Summary
Dante encounters souls on the first terrace of Purgatory, where the prideful are purged of their sin by carrying enormous stones on their backs. These souls recite the Lord's Prayer together, modified to reflect their spiritual journey. The weight they bear mirrors how pride weighs us down in life, making every step a struggle. Dante meets Omberto, a nobleman whose arrogance destroyed his entire family line. Omberto's story reveals how unchecked pride doesn't just harm the individual - it ripples out to damage everyone connected to them. Next, Dante encounters Oderigi, a famous illuminator who speaks about the fleeting nature of artistic fame. Oderigi explains how one artist replaces another in public memory, using examples of painters and poets whose reputations have already faded. His words cut to the heart of human ambition: we chase recognition that will inevitably disappear. The chapter also introduces Provenzano, a powerful ruler who earned his place in Purgatory through a single act of humility - he publicly begged for money to save a friend's life, abandoning his dignity for love. This powerful scene shows that pride isn't just about thinking you're better than others - it's about forgetting our shared humanity and interconnectedness. The souls here teach that true greatness comes not from being above others, but from serving them.
Coming Up in Chapter 46
Dante prepares to leave these humbled souls behind and continue his climb up the mountain. But the journey ahead will test his own relationship with pride and ambition as he moves toward the next terrace of purification.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1116 words)
O thou Almighty Father, who dost make The heavens thy dwelling, not in bounds confin’d, But that with love intenser there thou view’st Thy primal effluence, hallow’d be thy name: Join each created being to extol Thy might, for worthy humblest thanks and praise Is thy blest Spirit. May thy kingdom’s peace Come unto us; for we, unless it come, With all our striving thither tend in vain. As of their will the angels unto thee Tender meet sacrifice, circling thy throne With loud hosannas, so of theirs be done By saintly men on earth. Grant us this day Our daily manna, without which he roams Through this rough desert retrograde, who most Toils to advance his steps. As we to each Pardon the evil done us, pardon thou Benign, and of our merit take no count. ’Gainst the old adversary prove thou not Our virtue easily subdu’d; but free From his incitements and defeat his wiles. This last petition, dearest Lord! is made Not for ourselves, since that were needless now, But for their sakes who after us remain.” Thus for themselves and us good speed imploring, Those spirits went beneath a weight like that We sometimes feel in dreams, all, sore beset, But with unequal anguish, wearied all, Round the first circuit, purging as they go, The world’s gross darkness off: In our behalf If there vows still be offer’d, what can here For them be vow’d and done by such, whose wills Have root of goodness in them? Well beseems That we should help them wash away the stains They carried hence, that so made pure and light, They may spring upward to the starry spheres. “Ah! so may mercy-temper’d justice rid Your burdens speedily, that ye have power To stretch your wing, which e’en to your desire Shall lift you, as ye show us on which hand Toward the ladder leads the shortest way. And if there be more passages than one, Instruct us of that easiest to ascend; For this man who comes with me, and bears yet The charge of fleshly raiment Adam left him, Despite his better will but slowly mounts.” From whom the answer came unto these words, Which my guide spake, appear’d not; but ’twas said “Along the bank to rightward come with us, And ye shall find a pass that mocks not toil Of living man to climb: and were it not That I am hinder’d by the rock, wherewith This arrogant neck is tam’d, whence needs I stoop My visage to the ground, him, who yet lives, Whose name thou speak’st not him I fain would view. To mark if e’er I knew him? and to crave His pity for the fardel that I bear. I was of Latiun, of a Tuscan horn A mighty one: Aldobranlesco’s name My sire’s, I know not if ye e’er have heard. My old blood and forefathers’ gallant deeds Made me so haughty, that I clean forgot The common mother, and to such excess, Wax’d in my scorn of all men, that I fell, Fell therefore; by what fate Sienna’s sons, Each child in Campagnatico, can tell. I am Omberto; not me only pride Hath injur’d, but my kindred all involv’d In mischief with her. Here my lot ordains Under this weight to groan, till I appease God’s angry justice, since I did it not Amongst the living, here amongst the dead.” List’ning I bent my visage down: and one (Not he who spake) twisted beneath the weight That urg’d him, saw me, knew me straight, and call’d, Holding his eyes With difficulty fix’d Intent upon me, stooping as I went Companion of their way. “O!” I exclaim’d, “Art thou not Oderigi, art not thou Agobbio’s glory, glory of that art Which they of Paris call the limmer’s skill?” “Brother!” said he, “with tints that gayer smile, Bolognian Franco’s pencil lines the leaves. His all the honour now; mine borrow’d light. In truth I had not been thus courteous to him, The whilst I liv’d, through eagerness of zeal For that pre-eminence my heart was bent on. Here of such pride the forfeiture is paid. Nor were I even here; if, able still To sin, I had not turn’d me unto God. O powers of man! how vain your glory, nipp’d E’en in its height of verdure, if an age Less bright succeed not! Cimabue thought To lord it over painting’s field; and now The cry is Giotto’s, and his name eclips’d. Thus hath one Guido from the other snatch’d The letter’d prize: and he perhaps is born, Who shall drive either from their nest. The noise Of worldly fame is but a blast of wind, That blows from divers points, and shifts its name Shifting the point it blows from. Shalt thou more Live in the mouths of mankind, if thy flesh Part shrivel’d from thee, than if thou hadst died, Before the coral and the pap were left, Or ere some thousand years have passed? and that Is, to eternity compar’d, a space, Briefer than is the twinkling of an eye To the heaven’s slowest orb. He there who treads So leisurely before me, far and wide Through Tuscany resounded once; and now Is in Sienna scarce with whispers nam’d: There was he sov’reign, when destruction caught The madd’ning rage of Florence, in that day Proud as she now is loathsome. Your renown Is as the herb, whose hue doth come and go, And his might withers it, by whom it sprang Crude from the lap of earth.” I thus to him: “True are thy sayings: to my heart they breathe The kindly spirit of meekness, and allay What tumours rankle there. But who is he Of whom thou spak’st but now?”—“This,” he replied, “Is Provenzano. He is here, because He reach’d, with grasp presumptuous, at the sway Of all Sienna. Thus he still hath gone, Thus goeth never-resting, since he died. Such is th’ acquittance render’d back of him, Who, beyond measure, dar’d on earth.” I then: “If soul that to the verge of life delays Repentance, linger in that lower space, Nor hither mount, unless good prayers befriend, How chanc’d admittance was vouchsaf’d to him?” “When at his glory’s topmost height,” said he, “Respect of dignity all cast aside, Freely He fix’d him on Sienna’s plain, A suitor to redeem his suff’ring friend, Who languish’d in the prison-house of Charles, Nor for his sake refus’d through every vein To tremble. More I will not say; and dark, I know, my words are, but thy neighbours soon Shall help thee to a comment on the text. This is the work, that from these limits freed him.”
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Weight of Being Right
The defensive need to be right or superior becomes a crushing burden that prevents growth, connection, and forward movement in life.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when authority becomes a burden that isolates you from the people you're meant to serve or lead.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel defensive about your position or expertise - ask yourself if you're protecting your effectiveness or just your ego.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Purgatory
In Catholic theology, a state after death where souls are purified of their sins before entering Heaven. Unlike Hell, this is temporary - souls here will eventually be saved. Dante imagines it as a mountain with seven terraces, each addressing a different sin.
Modern Usage:
We talk about being 'in purgatory' when we're stuck in an uncomfortable waiting period, like sitting in a hospital waiting room or dealing with bureaucracy.
Seven Deadly Sins
Pride, envy, wrath, sloth, greed, gluttony, and lust - the traditional list of sins that lead to spiritual death. Dante structures Purgatory around purging these sins, starting with pride as the root of all others.
Modern Usage:
These show up constantly in modern storytelling and self-help - from characters in movies to workplace dynamics to relationship problems.
Illuminator
An artist who decorated manuscripts with elaborate designs, borders, and miniature paintings before the printing press existed. This was highly skilled, prestigious work that took years to master.
Modern Usage:
Today's equivalent would be graphic designers, illustrators, or any creative professional whose work can be easily replaced by new technology or trends.
Contrapasso
Dante's principle of divine justice where the punishment fits the crime in an ironic way. In Purgatory, souls experience the opposite of their sin - the proud must carry heavy stones to learn humility.
Modern Usage:
We see this in everyday karma - the gossip who gets gossiped about, or the control freak who loses control of their own life.
Feudal Nobility
The medieval social system where noble families held land and power through hereditary titles. Your family name determined your entire life - wealth, status, marriage prospects, everything.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how family wealth, connections, and reputation still open or close doors today, though we pretend merit matters more than it actually does.
Artistic Fame
The pursuit of lasting recognition for creative work. In Dante's time, artists competed fiercely for patronage and reputation, knowing that fame was their only shot at immortality.
Modern Usage:
Social media influencers, viral content creators, and artists chasing likes and followers are modern versions of this same desperate grab for lasting recognition.
Characters in This Chapter
Dante
Protagonist/observer
Witnesses the souls carrying stones and learns about pride from their stories. He's still alive, so he doesn't have to carry the weight, but he's learning the lessons they're teaching through their suffering.
Modern Equivalent:
The person in therapy watching others share their struggles and realizing their own patterns
Omberto
Penitent soul/cautionary example
A nobleman whose family pride led to their destruction. He carries stones while admitting his arrogance ruined not just himself but his entire bloodline, showing how pride damages everyone around us.
Modern Equivalent:
The family patriarch whose ego and stubbornness tore the family apart
Oderigi
Mentor figure/reformed artist
A famous manuscript illuminator who teaches Dante about the fleeting nature of artistic fame. He explains how artists are constantly replaced in public memory, revealing the futility of chasing recognition.
Modern Equivalent:
The veteran creative professional who's watched younger talent replace them and learned to let go of ego
Provenzano
Redeemed ruler/example of transformation
A powerful leader who earned his place in Purgatory through one act of humility - publicly begging for money to save a friend. His story shows that even the proudest can be saved through genuine love for others.
Modern Equivalent:
The high-powered executive who swallows their pride to help a friend in crisis
Key Quotes & Analysis
"O thou Almighty Father, who dost make The heavens thy dwelling, not in bounds confined"
Context: The prideful souls recite a modified version of the Lord's Prayer as they carry their stones
This prayer shows how even in punishment, these souls are learning to focus outward toward God and others rather than inward on themselves. The modification reflects their spiritual growth - they're asking not just for themselves but for those still living.
In Today's Words:
God, help us think beyond ourselves and our own problems
"I bore the belt of pride so long, that all My kindred to perdition I have brought"
Context: Omberto explains how his family pride destroyed his entire lineage
This reveals the true cost of unchecked pride - it doesn't just hurt the individual but ripples out to damage everyone connected to them. Omberto's admission shows he finally understands the collective damage his ego caused.
In Today's Words:
My ego was so out of control that I dragged my whole family down with me
"O empty glory of the powers of humans! How briefly lasts the green upon the peak"
Context: Speaking about how artistic fame fades quickly as new artists replace old ones
This cuts to the heart of human ambition and the futility of chasing recognition. Oderigi uses the metaphor of leaves that quickly turn brown to show how temporary all earthly achievements really are.
In Today's Words:
Fame is meaningless - you're hot one minute and forgotten the next
Thematic Threads
Pride
In This Chapter
Souls literally carry crushing stones while learning that pride weighs down every aspect of life
Development
Introduced here as the first sin addressed in Purgatory, establishing it as foundational to human struggle
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in your reluctance to admit mistakes at work or ask for help when struggling.
Class
In This Chapter
Omberto's noble birth becomes his downfall, while Provenzano's public begging shows true nobility
Development
Continues examining how social status can corrupt, but adds redemption through humility
In Your Life:
You see this when people use their position or background to avoid accountability or genuine connection.
Identity
In This Chapter
Oderigi's artistic fame fades quickly, showing how external recognition creates false identity
Development
Builds on earlier themes of mistaken identity by showing how reputation-based identity crumbles
In Your Life:
You experience this when your sense of worth depends on others' recognition of your achievements or status.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
The weight-bearing process transforms souls by forcing them to experience humility physically
Development
Introduces the active, transformative nature of growth through accepting difficulty
In Your Life:
You might find this in how your hardest challenges become your greatest teachers about who you really are.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Provenzano's willingness to humiliate himself publicly to save a friend demonstrates love over pride
Development
Shows how genuine connection requires abandoning self-protective pride
In Your Life:
You see this choice between protecting your image and protecting your relationships in every conflict with people you love.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why are the prideful souls carrying heavy stones, and what does this teach us about how pride actually works in our lives?
analysis • surface - 2
Omberto's pride destroyed his entire family line, while Oderigi learned that artistic fame fades quickly. What pattern do you see in how pride sets us up for disappointment?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about your workplace or family. Where do you see people carrying the 'weight' of pride - refusing to admit mistakes, ask for help, or show vulnerability?
application • medium - 4
Provenzano earned his place in Purgatory by publicly begging to save a friend, abandoning his dignity for love. When have you had to choose between protecting your image and doing what really mattered?
application • deep - 5
The chapter suggests that true greatness comes from serving others, not being above them. How does this challenge the way we usually think about success and power?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Pride Triggers
Think of a recent situation where you felt defensive or had to 'be right' about something. Write down what triggered that feeling, what you were protecting (your expertise, your reputation, your authority), and what it cost you (connection, learning opportunity, peace of mind). Then rewrite the scenario: what would have happened if you had chosen curiosity over defensiveness?
Consider:
- •Pride often disguises itself as 'standing up for what's right' or 'maintaining standards'
- •The weight of pride gets heavier when we double down instead of letting go
- •Sometimes admitting you don't know something is the strongest position you can take
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's willingness to be vulnerable or admit they were wrong actually made you respect them more. What did that teach you about real strength?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 46: Looking Down to Move Forward
As the story unfolds, you'll explore examining past failures helps us avoid repeating them, while uncovering humility and self-awareness are essential for growth. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.
