Summary
Zarathustra's shadow pleads with him not to leave, fearing that without his presence, the gathered higher men will fall back into their old patterns of despair and melancholy. The shadow warns that even the kings, who seem confident, are just performing—underneath, they're as lost as everyone else. To illustrate his point, the shadow shares a nostalgic song about his time in the desert with exotic maidens, painting a picture of an idealized past where life seemed simpler and more beautiful. His desert song is elaborate and whimsical, filled with oriental imagery and romantic fantasy, but it reveals something troubling: he's living in memories rather than engaging with present reality. The song becomes increasingly absurd, describing dancing palm trees and missing legs, showing how nostalgia distorts memory into something unreal. Through this performance, Nietzsche demonstrates how people often retreat into romanticized versions of the past when facing difficult truths about themselves. The shadow's plea and his song both reveal the same underlying problem: the fear of standing alone without external support or comforting illusions. This chapter explores the human tendency to seek escape through fantasy, nostalgia, or dependence on others rather than developing genuine inner strength. The shadow represents our tendency to avoid the hard work of self-creation by clinging to what feels safe and familiar.
Coming Up in Chapter 77
Zarathustra must now respond to his shadow's desperate plea and romantic escapism. Will he provide the comfort and dependency his followers seek, or will he challenge them to find their own strength?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
G1. “o not away!” said then the wanderer who called himself Zarathustra’s shadow, “abide with us—otherwise the old gloomy affliction might again fall upon us. Now hath that old magician given us of his worst for our good, and lo! the good, pious pope there hath tears in his eyes, and hath quite embarked again upon the sea of melancholy. Those kings may well put on a good air before us still: for that have THEY learned best of us all at present! Had they however no one to see them, I wager that with them also the bad game would again commence,— —The bad game of drifting clouds, of damp melancholy, of curtained heavens, of stolen suns, of howling autumn-winds, —The bad game of our howling and crying for help! Abide with us, O Zarathustra! Here there is much concealed misery that wisheth to speak, much evening, much cloud, much damp air! Thou hast nourished us with strong food for men, and powerful proverbs: do not let the weakly, womanly spirits attack us anew at dessert! Thou alone makest the air around thee strong and clear! Did I ever find anywhere on earth such good air as with thee in thy cave? Many lands have I seen, my nose hath learned to test and estimate many kinds of air: but with thee do my nostrils taste their greatest delight! Unless it be,—unless it be—, do forgive an old recollection! Forgive me an old after-dinner song, which I once composed amongst daughters of the desert:— For with them was there equally good, clear, Oriental air; there was I furthest from cloudy, damp, melancholy Old-Europe! Then did I love such Oriental maidens and other blue kingdoms of heaven, over which hang no clouds and no thoughts. Ye would not believe how charmingly they sat there, when they did not dance, profound, but without thoughts, like little secrets, like beribboned riddles, like dessert-nuts— Many-hued and foreign, forsooth! but without clouds: riddles which can be guessed: to please such maidens I then composed an after-dinner psalm.” Thus spake the wanderer who called himself Zarathustra’s shadow; and before any one answered him, he had seized the harp of the old magician, crossed his legs, and looked calmly and sagely around him:—with his nostrils, however, he inhaled the air slowly and questioningly, like one who in new countries tasteth new foreign air. Afterward he began to sing with a kind of roaring. 2. THE DESERTS GROW: WOE HIM WHO DOTH THEM HIDE! —Ha! Solemnly! In effect solemnly! A worthy beginning! Afric manner, solemnly! Of a lion worthy, Or perhaps of a virtuous howl-monkey— —But it’s naught to you, Ye friendly damsels dearly loved, At whose own feet to me, The first occasion, To a European under palm-trees, A seat is now granted. Selah. Wonderful, truly! Here do I sit now, The desert nigh, and yet I am So far still from the desert, Even in naught yet deserted: That is, I’m swallowed down By this...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Nostalgic Escape
When facing difficult present realities, people retreat into idealized versions of the past rather than doing the work required to improve their current situation.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches you to recognize when people use romanticized past stories to avoid taking responsibility for present problems.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone starts a complaint with 'back in my day' or 'remember when'—ask yourself what current challenge they're avoiding by retreating into that story.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Shadow archetype
In psychology and literature, the shadow represents the parts of ourselves we don't want to face - our fears, weaknesses, and dependencies. Zarathustra's shadow is literally a character who embodies human neediness and the fear of being alone.
Modern Usage:
We all have a 'shadow self' that emerges when we're stressed - the part that wants to give up, blame others, or retreat into comfort zones.
Nostalgia as escape
The tendency to romanticize the past as a way to avoid dealing with present difficulties. The shadow's elaborate desert song represents how we distort memories to make them more beautiful than reality ever was.
Modern Usage:
Social media feeds full of 'the good old days' posts, or constantly talking about high school glory days instead of building something new.
Performative confidence
Putting on a show of strength or success while feeling lost underneath. The shadow notes that even the kings are just acting confident because they've learned to perform for others.
Modern Usage:
The carefully curated Instagram life that hides real struggles, or the boss who acts tough but panics when no one's watching.
Emotional dependency
Relying on others to maintain your emotional stability rather than developing inner strength. The shadow begs Zarathustra not to leave because he can't handle his own feelings without support.
Modern Usage:
The friend who falls apart every time their partner travels, or needing constant validation from others to feel okay about yourself.
Oriental fantasy
In 19th-century literature, exotic Eastern settings were often used to represent escape from Western reality. The shadow's desert song with dancing maidens is pure romantic fantasy with no connection to real experience.
Modern Usage:
Any idealized fantasy we use to avoid real life - from romance novels to vacation dreams that become substitutes for actually improving our situation.
Higher men
Nietzsche's term for people who have the potential to transcend ordinary human limitations but often fall short. They're closer to greatness than most people but still struggle with human weaknesses.
Modern Usage:
High achievers who still battle imposter syndrome, or talented people who sabotage themselves when things get difficult.
Characters in This Chapter
Zarathustra's shadow
Needy dependent figure
Represents the part of humanity that fears being alone and seeks constant external validation. He begs Zarathustra to stay because he can't maintain his own emotional stability. His elaborate desert song reveals how he retreats into fantasy when facing difficult truths.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who can't be alone and always needs someone to lean on
The old magician
Manipulative performer
Mentioned as someone who has just given them 'his worst for our good,' suggesting he's been performing false emotions or creating drama. He represents those who use theatrical displays to control others.
Modern Equivalent:
The drama queen who creates crises for attention
The pious pope
Emotional follower
Described as having tears in his eyes and embarking 'again upon the sea of melancholy.' He represents religious or spiritual people who still struggle with depression despite their beliefs.
Modern Equivalent:
The religious person who preaches positivity but battles private despair
The kings
Insecure leaders
They put on 'a good air' in front of others but would return to their 'bad game' of misery if no one was watching. They represent leadership that's all performance with no substance.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss who acts confident in meetings but falls apart in private
Zarathustra
Reluctant teacher
The source of strength that everyone wants to cling to. His presence makes the air 'strong and clear' but the others fear they'll collapse without him, showing their dependency rather than learning from his example.
Modern Equivalent:
The strong friend everyone leans on but never tries to become
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Go not away! abide with us—otherwise the old gloomy affliction might again fall upon us."
Context: The shadow pleads with Zarathustra not to leave the gathering
This reveals the fundamental weakness of depending on others for emotional stability. The shadow admits that without Zarathustra's presence, they'll all fall back into depression and despair, showing they haven't actually grown.
In Today's Words:
Don't leave us - we'll fall apart without you here to keep us together.
"Those kings may well put on a good air before us still: for that have THEY learned best of us all at present!"
Context: Warning that even the seemingly confident leaders are just performing
This exposes how much of leadership and confidence is pure performance. The kings have learned to act strong in public, but underneath they're as lost and needy as everyone else.
In Today's Words:
Even the people who seem to have it together are just really good at faking it.
"Thou alone makest the air around thee strong and clear!"
Context: Praising Zarathustra's effect on others while revealing dependency
This shows both genuine recognition of strength and unhealthy dependency. The shadow can see what real strength looks like but wants to consume it rather than develop it himself.
In Today's Words:
You're the only one who makes everything feel okay and makes sense.
"do not let the weakly, womanly spirits attack us anew at dessert!"
Context: Begging for protection from their own weak impulses
The shadow recognizes that their tendency toward emotional collapse and self-pity will return the moment their support system leaves. He's asking to be protected from his own nature rather than working to change it.
In Today's Words:
Don't let us fall back into our old patterns of feeling sorry for ourselves.
Thematic Threads
Dependence
In This Chapter
The shadow begs Zarathustra not to leave, fearing he and the others will fall back into old patterns without external support
Development
Evolved from earlier chapters about following leaders - now showing the fear of losing that guidance
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you panic at the thought of your mentor, boss, or strong friend not being available to guide your decisions.
Performance
In This Chapter
The shadow reveals that even the confident kings are just performing, hiding their inner confusion and despair
Development
Builds on themes of masks and false confidence shown throughout the book
In Your Life:
You see this when colleagues who seem to have it all together privately admit they're just as lost as everyone else.
Escapism
In This Chapter
The shadow's elaborate desert song represents retreat into fantasy and nostalgia rather than facing present challenges
Development
New manifestation of the avoidance patterns seen in other higher men
In Your Life:
This appears when you find yourself constantly reminiscing about 'better times' instead of working on current problems.
Memory Distortion
In This Chapter
The shadow's song becomes increasingly absurd and unreal, showing how nostalgia corrupts actual memory
Development
Introduced here as a specific mechanism of self-deception
In Your Life:
You might notice this when your stories about the past keep getting more dramatic and perfect each time you tell them.
Fear of Solitude
In This Chapter
The shadow's entire plea stems from terror of being alone without Zarathustra's presence and guidance
Development
Continues the theme of higher men's inability to stand independently
In Your Life:
This shows up when you realize you're more afraid of being alone with your thoughts than you are of staying in unsatisfying situations.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Zarathustra's shadow beg him not to leave, and what does he fear will happen to the other men?
analysis • surface - 2
What does the shadow's elaborate desert song reveal about how he's dealing with his current situation?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people using nostalgic stories or fantasies to avoid dealing with present challenges in your workplace, family, or community?
application • medium - 4
When you catch yourself or someone else retreating into 'remember when' thinking, what specific steps would you take to redirect toward present action?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter suggest about the difference between healthy appreciation of the past and using nostalgia as an escape mechanism?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track Your Escape Routes
For the next three days, notice when you or people around you use phrases like 'remember when,' 'back in my day,' 'if only,' or 'things used to be.' Write down the specific situation that triggered this nostalgic thinking. Then identify what present-moment challenge or responsibility the person might be avoiding through this mental time travel.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns in when nostalgic thinking appears - is it during stress, conflict, or when facing new demands?
- •Notice the difference between sharing positive memories and using the past to avoid present action
- •Pay attention to how nostalgic thinking affects your energy and motivation to tackle current problems
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you found yourself constantly referencing how things 'used to be' instead of dealing with how things are now. What were you really avoiding, and what would have happened if you'd faced that challenge directly?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 77: The Ass Worship Ceremony
The coming pages reveal people can swing from one extreme to another when seeking meaning, and teach us genuine transformation requires more than just rejecting old beliefs. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.