Summary
Montaigne explores a radical idea: that sometimes the threat of death can clarify what truly matters in life. He starts with ancient wisdom suggesting it's better to die than live miserably, then examines how philosophers like Seneca took this further. When advising a wealthy Roman to abandon his luxurious lifestyle for philosophical contemplation, Seneca essentially said: 'Either change your life completely, or end it.' This wasn't suicidal advice, but a way of showing how seriously we should take life choices. The chapter's most striking example involves St. Hilary, a Christian bishop who actually prayed for his daughter's death rather than see her marry into worldly wealth and pleasure. When she died, he rejoiced, believing he had saved her soul. His wife, inspired by this logic, asked him to pray for her death too, which also came to pass. Montaigne presents these stories without judgment, fascinated by how different belief systems lead to similar conclusions: that some things are worse than death. The essay reveals how our deepest convictions about what makes life worth living can drive us to extreme positions. It's not really about death at all, but about having the courage to live according to our values, even when that means walking away from everything society tells us we should want.
Coming Up in Chapter 33
After exploring death as life's ultimate decision-maker, Montaigne turns to examine how fortune and fate seem to follow their own mysterious logic. Sometimes what looks like random chance reveals surprising patterns of reason.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
THAT WE ARE TO AVOID PLEASURES, EVEN AT THE EXPENSE OF LIFE I had long ago observed most of the opinions of the ancients to concur in this, that it is high time to die when there is more ill than good in living, and that to preserve life to our own torment and inconvenience is contrary to the very rules of nature, as these old laws instruct us. [“Either tranquil life, or happy death. It is well to die when life is wearisome. It is better to die than to live miserable.” --Stobaeus, Serm. xx.] But to push this contempt of death so far as to employ it to the removing our thoughts from the honours, riches, dignities, and other favours and goods, as we call them, of fortune, as if reason were not sufficient to persuade us to avoid them, without adding this new injunction, I had never seen it either commanded or practised, till this passage of Seneca fell into my hands; who advising Lucilius, a man of great power and authority about the emperor, to alter his voluptuous and magnificent way of living, and to retire himself from this worldly vanity and ambition, to some solitary, quiet, and philosophical life, and the other alleging some difficulties: “I am of opinion,” says he, “either that thou leave that life of thine, or life itself; I would, indeed, advise thee to the gentle way, and to untie, rather than to break, the knot thou hast indiscreetly knit, provided, that if it be not otherwise to be untied, thou resolutely break it. There is no man so great a coward, that had not rather once fall than to be always falling.” I should have found this counsel conformable enough to the Stoical roughness: but it appears the more strange, for being borrowed from Epicurus, who writes the same thing upon the like occasion to Idomeneus. And I think I have observed something like it, but with Christian moderation, amongst our own people. St. Hilary, Bishop of Poictiers, that famous enemy of the Arian heresy, being in Syria, had intelligence thither sent him, that Abra, his only daughter, whom he left at home under the eye and tuition of her mother, was sought in marriage by the greatest noblemen of the country, as being a virgin virtuously brought up, fair, rich, and in the flower of her age; whereupon he wrote to her (as appears upon record), that she should remove her affection from all the pleasures and advantages proposed to her; for that he had in his travels found out a much greater and more worthy fortune for her, a husband of much greater power and magnificence, who would present her with robes and jewels of inestimable value; wherein his design was to dispossess her of the appetite and use of worldly delights, to join her wholly to God; but the nearest and most certain way to this, being, as he conceived, the death of his daughter; he never...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Ultimate Clarity
Crisis forces us to choose what we value most, revealing our true priorities by making compromise impossible.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to spot situations where trying to have everything means losing what matters most.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone offers you a 'solution' that requires abandoning your core principles—usually it's not really a solution.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Stoicism
An ancient philosophy teaching that virtue and wisdom matter more than external things like wealth, status, or even life itself. Stoics believed in accepting what you cannot control while focusing on what you can: your thoughts and actions.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who stay calm during crises, focusing on solutions rather than drama.
Contempt of death
Not being afraid to die, which philosophers believed freed you to make better life choices. When you're not desperately clinging to life, you can live more authentically and take principled stands.
Modern Usage:
Like people who quit toxic jobs without another one lined up because they'd rather risk uncertainty than stay miserable.
Worldly vanity
The pursuit of status symbols, luxury, and social recognition that philosophers saw as empty distractions from meaningful living. These things look impressive but don't actually make life better.
Modern Usage:
Think Instagram culture, keeping up with the Joneses, or working yourself to death for a bigger house you never get to enjoy.
Philosophical retirement
Withdrawing from public life and material pursuits to focus on wisdom, self-knowledge, and simple living. Not about age, but about choosing contemplation over ambition.
Modern Usage:
Like people who downsize, move to smaller towns, or choose meaningful work over high-paying careers.
Christian asceticism
The practice of rejecting worldly pleasures and comforts to focus entirely on spiritual matters. Ascetics believed earthly happiness could corrupt the soul and prevent salvation.
Modern Usage:
We see milder versions in people who fast, do digital detoxes, or choose simple living for spiritual reasons.
Moral extremism
Taking ethical principles to their absolute limit, even when it seems harsh or unnatural to others. It shows how deeply held beliefs can justify actions that shock conventional thinking.
Modern Usage:
Like parents who disown children for lifestyle choices, or activists who sacrifice everything for their cause.
Characters in This Chapter
Seneca
Philosophical advisor
A Roman philosopher who counsels his wealthy friend Lucilius to abandon luxury for simple living. He presents the stark choice: change your life completely or end it, showing how seriously he takes moral decisions.
Modern Equivalent:
The brutally honest friend who tells you to quit your soul-crushing job or stop complaining about it
Lucilius
Conflicted student
A powerful Roman official living luxuriously who receives Seneca's advice. He represents the difficulty of giving up comfort and status even when you know they're not making you happy.
Modern Equivalent:
The successful person trapped in golden handcuffs, knowing they should change but scared to give up security
St. Hilary
Religious extremist
A Christian bishop who prays for his daughter's death rather than let her marry into wealth and worldly pleasure. His actions shock even Montaigne but show the logical extreme of believing earthly life corrupts the soul.
Modern Equivalent:
The religious parent who cuts off kids for not following their strict beliefs
Hilary's daughter
Sacrificial victim
Dies young after her father prays for her death to save her from worldly temptation. Her story illustrates how other people pay the price for moral extremism.
Modern Equivalent:
The child whose life is controlled by a parent's rigid ideology
Hilary's wife
Convert to extremism
Initially horrified by her husband's prayer for their daughter's death, she eventually asks him to pray for her own death too, showing how extreme beliefs can spread.
Modern Equivalent:
The spouse who gets pulled into their partner's extreme lifestyle or beliefs
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am of opinion that thou either leave that life of thine, or life itself"
Context: Advising Lucilius to abandon his luxurious lifestyle for philosophical living
This shocking ultimatum shows how seriously philosophers took moral choices. Seneca isn't being cruel but highlighting that some compromises aren't worth making if they destroy your integrity.
In Today's Words:
Either completely change how you're living, or what's the point of living at all?
"It is high time to die when there is more ill than good in living"
Context: Establishing the principle that life isn't worth preserving at any cost
This challenges our modern assumption that life is always precious. It suggests that quality matters more than quantity, and that clinging to miserable existence isn't virtuous.
In Today's Words:
When your life sucks more than it doesn't, maybe it's time to go.
"Either tranquil life, or happy death"
Context: Summarizing the ancient view that peace in life or peace in death are both acceptable
This presents death not as failure but as one of two good options. It removes the desperate fear that makes people accept terrible conditions just to keep breathing.
In Today's Words:
Live peacefully or die peacefully - both beat living miserably.
Thematic Threads
Values
In This Chapter
Montaigne examines how extreme situations force people to choose between competing values, revealing what they truly prioritize
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when facing a decision that forces you to choose between security and integrity, or comfort and principle.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
The wealthy Roman is expected to enjoy his luxury, St. Hilary's daughter should want marriage and worldly success, yet both stories challenge these assumptions
Development
Continues theme from earlier chapters
In Your Life:
You see this when society tells you to want something that feels wrong for your situation or values.
Sacrifice
In This Chapter
Characters make extreme sacrifices—wealth, comfort, even life—for higher principles they believe in
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might face this when protecting what matters most requires giving up something everyone else thinks you should want.
Belief Systems
In This Chapter
Different philosophies and religions lead to similar conclusions about what's worth living or dying for
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You experience this when your personal beliefs conflict with what your family, workplace, or community expects from you.
Judgment
In This Chapter
Montaigne presents extreme examples without condemning them, exploring how sincere beliefs can lead to actions others find shocking
Development
Continues from earlier chapters
In Your Life:
You see this when you have to make decisions others don't understand, even when you know they're right for you.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What did Seneca tell the wealthy Roman to do, and what was St. Hilary's shocking decision about his daughter?
analysis • surface - 2
Why did these men believe that death was preferable to certain ways of living?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today making extreme choices to protect what they value most - walking away from money, status, or comfort?
application • medium - 4
When have you faced a moment where you had to choose between what looked good to others and what felt right to you?
reflection • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how crisis forces us to discover our true priorities?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Values Under Pressure
Think of a time when you felt pulled in different directions - maybe between a job opportunity and family time, or between fitting in and standing up for someone. Write down what you were being asked to choose between, then identify what value was most important to you in that moment. How did recognizing that core value help clarify your decision?
Consider:
- •Crisis doesn't create your values - it reveals them
- •The choice that feels hardest often protects what matters most
- •Sometimes saying no to good things protects what's essential
Journaling Prompt
Write about a decision you're facing now where you feel torn. What would happen if you could only protect one thing that matters to you? What does that tell you about your true priorities?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 33: When Fortune Plays by Its Own Rules
What lies ahead teaches us unexpected outcomes can reveal hidden patterns in chaos, and shows us timing and chance often matter more than careful planning. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.