Summary
Marcus Aurelius opens this chapter with a fundamental truth: injustice is impiety because the universe designed all rational beings to help, not harm each other. Those who lie, chase pleasures, or fear pain work against this natural order and hurt themselves most of all. He argues that we should be indifferent to things like pleasure, pain, honor, and dishonor—not because they don't matter, but because nature herself treats them as neutral tools in her grand design. The emperor then tackles humanity's greatest fear: death. He reframes it not as an ending to dread, but as natural as a child growing into an adult or getting gray hair. Death is simply the soul shedding its physical coat, and fearing it makes as much sense as a stone worrying about falling. Marcus observes a painful irony: while unreasonable animals naturally flock together, humans—the most rational creatures—have forgotten how to live in harmony. Yet nature still pulls us toward each other despite our resistance. He advises treating difficult people with patience, remembering that even the gods are kind to flawed humans. The chapter emphasizes that our troubles come not from external events but from our opinions about them. Marcus reminds us that fame and reputation are fleeting—most people will forget us quickly anyway. The key is accepting what happens as part of the cosmic order while ensuring our own actions serve the common good. He ends with practical wisdom about prayer: instead of asking for things, pray for the wisdom not to be disturbed by their presence or absence.
Coming Up in Chapter 10
In the tenth chapter, Marcus turns his attention to the art of living each day as if it were complete in itself, exploring how to find meaning in the present moment while preparing for whatever may come.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
THE NINTH BOOK I. He that is unjust, is also impious. For the nature of the universe, having made all reasonable creatures one for another, to the end that they should do one another good; more or less according to the several persons and occasions but in nowise hurt one another: it is manifest that he that doth transgress against this her will, is guilty of impiety towards the most ancient and venerable of all the deities. For the nature of the universe, is the nature the common parent of all, and therefore piously to be observed of all things that are, and that which now is, to whatsoever first was, and gave it its being, hath relation of blood and kindred. She is also called truth and is the first cause of all truths. He therefore that willingly and wittingly doth lie, is impious in that he doth receive, and so commit injustice: but he that against his will, in that he disagreeth from the nature of the universe, and in that striving with the nature of the world he doth in his particular, violate the general order of the world. For he doth no better than strive and war against it, who contrary to his own nature applieth himself to that which is contrary to truth. For nature had before furnished him with instincts and opportunities sufficient for the attainment of it; which he having hitherto neglected, is not now able to discern that which is false from that which is true. He also that pursues after pleasures, as that which is truly good and flies from pains, as that which is truly evil: is impious. For such a one must of necessity oftentimes accuse that common nature, as distributing many things both unto the evil, and unto the good, not according to the deserts of either: as unto the bad oftentimes pleasures, and the causes of pleasures; so unto the good, pains, and the occasions of pains. Again, he that feareth pains and crosses in this world, feareth some of those things which some time or other must needs happen in the world. And that we have already showed to be impious. And he that pursueth after pleasures, will not spare, to compass his desires, to do that which is unjust, and that is manifestly impious. Now those things which unto nature are equally indifferent (for she had not created both, both pain and pleasure, if both had not been unto her equally indifferent): they that will live according to nature, must in those things (as being of the same mind and disposition that she is) be as equally indifferent. Whosoever therefore in either matter of pleasure and pain; death and life; honour and dishonour, (which things nature in the administration of the world, indifferently doth make use of), is not as indifferent, it is apparent that he is impious. When I say that common nature doth indifferently make use of them, my meaning is, that they...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Natural Order - When Fighting Reality Hurts Most
Fighting against natural order or inevitable reality wastes energy and creates more suffering than acceptance and strategic adaptation.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches the crucial skill of separating what we can influence from what we cannot, preventing wasted energy on futile battles.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel frustrated or angry, then ask yourself: 'Is this something I can actually change, or am I fighting reality?'
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Stoic Physics
The Stoic belief that the universe is a single, rational organism where everything happens according to divine reason. Marcus sees all events as part of a cosmic plan, not random chaos.
Modern Usage:
We see this when people say 'everything happens for a reason' or talk about the universe having a plan.
Rational Nature
The Stoic idea that humans are designed by nature to use reason and work together for the common good. Going against this rational nature causes suffering.
Modern Usage:
This shows up in modern psychology's emphasis on cooperation and community as essential for mental health.
Indifferent Things
Stoic term for things that are neither good nor bad in themselves - like wealth, health, or reputation. They only become good or bad based on how we use them.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how we might say money or social media are 'tools' that can be used for good or bad.
Cosmic Sympathy
The Stoic belief that all parts of the universe are connected and influence each other, like organs in a body. What affects one part affects the whole.
Modern Usage:
We see this in modern ideas about interconnectedness, like how climate change affects everyone or how social movements spread globally.
Divine Providence
The Stoic view that the universe is guided by a rational, divine force that arranges everything for the best possible outcome, even when we can't see it.
Modern Usage:
This appears when people talk about trusting the process or believing that challenges make us stronger.
Natural Death
Marcus's view that death is simply a natural process, like leaves falling from trees or children growing up. Fighting it is like fighting gravity.
Modern Usage:
Modern grief counseling often emphasizes accepting death as a natural part of life rather than something to defeat.
Characters in This Chapter
Marcus Aurelius
Philosopher-emperor and narrator
He's writing personal reminders to himself about how to handle the stress of ruling an empire. Shows vulnerability despite his power, struggling with the same human challenges we all face.
Modern Equivalent:
The CEO who journals about work stress and tries to stay grounded
The Liar
Example of someone working against nature
Marcus uses this as an example of someone who harms themselves by going against their rational nature. The liar thinks they're getting ahead but actually damages their own character.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who throws others under the bus to get promoted
The Pleasure-Seeker
Example of misguided priorities
Represents people who chase temporary pleasures instead of lasting fulfillment. Marcus sees this as working against the natural order and ultimately self-destructive.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who maxes out credit cards for instant gratification
Unreasonable Animals
Contrast to humans
Marcus points out that even animals without reason naturally cooperate, while humans with reason often fail to work together. Shows how we've lost touch with our nature.
Modern Equivalent:
How wolves work as a pack while humans fight over parking spaces
Key Quotes & Analysis
"To act unjustly is impiety. For since universal nature has made rational animals for the sake of one another to help one another according to their deserts, but in no way to injure one another, he who transgresses her will is clearly guilty of impiety toward the highest divinity."
Context: Opening the chapter by establishing that harming others goes against the universe's design
This sets up Marcus's core argument that cooperation isn't just nice - it's our cosmic duty. He's telling himself that when people hurt others, they're fighting against the fundamental order of reality.
In Today's Words:
Being mean to people isn't just rude - it goes against how we're wired to work together.
"Death smiles at all of us, but all a man can do is smile back."
Context: Discussing how to face mortality with acceptance rather than fear
Marcus reframes death from something terrifying to something natural that deserves respect, not panic. He's coaching himself to meet life's ultimate challenge with dignity.
In Today's Words:
Death is coming for everyone, so you might as well face it with grace.
"Very little is needed to make a happy life; it is all within yourself, in your way of thinking."
Context: Reflecting on how our internal state matters more than external circumstances
This captures the Stoic emphasis on internal control versus external events. Marcus is reminding himself that happiness comes from how we process life, not what happens to us.
In Today's Words:
Happiness is an inside job - it's about your mindset, not your situation.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Marcus shows how even emperors must accept natural limits and work within cosmic order rather than above it
Development
Evolved from earlier themes about duty—now showing that true power comes from alignment, not opposition
In Your Life:
You might see this when trying to maintain appearances that drain your resources instead of accepting your actual circumstances
Identity
In This Chapter
Death reframed not as identity loss but as natural transformation, like aging or seasons changing
Development
Building on earlier acceptance themes—identity isn't fixed but part of larger flow
In Your Life:
You might struggle with this when facing major life changes that threaten your sense of who you are
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Fame and reputation revealed as fleeting distractions from what actually matters in human cooperation
Development
Deepening the theme of external validation vs internal worth from previous chapters
In Your Life:
You might see this in social media pressure or workplace politics that distract from meaningful relationships
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Growth happens through accepting difficult people and situations as teachers rather than obstacles
Development
Advanced application of earlier stoic principles—using adversity as curriculum
In Your Life:
You might find this when dealing with difficult family members or coworkers who trigger your worst reactions
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Even when humans forget how to cooperate, nature still pulls us toward each other—connection is our default
Development
Introduced here as fundamental insight about human nature and social bonds
In Your Life:
You might notice this when conflict with someone reveals underlying care or when strangers help during crises
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Anthony says injustice is 'impiety' because rational beings were designed to help each other. What examples does he give of people working against this natural order?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Anthony argue that fearing death is as pointless as a stone worrying about falling? What does this reveal about his view of natural processes?
analysis • medium - 3
Anthony notes that even unreasonable animals naturally cooperate, while humans struggle with harmony. Where do you see this pattern in your workplace, family, or community?
application • medium - 4
When you catch yourself fighting against something that's already happened or inevitable, how could you redirect that energy more productively?
application • deep - 5
Anthony suggests our troubles come from our opinions about events, not the events themselves. What does this teach us about where real power lies in difficult situations?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Resistance Points
Think of a current situation that's causing you stress or frustration. Write it down, then identify what parts of this situation you're fighting against versus what you're actually able to control. Create two columns: 'Fighting Reality' and 'Can Actually Influence.' Be brutally honest about which column has more items.
Consider:
- •Notice if you're spending more energy on the 'Fighting Reality' column than the 'Can Actually Influence' column
- •Ask yourself what would happen if you fully accepted everything in the first column
- •Consider how you could redirect your resistance energy toward the things you can actually change
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you stopped fighting an unchangeable situation and focused on what you could control instead. What shifted? How did this change your stress level and your results?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 10: The Soul's Journey to Simplicity
In the next chapter, you'll discover to recognize your true nature beyond external circumstances, and learn accepting your role in the universal order brings peace. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.