Summary
Meg gets invited to spend two weeks with the wealthy Moffat family, and what starts as an innocent adventure becomes a lesson in the seductive power of luxury and social pressure. At first, she's content with her simple wardrobe and grateful for the experience. But surrounded by wealth and fashion, she begins to feel ashamed of her modest clothes and envious of what she lacks. The Moffats, meaning well, dress her up for a party in an elaborate gown that transforms her appearance but makes her uncomfortable. When Laurie sees her, his honest disapproval cuts through the flattery she's been receiving, forcing her to confront how far she's drifted from herself. The evening becomes a series of small humiliations as she overhears gossip suggesting her family has 'plans' to marry her to Laurie for his money, and she realizes she's become a spectacle rather than a person. By the end of her visit, she's physically and emotionally exhausted, returning home with a new appreciation for authenticity over appearances. When she confesses everything to her mother, Mrs. March responds with wisdom rather than judgment, explaining her true 'plans' for her daughters: that they find genuine love and happiness rather than chase wealth or status. This chapter explores how easily we can lose ourselves when we're desperate to fit in, and how the pursuit of external validation often leaves us feeling emptier than when we started.
Coming Up in Chapter 10
Back home, the March sisters are about to discover that their own small world has its share of drama and secrets. Jo's literary ambitions are about to take an unexpected turn that will test her principles and her pride.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
CHAPTER NINE MEG GOES TO VANITY FAIR “I do think it was the most fortunate thing in the world that those children should have the measles just now,” said Meg, one April day, as she stood packing the ‘go abroady’ trunk in her room, surrounded by her sisters. “And so nice of Annie Moffat not to forget her promise. A whole fortnight of fun will be regularly splendid,” replied Jo, looking like a windmill as she folded skirts with her long arms. “And such lovely weather, I’m so glad of that,” added Beth, tidily sorting neck and hair ribbons in her best box, lent for the great occasion. “I wish I was going to have a fine time and wear all these nice things,” said Amy with her mouth full of pins, as she artistically replenished her sister’s cushion. “I wish you were all going, but as you can’t, I shall keep my adventures to tell you when I come back. I’m sure it’s the least I can do when you have been so kind, lending me things and helping me get ready,” said Meg, glancing round the room at the very simple outfit, which seemed nearly perfect in their eyes. “What did Mother give you out of the treasure box?” asked Amy, who had not been present at the opening of a certain cedar chest in which Mrs. March kept a few relics of past splendor, as gifts for her girls when the proper time came. “A pair of silk stockings, that pretty carved fan, and a lovely blue sash. I wanted the violet silk, but there isn’t time to make it over, so I must be contented with my old tarlaton.” “It will look nice over my new muslin skirt, and the sash will set it off beautifully. I wish I hadn’t smashed my coral bracelet, for you might have had it,” said Jo, who loved to give and lend, but whose possessions were usually too dilapidated to be of much use. “There is a lovely old-fashioned pearl set in the treasure chest, but Mother said real flowers were the prettiest ornament for a young girl, and Laurie promised to send me all I want,” replied Meg. “Now, let me see, there’s my new gray walking suit, just curl up the feather in my hat, Beth, then my poplin for Sunday and the small party, it looks heavy for spring, doesn’t it? The violet silk would be so nice. Oh, dear!” “Never mind, you’ve got the tarlaton for the big party, and you always look like an angel in white,” said Amy, brooding over the little store of finery in which her soul delighted. “It isn’t low-necked, and it doesn’t sweep enough, but it will have to do. My blue housedress looks so well, turned and freshly trimmed, that I feel as if I’d got a new one. My silk sacque isn’t a bit the fashion, and my bonnet doesn’t look like Sallie’s. I didn’t like to say...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Borrowed Identity
When insecurity makes us adopt someone else's identity to fit in, leading to exhaustion and loss of authentic self.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when social pressure is slowly replacing your authentic self with a performance.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel the urge to hide or change parts of yourself to fit in—that's your early warning system for identity erosion.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Vanity Fair
A reference to John Bunyan's 'Pilgrim's Progress' - a place where people are tempted by worldly pleasures and lose sight of what really matters. Alcott uses it as the chapter title to show how Meg gets seduced by luxury and status.
Modern Usage:
We see this whenever someone gets caught up in keeping up appearances on social media or buying things they can't afford to impress others.
Social climbing
The attempt to gain acceptance into a higher social class, often by changing your behavior, appearance, or values to fit in. Meg experiences this when she tries to become someone she's not to impress the wealthy Moffats.
Modern Usage:
This happens when people change their accent, lie about their background, or go into debt buying designer items to appear more successful than they are.
Genteel poverty
Being poor but maintaining the manners and appearance of respectability. The March family has good breeding and education but little money, which creates unique social pressures.
Modern Usage:
Like families today who struggle financially but still try to keep up middle-class appearances, or people who are 'house poor' but won't admit they're struggling.
Coming out
In the 1800s, this meant a young woman's formal introduction to society, marking her availability for marriage. It involved elaborate parties and specific social rituals that determined her future prospects.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how young people today feel pressure around prom, graduation parties, or sweet sixteen celebrations - events that feel like they define your social status.
Dress up/costume
When the Moffats dress Meg in elaborate clothes and makeup, she becomes like someone in costume - beautiful but not herself. The fancy dress literally transforms her into someone else.
Modern Usage:
Like when people create a completely different persona online or feel they have to 'dress the part' for certain jobs or social situations.
Gossip mill
The way rumors and speculation spread through social circles, often distorting the truth. Meg overhears people discussing her family's supposed 'plans' for her, which aren't true but still hurt.
Modern Usage:
Exactly like workplace gossip, neighborhood drama, or how rumors spread on social media - often based on assumptions rather than facts.
Characters in This Chapter
Meg
Protagonist facing temptation
She starts the chapter grateful and content, but gradually becomes ashamed of her simple life when surrounded by wealth. Her transformation into someone she doesn't recognize teaches her about the cost of trying to be someone you're not.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who changes everything about themselves for a new job or relationship, then realizes they've lost who they really are
The Moffat family
Well-meaning tempters
They're not malicious, but their wealth and different values create pressure on Meg to conform. They dress her up and include her in their world, but this 'kindness' actually makes her feel worse about herself.
Modern Equivalent:
The wealthy friends who always want to pay for expensive dinners and trips, making you feel awkward about your budget
Laurie
Truth-telling friend
When he sees Meg all dressed up, his honest disapproval cuts through all the flattery she's been receiving. His reaction forces her to see herself as she really looks - not herself.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who tells you the truth when everyone else is just being polite - sometimes it stings, but you need to hear it
Mrs. March
Wise counselor
When Meg confesses everything, her mother responds with understanding rather than judgment. She explains that real plans for her daughters involve finding genuine happiness, not chasing status or money.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent who listens without lecturing and helps you figure out what you really want versus what you think you should want
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I'm not Meg tonight, I'm 'a doll' who does all sorts of crazy things."
Context: When she's all dressed up for the party and feeling like she's lost herself
This shows how external transformation can make us feel disconnected from our true selves. Meg recognizes she's become an object for others' entertainment rather than being valued for who she really is.
In Today's Words:
I don't even recognize myself anymore - I'm just playing a role that everyone else wants me to play.
"You don't look like yourself, but you are not spoiled yet."
Context: When he sees Meg at the party, dressed up and acting differently
Laurie's honest reaction serves as a wake-up call. He sees that she's lost herself but believes she can still find her way back to who she really is.
In Today's Words:
This isn't you, but you haven't gone too far down this road to turn back.
"My dear, I have a great many plans, but the favorite one is to see my daughters happy."
Context: When Meg confesses about the gossip suggesting her mother has 'plans' to marry her to Laurie for money
This reveals Mrs. March's true values - she wants authentic happiness for her daughters, not social advancement or financial gain. It's a rejection of using marriage as a business transaction.
In Today's Words:
I do have hopes for you, but mainly I just want you to be genuinely happy, not successful by other people's standards.
Thematic Threads
Class Pressure
In This Chapter
Meg feels ashamed of her simple clothes when surrounded by the Moffats' wealth and begins to see her family's modest means as embarrassing
Development
Building from earlier hints about the March family's reduced circumstances
In Your Life:
You might feel this when you're the only one in your friend group who can't afford certain activities or purchases
Authentic Identity
In This Chapter
Meg loses herself in borrowed finery and artificial behavior, becoming uncomfortable in her own skin
Development
Contrasts with earlier chapters showing the sisters' genuine personalities
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you catch yourself acting completely different around certain people or in specific situations
Social Performance
In This Chapter
Meg becomes a spectacle at the party, playing a role rather than being herself, leading to gossip and misunderstanding
Development
New theme introduced here
In Your Life:
You might experience this when you feel like you're constantly 'on stage' in social situations rather than just being yourself
Parental Wisdom
In This Chapter
Mrs. March responds to Meg's confession with understanding rather than judgment, offering perspective on true values versus social expectations
Development
Continues the theme of Mrs. March as moral compass established in earlier chapters
In Your Life:
You might need this when you're struggling with decisions about what others expect versus what feels right to you
External Validation
In This Chapter
Meg craves the attention and compliments that come with her makeover but finds them ultimately hollow and exhausting
Development
Introduced here as counterpoint to the family's emphasis on internal worth
In Your Life:
You might notice this when you find yourself constantly seeking approval or feeling empty after receiving praise for things that aren't really 'you'
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific changes do you see in Meg from the beginning to the end of her visit with the Moffats?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Meg feel so uncomfortable when Laurie sees her at the party, even though everyone else is complimenting her appearance?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today changing themselves to fit in with a wealthier or more prestigious group? What are the warning signs?
application • medium - 4
If you were Meg's friend and noticed she was losing herself trying to fit in, how would you help her without making her feel judged?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between wanting to improve yourself versus wanting to become someone else entirely?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track Your Identity Compass
Think of a time when you felt pressure to change who you are to fit in somewhere new - a job, school, social group, or relationship. Write down three specific things you changed about yourself and how each change made you feel. Then identify which changes helped you grow versus which ones made you feel like you were performing.
Consider:
- •Notice the difference between adapting your behavior and abandoning your values
- •Pay attention to whether the changes energized you or drained you over time
- •Consider whether the people around you liked the real you or just the performance
Journaling Prompt
Write about a relationship or environment where you feel most authentically yourself. What makes that space safe for you to be genuine, and how can you create more of that in your life?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 10: The Pickwick Club and Post Office
In the next chapter, you'll discover creative projects strengthen family bonds and individual identity, and learn the power of inclusive communities that welcome new perspectives. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.