Summary
Socrates delivers his final arguments about justice, beginning with a renewed attack on poetry and imitation. He explains that artists and poets are 'three times removed' from truth—they copy the physical world, which itself is just a copy of the divine forms. This isn't just philosophical nitpicking; it's about what we allow to influence our minds and hearts. Poetry feeds our emotions and weakens our reason, making us weep over fictional sorrows while neglecting real wisdom. After establishing why the ideal state must carefully control artistic influence, Socrates pivots to his ultimate proof: the immortality of the soul. Just as disease destroys the body but not the soul, injustice corrupts but cannot kill our essential being. This leads to the book's climax—the Myth of Er, a soldier who died and returned to tell of the afterlife. Er witnesses souls choosing their next lives from countless options, and here Plato drives home his crucial point: we are responsible for our choices. The tyrant who chooses another tyrannical life, the hero Ajax choosing to become a lion in bitterness, Odysseus selecting a simple, quiet life—each soul shapes its own destiny. The universe isn't random; it operates on justice. Good deeds and wisdom in this life prepare us to choose wisely in the next. The Republic ends where it began, with the question of how to live, but now we understand the stakes are eternal. Socrates delivers his final judgment on poetry and art in the ideal state, arguing that most forms of artistic imitation must be banned. He explains that artists create copies of copies—their paintings and poems are twice removed from truth, since they imitate physical objects which are themselves mere shadows of eternal Forms. A poet writing about courage knows less than a soldier, who knows less than the Form of Courage itself. This matters because citizens, especially guardians, must pursue truth rather than illusion. Socrates particularly condemns dramatic poetry that portrays heroes lamenting, gods misbehaving, or any excessive emotions. Such works teach the wrong lessons: that good people suffer terribly, that self-control doesn't matter, that the gods are petty. He argues that consuming these stories shapes character, especially in youth. The chapter becomes deeply personal when Socrates admits his own love for Homer while insisting that even beloved poetry must go if it corrupts souls. The discussion expands beyond literature to cover music (only certain modes allowed), rhythm, and all arts. Socrates envisions a city where every creative work reinforces virtue rather than undermining it. The chapter ends with a haunting preview of Book X's deeper exploration of the soul's immortality and ultimate fate. Socrates presents his most famous allegory: prisoners chained in a cave, watching shadows on a wall, believing these flickerings to be reality. When one prisoner breaks free and sees the true world illuminated by the sun, he faces a terrible dilemma—returning to help his fellow prisoners means being mocked and possibly killed by those who prefer their familiar darkness. This powerful image captures the philosopher's journey from ignorance to wisdom, and the responsibility that comes with understanding. The chapter then explores the nature of ultimate reality through the concept of the Good—the source of all truth and knowledge, like the sun that makes vision possible. Socrates maps out the long educational journey required to perceive this highest truth, involving mathematics, geometry, astronomy, and finally dialectic (philosophical reasoning). The ideal state needs guardians who have completed this journey, who understand true reality, and who will reluctantly but dutifully return to govern those still dwelling in the cave. The chapter concludes with a vision of the soul's immortality and a mythical tale of how souls choose their next lives, warning that without philosophical wisdom, we're doomed to repeat our mistakes across lifetimes. Every choice we make shapes not just this life but our eternal journey.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
BOOK X. Many things pleased me in the order of our State, but there was nothing which I liked better than the regulation about poetry. The division of the soul throws a new light on our exclusion of imitation. I do not mind telling you in confidence that all poetry is an outrage on the understanding, unless the hearers have that balm of knowledge which heals error. I have loved Homer ever since I was a boy, and even now he appears to me to be the great master of tragic poetry. But much as I love the man, I love truth more, and therefore I must speak out: and first of all, will you explain what is imitation, for really I do not understand? ‘How likely then that I should understand!’ That might very well be, for the duller often sees better than the keener eye. ‘True, but in your presence I can hardly venture to say what I think.’ Then suppose that we begin in our old fashion, with the doctrine of universals. Let us assume the existence of beds and tables. There is one idea of a bed, or of a table, which the maker of each had in his mind when making them; he did not make the ideas of beds and tables, but he made beds and tables according to the ideas. And is there not a maker of the works of all workmen, who makes not only vessels but plants and animals, himself, the earth and heaven, and things in heaven and under the earth? He makes the Gods also. ‘He must be a wizard indeed!’ But do you not see that there is a sense in which you could do the same? You have only to take a mirror, and catch the reflection of the sun, and the earth, or anything else—there now you have made them. ‘Yes, but only in appearance.’ Exactly so; and the painter is such a creator as you are with the mirror, and he is even more unreal than the carpenter; although neither the carpenter nor any other artist can be supposed to make the absolute bed. ‘Not if philosophers may be believed.’ Nor need we wonder that his bed has but an imperfect relation to the truth. Reflect:—Here are three beds; one in nature, which is made by God; another, which is made by the carpenter; and the third, by the painter. God only made one, nor could he have made more than one; for if there had been two, there would always have been a third—more absolute and abstract than either, under which they would have been included. We may therefore conceive God to be the natural maker of the bed, and in a lower sense the carpenter is also the maker; but the painter is rather the imitator of what the other two make; he has to do with a creation which is thrice removed from reality. And the tragic poet is an imitator, and,...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches you to recognize when people's anger at you is really fear of what you represent—the possibility that their worldview needs updating.
Practice This Today
This week, when someone reacts strongly to a simple observation you make, ask yourself: what comfortable belief am I threatening?
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Forms/Ideas
Plato's concept that everything in our world is an imperfect copy of a perfect, eternal template. Like how every chair you see is trying to be the perfect 'idea' of Chair that exists somewhere beyond our world.
Modern Usage:
We use this when we say someone is 'the platonic ideal' of something - like the perfect example of a teacher or athlete
Mimesis (Imitation)
The Greek idea that art copies life, and those copies can be dangerous because they're several steps removed from truth. Plato worried that watching fake emotions in plays makes us worse at handling real ones.
Modern Usage:
We see this in debates about violent video games or reality TV - does consuming fake drama affect how we handle real life?
The Immortal Soul
The belief that your essential self survives death and can't be destroyed by physical harm or moral corruption. For Plato, this means our choices matter beyond this lifetime.
Modern Usage:
Whether religious or not, we talk about leaving a 'legacy' or how someone's spirit lives on after death
Metempsychosis
The transmigration of souls - the idea that after death, souls choose new lives based on their previous experiences and wisdom. Your next life depends on how wisely you lived this one.
Modern Usage:
We echo this in phrases like 'you reap what you sow' or when we talk about karma
The Myth of Er
A story about a soldier who died in battle and came back to describe the afterlife. Plato uses this near-death experience tale to illustrate how justice works across lifetimes.
Modern Usage:
Similar to modern near-death experience accounts that people share to prove there's meaning beyond this life
Three Removes from Truth
Plato's criticism that artists are copycats of copycats - they paint beds that copy physical beds that copy the true Form of Bed. Each copy gets further from what's real.
Modern Usage:
Like how a movie based on a book based on true events gets less accurate with each adaptation
Forms
Plato's idea that perfect, eternal versions of everything exist beyond our physical world. A chair is just a flawed copy of the perfect Form of Chair. This matters because Socrates argues art is a copy of a copy—even further from truth.
Modern Usage:
We still debate whether movies/games/social media show us reality or distort it
Mimesis
Greek term for artistic imitation or representation. Socrates condemns it because artists pretend to know things they don't—a poet writes about war without being a soldier. This fake expertise misleads people.
Modern Usage:
Like influencers giving life advice when they've never held a regular job
Guardians
The warrior class in Plato's ideal state, responsible for protecting the city. Socrates worries that emotional poetry will make them soft when they need to be strong. Their education must build character, not weaken it.
Modern Usage:
Similar to concerns about what police/military training should emphasize
Homer
Ancient Greece's most beloved poet, author of the Iliad and Odyssey. Even though everyone loved his work, Socrates says it must go because it shows heroes crying and gods behaving badly.
Modern Usage:
Like banning a classic movie everyone loves because it sets bad examples
Modes (in music)
Different musical scales that Greeks believed created different moods and behaviors. Socrates only allows modes that inspire courage or self-discipline, banning those that might make people lazy or emotional.
Modern Usage:
Like debates over whether violent video games or certain music genres influence behavior
Styx and Cocytus
Rivers in the Greek underworld, representing death's horrors. Socrates wants these scary names banned because they make people fear death too much. Guardians should fear dishonor more than dying.
Modern Usage:
Like sheltering kids from horror movies or disturbing news to protect their mental state
Allegory of the Cave
A story where prisoners chained in a cave mistake shadows on the wall for reality. When freed, they discover the real world outside. This represents how most people live in ignorance, mistaking appearances for truth.
Modern Usage:
We see this when people believe social media is real life, or when someone's whole worldview changes after leaving their hometown
The Good
The ultimate source of truth and knowledge in Plato's philosophy, like the sun that makes sight possible. It's the highest form of understanding that philosophers seek. Without it, we can't truly know anything.
Modern Usage:
Like core values that guide all our decisions - the fundamental principles we return to when making tough choices
Dialectic
The art of philosophical questioning and reasoning to reach truth. It's like peeling back layers of assumptions through careful conversation. The highest form of education in Plato's system.
Modern Usage:
Similar to therapy or deep conversations where someone asks probing questions to help you realize truths about yourself
Philosopher-Kings
Rulers who have completed the journey from the cave to understanding the Good. They don't want to rule but do it from duty. They govern because they understand reality, not because they seek power.
Modern Usage:
Like reluctant leaders who step up during crisis because they have expertise others lack - think doctors during pandemics
Transmigration of Souls
The belief that souls are reborn into new bodies after death. Your choices in this life affect your next one. Wisdom helps you choose better lives.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how our choices create patterns we repeat in relationships or jobs until we learn better
Characters in This Chapter
Socrates
protagonist and primary teacher
Wraps up his entire argument about justice by attacking poetry and proving the soul is immortal. Shows his deepest beliefs about truth being more important than even beloved traditions like Homer.
Modern Equivalent:
The tough-love teacher who makes you question everything you thought you knew
Glaucon
student and dialogue partner
Continues as Socrates' sounding board, helping readers follow the argument by asking clarifying questions. Represents someone genuinely trying to understand these deep ideas.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who asks the questions everyone's thinking but afraid to ask
Er the Pamphylian
mythological witness
A soldier who died for twelve days and returned to tell what he saw in the afterlife. His story becomes Plato's way of showing how justice works beyond death.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone who had a near-death experience and came back changed
Homer
referenced master poet
Though not present, he's discussed as the greatest poet who Socrates loves but must criticize. Represents the conflict between loving art and recognizing its potential harm.
Modern Equivalent:
Like criticizing your favorite filmmaker for promoting unhealthy ideas
Tiresias
Referenced prophet from Homer
Example of the underworld imagery Socrates wants banned. Even though Tiresias kept wisdom after death, these ghost stories make people fear dying instead of fearing dishonor.
Modern Equivalent:
The psychic or medium in shows that make death seem scary
The Escaped Prisoner
symbolic protagonist
Represents anyone who breaks free from ignorance to see reality. Faces the choice between comfortable darkness and painful truth. Must decide whether to help others still trapped.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone who escaped a cult or toxic situation and debates warning others
The Cave Prisoners
symbolic antagonists
Represent humanity trapped in ignorance, mistaking shadows for reality. They mock and might even kill anyone who challenges their worldview. Show how people resist truth.
Modern Equivalent:
People who attack anyone questioning their echo chamber
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Much as I love the man, I love truth more"
Context: Explaining why he must criticize Homer despite admiring him since childhood
Shows the philosophical commitment to truth over personal feelings or cultural traditions. Socrates models how to examine even things we love if they might lead us astray.
In Today's Words:
I'm a huge fan, but I've got to call this out when it's wrong
"The soul of each of us is immortal and imperishable"
Context: Introducing his proof that souls cannot be destroyed, only corrupted
The turning point where Plato shows why justice matters eternally, not just in this life. If souls are immortal, then developing wisdom and virtue becomes the most practical life investment.
In Today's Words:
The real you can't be killed - it lives on, so what you do with it matters forever
"The blame is his who chooses; Heaven is blameless"
Context: Announcing to souls about to choose their next lives
Plato's ultimate statement on free will and responsibility. We can't blame God, fate, or circumstances for our choices - we own them completely, and they shape our destiny.
In Today's Words:
You picked this life, so don't blame anyone else for how it turns out
"Poetry feeds and waters the passions instead of starving them"
Context: Explaining why poetry is dangerous for the soul's health
Reveals Plato's psychology - he believes we have limited emotional energy, and wasting it on fictional sorrows weakens our ability to handle real challenges with wisdom and restraint.
In Today's Words:
Binge-watching drama shows makes you more dramatic in real life
"The greater the poetical charm of them, the less are they meet for the ears of boys and men who are meant to be free"
Context: Explaining why the most beautiful poetry is the most dangerous
Reveals the paradox at the heart of censorship—the best art is the most seductive and therefore the most threatening. Socrates admits poetry's power even as he bans it. Shows how beauty and truth can conflict.
In Today's Words:
The catchier the song, the more careful you need to be about what it's teaching your kids
"We must beg Homer and the other poets not to be angry if we strike out these and similar passages"
Context: Apologizing while censoring beloved poetry
Shows Socrates' genuine respect for the artists he's censoring. He's not dismissing their talent—he's acknowledging it's too powerful to leave unchecked. The apologetic tone reveals his inner conflict.
In Today's Words:
Sorry Homer, you're canceled—it's not personal, but your content doesn't align with our values
"There is a danger that the nerves of our guardians may be rendered too excitable and effeminate by them"
Context: Warning about poetry's effect on warriors
Connects artistic consumption directly to character formation. Socrates believes you become what you consume—read about heroes crying, and you'll cry when you should fight. Shows ancient concerns about 'softening' influences.
In Today's Words:
If our soldiers watch too many emotional movies, they won't be tough enough when it counts
"Men who are meant to be free, and who should fear slavery more than death"
Context: Describing the proper mindset for citizens
Establishes the hierarchy of values in the ideal state—freedom and honor matter more than life itself. This explains why death shouldn't be portrayed as the ultimate evil. Reveals the warrior ethic underlying the entire system.
In Today's Words:
Better to die standing than live on your knees
"The prisoners would in every way believe that the truth is nothing other than the shadows of those artifacts."
Context: Describing how the chained prisoners mistake shadows for reality
This captures how we mistake surface appearances for deep truth. We're so used to our limited perspective that we can't imagine there's more. It explains why people resist new ideas so strongly.
In Today's Words:
They'd swear those shadows were the real deal, just like people think their news feed shows the whole truth
"Anyone who is to act sensibly in private or public must see the Good."
Context: Explaining why philosophers must understand the highest truth before ruling
Leadership requires understanding fundamental truths, not just managing appearances. You can't guide others well if you're also lost in illusions. True wisdom must come before true authority.
In Today's Words:
You can't give good advice or make good decisions if you don't understand what really matters
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
In the Myth of Er, what happens when souls choose their next lives? Why does the tyrant choose to be a tyrant again?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Plato think poetry and art are 'three times removed' from truth? What's he really warning us about?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about social media algorithms. How do they trap people in loops like the souls in Er's myth? What 'life' are people choosing when they only click on outrage content?
application • medium - 4
You notice a coworker starting to cut corners—arriving late, skipping procedures. Using Plato's pattern, how would you help them before they get trapped in that loop?
application • deep - 5
If every choice is practice for who we become, what does this say about 'just this once' decisions? Why might small compromises be more dangerous than big ones?
reflection • deep - 6
Why does Socrates want to ban poetry and art from the ideal state, even though he admits he loves Homer?
analysis • surface
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track Your Choice Loops
List three recurring patterns in your life—things you find yourself doing repeatedly even when you don't want to. For each pattern, identify the 'first small choice' that starts the loop. Then write one specific action you could take tomorrow to choose differently and break the pattern.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns in how you respond to stress, conflict, or boredom
- •Notice which choices feel automatic versus deliberate
- •Consider what identity each pattern is reinforcing—who are you practicing to become?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you successfully broke a negative pattern. What was the first different choice you made? How did it feel to act against your usual habit?