Summary
Prince Myshkin returns to St. Petersburg and visits Lebedeff, finding him in the midst of a theatrical speech to his family. The household is chaotic - Lebedeff's nephew demands money while criticizing his uncle's character, children interrupt constantly, and everyone seems to be performing rather than genuinely communicating. Lebedeff himself switches between dramatic religious pronouncements and scheming behavior, even lying about his own name 'to humble himself.' Through the nephew's accusations, we learn that Lebedeff has been playing multiple sides - helping both Myshkin and Rogojin while serving his own interests. The conversation reveals that Nastasya Filippovna has fled from Rogojin again and is hiding in St. Petersburg, terrified of both men who claim to love her. Lebedeff offers to rent Myshkin a villa in Pavlofsk, the same place where the Epanchin family has gone for the summer. This chapter masterfully shows how people use emotional manipulation, religious rhetoric, and family drama to avoid direct confrontation with uncomfortable truths. Lebedeff embodies the kind of person who creates chaos to maintain control, using his children and nephew as both audience and shields for his schemes.
Coming Up in Chapter 19
As plans form for the move to Pavlofsk, the stage is set for an inevitable collision between Myshkin's hopes and the harsh realities waiting in the summer resort where all the key players will soon converge.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
T was the beginning of June, and for a whole week the weather in St. Petersburg had been magnificent. The Epanchins had a luxurious country-house at Pavlofsk, [One of the fashionable summer resorts near St. Petersburg.] and to this spot Mrs. Epanchin determined to proceed without further delay. In a couple of days all was ready, and the family had left town. A day or two after this removal to Pavlofsk, Prince Muishkin arrived in St. Petersburg by the morning train from Moscow. No one met him; but, as he stepped out of the carriage, he suddenly became aware of two strangely glowing eyes fixed upon him from among the crowd that met the train. On endeavouring to re-discover the eyes, and see to whom they belonged, he could find nothing to guide him. It must have been a hallucination. But the disagreeable impression remained, and without this, the prince was sad and thoughtful already, and seemed to be much preoccupied. His cab took him to a small and bad hotel near the Litaynaya. Here he engaged a couple of rooms, dark and badly furnished. He washed and changed, and hurriedly left the hotel again, as though anxious to waste no time. Anyone who now saw him for the first time since he left Petersburg would judge that he had improved vastly so far as his exterior was concerned. His clothes certainly were very different; they were more fashionable, perhaps even too much so, and anyone inclined to mockery might have found something to smile at in his appearance. But what is there that people will not smile at? The prince took a cab and drove to a street near the Nativity, where he soon discovered the house he was seeking. It was a small wooden villa, and he was struck by its attractive and clean appearance; it stood in a pleasant little garden, full of flowers. The windows looking on the street were open, and the sound of a voice, reading aloud or making a speech, came through them. It rose at times to a shout, and was interrupted occasionally by bursts of laughter. Prince Muishkin entered the court-yard, and ascended the steps. A cook with her sleeves turned up to the elbows opened the door. The visitor asked if Mr. Lebedeff were at home. “He is in there,” said she, pointing to the salon. The room had a blue wall-paper, and was well, almost pretentiously, furnished, with its round table, its divan, and its bronze clock under a glass shade. There was a narrow pier-glass against the wall, and a chandelier adorned with lustres hung by a bronze chain from the ceiling. When the prince entered, Lebedeff was standing in the middle of the room, his back to the door. He was in his shirt-sleeves, on account of the extreme heat, and he seemed to have just reached the peroration of his speech, and was impressively beating his breast. His audience consisted of a youth of about fifteen...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Performing Crisis - How Chaos Becomes Control
Creating constant emotional drama to avoid accountability while maintaining power over others through manufactured chaos.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone creates constant drama to avoid accountability and maintain control over others.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's life seems perpetually chaotic, and ask yourself what they might be avoiding through the constant crisis.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Pavlovsk
A fashionable summer resort near St. Petersburg where wealthy Russians escaped the city heat. These seasonal migrations created intense social dynamics as families competed for status in a smaller, more concentrated setting.
Modern Usage:
Like wealthy families today who have summer homes in the Hamptons or Martha's Vineyard - same social pressures, just different locations.
Theatrical manipulation
Using dramatic emotional displays and religious language to control others and avoid accountability. Lebedeff performs grief, humility, and outrage as tools to get what he wants while making others feel guilty for questioning him.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who use crying, anger, or 'poor me' stories to shut down criticism or get their way in relationships and workplaces.
Playing all sides
Secretly helping multiple people with conflicting interests while serving your own agenda. Lebedeff assists both Myshkin and Rogojin in their pursuit of Nastasya while positioning himself to benefit regardless of who wins.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who tells different friends different versions of the same story, or a coworker who gossips to everyone while claiming to be loyal to each person.
Family as audience
Using family members, especially children, as props in emotional performances. Lebedeff involves his household in his dramatic speeches, making them witnesses to his supposed virtue and suffering.
Modern Usage:
Parents who argue in front of kids to make the other parent look bad, or people who post family drama on social media for sympathy.
Chaos as control
Creating constant drama and confusion to maintain power and avoid direct confrontation. When everything is always in crisis, no one can pin down what's really happening or hold you accountable.
Modern Usage:
People who always have some emergency or crisis that prevents them from keeping commitments or having honest conversations.
False humility
Performing self-degradation as a form of manipulation. Lebedeff claims to lie about his own name 'to humble himself' but really uses this supposed virtue to justify his deceptions.
Modern Usage:
Social media posts like 'I'm so ugly' fishing for compliments, or people who constantly put themselves down so others will reassure them.
Characters in This Chapter
Prince Myshkin
Protagonist returning to chaos
Returns to St. Petersburg improved in appearance but still naive about the web of manipulation surrounding him. He's walking back into the same toxic dynamics he left, but now everyone has had time to scheme.
Modern Equivalent:
The good-hearted person who keeps giving toxic people second chances
Lebedeff
Manipulative schemer
Masters the art of emotional manipulation, switching between religious pronouncements and scheming behavior. He creates constant household drama while positioning himself as both victim and helper to everyone.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who always has drama but somehow makes money off everyone else's problems
Lebedeff's nephew
Truth-telling accuser
Openly calls out his uncle's manipulative behavior and demands money, serving as the voice that says what everyone else is thinking. His accusations reveal how Lebedeff operates behind the scenes.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who finally says what everyone's been thinking about the toxic relative
Nastasya Filippovna
The hunted woman
Though not physically present, she haunts the chapter as someone fleeing from the men who claim to love her. Her terror drives much of the plot and reveals how 'love' can become pursuit and control.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman trying to escape controlling relationships but finding nowhere safe to go
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He suddenly became aware of two strangely glowing eyes fixed upon him from among the crowd"
Context: Myshkin arrives at the train station and senses he's being watched
This creates immediate tension and suggests Myshkin is walking back into danger. The 'glowing eyes' imagery makes the watcher seem predatory, not protective.
In Today's Words:
He got that creepy feeling someone was staring at him from the crowd
"I tell lies in order to humble myself"
Context: When confronted about lying about his own name
This perfectly captures how manipulative people twist virtue into justification for bad behavior. He's making dishonesty sound spiritual and noble.
In Today's Words:
I lie because it makes me a better person
"You help everybody and everybody deceives you"
Context: Describing his uncle's relationship with both Myshkin and Rogojin
This reveals how Lebedeff presents himself as helpful while actually serving his own interests. He's not being deceived - he's playing both sides deliberately.
In Today's Words:
You act like you're helping everyone but really you're working every angle
Thematic Threads
Deception
In This Chapter
Lebedeff lies about his own name and plays multiple sides while presenting himself as humble and religious
Development
Evolving from earlier chapters where characters wore social masks - now showing active manipulation
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in people who constantly reinvent their story depending on their audience
Performance
In This Chapter
Everyone in Lebedeff's household performs roles - he's the dramatic patriarch, nephew is the righteous accuser, children are the interrupting chorus
Development
Building on themes of social performance, now showing how families can become theater troupes
In Your Life:
You see this in families where everyone has assigned roles they perform instead of being authentic
Control
In This Chapter
Lebedeff maintains power through chaos, using drama and religious rhetoric to deflect accountability
Development
Deepening from earlier power dynamics to show how manipulation can masquerade as helplessness
In Your Life:
You might experience this with people who control situations by appearing to be out of control
Class
In This Chapter
The nephew's accusations reveal how Lebedeff exploits class differences, serving both wealthy Myshkin and Rogojin while maintaining his servant status
Development
Continuing exploration of how class position enables certain types of manipulation
In Your Life:
You see this in workplaces where people use their position to play different groups against each other
Fear
In This Chapter
Nastasya Filippovna's terror drives her into hiding, while Lebedeff's schemes are motivated by financial insecurity
Development
Showing how fear creates the conditions that manipulators exploit
In Your Life:
You might recognize how your own fears make you vulnerable to people who offer false solutions
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What strategies does Lebedeff use to control the conversation when his nephew confronts him about his schemes?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Lebedeff create constant drama in his household, and how does this serve his interests?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen people use emotional chaos or family drama to avoid accountability in your own life?
application • medium - 4
How would you respond differently than Prince Myshkin when dealing with someone who weaponizes drama for control?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how people use performance and manipulation to maintain power in relationships?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Drama Pattern
Think of someone in your life who always seems to be in crisis or creates dramatic situations. Map out their pattern: What triggers the drama? Who gets pulled in? What does the person avoid dealing with while everyone focuses on their latest crisis? Write down three specific examples of this pattern playing out.
Consider:
- •Notice how the timing of crises often coincides with accountability moments
- •Observe who gets cast in supporting roles during these dramatic episodes
- •Consider what legitimate concerns get buried under the emotional chaos
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you either used drama to avoid a difficult conversation, or when someone used it on you. How did you recognize what was really happening, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 19: The Knife Between Friends
Moving forward, we'll examine toxic obsession masquerades as love and destroys both people involved, and understand some people choose relationships they know will harm them. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.