Summary
Montaigne tackles a universal human problem: we're never satisfied with what we have. Drawing on Caesar's observation that people fear unknown threats more than visible ones, he explores why we constantly chase new things while ignoring the good already in our lives. He points out that philosophers have been arguing forever about what makes life worth living, with no agreement in sight. This isn't because life lacks meaning, but because we approach it with greedy, impatient minds. Using vivid quotes from Lucretius, Montaigne paints a picture of people who have everything they need for a good life - wealth, honor, family - yet remain anxious and complaining. The problem isn't our circumstances; it's like having a cracked vessel that spoils whatever you pour into it. We blame external things for our dissatisfaction when the real issue is internal. Our appetites are fickle and restless, unable to enjoy what we possess. Instead, we romanticize distant, unknown possibilities, giving them power over our peace of mind. This pattern keeps us trapped in perpetual wanting, always believing the next thing will finally satisfy us. Montaigne's insight cuts deep: we often trust and fear what we can't see more than what's right in front of us, making ourselves miserable in the process.
Coming Up in Chapter 54
Next, Montaigne turns his sharp eye to the clever arguments and elaborate reasoning people use to sound smart, questioning whether all our intellectual complexity actually helps us live better lives.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
OF A SAYING OF CAESAR If we would sometimes bestow a little consideration upon ourselves, and employ the time we spend in prying into other men’s actions, and discovering things without us, in examining our own abilities we should soon perceive of how infirm and decaying material this fabric of ours is composed. Is it not a singular testimony of imperfection that we cannot establish our satisfaction in any one thing, and that even our own fancy and desire should deprive us of the power to choose what is most proper and useful for us? A very good proof of this is the great dispute that has ever been amongst the philosophers, of finding out man’s sovereign good, that continues yet, and will eternally continue, without solution or accord: “Dum abest quod avemus, id exsuperare videtur Caetera; post aliud, quum contigit illud, avemus, Et sitis aequa tenet.” [“While that which we desire is wanting, it seems to surpass all the rest; then, when we have got it, we want something else; ‘tis ever the same thirst”--Lucretius, iii. 1095.] Whatever it is that falls into our knowledge and possession, we find that it satisfies not, and we still pant after things to come and unknown, inasmuch as those present do not suffice for us; not that, in my judgment, they have not in them wherewith to do it, but because we seize them with an unruly and immoderate haste: “Nam quum vidit hic, ad victum qux flagitat usus, Et per quae possent vitam consistere tutam, Omnia jam ferme mortalibus esse parata; Divitiis homines, et honore, et laude potentes Aflluere, atque bona natorum excellere fama; Nec minus esse domi cuiquam tamen anxia corda, Atque animi ingratis vitam vexare querelis Causam, quae infestis cogit saevire querelis, Intellegit ibi; vitium vas efficere ipsum, Omniaque, illius vitio, corrumpier intus, Qux collata foris et commoda quomque venirent.” [“For when he saw that almost all things necessarily required for subsistence, and which may render life comfortable, are already prepared to their hand, that men may abundantly attain wealth, honour, praise, may rejoice in the reputation of their children, yet that, notwithstanding, every one has none the less in his heart and home anxieties and a mind enslaved by wearing complaints, he saw that the vessel itself was in fault, and that all good things which were brought into it from without were spoilt by its own imperfections.”--Lucretius, vi. 9.] Our appetite is irresolute and fickle; it can neither keep nor enjoy anything with a good grace: and man concluding it to be the fault of the things he is possessed of, fills himself with and feeds upon the idea of things he neither knows nor understands, to which he devotes his hopes and his desires, paying them all reverence and honour, according to the saying of Caesar: “Communi fit vitio naturae, ut invisis, latitantibus atque incognitis rebus magis confidamas, vehementiusque exterreamur.” [“‘Tis the common vice of nature, that we at once repose most confidence, and receive the...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Never Enough - Breaking the Dissatisfaction Trap
The tendency to devalue present circumstances while overvaluing imagined alternatives, creating perpetual wanting despite having enough.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when your mind is systematically devaluing what you have while overvaluing what you lack.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you catch yourself fantasizing about how much better life would be 'somewhere else' - then list three things working in your current situation.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Sovereign good
The ultimate goal or highest value that philosophers believe should guide human life - like happiness, virtue, or pleasure. Ancient and medieval thinkers spent centuries debating what this should be, with no consensus.
Modern Usage:
We see this in endless self-help debates about whether success means money, relationships, health, or 'following your passion.'
Stoic philosophy
A school of thought emphasizing self-control, accepting what you can't change, and finding peace through reason rather than emotion. Popular among Roman leaders like Caesar.
Modern Usage:
Modern therapy techniques like CBT borrow heavily from Stoic ideas about controlling your thoughts and reactions.
Classical quotation
Montaigne frequently quotes ancient Roman and Greek writers like Lucretius to support his points. This was standard practice for educated Renaissance writers to show learning and authority.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how people today quote famous movies, songs, or viral memes to make their point more relatable or credible.
Self-examination
The practice of looking inward at your own thoughts, motivations, and behaviors instead of constantly judging others. Montaigne pioneered this as a literary form.
Modern Usage:
This is the foundation of modern therapy, journaling, meditation apps, and any 'work on yourself' advice.
Human restlessness
The tendency to always want what we don't have and feel dissatisfied with our current situation, no matter how good it is. Montaigne sees this as a fundamental flaw in human nature.
Modern Usage:
Perfectly describes social media FOMO, constantly upgrading phones, or always planning the next vacation instead of enjoying where you are.
Renaissance humanism
An intellectual movement focusing on human potential, individual experience, and learning from classical texts. Montaigne embodies this by studying himself as much as ancient books.
Modern Usage:
Similar to today's emphasis on personal growth, self-actualization, and the idea that everyone has unique value and potential.
Characters in This Chapter
Caesar
Historical example
Montaigne references Caesar's observation that people fear unknown dangers more than visible ones. Caesar represents someone who understood human psychology despite his power and success.
Modern Equivalent:
The successful CEO who still understands that people are driven more by fear than facts
Lucretius
Ancient authority
Roman poet whose quotes Montaigne uses to illustrate how humans always want what they don't have. His poetry captures the endless cycle of human desire and dissatisfaction.
Modern Equivalent:
The wise songwriter whose lyrics perfectly capture universal human experiences
The philosophers
Collective antagonist
Montaigne criticizes how ancient and contemporary thinkers endlessly debate life's purpose without reaching agreement. They represent intellectual pride that misses practical wisdom.
Modern Equivalent:
Academic experts who overthink simple problems while regular people just need practical advice
Montaigne himself
Self-examining narrator
Uses his own experiences and observations to explore human nature. He's both the observer and the observed, admitting his own flaws while offering insights.
Modern Equivalent:
The honest friend who calls out everyone's BS, including their own
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Is it not a singular testimony of imperfection that we cannot establish our satisfaction in any one thing?"
Context: Opening his argument about human restlessness and inability to be content
This cuts to the heart of human psychology - we're literally incapable of being satisfied with what we have. Montaigne sees this as evidence of our flawed nature, not bad circumstances.
In Today's Words:
Isn't it weird that we're never happy with what we've got, no matter how good it is?
"While that which we desire is wanting, it seems to surpass all the rest; then, when we have got it, we want something else"
Context: Illustrating the cycle of human desire and disappointment
This ancient observation perfectly captures modern consumer culture and relationship patterns. The grass always looks greener, but once we get there, we're looking at the next hill.
In Today's Words:
We always think the thing we don't have is better than everything else, but once we get it, we're already wanting something new.
"We seize them with an unruly and immoderate haste"
Context: Explaining why good things don't satisfy us
The problem isn't that life lacks good things, but that we approach them with greedy, impatient minds. Our attitude spoils what should bring joy.
In Today's Words:
We grab at good things too desperately and mess them up for ourselves.
Thematic Threads
Contentment
In This Chapter
Montaigne argues that satisfaction comes from internal orientation, not external accumulation
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might notice this when you achieve a goal but immediately start wanting the next thing instead of enjoying what you accomplished.
Self-Knowledge
In This Chapter
Understanding that our 'cracked vessel' minds spoil good experiences through restless comparison
Development
Builds on earlier themes of honest self-examination
In Your Life:
You might see this when you catch yourself complaining about things that others would consider blessings.
Fear
In This Chapter
We fear and desire unknown possibilities more than we appreciate visible realities
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might experience this when you worry more about imaginary future problems than dealing with actual present challenges.
Perspective
In This Chapter
Our viewpoint determines whether we see abundance or scarcity in identical circumstances
Development
Connects to earlier discussions of judgment and perception
In Your Life:
You might notice this when the same situation feels terrible on a bad day but fine on a good day.
Human Nature
In This Chapter
The universal tendency toward fickleness and restlessness in our desires
Development
Builds on ongoing exploration of human behavioral patterns
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you find yourself always wanting something different from what you currently have.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Montaigne mean when he says we have a 'cracked vessel' problem, and how does this explain why people with good lives still complain?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do we fear and trust unknown things more than what's right in front of us, and how does this pattern keep us dissatisfied?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this 'grass is greener' pattern playing out in modern workplaces, relationships, or social media?
application • medium - 4
If someone you cared about was constantly chasing the next thing and missing what they already had, what specific advice would you give them?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter suggest about whether happiness comes from getting what we want or wanting what we have?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Present-Moment Inventory
Think of an area where you feel dissatisfied right now - work, relationships, money, or living situation. Write down everything that's actually working in that area, no matter how small. Then identify one thing you've been taking for granted that someone else would genuinely appreciate having. Finally, write what you're comparing your situation to and whether that comparison is helping or hurting you.
Consider:
- •Be honest about what's actually working, not just what feels dramatic or important
- •Notice if you resist acknowledging good things because it feels like settling
- •Pay attention to whether your comparisons are to real people or fantasy versions
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you got something you really wanted, only to find yourself wanting something else soon after. What does this pattern tell you about how your mind works?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 54: The Danger of Empty Cleverness
Moving forward, we'll examine to spot the difference between impressive skills and useful ones, and understand extremes often circle back to meet each other. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.