Summary
Dante encounters his beloved former teacher, Brunetto Latini, among the souls punished for sexual sins in the seventh circle of Hell. Despite the shocking circumstances, Dante shows deep respect and affection for the man who taught him "the way for man to win eternity." Brunetto, though condemned to walk eternally on burning sand, takes time to offer his former student encouragement and political advice. He warns Dante that Florence's corrupt political factions will both try to use him, but predicts great things for his future if he stays true to his principles. The scene captures the complex emotions of seeing a respected mentor in disgrace - the pain of disappointment mixed with enduring gratitude for past guidance. Brunetto's final act is to recommend his greatest work, "The Treasure," before running off to rejoin his group. This encounter shows how relationships can transcend moral boundaries, and how we can honor what someone taught us while acknowledging their failures. It's a masterclass in maintaining dignity during an awkward reunion, showing respect without condoning behavior, and accepting that even our heroes are flawed humans.
Coming Up in Chapter 16
Three more spirits approach Dante and Virgil, recognizing them as fellow Italians by their clothing. These souls have something urgent to discuss, and their arrival promises another intense encounter in this realm of eternal punishment.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1023 words)
One of the solid margins bears us now Envelop’d in the mist, that from the stream Arising, hovers o’er, and saves from fire Both piers and water. As the Flemings rear Their mound, ’twixt Ghent and Bruges, to chase back The ocean, fearing his tumultuous tide That drives toward them, or the Paduans theirs Along the Brenta, to defend their towns And castles, ere the genial warmth be felt On Chiarentana’s top; such were the mounds, So fram’d, though not in height or bulk to these Made equal, by the master, whosoe’er He was, that rais’d them here. We from the wood Were not so far remov’d, that turning round I might not have discern’d it, when we met A troop of spirits, who came beside the pier. They each one ey’d us, as at eventide One eyes another under a new moon, And toward us sharpen’d their sight as keen, As an old tailor at his needle’s eye. Thus narrowly explor’d by all the tribe, I was agniz’d of one, who by the skirt Caught me, and cried, “What wonder have we here!” And I, when he to me outstretch’d his arm, Intently fix’d my ken on his parch’d looks, That although smirch’d with fire, they hinder’d not But I remember’d him; and towards his face My hand inclining, answer’d: “Sir! Brunetto! And art thou here?” He thus to me: “My son! Oh let it not displease thee, if Brunetto Latini but a little space with thee Turn back, and leave his fellows to proceed.” I thus to him replied: “Much as I can, I thereto pray thee; and if thou be willing, That I here seat me with thee, I consent; His leave, with whom I journey, first obtain’d.” “O son!” said he, “ whoever of this throng One instant stops, lies then a hundred years, No fan to ventilate him, when the fire Smites sorest. Pass thou therefore on. I close Will at thy garments walk, and then rejoin My troop, who go mourning their endless doom.” I dar’d not from the path descend to tread On equal ground with him, but held my head Bent down, as one who walks in reverent guise. “What chance or destiny,” thus be began, “Ere the last day conducts thee here below? And who is this, that shows to thee the way?” “There up aloft,” I answer’d, “in the life Serene, I wander’d in a valley lost, Before mine age had to its fullness reach’d. But yester-morn I left it: then once more Into that vale returning, him I met; And by this path homeward he leads me back.” “If thou,” he answer’d, “follow but thy star, Thou canst not miss at last a glorious haven: Unless in fairer days my judgment err’d. And if my fate so early had not chanc’d, Seeing the heav’ns thus bounteous to thee, I Had gladly giv’n thee comfort in thy work. But that ungrateful and malignant race, Who in old times came down from Fesole, Ay and still smack of their rough mountain-flint, Will for thy good deeds shew thee enmity. Nor wonder; for amongst ill-savour’d crabs It suits not the sweet fig-tree lay her fruit. Old fame reports them in the world for blind, Covetous, envious, proud. Look to it well: Take heed thou cleanse thee of their ways. For thee Thy fortune hath such honour in reserve, That thou by either party shalt be crav’d With hunger keen: but be the fresh herb far From the goat’s tooth. The herd of Fesole May of themselves make litter, not touch the plant, If any such yet spring on their rank bed, In which the holy seed revives, transmitted From those true Romans, who still there remain’d, When it was made the nest of so much ill.” “Were all my wish fulfill’d,” I straight replied, “Thou from the confines of man’s nature yet Hadst not been driven forth; for in my mind Is fix’d, and now strikes full upon my heart The dear, benign, paternal image, such As thine was, when so lately thou didst teach me The way for man to win eternity; And how I priz’d the lesson, it behooves, That, long as life endures, my tongue should speak, What of my fate thou tell’st, that write I down: And with another text to comment on For her I keep it, the celestial dame, Who will know all, if I to her arrive. This only would I have thee clearly note: That so my conscience have no plea against me; Do fortune as she list, I stand prepar’d. Not new or strange such earnest to mine ear. Speed fortune then her wheel, as likes her best, The clown his mattock; all things have their course.” Thereat my sapient guide upon his right Turn’d himself back, then look’d at me and spake: “He listens to good purpose who takes note.” I not the less still on my way proceed, Discoursing with Brunetto, and inquire Who are most known and chief among his tribe. “To know of some is well;” thus he replied, “But of the rest silence may best beseem. Time would not serve us for report so long. In brief I tell thee, that all these were clerks, Men of great learning and no less renown, By one same sin polluted in the world. With them is Priscian, and Accorso’s son Francesco herds among that wretched throng: And, if the wish of so impure a blotch Possess’d thee, him thou also might’st have seen, Who by the servants’ servant was transferr’d From Arno’s seat to Bacchiglione, where His ill-strain’d nerves he left. I more would add, But must from farther speech and onward way Alike desist, for yonder I behold A mist new-risen on the sandy plain. A company, with whom I may not sort, Approaches. I commend my TREASURE to thee, Wherein I yet survive; my sole request.” This said he turn’d, and seem’d as one of those, Who o’er Verona’s champain try their speed For the green mantle, and of them he seem’d, Not he who loses but who gains the prize.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Complicated Gratitude
The challenge of honoring someone's positive influence on your life while acknowledging their moral failures or disappointing choices.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to honor what someone contributed to your growth without excusing their harmful behavior.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel conflicted about someone who helped you but disappointed you—practice saying 'I'm grateful for what you taught me' without adding 'so your mistakes don't matter.'
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Seventh Circle of Hell
In Dante's Hell, this is where violent sinners are punished - those who harmed others, themselves, or God. Different areas punish different types of violence with fitting torments.
Modern Usage:
We still talk about 'circles' of consequences, like how one bad choice leads to worse situations.
Sodomites
Medieval term for those guilty of sexual sins, particularly homosexuality. In Dante's time, this was considered a sin against nature and God.
Modern Usage:
Shows how society's moral judgments change over time - what one era condemns, another may accept.
Burning Sand
The punishment in this part of Hell where souls must walk eternally on hot sand under falling fire. The constant movement prevents them from finding rest.
Modern Usage:
Like being stuck in a job where you're always busy but never getting anywhere - constant motion without progress.
Political Exile
Being forced to leave your city due to political conflicts. Dante himself was exiled from Florence and never returned.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this with whistleblowers or activists who can't return home after speaking out against corruption.
Mentor-Student Bond
The deep relationship between teacher and pupil that goes beyond just sharing knowledge. It involves shaping character and life direction.
Modern Usage:
We still see this with coaches, bosses, or teachers who really invest in someone's future, not just their current performance.
The Treasure
Brunetto Latini's famous book that taught practical wisdom and knowledge. It was like an encyclopedia of how to succeed in medieval life.
Modern Usage:
Like self-help books or career guides today - works that promise to teach you how to navigate life successfully.
Characters in This Chapter
Dante
Protagonist and narrator
Shows genuine love and respect for his former teacher despite finding him in Hell. Struggles with seeing someone he admires in such a degraded state.
Modern Equivalent:
The former student running into their favorite teacher in an embarrassing situation
Brunetto Latini
Dante's former teacher and mentor
Despite being punished for sexual sins, he maintains his dignity and continues to care about his former student's future. Offers political advice and encouragement.
Modern Equivalent:
The respected mentor whose personal life scandals don't erase their professional wisdom
Virgil
Dante's guide through Hell
Remains present but allows Dante to handle this personal encounter on his own. Represents the wisdom that knows when to step back.
Modern Equivalent:
The supportive friend who gives you space when you run into your ex
Key Quotes & Analysis
"What wonder have we here!"
Context: Brunetto's surprise at seeing his former student alive in Hell
Shows the shock of an unexpected reunion in the worst possible circumstances. Despite his own torment, Brunetto's first reaction is amazement and concern for Dante.
In Today's Words:
Well, I'll be damned - what are you doing here?
"And art thou here?"
Context: Dante's response upon recognizing his beloved teacher in Hell
Captures the pain of seeing someone you respect in a fallen state. The question contains disbelief, sadness, and lingering affection all at once.
In Today's Words:
Oh my God, is that really you? What happened?
"My son! Oh let it not displease thee"
Context: Brunetto asking if he can walk with Dante despite his punishment
Shows how a true teacher never stops caring about their student's well-being, even when they're suffering consequences for their own choices. The paternal tone remains unchanged.
In Today's Words:
Hey kiddo, I hope you don't mind if I walk with you for a bit
Thematic Threads
Mentorship
In This Chapter
Dante encounters his former teacher Brunetto, showing deep respect despite finding him condemned in Hell
Development
Introduced here - first major mentor figure in the journey
In Your Life:
You might face this when a boss who trained you well gets fired for misconduct, or a family member who taught you important values makes choices you can't support.
Dignity
In This Chapter
Both Dante and Brunetto maintain respectful interaction despite the shocking circumstances of their reunion
Development
Continues from earlier encounters - how to handle difficult conversations with grace
In Your Life:
You see this when running into an ex at the grocery store or having to work with someone after a falling out.
Identity
In This Chapter
Brunetto predicts Dante's future greatness and warns about political challenges, helping shape Dante's understanding of his path
Development
Building on earlier themes about Dante's purpose and destiny
In Your Life:
This appears when former teachers or mentors continue to influence how you see your potential, even years later.
Human Complexity
In This Chapter
Brunetto is simultaneously a condemned soul and a beloved teacher, showing how people contain contradictions
Development
Deepens earlier observations about how good and evil coexist in individuals
In Your Life:
You experience this when realizing that people who hurt you also had redeeming qualities, or when your heroes disappoint you.
Class
In This Chapter
The interaction shows how intellectual and social connections can transcend current circumstances
Development
Continues exploration of how relationships cross social boundaries
In Your Life:
This shows up when you maintain friendships across different life paths or economic situations.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How does Dante react when he recognizes his former teacher Brunetto in Hell, and what does this tell us about their past relationship?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Dante show such respect to Brunetto despite finding him in Hell for sexual sins? What internal conflict is he navigating?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this same pattern today - people who taught you important things but later disappointed you with their choices?
application • medium - 4
If someone who mentored you was caught doing something you found morally wrong, how would you handle seeing them again? What would you say?
application • deep - 5
What does this encounter teach us about separating the value of what someone taught us from our judgment of their personal choices?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Navigate the Mentor Dilemma
Think of someone who taught you something valuable but later disappointed you with their actions or choices. Write a brief letter you would send them if you met today - one that acknowledges what they gave you while maintaining your boundaries about their behavior. Practice Dante's approach: respectful but not enabling.
Consider:
- •You can be grateful for past lessons without excusing current bad behavior
- •Maintaining your values doesn't require you to erase the good they contributed
- •It's possible to honor someone's positive impact while still holding them accountable
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to separate your gratitude for what someone taught you from your disappointment in their choices. How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 16: Meeting the Noble Damned
As the story unfolds, you'll explore reputation and legacy matter even in our darkest moments, while uncovering showing respect to others, regardless of their circumstances, reveals character. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.
