Summary
Hippolyte concludes his manifesto with a chilling philosophical argument about his right to end his own life on his own terms. He questions why society demands he endure his final weeks when death is inevitable, rejecting both religious consolation and moral obligations. His manifesto reveals a young man who feels fundamentally excluded from the beauty and meaning of existence—like watching a festival he can never join. When he finishes reading, the tension explodes. Hippolyte dramatically pulls out a pistol and attempts to shoot himself in front of everyone, but the gun misfires—there was no percussion cap. The failed suicide becomes a humiliating spectacle, with some guests laughing cruelly while others show genuine concern. Hippolyte collapses, claiming he forgot to load the cap 'accidentally,' though doubt lingers about whether this was genuine desperation or theatrical manipulation. The incident forces everyone to confront uncomfortable questions about mental illness, attention-seeking, and how we respond to others' pain. Prince Myshkin, deeply affected, later reflects in the park on his own past feelings of being an outsider to life's meaning, recognizing himself in Hippolyte's tortured words. The chapter exposes how society often responds to mental health crises with a mixture of genuine compassion and cruel skepticism, leaving the sufferer even more isolated.
Coming Up in Chapter 36
As Myshkin sits alone in the park, haunted by Hippolyte's words and his own memories of feeling excluded from life, a mysterious figure approaches him in his dreams—someone he knows but who appears transformed by guilt and horror.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
I“ had a small pocket pistol. I had procured it while still a boy, at that droll age when the stories of duels and highwaymen begin to delight one, and when one imagines oneself nobly standing fire at some future day, in a duel. “There were a couple of old bullets in the bag which contained the pistol, and powder enough in an old flask for two or three charges. “The pistol was a wretched thing, very crooked and wouldn’t carry farther than fifteen paces at the most. However, it would send your skull flying well enough if you pressed the muzzle of it against your temple. “I determined to die at Pavlofsk at sunrise, in the park—so as to make no commotion in the house. “This ‘explanation’ will make the matter clear enough to the police. Students of psychology, and anyone else who likes, may make what they please of it. I should not like this paper, however, to be made public. I request the prince to keep a copy himself, and to give a copy to Aglaya Ivanovna Epanchin. This is my last will and testament. As for my skeleton, I bequeath it to the Medical Academy for the benefit of science. “I recognize no jurisdiction over myself, and I know that I am now beyond the power of laws and judges. “A little while ago a very amusing idea struck me. What if I were now to commit some terrible crime—murder ten fellow-creatures, for instance, or anything else that is thought most shocking and dreadful in this world—what a dilemma my judges would be in, with a criminal who only has a fortnight to live in any case, now that the rack and other forms of torture are abolished! Why, I should die comfortably in their own hospital—in a warm, clean room, with an attentive doctor—probably much more comfortably than I should at home. “I don’t understand why people in my position do not oftener indulge in such ideas—if only for a joke! Perhaps they do! Who knows! There are plenty of merry souls among us! “But though I do not recognize any jurisdiction over myself, still I know that I shall be judged, when I am nothing but a voiceless lump of clay; therefore I do not wish to go before I have left a word of reply—the reply of a free man—not one forced to justify himself—oh no! I have no need to ask forgiveness of anyone. I wish to say a word merely because I happen to desire it of my own free will. “Here, in the first place, comes a strange thought! “Who, in the name of what Law, would think of disputing my full personal right over the fortnight of life left to me? What jurisdiction can be brought to bear upon the case? Who would wish me, not only to be sentenced, but to endure the sentence to the end? Surely there exists no man who would wish such a thing—why...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Public Pain - When Private Suffering Becomes Performance
When genuine suffering gets transformed into public spectacle, creating a cycle where the performance undermines the very recognition and help the person desperately needs.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone's theatrical behavior masks genuine suffering that found no other outlet.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's dramatic behavior escalates—look past the theater to ask what real need they're trying to express, and respond to that need directly.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Manifesto
A public declaration of beliefs, intentions, or motives, often written by someone who feels powerless or misunderstood. Hippolyte's written statement explains his worldview and justifies his planned suicide.
Modern Usage:
We see manifestos in suicide notes, social media posts before dramatic actions, or even workplace resignation letters that 'tell the truth.'
Nihilism
The belief that life has no inherent meaning or purpose, and that moral principles are baseless. Hippolyte embodies this philosophy, arguing that since he'll die anyway, nothing matters.
Modern Usage:
Shows up in depression, existential crises, or when people say 'nothing matters' after major disappointments or trauma.
Spectacle of suffering
When personal pain becomes public entertainment or drama. Hippolyte's suicide attempt turns into a performance that others judge rather than simply witness with compassion.
Modern Usage:
Social media posts about mental health struggles, public breakdowns, or when someone's crisis becomes gossip rather than receiving genuine help.
Percussion cap
A small explosive charge needed to fire old pistols. Without it, the gun won't work. The missing cap makes Hippolyte's suicide attempt fail dramatically.
Modern Usage:
Like forgetting the key component in any dramatic gesture - the missing piece that makes your big moment fall flat.
Moral jurisdiction
The idea that society has the right to judge and control individual actions based on shared moral standards. Hippolyte rejects this, claiming only he can decide his fate.
Modern Usage:
Debates about personal autonomy versus social responsibility - from vaccine mandates to right-to-die laws to 'my body, my choice' arguments.
Exclusion from meaning
The feeling of being permanently outside life's joy and purpose, like watching a party through a window you can never enter. Hippolyte sees healthy people experiencing a world he can't access.
Modern Usage:
Chronic illness, depression, poverty, or disability can create this feeling of being locked out of 'normal' life experiences.
Characters in This Chapter
Hippolyte Terentyev
Tragic antagonist
A dying teenager who reads his philosophical manifesto justifying suicide, then attempts to shoot himself with a pistol that misfires. His failed suicide becomes both genuine crisis and suspected manipulation.
Modern Equivalent:
The chronically ill young person who posts dramatic content online, making others unsure whether to offer help or suspect attention-seeking
Prince Myshkin
Compassionate observer
Deeply affected by Hippolyte's words and actions, he later reflects on his own past feelings of exclusion from life's meaning. He shows genuine concern while others react with skepticism or cruelty.
Modern Equivalent:
The empathetic person who takes mental health seriously while others dismiss it as drama
Aglaya Epanchin
Intended recipient
Specifically named in Hippolyte's will to receive a copy of his manifesto, suggesting his feelings for her influenced his decision to make this dramatic gesture at this particular gathering.
Modern Equivalent:
The person whose attention someone desperately wants when making dramatic life decisions
The gathered guests
Judgmental audience
Their mixed reactions of laughter, concern, and skepticism after the failed suicide attempt reveal how society responds to mental health crises with both compassion and cruelty.
Modern Equivalent:
Social media commenters who react to someone's crisis with everything from genuine support to cruel mockery
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I recognize no jurisdiction over myself, and I know that I am now beyond the power of laws and judges."
Context: From his written manifesto, rejecting society's right to prevent his suicide
This captures the ultimate assertion of individual autonomy over one's own life and death. Hippolyte argues that terminal illness places him outside normal social contracts and moral obligations.
In Today's Words:
Nobody gets to tell me what to do with my life - I'm dying anyway, so your rules don't apply to me.
"What if I were now to commit some terrible crime—murder ten fellow-creatures, for instance, or anything else that is thought most awful and dreadful in this world?"
Context: Exploring the logical conclusion of his rejection of moral authority
He's testing the boundaries of his nihilistic philosophy, wondering if approaching death gives him license to ignore all moral restraints. It reveals the dangerous territory his thinking has entered.
In Today's Words:
If I'm going to die anyway, why shouldn't I do whatever I want, even hurt people? What's the point of being good?
"The pistol was a wretched thing, very crooked and wouldn't carry farther than fifteen paces at the most. However, it would send your skull flying well enough if you pressed the muzzle of it against your temple."
Context: Describing the weapon he plans to use for suicide
The clinical, almost casual description of the gun's lethal capability shows his detached state of mind. The detail about its poor accuracy but effectiveness at close range emphasizes his serious intent.
In Today's Words:
The gun was junk for shooting anything far away, but it would definitely kill me if I put it right against my head.
Thematic Threads
Mental Health Stigma
In This Chapter
Hippolyte's failed suicide attempt is met with both cruel laughter and genuine concern, showing society's conflicted response to mental health crises
Development
Building from earlier hints about Hippolyte's illness, now explicitly confronting how society handles visible mental health struggles
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone's depression or anxiety gets dismissed as 'drama' or 'attention-seeking' rather than recognized as genuine illness.
Authenticity vs Performance
In This Chapter
Questions arise about whether Hippolyte genuinely forgot the percussion cap or staged the misfire, blurring the line between real desperation and manipulation
Development
Extends the ongoing theme of characters struggling to present authentic selves in social situations
In Your Life:
You face this when your genuine struggles get questioned because you expressed them 'wrong' or at the 'wrong' time.
Social Isolation
In This Chapter
Hippolyte describes feeling like an outsider watching a festival he can never join, expressing profound alienation from life's meaning and beauty
Development
Deepens the exploration of how characters feel excluded from social belonging and life's joys
In Your Life:
You might recognize this feeling when watching others seem to effortlessly navigate social situations or life milestones that feel impossible for you.
Compassion vs Judgment
In This Chapter
The guests' varied reactions—from laughter to genuine concern—reveal how differently people respond to others' visible pain
Development
Continues examining how characters choose between empathy and self-protection when confronted with others' suffering
In Your Life:
You see this in how you and others respond to someone's breakdown—whether with immediate judgment or patient understanding.
Control Over Death
In This Chapter
Hippolyte argues for his right to die on his own terms rather than endure society's timeline for his terminal illness
Development
Introduced here as a new exploration of individual agency versus social expectations around suffering
In Your Life:
You might grapple with this when facing any situation where others want to control how you handle your own pain or major life decisions.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Hippolyte's gun misfire, and how do the other characters react to his failed suicide attempt?
analysis • surface - 2
What drives someone to turn their private pain into a public spectacle, and why does this strategy often backfire?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen people escalate their expressions of distress when they feel unheard or invisible?
application • medium - 4
How can you respond to someone's dramatic cry for help in a way that addresses their real need without encouraging the theatrical behavior?
application • deep - 5
What does this scene reveal about how society treats mental health crises, and why do people sometimes doubt the authenticity of others' suffering?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Real Need
Think of someone you know who tends to express their problems dramatically or creates crisis situations to get attention. Write down what you think their real, underlying need might be. Then brainstorm three direct ways they could ask for what they actually need, and three ways you could respond that address the need without rewarding the drama.
Consider:
- •Look past the behavior to identify the genuine emotional need underneath
- •Consider how your own reactions might either help or make the situation worse
- •Think about the difference between supporting someone and enabling their dramatic patterns
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt like your needs weren't being heard. How did you try to get attention or support? What would have been a more direct way to ask for what you needed?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 36: Truth and Lies in the Garden
As the story unfolds, you'll explore people use lies to test relationships and reveal deeper truths, while uncovering someone might reject help when they need it most. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.