Summary
Zarathustra reflects on his failed attempt to reach the common people in the marketplace, realizing that trying to speak to everyone means speaking to no one. He addresses the 'higher men' - those who refuse to settle for mediocrity - warning them that the masses will always demand equality and conformity. The death of God, he argues, has freed humanity to create new values, but most people cling to 'petty virtues' like submission and comfort rather than striving for greatness. Zarathustra challenges his listeners to embrace their failures as necessary steps toward becoming something greater. He criticizes those who seek easy paths or borrowed wisdom, insisting that true creators must forge their own way. The chapter builds to a powerful metaphor about dancing - learning to laugh at yourself, to move with lightness even through difficulty, and to find joy in the struggle itself. Rather than mourning failures or seeking sympathy, Zarathustra calls for a spirit of celebration and courage. He crowns himself with laughter, declaring that the ability to dance through life's challenges is the mark of those who transcend ordinary existence. The message is clear: stop trying to please everyone, embrace your authentic path even when it's difficult, and learn to find joy in becoming who you're meant to be.
Coming Up in Chapter 74
As Zarathustra's teachings near their end, he prepares for a final revelation about the eternal return and what it truly means to live fully in each moment.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
W1. hen I came unto men for the first time, then did I commit the anchorite folly, the great folly: I appeared on the market-place. And when I spake unto all, I spake unto none. In the evening, however, rope-dancers were my companions, and corpses; and I myself almost a corpse. With the new morning, however, there came unto me a new truth: then did I learn to say: “Of what account to me are market-place and populace and populace-noise and long populace-ears!” Ye higher men, learn THIS from me: On the market-place no one believeth in higher men. But if ye will speak there, very well! The populace, however, blinketh: “We are all equal.” “Ye higher men,”—so blinketh the populace—“there are no higher men, we are all equal; man is man, before God—we are all equal!” Before God!—Now, however, this God hath died. Before the populace, however, we will not be equal. Ye higher men, away from the market-place! 2. Before God!—Now however this God hath died! Ye higher men, this God was your greatest danger. Only since he lay in the grave have ye again arisen. Now only cometh the great noontide, now only doth the higher man become—master! Have ye understood this word, O my brethren? Ye are frightened: do your hearts turn giddy? Doth the abyss here yawn for you? Doth the hell-hound here yelp at you? Well! Take heart! ye higher men! Now only travaileth the mountain of the human future. God hath died: now do WE desire—the Superman to live. 3. The most careful ask to-day: “How is man to be maintained?” Zarathustra however asketh, as the first and only one: “How is man to be SURPASSED?” The Superman, I have at heart; THAT is the first and only thing to me—and NOT man: not the neighbour, not the poorest, not the sorriest, not the best.— O my brethren, what I can love in man is that he is an over-going and a down-going. And also in you there is much that maketh me love and hope. In that ye have despised, ye higher men, that maketh me hope. For the great despisers are the great reverers. In that ye have despaired, there is much to honour. For ye have not learned to submit yourselves, ye have not learned petty policy. For to-day have the petty people become master: they all preach submission and humility and policy and diligence and consideration and the long et cetera of petty virtues. Whatever is of the effeminate type, whatever originateth from the servile type, and especially the populace-mishmash:—THAT wisheth now to be master of all human destiny—O disgust! Disgust! Disgust! THAT asketh and asketh and never tireth: “How is man to maintain himself best, longest, most pleasantly?” Thereby—are they the masters of to-day. These masters of to-day—surpass them, O my brethren—these petty people: THEY are the Superman’s greatest danger! Surpass, ye higher men, the petty virtues, the petty policy, the sand-grain considerateness, the ant-hill trumpery, the pitiable...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Audience Capture
Trying to please everyone dilutes your message and authenticity until you serve no one effectively.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when fear of rejection causes you to water down your authentic voice until it becomes meaningless.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you soften your real opinions to avoid conflict—then ask yourself: 'Who actually needs to hear my authentic perspective, even if others won't like it?'
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Market-place
In Nietzsche's philosophy, this represents the public square where common people gather - a symbol for trying to please everyone or speak to the masses. It's where individual excellence gets watered down to fit popular opinion.
Modern Usage:
We see this today in social media echo chambers or when someone compromises their authentic message to go viral.
Higher men
Not about social class or money, but people who refuse to settle for mediocrity and create their own values instead of following the crowd. They're willing to stand alone rather than blend in.
Modern Usage:
Think of entrepreneurs who quit stable jobs to build something new, or artists who create what they believe in rather than what sells.
Death of God
Nietzsche's famous concept meaning traditional religious authority and absolute moral rules have lost their power in modern society. People must now create meaning for themselves instead of following inherited beliefs.
Modern Usage:
We see this in declining church attendance and people creating their own spiritual practices or moral codes.
Populace
The common people or masses who, according to Zarathustra, demand equality and conformity. They resist anyone who tries to rise above average or challenge accepted ways of thinking.
Modern Usage:
Like social media pile-ons against anyone who expresses unpopular opinions, or workplace cultures that punish high achievers.
Great noontide
A metaphor for the moment of greatest clarity and potential - when humanity can finally create new values after old religious systems have collapsed. It's both opportunity and responsibility.
Modern Usage:
Similar to major life transitions like divorce or career changes - scary but full of potential to rebuild better.
Dancing
Nietzsche's symbol for living with lightness, joy, and grace even through difficulties. It means finding celebration in struggle rather than being weighed down by life's challenges.
Modern Usage:
Like people who find humor in tough situations or celebrate small wins during hard times instead of just complaining.
Characters in This Chapter
Zarathustra
Philosopher-prophet
Reflects on his failed attempt to reach common people and now speaks directly to those willing to forge their own path. He's learned that trying to please everyone means reaching no one.
Modern Equivalent:
The life coach who stops trying to help everyone and focuses on clients actually ready to change
The populace
Collective antagonist
Represents the masses who demand equality and conformity, rejecting anyone who tries to rise above average. They insist 'we are all equal' to pull down those who strive for excellence.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworkers who complain when someone gets promoted or the neighbors who gossip about anyone doing well
Higher men
Zarathustra's intended audience
Those who refuse to settle for mediocrity but are frightened by the responsibility of creating their own values. They're caught between their potential and their fear.
Modern Equivalent:
People with big dreams who are scared to quit their safe job or leave their comfort zone
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Of what account to me are market-place and populace and populace-noise and long populace-ears!"
Context: After realizing his mistake of trying to speak to everyone in the marketplace
This shows Zarathustra's evolution from trying to please the masses to focusing on those ready to hear his message. He's learned that authentic communication requires the right audience.
In Today's Words:
Why should I care what everyone else thinks or try to make everyone happy?
"On the market-place no one believeth in higher men"
Context: Warning the higher men about the futility of seeking validation from the masses
This reveals the core conflict between excellence and popularity. The crowd will always try to bring exceptional people down to their level rather than be inspired to rise.
In Today's Words:
Don't expect average people to support your big dreams - they'll just try to talk you out of them.
"Now only cometh the great noontide, now only doth the higher man become—master!"
Context: Explaining the opportunity created by the death of traditional authority
This captures both the terror and excitement of complete freedom. Without old rules to follow, people can finally become who they're meant to be - but they must take full responsibility.
In Today's Words:
This is your moment to finally take control of your own life and stop following everyone else's rules.
Thematic Threads
Authenticity
In This Chapter
Zarathustra realizes that speaking to everyone means speaking to no one, and chooses to address only those ready to hear his truth
Development
Evolved from earlier themes of self-creation to practical wisdom about authentic communication
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you find yourself changing your opinions based on who's in the room
Class
In This Chapter
The distinction between 'higher men' who strive for excellence and masses who demand comfortable mediocrity
Development
Continues Nietzsche's exploration of different types of people and their values
In Your Life:
You see this in workplaces where some people push for quality while others just want to get by
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Embracing failure as necessary for becoming something greater, learning to dance through difficulties
Development
Builds on earlier themes of self-overcoming with practical advice about handling setbacks
In Your Life:
You experience this when you realize your mistakes were actually teaching you what you needed to know
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Rejecting the crowd's demand for equality and conformity in favor of individual excellence
Development
Intensifies the conflict between social pressure and personal truth established in earlier chapters
In Your Life:
You feel this tension when your family or friends pressure you to 'not think you're better than us'
Joy
In This Chapter
The metaphor of dancing and laughter as ways to transcend difficulty rather than being crushed by it
Development
Introduces a new theme of finding celebration within struggle
In Your Life:
You discover this when you learn to laugh at your own mistakes instead of being devastated by them
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Zarathustra say that trying to speak to everyone in the marketplace means speaking to no one?
analysis • surface - 2
What's the difference between seeking approval from 'the crowd' versus connecting with people who share your values?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people watering down their message or beliefs to avoid offending anyone? What usually happens to their effectiveness?
application • medium - 4
Think of someone you respect who stands for something specific, even when it's unpopular. How do they handle criticism or rejection?
application • deep - 5
What does Zarathustra's 'dancing through difficulty' suggest about how we should handle the loneliness that comes with being authentic?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Identify Your Non-Negotiables
Write down three principles or values you hold that you wouldn't compromise, even if it meant some people wouldn't like you. For each one, identify a specific situation where you've either stood firm or wish you had. Then consider: what would 'dancing through the difficulty' look like in these situations?
Consider:
- •Think about times when trying to please everyone actually hurt your relationships or effectiveness
- •Consider the difference between being kind and being a people-pleaser
- •Notice how authentic people attract the right connections, even if they repel others
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you diluted your message or beliefs to avoid conflict. What was the real cost? How might you handle a similar situation differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 74: The Magician's Seductive Song
Moving forward, we'll examine to recognize when someone is using emotional manipulation to draw you in, and understand the difference between authentic vulnerability and performative suffering. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.