Summary
Zarathustra tries to escape the growing crowd on his mountain, feeling overwhelmed and irritated. His own shadow calls out to him, but Zarathustra runs away, not wanting to deal with another follower. Eventually he stops and confronts this 'shadow' - who turns out to be a real person, thin and worn out from years of following Zarathustra around the world. This shadow-man tells his tragic story: he's been Zarathustra's devoted follower, going everywhere Zarathustra went, breaking all the same rules, rejecting all the same beliefs. But in copying Zarathustra's rejection of everything, he's ended up with nothing of his own - no goals, no home, no values, no sense of self. He's become hollow, existing only as a reflection of someone else. The shadow represents what happens when you follow a philosophy of total freedom and rejection without building anything positive in its place. He's adopted Zarathustra's motto 'nothing is true, all is permitted' but has no inner compass to guide him. Zarathustra recognizes the danger - this shadow shows what he himself could become. He warns the shadow that people who lose all direction often end up desperately clinging to rigid beliefs just to have something to hold onto. Despite his concern, Zarathustra offers the shadow shelter in his cave, then runs away again, not wanting this emptiness to infect him. The chapter shows how dangerous it can be to live without any personal values or direction.
Coming Up in Chapter 70
Zarathustra runs alone through his mountains, finally finding the solitude he craved. But at noon, he discovers something unexpected - an old tree embraced by a vine heavy with grapes, and suddenly feels a different kind of thirst.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
carcely however was the voluntary beggar gone in haste, and Zarathustra again alone, when he heard behind him a new voice which called out: “Stay! Zarathustra! Do wait! It is myself, forsooth, O Zarathustra, myself, thy shadow!” But Zarathustra did not wait; for a sudden irritation came over him on account of the crowd and the crowding in his mountains. “Whither hath my lonesomeness gone?” spake he. “It is verily becoming too much for me; these mountains swarm; my kingdom is no longer of THIS world; I require new mountains. My shadow calleth me? What matter about my shadow! Let it run after me! I—run away from it.” Thus spake Zarathustra to his heart and ran away. But the one behind followed after him, so that immediately there were three runners, one after the other—namely, foremost the voluntary beggar, then Zarathustra, and thirdly, and hindmost, his shadow. But not long had they run thus when Zarathustra became conscious of his folly, and shook off with one jerk all his irritation and detestation. “What!” said he, “have not the most ludicrous things always happened to us old anchorites and saints? Verily, my folly hath grown big in the mountains! Now do I hear six old fools’ legs rattling behind one another! But doth Zarathustra need to be frightened by his shadow? Also, methinketh that after all it hath longer legs than mine.” Thus spake Zarathustra, and, laughing with eyes and entrails, he stood still and turned round quickly—and behold, he almost thereby threw his shadow and follower to the ground, so closely had the latter followed at his heels, and so weak was he. For when Zarathustra scrutinised him with his glance he was frightened as by a sudden apparition, so slender, swarthy, hollow and worn-out did this follower appear. “Who art thou?” asked Zarathustra vehemently, “what doest thou here? And why callest thou thyself my shadow? Thou art not pleasing unto me.” “Forgive me,” answered the shadow, “that it is I; and if I please thee not—well, O Zarathustra! therein do I admire thee and thy good taste. A wanderer am I, who have walked long at thy heels; always on the way, but without a goal, also without a home: so that verily, I lack little of being the eternally Wandering Jew, except that I am not eternal and not a Jew. What? Must I ever be on the way? Whirled by every wind, unsettled, driven about? O earth, thou hast become too round for me! On every surface have I already sat, like tired dust have I fallen asleep on mirrors and window-panes: everything taketh from me, nothing giveth; I become thin—I am almost equal to a shadow. After thee, however, O Zarathustra, did I fly and hie longest; and though I hid myself from thee, I was nevertheless thy best shadow: wherever thou hast sat, there sat I also. With thee have I wandered about in the remotest, coldest worlds, like a phantom that voluntarily haunteth winter...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Empty Following
Following someone else's path of rejection without building your own positive foundation, leaving you hollow and directionless.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between conscious influence and hollow mimicry by examining the difference between adopting someone's methods versus copying their rejections.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you're defining yourself by what you're against rather than what you're building—ask yourself what positive values you're creating to replace what you're questioning.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Shadow
In philosophy and psychology, your shadow represents the parts of yourself you don't want to acknowledge - often your weaknesses, fears, or the negative consequences of your beliefs. Here it's literally a person who became Zarathustra's shadow by copying everything he did.
Modern Usage:
We talk about 'living in someone's shadow' when you lose your own identity by always comparing yourself to or copying someone else.
Nihilism
The belief that nothing has meaning, purpose, or value - that life is fundamentally empty. The shadow character represents what happens when you reject everything without building anything new to replace it.
Modern Usage:
When someone says 'nothing matters anyway' and stops trying, or when people become cynical and dismissive about everything.
Anchorite
A religious hermit who withdraws from society to focus on spiritual matters. Zarathustra calls himself an 'old anchorite' - someone who's chosen isolation to think deeply about life's big questions.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who goes off-grid or becomes a minimalist to escape modern distractions and find themselves.
Lonesomeness
Nietzsche's term for the necessary solitude that allows deep thinking and self-discovery. Different from loneliness - it's chosen isolation that helps you develop your own ideas without outside influence.
Modern Usage:
When you need alone time to figure out what you actually think, separate from what everyone else expects you to think.
Free Spirit
Someone who thinks independently and questions everything, refusing to accept ideas just because they're traditional or popular. But as this chapter shows, total freedom without direction can leave you empty.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who rebels against everything their parents believed but then doesn't know what they stand for themselves.
Mimicry
Copying someone else's behavior, beliefs, or lifestyle without understanding the deeper reasons behind it. The shadow followed Zarathustra everywhere but never developed his own path.
Modern Usage:
When people copy influencers or celebrities without thinking about whether that lifestyle actually fits their own values and circumstances.
Characters in This Chapter
Zarathustra
Protagonist seeking solitude
He's overwhelmed by followers and tries to escape, but realizes he can't run from the consequences of his teachings. He sees in his shadow what he could become - empty and directionless.
Modern Equivalent:
The self-help guru who realizes their advice might be harmful
The Shadow
Devoted but hollow follower
A man who spent years copying everything Zarathustra did, rejecting all the same beliefs, but never developed his own values. He's become empty and lost, existing only as a reflection of someone else.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who defines themselves entirely by what they're against
The voluntary beggar
Another seeker who appears briefly
Mentioned as running ahead of them, representing another type of follower who's also seeking something from Zarathustra's teachings.
Modern Equivalent:
The spiritual seeker jumping from one philosophy to another
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Whither hath my lonesomeness gone? It is verily becoming too much for me; these mountains swarm; my kingdom is no longer of THIS world; I require new mountains."
Context: When he realizes his mountain retreat is being invaded by followers and seekers
This shows how even someone who values solitude can be overwhelmed when their space is invaded. Zarathustra needs alone time to think clearly, but his followers are making that impossible.
In Today's Words:
I can't get a moment's peace anymore - everyone wants something from me and I need to get away from all this.
"Nothing is true, all is permitted"
Context: When explaining the philosophy he learned from following Zarathustra
This motto sounds liberating but the shadow shows its dark side - without any guiding principles, you can become completely lost and empty. Freedom without purpose becomes meaningless.
In Today's Words:
Rules don't matter, you can do whatever you want - but now I don't know what I want to do.
"I have followed thee always, have gone wherever thou wentest"
Context: When explaining how he's spent years copying Zarathustra's every move
This reveals the tragedy of losing your own identity by trying to become someone else. The shadow never learned to think for himself, only to imitate.
In Today's Words:
I've been copying everything you do for years, but I never figured out who I am.
"But doth Zarathustra need to be frightened by his shadow?"
Context: When he stops running and decides to confront what's following him
This moment of self-reflection shows Zarathustra recognizing he needs to face the consequences of his influence rather than running away from them.
In Today's Words:
Why am I running scared from my own problems? I need to deal with this.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
The shadow has no independent identity, existing only as a reflection of Zarathustra's philosophy
Development
Continues the theme of authentic self-creation versus borrowed identity
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you define yourself entirely by what you're against rather than what you stand for.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
The shadow shows what happens when you adopt destruction without construction in personal development
Development
Explores the dark side of breaking free from conventional paths
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone encourages you to 'break all the rules' but offers no guidance for what to build instead.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
The shadow rejected all social norms but created no personal code to replace them
Development
Shows the consequences of total rejection of social structure without replacement
In Your Life:
You might experience this when you leave a restrictive environment but feel lost without any framework for decision-making.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Zarathustra recognizes the danger the shadow represents and flees rather than engage
Development
Demonstrates how emptiness can be contagious and must be avoided
In Your Life:
You might need to distance yourself from people who only tear down without building up, as their negativity can infect your own growth.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What happens to the shadow-man after years of following Zarathustra around the world?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does copying someone else's rebellion lead to emptiness rather than freedom?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today who define themselves only by what they're against, never what they're for?
application • medium - 4
How can someone tear down old beliefs or systems while building something meaningful to replace them?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between following a path and finding your own way?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Build While You Tear Down
Think of something in your life you want to change or reject - a habit, belief, relationship pattern, or system you're part of. Write down what you're tearing down, then immediately write what you're building to replace it. If you can't name what you're building, you're not ready to tear down yet.
Consider:
- •Empty rebellion creates a vacuum that gets filled by whatever's loudest
- •Your replacement doesn't have to be perfect, just intentional
- •Building takes longer than tearing down, so start the construction early
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you rejected something important but didn't replace it with anything meaningful. What happened in that empty space? What would you build there now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 70: The Perfect Moment at Noontide
Zarathustra runs alone through his mountains, finally finding the solitude he craved. But at noon, he discovers something unexpected - an old tree embraced by a vine heavy with grapes, and suddenly feels a different kind of thirst.
