Summary
The Servant's Tale
Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen
Elinor finally learns the truth about Edward's secret engagement to Lucy Steele, and it's even more complicated than she thought. When Mrs. Jennings bursts in with news that Edward has been disinherited by his mother for refusing to break his engagement, Elinor realizes that Edward's honor has cost him everything - his inheritance, his future prospects, and any chance of marrying for love. The twist? Lucy has actually married Edward's younger brother Robert instead, leaving Edward free but penniless. This chapter reveals the full cost of doing the right thing in a world where money determines everything. Edward chose duty over self-interest, sticking to his promise to Lucy even when it meant losing his fortune. Meanwhile, Lucy showed her true colors by immediately jumping to the brother with better prospects. Elinor watches all this unfold with a mixture of relief, admiration, and heartbreak - relief that Edward is free, admiration for his integrity, and heartbreak knowing that his principles have left him with nothing to offer her. Austen uses this moment to highlight how society's rigid class system punishes moral behavior while rewarding calculated opportunism. The chapter also shows Elinor's own moral strength as she processes these revelations without bitterness or judgment. She understands that Edward's poverty now makes their love even more impossible, yet she can't help but respect him more for choosing honor over wealth. This sets up the novel's final movement, where true worth must find a way to triumph over social expectations.
Coming Up in Chapter 41
With Edward finally free but financially ruined, the question becomes whether love can survive without fortune. Meanwhile, Marianne's own romantic situation takes an unexpected turn that will test everything she's learned about the heart versus the head.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
L. “Well, Miss Dashwood,” said Mrs. Jennings, sagaciously smiling, as soon as the gentleman had withdrawn, “I do not ask you what the Colonel has been saying to you; for though, upon my honour, I _tried_ to keep out of hearing, I could not help catching enough to understand his business. And I assure you I never was better pleased in my life, and I wish you joy of it with all my heart.” “Thank you, ma’am,” said Elinor. “It _is_ a matter of great joy to me; and I feel the goodness of Colonel Brandon most sensibly. There are not many men who would act as he has done. Few people who have so compassionate a heart! I never was more astonished in my life.” “Lord! my dear, you are very modest. I an’t the least astonished at it in the world, for I have often thought of late, there was nothing more likely to happen.” “You judged from your knowledge of the Colonel’s general benevolence; but at least you could not foresee that the opportunity would so very soon occur.” “Opportunity!” repeated Mrs. Jennings—“Oh! as to that, when a man has once made up his mind to such a thing, somehow or other he will soon find an opportunity. Well, my dear, I wish you joy of it again and again; and if ever there was a happy couple in the world, I think I shall soon know where to look for them.” “You mean to go to Delaford after them I suppose,” said Elinor, with a faint smile. “Aye, my dear, that I do, indeed. And as to the house being a bad one, I do not know what the Colonel would be at, for it is as good a one as ever I saw.” “He spoke of its being out of repair.” “Well, and whose fault is that? why don’t he repair it?—who should do it but himself?” They were interrupted by the servant’s coming in to announce the carriage being at the door; and Mrs. Jennings immediately preparing to go, said,— “Well, my dear, I must be gone before I have had half my talk out. But, however, we may have it all over in the evening; for we shall be quite alone. I do not ask you to go with me, for I dare say your mind is too full of the matter to care for company; and besides, you must long to tell your sister all about it.” Marianne had left the room before the conversation began. “Certainly, ma’am, I shall tell Marianne of it; but I shall not mention it at present to any body else.” “Oh! very well,” said Mrs. Jennings rather disappointed. “Then you would not have me tell it to Lucy, for I think of going as far as Holborn to-day.” “No, ma’am, not even Lucy if you please. One day’s delay will not be very material; and till I have written to Mr. Ferrars, I think it ought...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Principled Poverty - When Doing Right Costs Everything
When moral behavior gets punished by systems designed to reward self-interest and compliance.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when organizations punish moral behavior while rewarding calculated self-interest.
Practice This Today
This week, notice which behaviors actually get rewarded at your workplace versus which ones get praised in company meetings—the gap reveals everything.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Disinheritance
When a wealthy family cuts off a child completely, taking away their inheritance and financial support. In Austen's time, this was social and economic death - no inheritance meant no income, no status, and no marriage prospects.
Modern Usage:
Like when parents threaten to cut off college tuition or remove someone from the will for making choices they disapprove of.
Entailment
A legal arrangement where family wealth and property must pass to specific heirs, usually male relatives. This system kept fortunes intact but trapped people in predetermined roles.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how some family businesses or trust funds come with strings attached about who can inherit and under what conditions.
Marriage settlement
The financial arrangements made before marriage, including what money and property each person brings. These were business negotiations as much as romantic commitments.
Modern Usage:
Like prenups today, but more important because women had no legal right to earn their own money.
Living
A church position that provided steady income, usually given by wealthy landowners to younger sons or dependents. Edward needs one to survive as a clergyman.
Modern Usage:
Similar to getting a stable job with benefits through family connections or networking.
Fortune hunter
Someone who pursues romantic relationships primarily for financial gain rather than love. Lucy Steele represents this calculating approach to marriage.
Modern Usage:
Like people who date others mainly for their money, connections, or lifestyle upgrade potential.
Secret engagement
A private promise to marry that wasn't publicly announced. These were binding but dangerous - breaking them meant social disgrace, but keeping them secret often meant trouble.
Modern Usage:
Similar to keeping relationships private from family due to disapproval, but with much higher stakes.
Characters in This Chapter
Edward Ferrars
Conflicted hero
Edward faces the consequences of his honor when his mother disinherits him for refusing to break his engagement to Lucy. He chooses moral duty over financial security, losing his inheritance but keeping his integrity.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who quits a high-paying job rather than do something unethical
Lucy Steele
Opportunistic antagonist
Lucy reveals her true nature by immediately marrying Robert Ferrars when he becomes the heir, abandoning Edward the moment he loses his money. Her actions expose her as a pure fortune hunter.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who dumps someone the minute they lose their job or status
Elinor Dashwood
Moral observer
Elinor processes the complex emotions of learning Edward is free but penniless. She admires his integrity while understanding that his poverty makes their love even more impossible.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who handles everyone else's drama with grace while dealing with her own heartbreak
Mrs. Ferrars
Controlling matriarch
Edward's mother uses financial control to try to dictate his life choices, disinheriting him when he won't comply with her demands about marriage.
Modern Equivalent:
The controlling parent who uses money as leverage to control their adult children's decisions
Robert Ferrars
Opportunistic heir
Edward's younger brother benefits from his mother's favoritism and Edward's disgrace, becoming the new heir and Lucy's target for marriage.
Modern Equivalent:
The sibling who gets everything when the other one falls out of favor with the family
Key Quotes & Analysis
"His mother has determined, with a very natural kind of spirit, to settle that estate upon Robert immediately, which might have been Edward's, on proper conditions."
Context: Mrs. Jennings explains how Mrs. Ferrars has transferred Edward's inheritance to his brother
This quote shows how quickly financial power can shift based on family approval. The phrase 'very natural kind of spirit' is ironic - there's nothing natural about using money to control your children's lives.
In Today's Words:
His mom decided to give his brother everything that should have been Edward's, just because Edward wouldn't do what she wanted.
"Edward will only hold the curacy of Delaford, if that should be offered him, and how little that is!"
Context: Discussing Edward's bleak financial prospects after being disinherited
This highlights the harsh reality of Edward's situation - he's gone from wealthy heir to struggling clergyman overnight. The exclamation shows how shocking this fall from grace appears to others.
In Today's Words:
Edward will be lucky to get a basic church job, and that pays almost nothing!
"Lucy does not want sense, and that is the foundation on which every thing good may be built."
Context: Elinor trying to think charitably about Lucy despite everything
This shows Elinor's generous nature even when she has every reason to dislike Lucy. The irony is that Lucy's 'sense' is purely calculating - she's smart about getting what she wants, not about being good.
In Today's Words:
Lucy isn't stupid, and you can build something decent from there - though we're about to see how wrong this is.
Thematic Threads
Honor vs. Survival
In This Chapter
Edward chooses to honor his engagement despite losing his inheritance, while Lucy abandons honor for financial security
Development
This builds on earlier themes of duty versus desire, now showing the extreme cost of choosing duty
In Your Life:
You see this when staying loyal to principles costs you opportunities that compromise would have provided
Class Mobility
In This Chapter
Edward falls from wealth to poverty through moral choice, while Lucy climbs through calculated abandonment
Development
Develops the ongoing theme of how quickly social position can change based on strategic decisions
In Your Life:
You experience this when financial pressures tempt you to abandon your values for better opportunities
True Character
In This Chapter
Crisis reveals who people really are—Edward's integrity, Lucy's opportunism, Elinor's grace under pressure
Development
Culminates the novel's exploration of how extreme situations strip away pretense
In Your Life:
You see this when stress or opportunity reveals whether people will stick to their word or abandon you
Social Punishment
In This Chapter
Society punishes Edward for moral behavior while rewarding Lucy for calculated betrayal
Development
Intensifies earlier themes about how social systems often work against individual integrity
In Your Life:
You face this when doing the right thing makes you the target while those who cut corners get ahead
Love's Impossibility
In This Chapter
Edward's freedom comes with poverty, making love with Elinor seem even more impossible despite being morally available
Development
Develops the ongoing tension between heart and practical reality that has driven the entire novel
In Your Life:
You know this feeling when circumstances make love seem impossible even when both people are willing
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What choice did Edward make that cost him his inheritance, and what did Lucy do when she learned about the consequences?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do you think Edward stuck to his engagement with Lucy even when it meant losing everything, while Lucy immediately switched to his brother Robert?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen people get punished for doing the right thing while others get rewarded for being opportunistic?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Edward's position - having to choose between your principles and your financial security - how would you prepare yourself to handle the consequences?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between having character and having strategy, and why might you need both?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Integrity Costs
Think of a situation where doing the right thing might cost you something important - a job opportunity, family approval, social acceptance, or financial security. Write down what the principled choice would be, what it would cost you, and what you could do to prepare for those consequences. Then identify one person who shares your values who might support you through it.
Consider:
- •Consider both the immediate costs and long-term benefits of principled choices
- •Think about how you can build support systems before you need them
- •Remember that institutions often reward compliance over character
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you compromised your principles for practical reasons. What did you learn about yourself, and how would you handle a similar situation now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 41: Edward's Freedom
The next chapter brings new insights and deeper understanding. Continue reading to discover how timeless patterns from this classic literature illuminate our modern world and the choices we face.