Summary
Pierre visits Natasha to deliver letters and finds her devastated by shame over her failed elopement with Anatole. Instead of judgment, he offers something unexpected: complete understanding and forgiveness. When Natasha begs him to tell Prince Andrew she's sorry, Pierre sees past her mistakes to her suffering. In a spontaneous moment of grace, he tells her that if he were free, he would ask for her hand—not despite her flaws, but seeing her true worth. This simple act of unconditional acceptance transforms them both. Natasha weeps with gratitude for the first time in days, while Pierre leaves feeling elevated by love and tenderness. Outside, he notices the brilliant comet of 1812 in the winter sky—a celestial body that others see as an omen of doom, but which Pierre views as a symbol of hope and renewal. The chapter captures how genuine compassion can break through shame and despair, creating moments of profound human connection. Pierre's offer isn't romantic manipulation—it's recognition of Natasha's inherent worth when she can't see it herself. This scene shows how sometimes the most healing thing we can offer someone isn't advice or solutions, but simply seeing them clearly and refusing to judge them by their worst moments.
Coming Up in Chapter 168
As 1812 dawns, Napoleon's massive army begins its fateful march toward Russia. The personal dramas of Moscow's elite are about to collide with the greatest military campaign in history.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
That same evening Pierre went to the Rostóvs’ to fulfill the commission entrusted to him. Natásha was in bed, the count at the club, and Pierre, after giving the letters to Sónya, went to Márya Dmítrievna who was interested to know how Prince Andrew had taken the news. Ten minutes later Sónya came to Márya Dmítrievna. “Natásha insists on seeing Count Peter Kirílovich,” said she. “But how? Are we to take him up to her? The room there has not been tidied up.” “No, she has dressed and gone into the drawing room,” said Sónya. Márya Dmítrievna only shrugged her shoulders. “When will her mother come? She has worried me to death! Now mind, don’t tell her everything!” said she to Pierre. “One hasn’t the heart to scold her, she is so much to be pitied, so much to be pitied.” Natásha was standing in the middle of the drawing room, emaciated, with a pale set face, but not at all shamefaced as Pierre expected to find her. When he appeared at the door she grew flurried, evidently undecided whether to go to meet him or to wait till he came up. Pierre hastened to her. He thought she would give him her hand as usual; but she, stepping up to him, stopped, breathing heavily, her arms hanging lifelessly just in the pose she used to stand in when she went to the middle of the ballroom to sing, but with quite a different expression of face. “Peter Kirílovich,” she began rapidly, “Prince Bolkónski was your friend—is your friend,” she corrected herself. (It seemed to her that everything that had once been must now be different.) “He told me once to apply to you...” Pierre sniffed as he looked at her, but did not speak. Till then he had reproached her in his heart and tried to despise her, but he now felt so sorry for her that there was no room in his soul for reproach. “He is here now: tell him... to for... forgive me!” She stopped and breathed still more quickly, but did not shed tears. “Yes... I will tell him,” answered Pierre; “but...” He did not know what to say. Natásha was evidently dismayed at the thought of what he might think she had meant. “No, I know all is over,” she said hurriedly. “No, that can never be. I’m only tormented by the wrong I have done him. Tell him only that I beg him to forgive, forgive, forgive me for everything....” She trembled all over and sat down on a chair. A sense of pity he had never before known overflowed Pierre’s heart. “I will tell him, I will tell him everything once more,” said Pierre. “But... I should like to know one thing....” “Know what?” Natásha’s eyes asked. “I should like to know, did you love...” Pierre did not know how to refer to Anatole and flushed at the thought of him—“did you love that bad man?” “Don’t call him bad!” said Natásha....
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Radical Grace
When someone is consumed by shame over their failures, offering unconditional acceptance of their worth breaks the shame spiral and enables healing.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to break shame spirals by separating someone's worth from their worst moments.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone is drowning in embarrassment or regret—resist the urge to lecture and instead affirm something genuine about their character.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Drawing room
The formal living room where upper-class families received guests and conducted important conversations. It was a semi-public space within the private home where social rules still applied.
Modern Usage:
Like meeting someone in your living room versus your bedroom - it's more formal and appropriate for serious conversations.
Commission
A formal task or duty entrusted to someone, often involving delivering messages or handling delicate matters. Pierre has been asked to deliver letters and news to the Rostov family.
Modern Usage:
When someone asks you to be the messenger in a difficult situation, like telling your friend what their ex said.
Elopement scandal
Natasha's attempted runaway with Anatole has ruined her reputation and broken her engagement to Prince Andrew. In this society, a woman's virtue and reputation were everything.
Modern Usage:
Like when someone's personal drama goes public and everyone's judging them for their worst moment.
Social shame
The crushing weight of public disgrace that Natasha feels after her failed elopement. She believes she's worthless and that everyone will judge her forever.
Modern Usage:
That feeling when you've made a huge mistake and think everyone will always see you as that screw-up.
Unconditional acceptance
Pierre's response to Natasha - seeing her worth despite her mistakes and offering love without conditions or judgment. He recognizes her suffering rather than focusing on her failures.
Modern Usage:
When someone loves you at your lowest point and reminds you that you're more than your worst decisions.
Comet of 1812
A real historical comet that appeared over Russia and was seen by many as an omen of war and disaster. Tolstoy uses it symbolically to represent different perspectives on fate.
Modern Usage:
Like how the same event can look like a disaster to some people but a fresh start to others.
Characters in This Chapter
Pierre
Compassionate friend
He visits to deliver letters but ends up offering Natasha something more valuable - complete acceptance and recognition of her worth. His spontaneous declaration that he would marry her if he were free transforms both of them.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who shows up when you're at rock bottom and reminds you that you matter
Natasha
Shamed protagonist
She's devastated by her failed elopement and believes she's worthless. Pierre's acceptance allows her to cry and begin healing for the first time since her scandal.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone dealing with public humiliation who thinks their life is over
Sonya
Concerned cousin
She acts as messenger between Natasha and the adults, showing care for her cousin while navigating the household's concern about the situation.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member trying to help coordinate care for someone going through a crisis
Marya Dmitrievna
Protective guardian
She's caring for Natasha in her parents' absence and feels the weight of responsibility. She wants to protect Natasha from further harm while managing a delicate situation.
Modern Equivalent:
The family friend or relative who steps in when parents can't handle a crisis
Key Quotes & Analysis
"One hasn't the heart to scold her, she is so much to be pitied, so much to be pitied."
Context: She's telling Pierre how she feels about Natasha's condition
This shows how Natasha's suffering is so visible that even strict Marya Dmitrievna can only feel compassion. It reveals how genuine remorse and pain can transform how others see us.
In Today's Words:
She's been through enough - I can't bring myself to make her feel worse.
"If I were not myself, but the handsomest, cleverest, and best man in the world, and were free, I would this moment ask on my knees for your hand and your love!"
Context: Pierre spontaneously declares this to comfort the devastated Natasha
This isn't a marriage proposal but a gift of recognition - Pierre is telling Natasha that she has worth when she can't see it herself. His hypothetical removes pressure while offering pure validation.
In Today's Words:
If I could be with anyone in the world, I'd choose you - that's how valuable you are.
"The comet of 1812 - that comet which was said to portend all kinds of woes and the end of the world - did not seem to Pierre to be brighter or more terrible than the stars."
Context: Pierre sees the comet after leaving Natasha, feeling elevated by love
While others see the comet as an omen of doom, Pierre sees beauty and hope. This reflects how love and compassion can transform our entire perspective on life and the future.
In Today's Words:
Everyone else saw disaster coming, but all Pierre could see was possibility.
Thematic Threads
Shame
In This Chapter
Natasha is paralyzed by shame over her failed elopement, unable to see past her mistakes to her own worth
Development
Building from her earlier impulsive actions, now showing the psychological aftermath of public failure
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you can't stop replaying a mistake or when someone you care about is stuck in self-blame
Unconditional Love
In This Chapter
Pierre offers Natasha complete acceptance, seeing her worth despite knowing all her flaws and mistakes
Development
Pierre's capacity for love has deepened through his own struggles and spiritual growth
In Your Life:
You experience this when someone loves you through your worst moments, or when you choose to see past someone's failures to their heart
Redemption
In This Chapter
The comet that others see as an omen of doom becomes Pierre's symbol of hope and renewal
Development
Pierre's ability to find meaning and hope has grown throughout his journey of self-discovery
In Your Life:
You might see this when you choose to interpret difficult circumstances as opportunities for growth rather than just problems
Recognition
In This Chapter
Pierre recognizes Natasha's true worth when she cannot see it herself, offering her a mirror of her better self
Development
Evolved from earlier themes of social recognition to deeper recognition of human worth
In Your Life:
You experience this when someone sees potential in you that you've lost sight of, or when you help others remember who they really are
Healing
In This Chapter
Natasha's first tears in days come from gratitude rather than despair, marking the beginning of emotional healing
Development
Introduced here as the result of accumulated pain finally meeting genuine compassion
In Your Life:
You might recognize this moment when emotional numbness finally breaks and you can feel hope again
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Pierre offer Natasha when she's drowning in shame, and how is this different from what most people would do?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Pierre's declaration that he would marry her help Natasha more than advice or reassurance would have?
analysis • medium - 3
Think of someone you know who made a big mistake and felt terrible about it. How did people around them respond, and what effect did that have?
application • medium - 4
When someone you care about is stuck in shame about something they did, how could you use Pierre's approach to help them see their worth again?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between accountability and shame, and why does that distinction matter?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Practice Radical Grace
Think of someone in your life who recently made a mistake and is clearly beating themselves up about it. Write down what Pierre would say to them - not minimizing their mistake, but helping them see their worth beyond that moment. Then practice saying it out loud until it feels genuine.
Consider:
- •Focus on separating the person from their action without excusing harmful behavior
- •Look for something genuinely valuable about them that their mistake doesn't erase
- •Consider how your response could either deepen their shame or help them heal
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone showed you radical grace after you messed up badly. How did their response change how you saw yourself and the situation?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 168: The Machinery of History
What lies ahead teaches us massive events result from countless small decisions, not just powerful leaders, and shows us simple explanations for complex problems are usually incomplete. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.