation
When someone cuts themselves off from human connection through their actions or beliefs. Raskolnikov's crime has isolated him from everyone around him, making him unable to feel normal human emotions.
Extraordinary vs. ordinary people
Raskolnikov's theory that some people (like Napoleon) are above normal moral rules and can commit crimes for a greater good. This chapter shows how this thinking has destroyed his ability to connect with others.
Prostration
The act of bowing down completely, face to the ground, as a sign of deep respect or worship. In Russian culture, this gesture shows profound humility and recognition of another's spiritual worth.
Compassionate witness
Someone who sees another person's pain without judgment and responds with love rather than condemnation. Sonia serves this role for Raskolnikov, offering understanding instead of horror at his confession.
Characters in This Chapter
Raskolnikov
Tormented protagonist
Finally breaks his isolation by confessing to Sonia. His careful, circling approach to the confession shows he's desperate for connection but terrified of rejection. This moment reveals his deep need for human understanding.
Sonia
Compassionate witness
Responds to Raskolnikov's confession not with horror but with love and sorrow for his suffering. Her reaction demonstrates her spiritual strength and shows that even the worst sins don't put someone beyond redemption.
Lizaveta
Innocent victim
Though dead, her memory haunts this confession scene. Raskolnikov must admit he killed not just the pawnbroker but also her innocent sister, making his crime even more horrific and senseless.
Katerina Ivanovna
Sonia's dying stepmother
Her presence in the background reminds us of the real-world pressures that drove Sonia to prostitution, showing how poverty forces impossible choices on good people.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Did I murder the old woman? I murdered myself, not her!"
Context: During his confession to Sonia, explaining the true cost of his crime
This reveals that Raskolnikov understands his crime destroyed his own humanity more than it harmed his victim. He's recognizing that murder doesn't just end one life - it kills something essential in the murderer too.
"What have you done to yourself?"
Context: Her immediate response upon hearing Raskolnikov's confession
Instead of asking about his victims, Sonia focuses on what he's done to his own soul. This shows her understanding that sin damages the sinner most of all, and her response is compassion rather than judgment.
"We will suffer together, and together we will carry our cross!"
Context: After hearing his full confession, offering to share his burden
This embodies the Christian ideal of bearing one another's burdens. Sonia doesn't try to fix Raskolnikov or minimize his crime - she offers to walk the difficult path of redemption alongside him.
Thematic Threads
Isolation
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov's guilt has cut him off from human connection until this moment of confession
Development
Evolved from earlier chapters showing his increasing withdrawal from family and friends
Compassion
In This Chapter
Sonia responds to Raskolnikov's confession with understanding rather than horror
Development
Building on her earlier scenes showing her ability to love despite suffering
Class
In This Chapter
The difference between Raskolnikov's intellectual pride and Sonia's humble faith creates their dynamic
Development
Continued exploration of how different class backgrounds shape moral responses
Identity
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov begins to see himself as human again through Sonia's eyes rather than as a monster
Development
Shift from his earlier self-image as extraordinary person above ordinary morality
Redemption
In This Chapter
The confession opens a path toward possible healing and reconnection with humanity
Development
First concrete step toward the redemption arc that has been building throughout
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Raskolnikov actually tell Sonia, and how does she react when he confesses?
- 2
Why does Raskolnikov choose Sonia specifically to tell his secret to, rather than his family or friends?
- 3
Think about times when someone shared something difficult with you, or when you shared something with someone else. How did it change the situation?
- 4
If you were carrying a heavy secret or guilt about something, how would you decide who to tell and when?
- 5
What does Sonia's response to Raskolnikov's confession reveal about the difference between judgment and compassion?
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Trust Network
Think about the different types of difficult things people might need to share - work mistakes, family problems, health scares, financial trouble, relationship issues. Create a simple map of who in your life you would trust with each type of problem. Consider not just who you like, but who has shown they can handle difficult information without making it about themselves.
Consider:
- •Some people are great listeners for certain topics but not others - your work mentor might not be the right person for relationship problems
- •Trust isn't just about keeping secrets - it's about responding with compassion rather than judgment or panic
- •Having no one to talk to about certain issues is a warning sign that you might need to build stronger connections
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 17: The Painter's Confession
The coming pages reveal false confessions offer escape, and teach us the desire for punishment as relief. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.