An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 552 words)
ecapitulation of the foregoing Chapters.
We do not, therefore, thoroughly and heartily
sympathize with the gratitude of one man towards
another, merely because this other has been the
cause of his good fortune, unless he has been the
cause of it from motives which we entirely go along
with. Our heart must adopt the principles of the
agent, and go along with all the affections which
influenced his conduct, before it can entirely sympathize
with, and beat time to, the gratitude of
the person who has been benefited by his actions.
If in the conduct of the benefactor there appears
to have been no propriety, how beneficial soever its
effects, it does not seem to demand, or necessarily
to require, any proportionable recompense.
But when to the beneficent tendency of the
action is joined the propriety of the affection from
which it proceeds, when we entirely sympathize
and go along with the motives of the agent, the
love which we conceive for him upon his own
account, enhances and enlivens our fellow-feeling
110with the gratitude of those who owe their prosperity
to his good conduct. His actions seem then to
demand, and, if I may say so, to call aloud for a
proportionable recompense. We then entirely enter
into that gratitude which prompts to bestow it.
The benefactor seems then to be the proper object
of reward, when we thus entirely sympathize with,
and approve of, that sentiment which prompts to
reward him. When we approve of, and go along
with, the affection from which the action proceeds,
we must necessarily approve of the action, and regard
the person towards whom it is directed as its
proper and suitable object.
2. In the same manner, we cannot at all sympathize
with the resentment of one man against another,
merely because this other has been the cause
of his misfortune, unless he has been the cause of it
from motives which we cannot enter into. Before
we can adopt the resentment of the sufferer, we
must disapprove of the motives of the agent, and
feel that our heart renounces all sympathy with the
affections which influenced his conduct. If there
appears to have been no impropriety in these, how
fatal soever the tendency of the action which proceeds
from them to those against whom it is directed,
it does not seem to deserve any punishment,
or to be the proper object of any resentment.
But when to the hurtfulness of the action is joined
the impropriety of the affection from whence it
proceeds, when our heart rejects with abhorrence
all fellow-feeling with the motives of the agent,
111we then heartily and entirely sympathize with the
resentment of the sufferer. Such actions seem then
to deserve, and, if I may say so, to call aloud for,
a proportionable punishment; and we entirely enter
into, and thereby approve of, that resentment which
prompts to inflict it. The offender necessarily
seems then to be the proper object of punishment,
when we thus entirely sympathize with, and thereby
approve of, that sentiment which prompts to punish.
In this case too, when we approve, and go along
with, the affection from which the action proceeds,
we must necessarily approve of the action, and
regard the person against whom it is directed, as its
proper and suitable object.
112
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Humans judge worthiness based on perceived motives behind actions, not just outcomes alone.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to detect the difference between helpful actions driven by good motives versus self-interest.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone helps you - ask yourself whether they seem genuinely caring or performing for an audience, and notice how differently you feel about each type of help.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"We do not, therefore, thoroughly and heartily sympathize with the gratitude of one man towards another, merely because this other has been the cause of his good fortune, unless he has been the cause of it from motives which we entirely go along with."
Context: Smith explains why we don't automatically approve when someone feels grateful for help they received.
This reveals that our moral instincts are more sophisticated than simple cause-and-effect thinking. We naturally evaluate not just what people do, but why they do it, before deciding if gratitude or praise is deserved.
In Today's Words:
Just because someone helped you doesn't mean they deserve your thanks - it depends on why they helped you in the first place.
"If in the conduct of the benefactor there appears to have been no propriety, how beneficial soever its effects, it does not seem to demand, or necessarily to require, any proportionable recompense."
Context: Smith argues that good results don't automatically earn someone reward if their motives were wrong.
This challenges the idea that 'results are all that matter.' Smith shows that we instinctively know the difference between someone who helps us genuinely versus someone who helps us accidentally or for selfish reasons.
In Today's Words:
Even if someone's actions helped you out, they don't deserve special credit if they were doing it for the wrong reasons.
"His actions seem then to demand, and, if I may say so, to call aloud for a proportionable recompense."
Context: Smith describes how we feel when someone acts from both good motives and achieves good results.
This captures that feeling when we know someone truly deserves recognition - when their heart was in the right place AND they made a positive difference. It's why some thank-yous feel inadequate.
In Today's Words:
When someone helps you for the right reasons, it feels like they really deserve to be rewarded for it.
Thematic Threads
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Smith shows how relationships depend on reading authentic intentions behind actions
Development
Builds on earlier discussions of sympathy to reveal how we actually evaluate people's worth
In Your Life:
You probably sense when someone's kindness feels genuine versus performed, even if you can't explain why.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Society expects us to judge merit by both actions and motives, creating complex moral calculations
Development
Expands the framework of social approval to include motive-reading as a social skill
In Your Life:
You navigate daily social situations by constantly reading whether people's behavior matches their stated intentions.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Understanding that others judge our motives pushes us toward authentic self-improvement
Development
Connects to earlier themes about self-command by showing external motivation for internal change
In Your Life:
Knowing people can sense your true intentions might motivate you to examine why you really do things.
Class
In This Chapter
Merit based on motive levels the playing field - good intentions matter regardless of social position
Development
Challenges earlier class-based judgments by suggesting moral worth transcends social status
In Your Life:
You might judge a wealthy person's charity differently if you suspect it's just for tax benefits versus genuine care.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
According to Smith, why don't we automatically feel grateful when someone helps us, even if we benefit from their actions?
analysis • surface - 2
Smith argues we judge people by their motives, not just outcomes. What makes this judgment process so sophisticated and automatic?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about your workplace or family relationships. Can you identify a time when you sensed someone's true motives didn't match their helpful actions?
application • medium - 4
When someone causes you harm accidentally while trying to help, how should Smith's insight change how you respond compared to intentional harm?
application • deep - 5
What does our ability to read motives behind actions reveal about what humans truly value in relationships and society?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Motive Behind the Action
Think of a recent situation where someone helped you or you helped someone else. Write down what actually happened, then dig deeper into the real motives involved. Were the intentions genuine care, obligation, self-interest, or something else? How did recognizing the true motive affect your feelings about the situation?
Consider:
- •Look beyond the surface action to what drove the behavior
- •Consider how you would have felt differently if the motives were different
- •Notice how your gut reaction already detected the true intention
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you misjudged someone's motives - either assuming bad intentions when they were good, or good intentions when they were selfish. What clues did you miss, and how would you read the situation differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 18: How We Judge Right and Wrong
Having established how we judge merit and blame, Smith will now dive deeper into analyzing exactly how our sense of what people deserve actually works in practice.
