Summary
Porfiry's Game Begins
Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky
A reckless encounter in a tavern marks a dangerous turning point. While dining in a public restaurant, our tormented protagonist spots Zamyotov, the police clerk who's been watching him with suspicion. Instead of avoiding him, something compulsive drives him to approach the table. What follows is one of the novel's most psychologically intense scenes - a verbal dance where he drops increasingly obvious hints about the murders, describing the crime in vivid detail while claiming he's merely theorizing. Zamyotov grows visibly uncomfortable as the conversation becomes more pointed and bizarre. Why would an innocent man practically confess in public? The impulse is self-destructive and irrational - he's almost daring Zamyotov to accuse him. After leaving the restaurant, he wanders to the actual murder scene and nearly confesses to the painters working there. The chapter brilliantly captures the overwhelming need to confess that guilt creates. Keeping the secret has become more unbearable than facing the consequences. His psyche is rebelling against his intellect, pushing him toward revelation even as his survival instinct fights against it. The near-confession shows how criminals often engineer their own capture through seemingly inexplicable actions - it's not stupidity but the unbearable weight of guilt forcing its way out.
Coming Up in Chapter 16
Raskolnikov's dangerous behavior at the crime scene attracts unwanted attention, and his emotional state reaches a breaking point. A chance encounter will force him to confront someone from his past in an unexpected way.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Raskolnikov got up, and sat down on the sofa. He waved his hand weakly to Razumihin to cut short the flow of warm and incoherent consolations he was addressing to his mother and sister, took them both by the hand and for a minute or two gazed from one to the other without speaking. His mother was alarmed by his expression. It revealed an emotion agonisingly poignant, and at the same time something immovable, almost insane. Pulcheria Alexandrovna began to cry. Avdotya Romanovna was pale; her hand trembled in her brother’s. “Go home... with him,” he said in a broken voice, pointing to Razumihin, “good-bye till to-morrow; to-morrow everything... Is it long since you arrived?” “This evening, Rodya,” answered Pulcheria Alexandrovna, “the train was awfully late. But, Rodya, nothing would induce me to leave you now! I will spend the night here, near you...” “Don’t torture me!” he said with a gesture of irritation. “I will stay with him,” cried Razumihin, “I won’t leave him for a moment. Bother all my visitors! Let them rage to their hearts’ content! My uncle is presiding there.” “How, how can I thank you!” Pulcheria Alexandrovna was beginning, once more pressing Razumihin’s hands, but Raskolnikov interrupted her again. “I can’t have it! I can’t have it!” he repeated irritably, “don’t worry me! Enough, go away... I can’t stand it!” “Come, mamma, come out of the room at least for a minute,” Dounia whispered in dismay; “we are distressing him, that’s evident.” “Mayn’t I look at him after three years?” wept Pulcheria Alexandrovna. “Stay,” he stopped them again, “you keep interrupting me, and my ideas get muddled.... Have you seen Luzhin?” “No, Rodya, but he knows already of our arrival. We have heard, Rodya, that Pyotr Petrovitch was so kind as to visit you today,” Pulcheria Alexandrovna added somewhat timidly. “Yes... he was so kind... Dounia, I promised Luzhin I’d throw him downstairs and told him to go to hell....” “Rodya, what are you saying! Surely, you don’t mean to tell us...” Pulcheria Alexandrovna began in alarm, but she stopped, looking at Dounia. Avdotya Romanovna was looking attentively at her brother, waiting for what would come next. Both of them had heard of the quarrel from Nastasya, so far as she had succeeded in understanding and reporting it, and were in painful perplexity and suspense. “Dounia,” Raskolnikov continued with an effort, “I don’t want that marriage, so at the first opportunity to-morrow you must refuse Luzhin, so that we may never hear his name again.” “Good Heavens!” cried Pulcheria Alexandrovna. “Brother, think what you are saying!” Avdotya Romanovna began impetuously, but immediately checked herself. “You are not fit to talk now, perhaps; you are tired,” she added gently. “You think I am delirious? No... You are marrying Luzhin for _my_ sake. But I won’t accept the sacrifice. And so write a letter before to-morrow, to refuse him... Let me read it in the morning and that will be the end of it!” “That I can’t...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how guilt-driven behavior creates predictable patterns that endanger the very thing we're trying to protect.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Psychological realism
A literary style that focuses on the inner mental and emotional lives of characters rather than just external actions. Dostoevsky pioneered showing how guilt, fear, and trauma actually work inside someone's mind, making readers feel like they're inside Raskolnikov's head as he spirals.
Compulsive confession
The psychological urge to reveal secrets or crimes, even when it's dangerous to do so. People carrying heavy guilt often find themselves dropping hints or returning to scenes of wrongdoing, like Raskolnikov can't help but talk about the murder and visit the apartment.
St. Petersburg taverns
Public drinking establishments in 19th-century Russia where people from different social classes would gather. These spaces allowed for unexpected encounters and conversations that might not happen elsewhere, making them perfect settings for dramatic confrontations.
Police clerk
A low-level government worker who handled paperwork and minor investigations in Imperial Russia. These clerks had some authority but weren't full detectives, making Zamyotov both a threat to Raskolnikov and someone he might be able to manipulate.
Plausible deniability
The ability to deny involvement in something while still being suspicious. Raskolnikov tries to discuss the murder as 'theory' so he can always claim he was just speculating, but his detailed knowledge makes this defense increasingly weak.
Crime scene revisitation
The psychological phenomenon where criminals return to the places where they committed crimes. This behavior often stems from guilt, fascination, or a subconscious desire to be caught, and it frequently leads to their capture.
Characters in This Chapter
Raskolnikov
Tormented protagonist
His mental state deteriorates as he compulsively hints about the murder to Zamyotov and returns to the crime scene. His behavior shows how guilt is driving him toward self-destruction, as he simultaneously craves confession and fears the consequences.
Zamyotov
Suspicious police clerk
He becomes increasingly uncomfortable as Raskolnikov describes the murder in disturbing detail. His reactions show he's starting to suspect Raskolnikov, making their conversation a dangerous game of cat and mouse.
The workmen
Unwitting witnesses
They're renovating the pawnbroker's apartment and become suspicious when Raskolnikov asks detailed questions about the bloodstains. Their threat to take him to police shows how his compulsive behavior is putting him in real danger.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"What if it was I who murdered the old woman and Lizaveta?"
Context: He says this to Zamyotov in the tavern, pretending it's just a hypothetical question.
This moment shows Raskolnikov's desperate need to confess while still trying to maintain deniability. He's testing how close he can come to the truth without actually admitting guilt, revealing his internal torment.
"There was blood here, blood!"
Context: He's questioning the workmen about bloodstains in the pawnbroker's apartment.
His obsession with the physical evidence of his crime shows how the murder has consumed his thoughts completely. He can't let go of any detail, even when discussing it puts him in danger.
"We'll take you to the police station!"
Context: They threaten Raskolnikov when his questions about the murder become too suspicious.
This threat represents how close Raskolnikov is coming to exposure through his own compulsive behavior. His guilt is literally driving him back toward the consequences he's trying to avoid.
Thematic Threads
Psychological Compulsion
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov's irresistible urge to revisit the crime scene and drop hints about his guilt
Development
Deepening from earlier anxiety into active self-sabotaging behavior
Class Dynamics
In This Chapter
Workers in the apartment become suspicious and threaten police involvement, showing how different social positions handle authority
Development
Continuing theme of how class affects who gets believed and who gets questioned
Self-Destruction
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov actively puts himself in danger through reckless behavior and near-confessions
Development
Escalating from internal torment to external risk-taking behaviors
Identity Crisis
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov can't maintain his ordinary self while carrying the secret of murder
Development
His fractured sense of self becoming more apparent to others through erratic behavior
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific behaviors does Raskolnikov exhibit that make Zamyotov and the workers suspicious of him?
- 2
Why does Raskolnikov keep putting himself in situations where he might be discovered, even though he fears being caught?
- 3
Where have you seen people drop hints about things they've done wrong instead of staying quiet or confessing directly?
- 4
If you noticed someone in your life exhibiting this pattern of guilt-driven behavior, how would you respond to help them without enabling the dangerous game?
- 5
What does Raskolnikov's compulsive return to the crime scene reveal about how unresolved guilt affects our decision-making and self-control?
Critical Thinking Exercise
Trace Your Own Guilt Orbits
Think of a time when you did something wrong and felt compelled to keep talking about it, revisiting it, or putting yourself near situations that could expose you. Write down the specific behaviors you exhibited and the internal tension you felt. Then identify what finally broke the cycle - did you confess, get caught, or find another resolution?
Consider:
- •Notice how guilt made you act against your own self-interest
- •Identify the difference between productive accountability and destructive guilt orbiting
- •Consider what you needed to resolve the internal tension in a healthier way
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 16: Cat and Mouse
As the story unfolds, you'll explore the exhaustion of being hunted, while uncovering pressure reveals character. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.