Summary
Zarathustra encounters a man writhing on the ground, crying out in apparent spiritual agony about being pursued by an 'unfamiliar God.' The dramatic performance includes poetic laments about loneliness, torture, and divine abandonment. But Zarathustra sees through the act and strikes the man with his staff, calling him out as a 'stage-player' and 'false coiner.' The man reveals himself as a magician who was testing Zarathustra, admitting he performed this role of 'the penitent in spirit' - someone who turns their intellect against themselves and suffers from their own knowledge. The magician confesses his deeper truth: he's weary of his own deceptions and desperately seeks greatness but knows he's not actually great. He admits to being disgusted with his own artifice, and this disgust is the only genuine thing left in him. When pressed about what he truly seeks, the magician reveals he's looking for 'a genuine one' - someone of perfect honesty and wisdom. He's actually seeking Zarathustra himself. Zarathustra, both moved and skeptical, directs him toward his cave but warns that true greatness is rare in their populist age. The chapter explores themes of authenticity versus performance, the difference between seeking attention and seeking truth, and how spiritual crisis can become another form of theater. It shows how even our suffering can become inauthentic when we perform it rather than simply experience it.
Coming Up in Chapter 66
Zarathustra's journey continues as he encounters another troubled figure - a tall, pale man in black who appears to be a priest. What does this religious figure want in Zarathustra's domain, and what new challenge will this meeting bring?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
W1. hen however Zarathustra had gone round a rock, then saw he on the same path, not far below him, a man who threw his limbs about like a maniac, and at last tumbled to the ground on his belly. “Halt!” said then Zarathustra to his heart, “he there must surely be the higher man, from him came that dreadful cry of distress,—I will see if I can help him.” When, however, he ran to the spot where the man lay on the ground, he found a trembling old man, with fixed eyes; and in spite of all Zarathustra’s efforts to lift him and set him again on his feet, it was all in vain. The unfortunate one, also, did not seem to notice that some one was beside him; on the contrary, he continually looked around with moving gestures, like one forsaken and isolated from all the world. At last, however, after much trembling, and convulsion, and curling-himself-up, he began to lament thus: Who warm’th me, who lov’th me still? Give ardent fingers! Give heartening charcoal-warmers! Prone, outstretched, trembling, Like him, half dead and cold, whose feet one warm’th— And shaken, ah! by unfamiliar fevers, Shivering with sharpened, icy-cold frost-arrows, By thee pursued, my fancy! Ineffable! Recondite! Sore-frightening! Thou huntsman ’hind the cloud-banks! Now lightning-struck by thee, Thou mocking eye that me in darkness watcheth: —Thus do I lie, Bend myself, twist myself, convulsed With all eternal torture, And smitten By thee, cruellest huntsman, Thou unfamiliar—GOD... Smite deeper! Smite yet once more! Pierce through and rend my heart! What mean’th this torture With dull, indented arrows? Why look’st thou hither, Of human pain not weary, With mischief-loving, godly flash-glances? Not murder wilt thou, But torture, torture? For why—ME torture, Thou mischief-loving, unfamiliar God?— Ha! Ha! Thou stealest nigh In midnight’s gloomy hour?... What wilt thou? Speak! Thou crowdst me, pressest— Ha! now far too closely! Thou hearst me breathing, Thou o’erhearst my heart, Thou ever jealous one! —Of what, pray, ever jealous? Off! Off! For why the ladder? Wouldst thou GET IN? To heart in-clamber? To mine own secretest Conceptions in-clamber? Shameless one! Thou unknown one!—Thief! What seekst thou by thy stealing? What seekst thou by thy hearkening? What seekst thou by thy torturing? Thou torturer! Thou—hangman-God! Or shall I, as the mastiffs do, Roll me before thee? And cringing, enraptured, frantical, My tail friendly—waggle! In vain! Goad further! Cruellest goader! No dog—thy game just am I, Cruellest huntsman! Thy proudest of captives, Thou robber ’hind the cloud-banks ... Speak finally! Thou lightning-veiled one! Thou unknown one! Speak! What wilt thou, highway-ambusher, from—ME? What WILT thou, unfamiliar—God? What? Ransom-gold? How much of ransom-gold? Solicit much—that bid’th my pride! And be concise—that bid’th mine other pride! Ha! Ha! ME—wantest thou? me? —Entire?... Ha! Ha! And torturest me, fool that thou art, Dead-torturest quite my pride? Give LOVE to me—who warm’th me still? Who lov’th me still?— Give ardent fingers, Give heartening charcoal-warmers, Give me, the lonesomest, The ice (ah! seven-fold...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Performed Pain
When genuine struggles become theatrical performances that prevent actual healing while demanding constant attention.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between genuine distress that seeks solutions and theatrical suffering that seeks audiences.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone tells you their problems—do they want advice or attention? Real problems welcome concrete help; performed problems reject solutions and continue the show.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Stage-player
Someone who performs emotions or experiences rather than genuinely feeling them. In Nietzsche's time, this referred to theatrical actors, but he uses it metaphorically for people who turn their lives into performances for others' attention.
Modern Usage:
We see this in social media influencers who perform their mental health struggles for likes, or people who dramatize every problem for sympathy.
False coiner
Originally someone who made counterfeit money, but Nietzsche uses it for people who create fake spiritual or emotional currency. They manufacture artificial depth and wisdom to appear more profound than they are.
Modern Usage:
Like wellness gurus who package basic advice as revolutionary wisdom, or people who use therapy language to manipulate others.
Penitent in spirit
Someone who turns their own intelligence against themselves, creating elaborate mental torture over their knowledge and awareness. They suffer not from ignorance, but from knowing too much and feeling guilty about it.
Modern Usage:
Think of highly educated people who constantly second-guess themselves, or activists who burn out from feeling responsible for every social problem.
The genuine one
Nietzsche's concept of a person of complete authenticity and honesty, someone who doesn't perform or pretend but simply is. This represents the ideal that many seek but few achieve.
Modern Usage:
We see this in our search for 'authentic' celebrities or leaders who seem real, not manufactured by PR teams.
Populist age
Nietzsche's term for an era where mediocrity is celebrated and true excellence is rare because society caters to the lowest common denominator. Mass culture flattens individual greatness.
Modern Usage:
Our current era of viral content, where being relatable often matters more than being exceptional, and algorithms reward what's popular over what's profound.
Magician archetype
In literature, the figure who uses illusion and performance to hide their true self or test others. They possess knowledge but struggle with how to use it authentically.
Modern Usage:
Like therapists who are deeply troubled themselves, or teachers who know the material but haven't figured out how to live by it.
Characters in This Chapter
Zarathustra
Protagonist and truth-seeker
He sees through the magician's performance immediately and calls him out with both compassion and firmness. Shows his ability to distinguish between genuine suffering and theatrical display.
Modern Equivalent:
The experienced supervisor who can spot when someone's faking a crisis for attention
The magician
Performer seeking authenticity
Initially appears as a tortured soul crying out to God, but reveals himself as someone who stages spiritual crises. Despite his deceptions, he genuinely seeks truth and admits his own fraudulence.
Modern Equivalent:
The social media influencer who performs vulnerability for followers but secretly craves real connection
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Smite deeper! Smite yet once more!"
Context: While performing his role as the tortured penitent crying out to an unfamiliar God
This reveals how even spiritual suffering can become performance art. The magician is so committed to his role that he demands more punishment, showing how we can become addicted to our own drama.
In Today's Words:
Hit me with more problems - I need the attention and sympathy that comes with being the victim.
"Thou art a stage-player and a false coiner!"
Context: When he strikes the magician with his staff and exposes the performance
Zarathustra cuts through the theatrical display to name what's really happening. This shows the importance of calling out performative behavior, even when it masquerades as spiritual seeking.
In Today's Words:
You're putting on an act and selling fake emotions for attention.
"I am weary of myself, that is my truth"
Context: When he finally admits his real condition after being exposed
This moment of genuine confession contrasts sharply with his earlier performance. His weariness with his own deceptions is the one authentic thing about him, showing how exhausting it is to constantly perform.
In Today's Words:
I'm sick of my own BS - that's the only honest thing I can say about myself.
"I seek one that is genuine, right, simple, unambiguous, a man of perfect honesty"
Context: Explaining what he's truly looking for when pressed by Zarathustra
Despite all his deceptions, he recognizes and craves authenticity in others. This reveals the deep human need for genuine connection, even among those who struggle to be genuine themselves.
In Today's Words:
I want to find someone who's completely real and honest, no games or pretending.
Thematic Threads
Authenticity
In This Chapter
The magician's admission that his spiritual crisis is performed, not genuine, yet his disgust with his own performance is real
Development
Building from earlier themes of self-creation and honest self-assessment
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself exaggerating problems to get sympathy instead of seeking actual solutions
Deception
In This Chapter
The magician as 'false coiner' who creates counterfeit spiritual experiences but seeks genuine wisdom
Development
Continues exploration of how we deceive ourselves and others about our true nature
In Your Life:
You might notice when you're putting on an act to get what you want instead of asking directly
Recognition
In This Chapter
Zarathustra immediately sees through the performance while the magician desperately seeks to be truly seen
Development
Develops the theme of seeing clearly versus being fooled by appearances
In Your Life:
You might recognize when someone's dramatic crisis is really a cry for attention or connection
Loneliness
In This Chapter
The magician's performed isolation masks his genuine desire for authentic connection with 'a genuine one'
Development
Explores how false connection through drama prevents real intimacy
In Your Life:
You might realize that performing your struggles actually pushes people away from real closeness
Self-Knowledge
In This Chapter
The magician knows he's not great but can't stop pretending, creating a prison of self-awareness
Development
Shows how knowing your flaws without changing them becomes its own form of suffering
In Your Life:
You might recognize when you're aware of your own patterns but feel stuck repeating them anyway
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Zarathustra immediately see through the magician's performance when others might have been fooled?
analysis • surface - 2
What's the difference between the magician's performed suffering and genuine spiritual crisis?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people performing their problems instead of solving them in your daily life?
application • medium - 4
How can you tell when someone genuinely needs help versus when they're seeking attention through drama?
application • deep - 5
Why does performing our pain make it harder to heal from it?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Spot the Performance Pattern
Think of someone in your life who always seems to be in crisis. Write down three specific examples of how they present their problems. Then identify what they might actually be seeking (attention, control, connection) and what a direct approach to getting that need met would look like.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns of rejecting help while continuing to complain
- •Notice if the drama escalates when they're not getting enough response
- •Consider whether the person seems more invested in the problem than the solution
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you caught yourself performing your own pain or problems. What were you really trying to get? How could you have asked for it directly?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 66: The Last Pope's Confession
As the story unfolds, you'll explore to recognize when old systems no longer serve you, while uncovering honest doubt can be more sacred than blind faith. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.