Summary
Maggie's morning explodes when she's told she can't go fetch her beloved brother Tom from school. Her reaction is swift and dramatic—she dunks her head in water to ruin her curls, ensuring no 'best bonnet' trip anyway. This isn't just a tantrum; it's a nine-year-old's desperate attempt to reclaim some control when adults make decisions for her. Maggie escapes to her secret attic refuge, where she has a wooden doll she uses as a 'fetish'—beating it against the wall to work out her fury. It's a surprisingly sophisticated coping mechanism for a child, showing how even young people find ways to process overwhelming emotions. The chapter takes a devastating turn when Maggie discovers Tom's rabbits have died while in her care. Her excitement about his homecoming transforms into dread—she's failed the one person she loves most. Luke the miller tries to comfort her, but his practical worldview ('things out of nature never thrive') contrasts sharply with Maggie's emotional intensity. The dead rabbits become a symbol of how responsibility can feel crushing when you're young and forgetful. Maggie's visit to Luke's cottage provides temporary distraction, but the weight of her failure lingers. This chapter reveals how children navigate complex emotions—rage, guilt, love, and fear—often more intensely than adults remember experiencing themselves.
Coming Up in Chapter 5
Tom finally comes home from school, but will Maggie's joy at seeing her brother survive the devastating news about his beloved rabbits? The reunion she's been anticipating may not go as she hoped.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Tom Is Expected It was a heavy disappointment to Maggie that she was not allowed to go with her father in the gig when he went to fetch Tom home from the academy; but the morning was too wet, Mrs Tulliver said, for a little girl to go out in her best bonnet. Maggie took the opposite view very strongly, and it was a direct consequence of this difference of opinion that when her mother was in the act of brushing out the reluctant black crop Maggie suddenly rushed from under her hands and dipped her head in a basin of water standing near, in the vindictive determination that there should be no more chance of curls that day. “Maggie, Maggie!” exclaimed Mrs Tulliver, sitting stout and helpless with the brushes on her lap, “what is to become of you if you’re so naughty? I’ll tell your aunt Glegg and your aunt Pullet when they come next week, and they’ll never love you any more. Oh dear, oh dear! look at your clean pinafore, wet from top to bottom. Folks ’ull think it’s a judgment on me as I’ve got such a child,—they’ll think I’ve done summat wicked.” Before this remonstrance was finished, Maggie was already out of hearing, making her way toward the great attic that ran under the old high-pitched roof, shaking the water from her black locks as she ran, like a Skye terrier escaped from his bath. This attic was Maggie’s favourite retreat on a wet day, when the weather was not too cold; here she fretted out all her ill humours, and talked aloud to the worm-eaten floors and the worm-eaten shelves, and the dark rafters festooned with cobwebs; and here she kept a Fetish which she punished for all her misfortunes. This was the trunk of a large wooden doll, which once stared with the roundest of eyes above the reddest of cheeks; but was now entirely defaced by a long career of vicarious suffering. Three nails driven into the head commemorated as many crises in Maggie’s nine years of earthly struggle; that luxury of vengeance having been suggested to her by the picture of Jael destroying Sisera in the old Bible. The last nail had been driven in with a fiercer stroke than usual, for the Fetish on that occasion represented aunt Glegg. But immediately afterward Maggie had reflected that if she drove many nails in she would not be so well able to fancy that the head was hurt when she knocked it against the wall, nor to comfort it, and make believe to poultice it, when her fury was abated; for even aunt Glegg would be pitiable when she had been hurt very much, and thoroughly humiliated, so as to beg her niece’s pardon. Since then she had driven no more nails in, but had soothed herself by alternately grinding and beating the wooden head against the rough brick of the great chimneys that made two square pillars supporting the roof....
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Emotional Overflow - When Big Feelings Need Small Outlets
When overwhelmed by emotions we can't directly address, we instinctively seek control through unrelated but manageable actions.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when we're channeling feelings about one situation into seemingly unrelated actions.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel compelled to control something minor after feeling powerless about something major—then pause and name what you're really upset about.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Gig
A light, two-wheeled horse-drawn carriage for one or two people. In the 1800s, owning a gig was a sign of middle-class respectability - not wealthy, but comfortable enough for small luxuries.
Modern Usage:
Like having a decent car today - not flashy, but it shows you're doing okay financially.
Pinafore
A sleeveless apron-like garment worn over a dress to keep it clean. For children, it was both practical protection and a sign that parents cared about appearances.
Modern Usage:
Think of how parents still dress kids in 'good clothes' for special occasions, then worry about them getting dirty.
Fetish (Victorian usage)
In Eliot's time, this meant an object believed to have magical powers or used for emotional release. Maggie uses her wooden doll this way - beating it against the wall to work out her anger.
Modern Usage:
Like having a stress ball, punching bag, or any object you use to cope with intense emotions.
Academy
A private school, usually for boys from middle-class families who couldn't afford elite schools but wanted better than local options. It represented social aspiration and investment in a child's future.
Modern Usage:
Similar to sending your kid to a charter school or private school when public schools don't seem good enough.
Things out of nature never thrive
Luke's philosophy that anything unnatural or forced won't succeed. He's talking about the rabbits, but it reflects a working-class wisdom about accepting life's limitations.
Modern Usage:
Like saying 'if it's meant to be, it'll happen' or 'you can't force what isn't natural.'
Judgment
Mrs. Tulliver's fear that people will see Maggie's behavior as divine punishment for her own sins. In religious communities, children's misbehavior often reflected on parents' moral standing.
Modern Usage:
That feeling when your kid acts up in public and you worry what other parents think about your parenting.
Characters in This Chapter
Maggie Tulliver
Protagonist
A passionate nine-year-old who feels everything intensely. Her dramatic reaction to being excluded shows her need for control and her deep attachment to her brother Tom. Her guilt over the dead rabbits reveals how seriously she takes responsibility.
Modern Equivalent:
The intense kid who has big feelings about everything and takes things personally
Mrs. Tulliver
Anxious mother figure
Worried about appearances and social judgment, she tries to control Maggie's wildness through threats about what relatives will think. She represents the pressure to conform to social expectations.
Modern Equivalent:
The mom who's always worried about what other people think and tries to manage her kid's image
Tom Tulliver
Absent but central figure
Though not physically present, he dominates Maggie's thoughts and emotions. Her excitement about his return and terror about disappointing him shows how much his approval means to her.
Modern Equivalent:
The sibling whose opinion matters more than anyone else's, even when they're not around
Luke
Working-class mentor
The miller who offers Maggie practical comfort and philosophical perspective. His matter-of-fact approach to the rabbits' death contrasts with Maggie's emotional intensity, showing different ways of handling loss.
Modern Equivalent:
The older coworker who's seen it all and gives you straight talk when you're upset
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Folks 'ull think it's a judgment on me as I've got such a child,—they'll think I've done summat wicked."
Context: After Maggie dunks her head in water and ruins her clean clothes
This reveals how much social pressure parents felt to produce 'good' children. Mrs. Tulliver fears that Maggie's wildness reflects her own moral failures in the eyes of their community.
In Today's Words:
People are going to think I'm a terrible mother because my kid acts out like this.
"Things out of nature never thrive."
Context: Explaining to Maggie why the rabbits died when kept in an unnatural environment
Luke's practical wisdom suggests that forcing situations or creatures into unnatural circumstances leads to failure. It's both literal advice about pet care and metaphorical wisdom about life.
In Today's Words:
If you try to force something that isn't natural, it's not going to work out.
"This attic was Maggie's favourite retreat on a wet day, when the weather was not tempting her out of doors."
Context: Describing where Maggie goes to escape after her confrontation with her mother
Everyone needs a private space to process emotions. Maggie's attic represents the human need for solitude and a place where we can be ourselves without judgment.
In Today's Words:
This was Maggie's safe space where she could go to deal with her feelings.
Thematic Threads
Control
In This Chapter
Maggie seeks control over her appearance and possessions when denied control over important decisions
Development
Building from earlier chapters where adult authority felt arbitrary
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you obsess over small details after feeling powerless in bigger situations
Responsibility
In This Chapter
The dead rabbits represent crushing weight of disappointing someone you love
Development
Introduced here as Maggie's first major failure of care
In Your Life:
That sick feeling when you've let down someone who trusted you with something important
Emotional Intensity
In This Chapter
Maggie's feelings are described as more intense than adults remember experiencing
Development
Continuing pattern of Maggie feeling everything more deeply than those around her
In Your Life:
When people tell you you're 'too sensitive' but your feelings are genuinely overwhelming
Class Awareness
In This Chapter
Luke's practical worldview contrasts with Maggie's emotional approach to problems
Development
Expanding from family dynamics to show different ways of processing reality
In Your Life:
When your emotional response to problems feels dismissed by more 'practical' people
Refuge
In This Chapter
The attic serves as Maggie's safe space for processing difficult emotions
Development
Introduced here as essential coping mechanism
In Your Life:
Everyone needs a place where they can fall apart safely without judgment
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific actions does Maggie take when she's told she can't fetch Tom from school, and what happens to the rabbits?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Maggie choose to ruin her curls and beat the wooden doll instead of directly confronting the adults who disappointed her?
analysis • medium - 3
When have you seen someone (including yourself) take control of something small when they felt powerless about something big?
application • medium - 4
If you were Maggie's parent, how would you help her process her anger while still maintaining necessary boundaries?
application • deep - 5
What does Maggie's need for a secret attic space and her ritual with the doll reveal about how humans cope with overwhelming emotions?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Pressure Release Valves
Think about the last time you felt frustrated or powerless in one situation but found yourself taking extra control in a completely different area. Draw or write out the connection between what you couldn't control and what you did control instead. Then identify three healthy outlets you could use next time you feel this way.
Consider:
- •Notice if your control behaviors help you feel better or just distract you temporarily
- •Consider whether your outlets affect other people (like Maggie's rabbits)
- •Think about the difference between healthy release and harmful displacement
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt responsible for something that went wrong despite your best efforts. How did you handle the guilt, and what would you tell your younger self about managing that kind of responsibility?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 5: Tom Comes Home
In the next chapter, you'll discover sibling dynamics shape us from childhood through adulthood, and learn the need for love often overrides our pride and anger. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.