Summary
Dante and Virgil continue their climb up Mount Purgatory, but now Virgil tells Dante he must proceed more independently - each person must navigate their own path using whatever tools they have. As they walk, Virgil instructs Dante to look down at the ground, where intricate carvings tell stories of pride's downfall throughout history. These aren't just decorative - they're lessons carved in stone. Dante sees famous figures who fell because of their arrogance: Lucifer cast from heaven, giants who tried to build the Tower of Babel, Niobe who boasted about her children, and many others who let pride destroy them. The artistry is so realistic that the dead look dead and the living seem alive. This isn't punishment - it's education. By studying these examples, Dante learns to recognize pride's patterns and dangers. An angel appears to guide them to the next level, and as they climb the stairs, Dante feels surprisingly light. Virgil explains this happens because one of the seven marks of sin has been erased from Dante's forehead - he's literally carrying less spiritual weight. The chapter shows how confronting our flaws and learning from others' mistakes makes our journey through life easier. Sometimes we need to look backward and downward to understand how to move forward and upward.
Coming Up in Chapter 47
Dante and Virgil reach the second level of Purgatory, where a new terrace awaits with its own lessons and challenges. What sin will they encounter next, and how will it test Dante's growing wisdom?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1019 words)
With equal pace as oxen in the yoke, I with that laden spirit journey’d on Long as the mild instructor suffer’d me; But when he bade me quit him, and proceed (For “here,” said he, “behooves with sail and oars Each man, as best he may, push on his bark”), Upright, as one dispos’d for speed, I rais’d My body, still in thought submissive bow’d. I now my leader’s track not loth pursued; And each had shown how light we far’d along When thus he warn’d me: “Bend thine eyesight down: For thou to ease the way shall find it good To ruminate the bed beneath thy feet.” As in memorial of the buried, drawn Upon earth-level tombs, the sculptur’d form Of what was once, appears (at sight whereof Tears often stream forth by remembrance wak’d, Whose sacred stings the piteous only feel), So saw I there, but with more curious skill Of portraiture o’erwrought, whate’er of space From forth the mountain stretches. On one part Him I beheld, above all creatures erst Created noblest, light’ning fall from heaven: On th’ other side with bolt celestial pierc’d Briareus: cumb’ring earth he lay through dint Of mortal ice-stroke. The Thymbraean god With Mars, I saw, and Pallas, round their sire, Arm’d still, and gazing on the giant’s limbs Strewn o’er th’ ethereal field. Nimrod I saw: At foot of the stupendous work he stood, As if bewilder’d, looking on the crowd Leagued in his proud attempt on Sennaar’s plain. O Niobe! in what a trance of woe Thee I beheld, upon that highway drawn, Sev’n sons on either side thee slain! O Saul! How ghastly didst thou look! on thine own sword Expiring in Gilboa, from that hour Ne’er visited with rain from heav’n or dew! O fond Arachne! thee I also saw Half spider now in anguish crawling up Th’ unfinish’d web thou weaved’st to thy bane! O Rehoboam! here thy shape doth seem Louring no more defiance! but fear-smote With none to chase him in his chariot whirl’d. Was shown beside upon the solid floor How dear Alcmaeon forc’d his mother rate That ornament in evil hour receiv’d: How in the temple on Sennacherib fell His sons, and how a corpse they left him there. Was shown the scath and cruel mangling made By Tomyris on Cyrus, when she cried: “Blood thou didst thirst for, take thy fill of blood!” Was shown how routed in the battle fled Th’ Assyrians, Holofernes slain, and e’en The relics of the carnage. Troy I mark’d In ashes and in caverns. Oh! how fall’n, How abject, Ilion, was thy semblance there! What master of the pencil or the style Had trac’d the shades and lines, that might have made The subtlest workman wonder? Dead the dead, The living seem’d alive; with clearer view His eye beheld not who beheld the truth, Than mine what I did tread on, while I went Low bending. Now swell out; and with stiff necks Pass on, ye sons of Eve! veil not your looks, Lest they descry the evil of your path! I noted not (so busied was my thought) How much we now had circled of the mount, And of his course yet more the sun had spent, When he, who with still wakeful caution went, Admonish’d: “Raise thou up thy head: for know Time is not now for slow suspense. Behold That way an angel hasting towards us! Lo Where duly the sixth handmaid doth return From service on the day. Wear thou in look And gesture seemly grace of reverent awe, That gladly he may forward us aloft. Consider that this day ne’er dawns again.” Time’s loss he had so often warn’d me ’gainst, I could not miss the scope at which he aim’d. The goodly shape approach’d us, snowy white In vesture, and with visage casting streams Of tremulous lustre like the matin star. His arms he open’d, then his wings; and spake: “Onward: the steps, behold! are near; and now Th’ ascent is without difficulty gain’d.” A scanty few are they, who when they hear Such tidings, hasten. O ye race of men Though born to soar, why suffer ye a wind So slight to baffle ye? He led us on Where the rock parted; here against my front Did beat his wings, then promis’d I should fare In safety on my way. As to ascend That steep, upon whose brow the chapel stands (O’er Rubaconte, looking lordly down On the well-guided city,) up the right Th’ impetuous rise is broken by the steps Carv’d in that old and simple age, when still The registry and label rested safe; Thus is th’ acclivity reliev’d, which here Precipitous from the other circuit falls: But on each hand the tall cliff presses close. As ent’ring there we turn’d, voices, in strain Ineffable, sang: “Blessed are the poor In spirit.” Ah how far unlike to these The straits of hell; here songs to usher us, There shrieks of woe! We climb the holy stairs: And lighter to myself by far I seem’d Than on the plain before, whence thus I spake: “Say, master, of what heavy thing have I Been lighten’d, that scarce aught the sense of toil Affects me journeying?” He in few replied: “When sin’s broad characters, that yet remain Upon thy temples, though well nigh effac’d, Shall be, as one is, all clean razed out, Then shall thy feet by heartiness of will Be so o’ercome, they not alone shall feel No sense of labour, but delight much more Shall wait them urg’d along their upward way.” Then like to one, upon whose head is plac’d Somewhat he deems not of but from the becks Of others as they pass him by; his hand Lends therefore help to’ assure him, searches, finds, And well performs such office as the eye Wants power to execute: so stretching forth The fingers of my right hand, did I find Six only of the letters, which his sword Who bare the keys had trac’d upon my brow. The leader, as he mark’d mine action, smil’d.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Looking Down to Move Up
Learning from others' failures and studying negative examples to develop pattern recognition and avoid repeating destructive behaviors.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to extract valuable lessons from others' mistakes without judgment or shame.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone at work fails or struggles—instead of judging, ask yourself what pattern led to that outcome and how you can avoid it.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Purgatory
A place of cleansing and learning between punishment and paradise. In Dante's vision, it's a mountain where souls work through their character flaws before reaching heaven. Unlike hell, this is about growth and improvement.
Modern Usage:
We use this concept when talking about any difficult but temporary situation that helps us grow - like rehab, therapy, or working a tough job to build skills.
Pride (Superbia)
The deadliest sin in medieval thinking - believing you're better than others or don't need help. Dante shows it as the root of all other character flaws. It's the first sin souls must overcome on their spiritual journey.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this in people who refuse to ask for help, take credit for others' work, or think they're above following rules that apply to everyone else.
Exempla
Teaching stories carved into the ground showing examples of pride's downfall throughout history. These visual lessons help souls learn by seeing patterns of how arrogance destroys people.
Modern Usage:
Like cautionary tales in movies, documentaries about failed businesses, or those 'What Not to Do' training videos at work.
Spiritual Independence
The moment when Virgil tells Dante he must navigate more on his own - each person must use their own tools to progress. You can have guides, but ultimately you're responsible for your own growth.
Modern Usage:
Like when a mentor tells you 'I've taught you what I can, now you need to figure out your own path' - in careers, relationships, or personal development.
Tower of Babel
Biblical story of people trying to build a tower to heaven out of pride, but God scattered them by confusing their languages. Symbol of how arrogance leads to failure and division.
Modern Usage:
We reference this when talking about overly ambitious projects that fail because of ego - like tech companies that crash, or politicians who overreach.
Lightening of Burden
As Dante overcomes pride, an angel erases one of seven marks from his forehead, making him literally feel lighter. Confronting our flaws actually makes life easier, not harder.
Modern Usage:
Like how admitting you have a problem and working on it feels scary at first, but then you feel relief - whether it's debt, addiction, or toxic relationships.
Characters in This Chapter
Dante
Protagonist/Student
Learning to navigate more independently while studying examples of pride's destruction. He's literally becoming lighter as he works through his character flaws and gains wisdom.
Modern Equivalent:
The person in therapy learning to recognize their own patterns
Virgil
Mentor/Guide
Tells Dante he must start navigating more on his own, but still provides guidance about looking down at the carved examples. He's teaching independence while still supporting.
Modern Equivalent:
The supervisor who starts giving you more responsibility but is still there for advice
Lucifer
Cautionary Example
Shown in the carvings as the ultimate example of pride - the most beautiful angel who fell from heaven because he thought he was equal to God.
Modern Equivalent:
The star employee who got fired because they thought they were irreplaceable
Nimrod
Cautionary Example
Depicted as confused and bewildered among the ruins of the Tower of Babel, showing how pride leads to isolation and failure of grand schemes.
Modern Equivalent:
The CEO standing in the ruins of their failed company, wondering how it all went wrong
Niobe
Cautionary Example
A mother who boasted that her children were better than the gods' children, leading to their destruction. Shows how pride can hurt the people we love most.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent whose bragging and competitiveness ends up damaging their kids
Key Quotes & Analysis
"here behooves with sail and oars each man, as best he may, push on his bark"
Context: Virgil tells Dante he must start navigating more independently
This marks a crucial transition where Dante must take more responsibility for his own spiritual journey. Virgil acknowledges that while guidance helps, ultimately each person must use whatever tools they have to move forward.
In Today's Words:
From here on out, you've got to figure out your own way forward using whatever skills you've got.
"Bend thine eyesight down: for thou to ease the way shall find it good to ruminate the bed beneath thy feet"
Context: Virgil instructs Dante to look at the carved examples on the ground
Sometimes we need to look backward and study others' mistakes to understand how to move forward. The carved examples aren't just decoration - they're practical education for the journey ahead.
In Today's Words:
Look down and really think about these examples - studying what went wrong for others will make your own path easier.
"Tears often stream forth by remembrance waked, whose sacred stings the piteous only feel"
Context: Describing how the carved figures are so realistic they evoke real emotion
True learning happens when we feel genuine empathy for others' suffering. Only people capable of compassion can learn from these cautionary tales - pride blocks our ability to learn from others.
In Today's Words:
Looking at these stories hits you right in the feelings, but only if you're the kind of person who actually cares about others.
Thematic Threads
Pride
In This Chapter
Pride is shown as a universal destroyer through historical examples—from Lucifer to everyday people who let arrogance ruin them
Development
Introduced here as the first sin Dante must confront and overcome
In Your Life:
You might see this when you refuse to ask for help, dismiss others' advice, or believe you're above certain consequences.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Growth literally makes Dante lighter—removing character flaws reduces the weight he carries through life
Development
Building on earlier themes of transformation, now showing growth has measurable effects
In Your Life:
You might notice feeling lighter and more energetic when you drop toxic behaviors or negative thought patterns.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
The carved examples show how social status and expectations led people to destructive pride
Development
Expanding from individual struggles to show how social pressures create character flaws
In Your Life:
You might feel pressure to appear perfect at work or maintain an image that exhausts you.
Identity
In This Chapter
Dante's identity is literally changing as marks are erased from his forehead—he's becoming someone new
Development
Continuing the journey of self-discovery, now showing concrete transformation
In Your Life:
You might notice your sense of self shifting as you outgrow old habits and develop new strengths.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Virgil teaches Dante to be more independent while still providing guidance—healthy mentorship
Development
Evolving from dependency to guided independence in the mentor-student relationship
In Your Life:
You might recognize when someone is helping you grow versus enabling your weaknesses.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Virgil tell Dante to look down at the ground instead of up toward their destination?
analysis • surface - 2
What makes the carved stories of pride's downfall effective teaching tools rather than just warnings?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today studying failure to avoid repeating it - in work, relationships, or other areas?
application • medium - 4
How would you create your own 'failure study system' in an area where you want to improve?
application • deep - 5
Why does learning from others' mistakes literally make us feel lighter, as Dante experiences?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Create Your Pattern Recognition Map
Choose one area where you want to improve (work relationships, money management, health habits, etc.). Research three specific examples of people who struggled in this area - could be public figures, people you know, or even yourself in the past. For each example, identify the warning signs that appeared before the major problems hit. Look for patterns across all three examples.
Consider:
- •Focus on behaviors and warning signs, not judging the people involved
- •Look for patterns that repeat across different examples - these are your early warning system
- •Consider how you might recognize these same patterns in your own life before they become problems
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you learned something valuable by studying someone else's mistake. How did that knowledge change your own choices or behavior?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 47: The Terrace of Envy
The coming pages reveal envy blinds us to our own blessings and others' humanity, and teach us taking joy in others' failures corrupts our own happiness. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.