Summary
Dante faces his most crucial examination yet as Saint Peter himself tests his understanding of faith. Beatrice introduces Dante to the apostle, requesting that he be questioned about the very foundation of Christian belief. Like a nervous student before a master, Dante prepares his arguments carefully, knowing this moment will determine his worthiness to continue his journey. When Peter asks the fundamental question - 'What is faith?' - Dante responds with the classical definition: faith is the substance of things hoped for and the proof of things not seen. But Peter pushes deeper, asking where this faith comes from and how Dante knows it's true. Dante explains that his faith flows from Scripture - the Old and New Testaments - and that the greatest proof of Christianity's truth is how it transformed the world without worldly power. He points out that even Peter himself went forth in poverty and hunger to plant the seeds of faith that grew into the Church. The examination becomes increasingly personal as Dante must declare his specific beliefs: one eternal God who moves all of heaven while remaining unmoved, existing as three persons in one essence. His answers satisfy Peter completely, and the apostle embraces him with benediction and song. This scene represents more than theological debate - it's about having the courage to stand by your convictions when questioned by authority, and the ability to explain not just what you believe, but why you believe it.
Coming Up in Chapter 92
Having passed the test of faith, Dante reflects on his long journey and expresses hope that his sacred poem might one day overcome the political forces that exiled him from Florence. The poet dreams of returning home in triumph.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1164 words)
“O ye! in chosen fellowship advanc’d To the great supper of the blessed Lamb, Whereon who feeds hath every wish fulfill’d! If to this man through God’s grace be vouchsaf’d Foretaste of that, which from your table falls, Or ever death his fated term prescribe; Be ye not heedless of his urgent will; But may some influence of your sacred dews Sprinkle him. Of the fount ye alway drink, Whence flows what most he craves.” Beatrice spake, And the rejoicing spirits, like to spheres On firm-set poles revolving, trail’d a blaze Of comet splendour; and as wheels, that wind Their circles in the horologe, so work The stated rounds, that to th’ observant eye The first seems still, and, as it flew, the last; E’en thus their carols weaving variously, They by the measure pac’d, or swift, or slow, Made me to rate the riches of their joy. From that, which I did note in beauty most Excelling, saw I issue forth a flame So bright, as none was left more goodly there. Round Beatrice thrice it wheel’d about, With so divine a song, that fancy’s ear Records it not; and the pen passeth on And leaves a blank: for that our mortal speech, Nor e’en the inward shaping of the brain, Hath colours fine enough to trace such folds. “O saintly sister mine! thy prayer devout Is with so vehement affection urg’d, Thou dost unbind me from that beauteous sphere.” Such were the accents towards my lady breath’d From that blest ardour, soon as it was stay’d: To whom she thus: “O everlasting light Of him, within whose mighty grasp our Lord Did leave the keys, which of this wondrous bliss He bare below! tent this man, as thou wilt, With lighter probe or deep, touching the faith, By the which thou didst on the billows walk. If he in love, in hope, and in belief, Be steadfast, is not hid from thee: for thou Hast there thy ken, where all things are beheld In liveliest portraiture. But since true faith Has peopled this fair realm with citizens, Meet is, that to exalt its glory more, Thou in his audience shouldst thereof discourse.” Like to the bachelor, who arms himself, And speaks not, till the master have propos’d The question, to approve, and not to end it; So I, in silence, arm’d me, while she spake, Summoning up each argument to aid; As was behooveful for such questioner, And such profession: “As good Christian ought, Declare thee, What is faith?” Whereat I rais’d My forehead to the light, whence this had breath’d, Then turn’d to Beatrice, and in her looks Approval met, that from their inmost fount I should unlock the waters. “May the grace, That giveth me the captain of the church For confessor,” said I, “vouchsafe to me Apt utterance for my thoughts!” then added: “Sire! E’en as set down by the unerring style Of thy dear brother, who with thee conspir’d To bring Rome in unto the way of life, Faith of things hop’d is substance, and the proof Of things not seen; and herein doth consist Methinks its essence,”—” Rightly hast thou deem’d,” Was answer’d: “if thou well discern, why first He hath defin’d it, substance, and then proof.” “The deep things,” I replied, “which here I scan Distinctly, are below from mortal eye So hidden, they have in belief alone Their being, on which credence hope sublime Is built; and therefore substance it intends. And inasmuch as we must needs infer From such belief our reasoning, all respect To other view excluded, hence of proof Th’ intention is deriv’d.” Forthwith I heard: “If thus, whate’er by learning men attain, Were understood, the sophist would want room To exercise his wit.” So breath’d the flame Of love: then added: “Current is the coin Thou utter’st, both in weight and in alloy. But tell me, if thou hast it in thy purse.” “Even so glittering and so round,” said I, “I not a whit misdoubt of its assay.” Next issued from the deep imbosom’d splendour: “Say, whence the costly jewel, on the which Is founded every virtue, came to thee.” “The flood,” I answer’d, “from the Spirit of God Rain’d down upon the ancient bond and new,— Here is the reas’ning, that convinceth me So feelingly, each argument beside Seems blunt and forceless in comparison.” Then heard I: “Wherefore holdest thou that each, The elder proposition and the new, Which so persuade thee, are the voice of heav’n?” “The works, that follow’d, evidence their truth; “ I answer’d: “Nature did not make for these The iron hot, or on her anvil mould them.” “Who voucheth to thee of the works themselves, Was the reply, “that they in very deed Are that they purport? None hath sworn so to thee.” “That all the world,” said I, “should have bee turn’d To Christian, and no miracle been wrought, Would in itself be such a miracle, The rest were not an hundredth part so great. E’en thou wentst forth in poverty and hunger To set the goodly plant, that from the vine, It once was, now is grown unsightly bramble.” That ended, through the high celestial court Resounded all the spheres. “Praise we one God!” In song of most unearthly melody. And when that Worthy thus, from branch to branch, Examining, had led me, that we now Approach’d the topmost bough, he straight resum’d; “The grace, that holds sweet dalliance with thy soul, So far discreetly hath thy lips unclos’d That, whatsoe’er has past them, I commend. Behooves thee to express, what thou believ’st, The next, and whereon thy belief hath grown.” “O saintly sire and spirit!” I began, “Who seest that, which thou didst so believe, As to outstrip feet younger than thine own, Toward the sepulchre? thy will is here, That I the tenour of my creed unfold; And thou the cause of it hast likewise ask’d. And I reply: I in one God believe, One sole eternal Godhead, of whose love All heav’n is mov’d, himself unmov’d the while. Nor demonstration physical alone, Or more intelligential and abstruse, Persuades me to this faith; but from that truth It cometh to me rather, which is shed Through Moses, the rapt Prophets, and the Psalms. The Gospel, and that ye yourselves did write, When ye were gifted of the Holy Ghost. In three eternal Persons I believe, Essence threefold and one, mysterious league Of union absolute, which, many a time, The word of gospel lore upon my mind Imprints: and from this germ, this firstling spark, The lively flame dilates, and like heav’n’s star Doth glitter in me.” As the master hears, Well pleas’d, and then enfoldeth in his arms The servant, who hath joyful tidings brought, And having told the errand keeps his peace; Thus benediction uttering with song Soon as my peace I held, compass’d me thrice The apostolic radiance, whose behest Had op’d lips; so well their answer pleas’d.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Standing Your Ground
Authority figures respect those who can articulate not just what they believe, but why they believe it with clear reasoning and evidence.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to transform interrogation into validation by preparing thoughtful responses to challenging questions.
Practice This Today
Next time someone questions your judgment at work or home, pause and ask yourself: What exactly do I believe here, and what evidence supports it?
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Apostolic Examination
A formal test of religious knowledge and faith conducted by church authorities, particularly the apostles in Dante's Paradise. This represents the ultimate spiritual pop quiz - being questioned by those who literally walked with Christ about the fundamentals of belief.
Modern Usage:
Like when you have to defend your qualifications to the CEO, or explain your parenting choices to your own parents - facing judgment from the ultimate authority figure.
Faith as Substance
The theological concept that faith isn't just wishful thinking, but the actual foundation and evidence for spiritual truths we can't physically see. It's treating belief as something solid and real, not just hope or opinion.
Modern Usage:
When we act on gut instincts about people or situations without concrete proof - our faith in our judgment becomes the 'substance' we build decisions on.
Trinity
The Christian doctrine that God exists as three persons (Father, Son, Holy Spirit) in one divine essence. For medieval Christians, this was the central mystery of faith - how one God could be three distinct persons simultaneously.
Modern Usage:
Like how someone can be simultaneously a parent, employee, and community volunteer - different roles, same person, but infinitely more complex.
Scripture as Authority
The belief that the Bible serves as the ultimate source of truth and the foundation for all religious knowledge. In Dante's time, questioning this was heretical - the written word was literally the word of God.
Modern Usage:
Like citing the employee handbook, the Constitution, or your lease agreement - appealing to the written rules everyone agreed to follow.
Apostolic Poverty
The idea that Christ's disciples deliberately chose lives of material hardship to spread their message, proving their sincerity through sacrifice. Their lack of worldly power made their success more miraculous.
Modern Usage:
When grassroots movements or nonprofit leaders gain influence despite having no money or connections - their success seems more authentic because they started with nothing.
Benediction
A formal blessing given by a religious authority, often marking approval or completion of a spiritual milestone. It's both a reward for passing the test and protection for the journey ahead.
Modern Usage:
Like getting your parents' blessing for a major life decision, or a mentor's endorsement - official approval that opens doors and provides emotional support.
Characters in This Chapter
Saint Peter
Divine examiner and gatekeeper
As the apostle who holds the keys to heaven, Peter conducts Dante's examination on faith. He asks increasingly challenging questions, testing not just knowledge but deep understanding and personal conviction.
Modern Equivalent:
The tough but fair interviewer who really wants to see if you know your stuff
Beatrice
Advocate and guide
She formally requests that Peter examine Dante, essentially vouching for him and asking the apostle to test his worthiness. She acts as both supporter and the one who puts Dante in this challenging position.
Modern Equivalent:
The mentor who recommends you for the promotion but knows you'll have to prove yourself
Dante
Student being tested
He must articulate his deepest beliefs under pressure, moving from textbook definitions to personal testimony. His nervousness shows even spiritual giants feel intimidated when facing ultimate authority.
Modern Equivalent:
The nervous job candidate who knows their stuff but still gets anxious when the big boss asks the hard questions
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Faith is the substance of things hoped for and the proof of things not seen"
Context: His initial answer when Peter asks him to define faith
This is the classic biblical definition, but Dante delivers it like a student reciting from memory. It shows he knows the textbook answer, but Peter will push him to go deeper and make it personal.
In Today's Words:
Faith is what makes our hopes feel real and proves things we can't actually see
"From Scripture comes the faith that fills me so"
Context: When Peter asks where his faith originates
Dante grounds his belief in written authority rather than personal experience or church tradition. This reflects medieval emphasis on Scripture as the ultimate source of truth, but also shows intellectual rather than emotional faith.
In Today's Words:
I believe because it's written in the Bible
"You went forth poor and hungry to plant the good seed"
Context: Explaining to Peter how Christianity's humble origins prove its divine nature
Dante argues that the apostles' success despite their poverty and lack of worldly power proves Christianity's truth. It's a clever argument - if they had no earthly advantages, their success must be supernatural.
In Today's Words:
You guys started with nothing and still changed the world - that has to be a miracle
Thematic Threads
Authority
In This Chapter
Saint Peter's examination represents the ultimate authority test—being questioned by the founder of the Church himself
Development
Evolved from earlier encounters with various authorities in Hell and Purgatory to this highest-stakes validation
In Your Life:
You face authority tests whenever bosses, doctors, teachers, or officials question your judgment or decisions
Preparation
In This Chapter
Dante carefully prepares his arguments like a student before an exam, showing respect for the process
Development
Builds on his growing wisdom throughout the journey, now applying it under pressure
In Your Life:
Success in important conversations depends on thinking through your position beforehand, not winging it
Faith
In This Chapter
Faith is examined not as blind belief but as reasoned conviction with logical foundations
Development
Represents the culmination of Dante's spiritual growth from doubt to confident understanding
In Your Life:
Whatever you believe in—your values, goals, or principles—you need to understand why you believe it
Validation
In This Chapter
Peter's embrace and blessing shows how proper preparation and articulation earn respect from authority
Development
First major validation Dante receives from a figure of ultimate spiritual authority
In Your Life:
When you can defend your positions thoughtfully, even critics often become allies
Growth
In This Chapter
Dante transforms from passive observer to active participant who can hold his own in crucial conversations
Development
Shows his evolution from the lost man in the dark wood to someone worthy of Paradise
In Your Life:
Personal growth means moving from reacting to situations to confidently engaging with them
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific questions did Saint Peter ask Dante, and how did Dante prepare himself before answering?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Peter push beyond Dante's first answer about faith to ask 'How do you know this is true?' What is he really testing?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about job interviews, parent-teacher conferences, or medical appointments - where do you see this same pattern of authority figures testing whether you've really thought through your positions?
application • medium - 4
If you had to defend an important belief or decision to someone in authority over you, how would you prepare? What would make your argument stronger?
application • deep - 5
What does this scene reveal about the difference between having opinions and having convictions? Why does preparation matter more when stakes are higher?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Defend Your Position
Think of one important belief, decision, or position you hold that someone in authority might question - maybe your parenting approach, work method, or life choice. Write out three things: what you believe, why you believe it, and what evidence supports your position. Then practice explaining it in 2-3 clear sentences, as if facing a skeptical authority figure.
Consider:
- •Authority figures respect preparation more than passion - emotion without reasoning often backfires
- •Your evidence can include personal experience, research, or logical reasoning - but it needs to be specific
- •The goal isn't to win an argument but to demonstrate you've done the thinking required for respect
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you were questioned by someone in authority and either handled it well or wish you had handled it differently. What would you do now with what you've learned from Dante's example?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 92: The Test of Hope
The coming pages reveal to articulate your deepest hopes when questioned by authority, and teach us being tested on your beliefs can strengthen rather than weaken them. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.
