An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 2518 words)
ADUMBRATIONS
It was about this time that the warnings of coming events began to fall
about us thick and fast. Ernest had already questioned father’s policy
of having socialists and labor leaders at his house, and of openly
attending socialist meetings; and father had only laughed at him for
his pains. As for myself, I was learning much from this contact with
the working-class leaders and thinkers. I was seeing the other side of
the shield. I was delighted with the unselfishness and high idealism I
encountered, though I was appalled by the vast philosophic and
scientific literature of socialism that was opened up to me. I was
learning fast, but I learned not fast enough to realize then the peril
of our position.
There were warnings, but I did not heed them. For instance, Mrs.
Pertonwaithe and Mrs. Wickson exercised tremendous social power in the
university town, and from them emanated the sentiment that I was a
too-forward and self-assertive young woman with a mischievous penchant
for officiousness and interference in other persons’ affairs. This I
thought no more than natural, considering the part I had played in
investigating the case of Jackson’s arm. But the effect of such a
sentiment, enunciated by two such powerful social arbiters, I
underestimated.
True, I noticed a certain aloofness on the part of my general friends,
but this I ascribed to the disapproval that was prevalent in my circles
of my intended marriage with Ernest. It was not till some time
afterward that Ernest pointed out to me clearly that this general
attitude of my class was something more than spontaneous, that behind
it were the hidden springs of an organized conduct. “You have given
shelter to an enemy of your class,” he said. “And not alone shelter,
for you have given your love, yourself. This is treason to your class.
Think not that you will escape being penalized.”
But it was before this that father returned one afternoon. Ernest was
with me, and we could see that father was angry—philosophically angry.
He was rarely really angry; but a certain measure of controlled anger
he allowed himself. He called it a tonic. And we could see that he was
tonic-angry when he entered the room.
“What do you think?” he demanded. “I had luncheon with Wilcox.”
Wilcox was the superannuated president of the university, whose
withered mind was stored with generalizations that were young in 1870,
and which he had since failed to revise.
“I was invited,” father announced. “I was sent for.”
He paused, and we waited.
“Oh, it was done very nicely, I’ll allow; but I was reprimanded. I! And
by that old fossil!”
“I’ll wager I know what you were reprimanded for,” Ernest said.
“Not in three guesses,” father laughed.
“One guess will do,” Ernest retorted. “And it won’t be a guess. It will
be a deduction. You were reprimanded for your private life.”
“The very thing!” father cried. “How did you guess?”
“I knew it was coming. I warned you before about it.”
“Yes, you did,” father meditated. “But I couldn’t believe it. At any
rate, it is only so much more clinching evidence for my book.”
“It is nothing to what will come,” Ernest went on, “if you persist in
your policy of having these socialists and radicals of all sorts at
your house, myself included.”
“Just what old Wilcox said. And of all unwarranted things! He said it
was in poor taste, utterly profitless, anyway, and not in harmony with
university traditions and policy. He said much more of the same vague
sort, and I couldn’t pin him down to anything specific. I made it
pretty awkward for him, and he could only go on repeating himself and
telling me how much he honored me, and all the world honored me, as a
scientist. It wasn’t an agreeable task for him. I could see he didn’t
like it.”
“He was not a free agent,” Ernest said. “The leg-bar[1] is not always
worn graciously.”
[1] Leg-bar—the African slaves were so manacled; also criminals. It
was not until the coming of the Brotherhood of Man that the leg-bar
passed out of use.
“Yes. I got that much out of him. He said the university needed ever so
much more money this year than the state was willing to furnish; and
that it must come from wealthy personages who could not but be offended
by the swerving of the university from its high ideal of the
passionless pursuit of passionless intelligence. When I tried to pin
him down to what my home life had to do with swerving the university
from its high ideal, he offered me a two years’ vacation, on full pay,
in Europe, for recreation and research. Of course I couldn’t accept it
under the circumstances.”
“It would have been far better if you had,” Ernest said gravely.
“It was a bribe,” father protested; and Ernest nodded.
“Also, the beggar said that there was talk, tea-table gossip and so
forth, about my daughter being seen in public with so notorious a
character as you, and that it was not in keeping with university tone
and dignity. Not that he personally objected—oh, no; but that there was
talk and that I would understand.”
Ernest considered this announcement for a moment, and then said, and
his face was very grave, withal there was a sombre wrath in it:
“There is more behind this than a mere university ideal. Somebody has
put pressure on President Wilcox.”
“Do you think so?” father asked, and his face showed that he was
interested rather than frightened.
“I wish I could convey to you the conception that is dimly forming in
my own mind,” Ernest said. “Never in the history of the world was
society in so terrific flux as it is right now. The swift changes in
our industrial system are causing equally swift changes in our
religious, political, and social structures. An unseen and fearful
revolution is taking place in the fibre and structure of society. One
can only dimly feel these things. But they are in the air, now, to-day.
One can feel the loom of them—things vast, vague, and terrible. My mind
recoils from contemplation of what they may crystallize into. You heard
Wickson talk the other night. Behind what he said were the same
nameless, formless things that I feel. He spoke out of a superconscious
apprehension of them.”
“You mean . . . ?” father began, then paused.
“I mean that there is a shadow of something colossal and menacing that
even now is beginning to fall across the land. Call it the shadow of an
oligarchy, if you will; it is the nearest I dare approximate it. What
its nature may be I refuse to imagine.[2] But what I wanted to say was
this: You are in a perilous position—a peril that my own fear enhances
because I am not able even to measure it. Take my advice and accept the
vacation.”
[2] Though, like Everhard, they did not dream of the nature of it,
there were men, even before his time, who caught glimpses of the
shadow. John C. Calhoun said: “A power has risen up in the government
greater than the people themselves, consisting of many and various and
powerful interests, combined into one mass, and held together by the
cohesive power of the vast surplus in the banks.” And that great
humanist, Abraham Lincoln, said, just before his assassination: “I
see in the near future a crisis approaching that unnerves me and
causes me to tremble for the safety of my country. . . . Corporations
have been enthroned, an era of corruption in high places will follow,
and the money-power of the country will endeavor to prolong its reign
by working upon the prejudices of the people until the wealth is
aggregated in a few hands and the Republic is destroyed.”
“But it would be cowardly,” was the protest.
“Not at all. You are an old man. You have done your work in the world,
and a great work. Leave the present battle to youth and strength. We
young fellows have our work yet to do. Avis will stand by my side in
what is to come. She will be your representative in the battle-front.”
“But they can’t hurt me,” father objected. “Thank God I am independent.
Oh, I assure you, I know the frightful persecution they can wage on a
professor who is economically dependent on his university. But I am
independent. I have not been a professor for the sake of my salary. I
can get along very comfortably on my own income, and the salary is all
they can take away from me.”
“But you do not realize,” Ernest answered. “If all that I fear be so,
your private income, your principal itself, can be taken from you just
as easily as your salary.”
Father was silent for a few minutes. He was thinking deeply, and I
could see the lines of decision forming in his face. At last he spoke.
“I shall not take the vacation.” He paused again. “I shall go on with
my book.[3] You may be wrong, but whether you are wrong or right, I
shall stand by my guns.”
[3] This book, “Economics and Education,” was published in that year.
Three copies of it are extant; two at Ardis, and one at Asgard. It
dealt, in elaborate detail, with one factor in the persistence of the
established, namely, the capitalistic bias of the universities and
common schools. It was a logical and crushing indictment of the whole
system of education that developed in the minds of the students only
such ideas as were favorable to the capitalistic regime, to the
exclusion of all ideas that were inimical and subversive. The book
created a furor, and was promptly suppressed by the Oligarchy.
“All right,” Ernest said. “You are travelling the same path that Bishop
Morehouse is, and toward a similar smash-up. You’ll both be
proletarians before you’re done with it.”
The conversation turned upon the Bishop, and we got Ernest to explain
what he had been doing with him.
“He is soul-sick from the journey through hell I have given him. I took
him through the homes of a few of our factory workers. I showed him the
human wrecks cast aside by the industrial machine, and he listened to
their life stories. I took him through the slums of San Francisco, and
in drunkenness, prostitution, and criminality he learned a deeper cause
than innate depravity. He is very sick, and, worse than that, he has
got out of hand. He is too ethical. He has been too severely touched.
And, as usual, he is unpractical. He is up in the air with all kinds of
ethical delusions and plans for mission work among the cultured. He
feels it is his bounden duty to resurrect the ancient spirit of the
Church and to deliver its message to the masters. He is overwrought.
Sooner or later he is going to break out, and then there’s going to be
a smash-up. What form it will take I can’t even guess. He is a pure,
exalted soul, but he is so unpractical. He’s beyond me. I can’t keep
his feet on the earth. And through the air he is rushing on to his
Gethsemane. And after this his crucifixion. Such high souls are made
for crucifixion.”
“And you?” I asked; and beneath my smile was the seriousness of the
anxiety of love.
“Not I,” he laughed back. “I may be executed, or assassinated, but I
shall never be crucified. I am planted too solidly and stolidly upon
the earth.”
“But why should you bring about the crucifixion of the Bishop?” I
asked. “You will not deny that you are the cause of it.”
“Why should I leave one comfortable soul in comfort when there are
millions in travail and misery?” he demanded back.
“Then why did you advise father to accept the vacation?”
“Because I am not a pure, exalted soul,” was the answer. “Because I am
solid and stolid and selfish. Because I love you and, like Ruth of old,
thy people are my people. As for the Bishop, he has no daughter.
Besides, no matter how small the good, nevertheless his little
inadequate wail will be productive of some good in the revolution, and
every little bit counts.”
I could not agree with Ernest. I knew well the noble nature of Bishop
Morehouse, and I could not conceive that his voice raised for
righteousness would be no more than a little inadequate wail. But I did
not yet have the harsh facts of life at my fingers’ ends as Ernest had.
He saw clearly the futility of the Bishop’s great soul, as coming
events were soon to show as clearly to me.
It was shortly after this day that Ernest told me, as a good story, the
offer he had received from the government, namely, an appointment as
United States Commissioner of Labor. I was overjoyed. The salary was
comparatively large, and would make safe our marriage. And then it
surely was congenial work for Ernest, and, furthermore, my jealous
pride in him made me hail the proffered appointment as a recognition of
his abilities.
Then I noticed the twinkle in his eyes. He was laughing at me.
“You are not going to . . . to decline?” I quavered.
“It is a bribe,” he said. “Behind it is the fine hand of Wickson, and
behind him the hands of greater men than he. It is an old trick, old as
the class struggle is old—stealing the captains from the army of labor.
Poor betrayed labor! If you but knew how many of its leaders have been
bought out in similar ways in the past. It is cheaper, so much cheaper,
to buy a general than to fight him and his whole army. There was—but
I’ll not call any names. I’m bitter enough over it as it is. Dear
heart, I am a captain of labor. I could not sell out. If for no other
reason, the memory of my poor old father and the way he was worked to
death would prevent.”
The tears were in his eyes, this great, strong hero of mine. He never
could forgive the way his father had been malformed—the sordid lies and
the petty thefts he had been compelled to, in order to put food in his
children’s mouths.
“My father was a good man,” Ernest once said to me. “The soul of him
was good, and yet it was twisted, and maimed, and blunted by the
savagery of his life. He was made into a broken-down beast by his
masters, the arch-beasts. He should be alive to-day, like your father.
He had a strong constitution. But he was caught in the machine and
worked to death—for profit. Think of it. For profit—his life blood
transmuted into a wine-supper, or a jewelled gewgaw, or some similar
sense-orgy of the parasitic and idle rich, his masters, the
arch-beasts.”
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
When you challenge power, the system first tries to buy you off or isolate you socially before resorting to direct punishment.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when friendly offers and social pressure are actually coordinated responses to neutralize your effectiveness.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when criticism of workplace problems gets met with sudden opportunities or when speaking up leads to subtle social isolation—these aren't coincidences.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I was learning fast, but I learned not fast enough to realize then the peril of our position."
Context: Reflecting on her political awakening and the dangers she didn't yet recognize
This shows how people often underestimate the consequences of challenging power. Avis is intellectually understanding socialism but hasn't grasped how ruthlessly the system defends itself against threats.
In Today's Words:
I was figuring things out, but I had no idea how much trouble we were really in.
"The sentiment that I was a too-forward and self-assertive young woman with a mischievous penchant for officiousness and interference in other persons' affairs."
Context: Describing how the social elite characterize Avis's investigation into worker conditions
This reveals how power frames resistance - not as legitimate concern for justice, but as personal character flaws. They make her activism about her being 'difficult' rather than addressing the issues she raises.
In Today's Words:
They painted me as a troublemaker who couldn't mind her own business.
"It is not spontaneous, this disapproval of yours. It is manufactured. It is paid for."
Context: Explaining to Avis why her friends are suddenly cold to her
Ernest reveals that social pressure campaigns aren't organic but orchestrated. This is a crucial insight about how power operates - what seems like natural social consequences is actually systematic manipulation.
In Today's Words:
This isn't real disapproval - someone's organizing this campaign against you and probably paying for it.
Thematic Threads
Class Betrayal
In This Chapter
Avis faces social punishment for associating with Ernest and adopting his views, labeled as 'class treason' by her former social circle
Development
Evolved from earlier intellectual curiosity to real social consequences for crossing class lines
In Your Life:
You might experience this when your education or success creates distance from family or childhood friends who see you as 'thinking you're better than them.'
Institutional Control
In This Chapter
The university and government use bribes and social pressure rather than direct force to manage dissent
Development
Shows the sophisticated machinery behind the power Ernest has been describing theoretically
In Your Life:
You see this when your workplace offers you a 'promotion' to a different department after you've raised uncomfortable questions about company practices.
Moral Awakening
In This Chapter
Ernest predicts Bishop Morehouse will face consequences for his growing awareness of social injustice
Development
Extends the theme of consciousness-raising having real-world costs
In Your Life:
This happens when learning about systemic problems makes it impossible to stay silent, even when speaking up threatens your position.
Economic Coercion
In This Chapter
Both Dr. Cunningham and Ernest receive financial offers designed to neutralize their political activities
Development
Demonstrates how money becomes a tool of social control beyond basic survival needs
In Your Life:
You experience this when staying quiet about problems becomes tied to keeping your job, your insurance, or your family's financial security.
Social Isolation
In This Chapter
Avis notices her social circle growing cold as punishment for her association with socialist ideas
Development
Shows how social belonging gets weaponized to enforce conformity
In Your Life:
This occurs when friends or family members start treating you differently after you express views that challenge their comfort or worldview.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific tactics does the university use to pressure Dr. Cunningham, and what do the 'bribes' offered to both him and Ernest reveal about how power operates?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Ernest immediately recognize the Commissioner appointment as a trap rather than an opportunity, and what does his father's story teach him about the system's true nature?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of 'golden handcuffs' and social isolation used to silence troublemakers in workplaces, schools, or communities today?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Ernest's position, how would you weigh the risks of refusing the bribe against the potential good you could do with the position and salary?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about why most people choose compliance over resistance, and how do institutions exploit our basic human needs for security and belonging?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Own Pressure Points
Think of a situation where you witnessed or experienced pressure to stay quiet about something wrong. Map out the specific tactics used: What carrots were offered? What sticks were threatened? How was social pressure applied? Then identify what made compliance tempting and what made resistance costly.
Consider:
- •Consider both obvious bribes and subtle social pressures like exclusion from informal networks
- •Notice how the system makes resistance seem unreasonable or selfish rather than principled
- •Think about how your basic needs for income, belonging, and security were leveraged against your values
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you faced a choice between speaking up and keeping quiet. What would you do differently now, knowing how these pressure systems work?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 7: When Truth Becomes Madness
Bishop Morehouse's journey through the slums has transformed him completely. Now he's preparing to confront his wealthy congregation with uncomfortable truths about their complicity in suffering—but Ernest fears the Bishop's pure soul is heading for destruction.




