Summary
Jo and Professor Bhaer have been taking 'accidental' walks together for weeks, with everyone pretending not to notice their obvious attraction. When Bhaer disappears for three days, Jo becomes miserable and goes into town ostensibly for errands but really hoping to see him. Caught in the rain without an umbrella, she literally runs into him near his workplace. As they shop together for gifts for his students, Jo's emotions swing wildly between hope and despair as she tries to figure out his intentions. When Bhaer mentions he's leaving for a teaching job out West, Jo can't hide her disappointment. This finally breaks through his uncertainty—he reveals he came to see if she could care for him, having been inspired by one of her published poems about loneliness. Standing in the muddy street under his old umbrella, they confess their love for each other. It's the opposite of a fairy-tale proposal—they're both bedraggled, surrounded by puddles, with their hands full of packages—but it's perfectly real. Jo realizes she's found her place walking beside this kind, scholarly man who sees her worth. The chapter shows how authentic love often comes through ordinary moments and shared struggles rather than grand romantic gestures.
Coming Up in Chapter 47
The final chapter brings us to harvest time, where we'll see how all the March sisters have grown and what their lives look like as they've become the women they were meant to be.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
CHAPTER FORTY-SIX UNDER THE UMBRELLA While Laurie and Amy were taking conjugal strolls over velvet carpets, as they set their house in order, and planned a blissful future, Mr. Bhaer and Jo were enjoying promenades of a different sort, along muddy roads and sodden fields. “I always do take a walk toward evening, and I don’t know why I should give it up, just because I happen to meet the Professor on his way out,” said Jo to herself, after two or three encounters, for though there were two paths to Meg’s whichever one she took she was sure to meet him, either going or returning. He was always walking rapidly, and never seemed to see her until quite close, when he would look as if his short-sighted eyes had failed to recognize the approaching lady till that moment. Then, if she was going to Meg’s he always had something for the babies. If her face was turned homeward, he had merely strolled down to see the river, and was just returning, unless they were tired of his frequent calls. Under the circumstances, what could Jo do but greet him civilly, and invite him in? If she was tired of his visits, she concealed her weariness with perfect skill, and took care that there should be coffee for supper, “as Friedrich—I mean Mr. Bhaer—doesn’t like tea.” By the second week, everyone knew perfectly well what was going on, yet everyone tried to look as if they were stone-blind to the changes in Jo’s face. They never asked why she sang about her work, did up her hair three times a day, and got so blooming with her evening exercise. And no one seemed to have the slightest suspicion that Professor Bhaer, while talking philosophy with the father, was giving the daughter lessons in love. Jo couldn’t even lose her heart in a decorous manner, but sternly tried to quench her feelings, and failing to do so, led a somewhat agitated life. She was mortally afraid of being laughed at for surrendering, after her many and vehement declarations of independence. Laurie was her especial dread, but thanks to the new manager, he behaved with praiseworthy propriety, never called Mr. Bhaer ‘a capital old fellow’ in public, never alluded, in the remotest manner, to Jo’s improved appearance, or expressed the least surprise at seeing the Professor’s hat on the Marches’ table nearly every evening. But he exulted in private and longed for the time to come when he could give Jo a piece of plate, with a bear and a ragged staff on it as an appropriate coat of arms. For a fortnight, the Professor came and went with lover-like regularity. Then he stayed away for three whole days, and made no sign, a proceeding which caused everybody to look sober, and Jo to become pensive, at first, and then—alas for romance—very cross. “Disgusted, I dare say, and gone home as suddenly as he came. It’s nothing to me, of course, but...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Authentic Connection
Real relationships form through shared vulnerability and imperfection, not through performed perfection or strategic distance.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how authentic connection requires dropping our masks and meeting others in our actual messy lives rather than our curated versions.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you're performing perfection instead of being real—then try sharing one genuine struggle or asking for help with something that actually matters to you.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Conjugal strolls
Walks taken by married couples, especially newlyweds. In the 1860s, taking walks together was a proper way for couples to spend time and show their relationship status. The word 'conjugal' refers to marriage.
Modern Usage:
Today we might call this 'couple time' or date nights - those activities married people do to stay connected.
Promenades
Formal walks, usually for pleasure or to be seen by others. In Alcott's time, promenading was a social activity where people dressed up and walked in public spaces to socialize and display their status.
Modern Usage:
Like walking through the mall or downtown strip just to see and be seen, or posting couple photos on social media.
Civilly
Politely and properly, according to social rules. In the 1860s, there were strict codes about how unmarried men and women should interact, especially when attraction was involved.
Modern Usage:
Today we might say 'keeping it professional' or 'being polite' when you're attracted to someone but trying to maintain boundaries.
Stone-blind
Completely blind, unable to see. Here it means pretending not to notice something obvious. Victorian families often pretended not to see romantic developments to maintain propriety.
Modern Usage:
Like when everyone knows two coworkers are into each other but pretends not to notice the obvious flirting.
Sodden fields
Fields soaked with water, muddy and wet. This describes the unglamorous reality of Jo's walks, contrasting with the luxurious 'velvet carpets' of Laurie and Amy's wealthy lifestyle.
Modern Usage:
Today this represents choosing substance over appearance - like preferring a genuine relationship over Instagram-perfect moments.
Short-sighted eyes
Nearsighted vision, unable to see clearly at a distance. In the 1860s, eyeglasses were less common and often seen as a sign of scholarly work. Bhaer's poor vision symbolizes his intellectual nature.
Modern Usage:
Today we might joke about someone being 'blind without their glasses' or use it as shorthand for the absent-minded professor type.
Characters in This Chapter
Jo
Protagonist in love
Jo struggles with her feelings for Bhaer, taking 'accidental' walks to see him and becoming miserable when he disappears. She's torn between hope and fear of rejection, showing her vulnerable side beneath her usual independence.
Modern Equivalent:
The strong woman who gets tongue-tied around her crush
Professor Bhaer (Friedrich)
Love interest
Bhaer also orchestrates 'chance' meetings with Jo but is too uncertain of her feelings to be direct. When he finally confesses his love, it's in the most unromantic setting possible, showing their love is based on real connection, not fantasy.
Modern Equivalent:
The thoughtful guy who overthinks everything before making his move
Laurie
Contrast figure
Mentioned briefly as enjoying luxury with Amy, his wealthy lifestyle contrasts sharply with Jo and Bhaer's muddy, practical courtship. This shows different types of happiness and love.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend living their best Instagram life
Amy
Contrast figure
Like Laurie, Amy represents the fairy-tale romance with wealth and comfort. Her 'velvet carpets' highlight how Jo's love story is grounded in reality rather than luxury.
Modern Equivalent:
The sister who married well and posts perfect vacation photos
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I always do take a walk toward evening, and I don't know why I should give it up, just because I happen to meet the Professor on his way out"
Context: Jo justifying to herself why she keeps taking walks where she'll 'accidentally' encounter Bhaer
This shows Jo's self-deception about her own feelings. She's clearly seeking him out but won't admit it to herself, revealing how scary it is to acknowledge romantic vulnerability.
In Today's Words:
I'm not changing my routine just because my crush happens to be there - it's totally a coincidence.
"as Friedrich—I mean Mr. Bhaer—doesn't like tea"
Context: Jo catching herself using his first name while explaining why she makes coffee
The slip from formal to intimate address shows how her feelings are breaking through her attempts at propriety. Small domestic details like knowing his beverage preference reveal growing intimacy.
In Today's Words:
I know exactly how he likes his coffee - I mean, I just happened to notice.
"everyone knew perfectly well what was going on, yet everyone tried to look as if they were stone-blind"
Context: Describing how the family pretends not to notice Jo and Bhaer's obvious attraction
This captures the polite fiction families maintain around budding romance. Sometimes love is obvious to everyone except the people involved, and others have to pretend not to see it.
In Today's Words:
Everyone could see they were into each other, but nobody wanted to say anything.
Thematic Threads
Authenticity
In This Chapter
Jo and Bhaer's love emerges through honest emotion in an unglamorous setting, not through romantic performance
Development
Evolved from Jo's earlier struggles with fitting social expectations to finding someone who values her true self
In Your Life:
You might find your strongest relationships form during difficult times when pretenses drop away.
Class
In This Chapter
Bhaer hesitates to propose because he thinks his modest circumstances make him unworthy of Jo
Development
Continues the book's examination of how economic status affects relationship choices and self-worth
In Your Life:
You might hold back from opportunities or relationships because you think your background isn't 'enough.'
Vulnerability
In This Chapter
Both characters must risk emotional exposure—Jo through her obvious disappointment, Bhaer through his confession
Development
Shows how vulnerability becomes strength rather than weakness in mature relationships
In Your Life:
You might find that sharing your real struggles creates deeper connections than sharing your successes.
Timing
In This Chapter
Their connection almost fails because both wait for the 'right' moment instead of creating honest moments
Development
Demonstrates that authentic timing matters more than perfect timing
In Your Life:
You might miss important connections by waiting for ideal circumstances instead of working with real ones.
Recognition
In This Chapter
Bhaer sees Jo's worth through her writing about loneliness, recognizing her depth beyond surface charm
Development
Culminates Jo's journey to find someone who values her mind and authentic self
In Your Life:
You might find that the right people recognize your value in ways that surprise you.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Jo go into town claiming she needs errands when she's really hoping to see Professor Bhaer?
analysis • surface - 2
What prevents both Jo and Bhaer from being honest about their feelings until they're caught in the rain?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today performing 'casual indifference' when they actually care deeply about the outcome?
application • medium - 4
How might Jo and Bhaer's relationship have developed differently if they had met at a fancy social event instead of in muddy streets?
analysis • deep - 5
What does this scene suggest about when we're most likely to form genuine connections with others?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Own Vulnerability Patterns
Think of a relationship (friendship, romantic, or professional) where you've been performing 'casual indifference' while actually caring deeply. Write down what you're really hoping for versus what you're showing the other person. Then identify one small way you could be more authentically yourself in that relationship.
Consider:
- •Notice the gap between what you want and what you're willing to risk showing
- •Consider what you're afraid might happen if you're more honest about your investment
- •Think about times when others' authenticity made you feel more connected to them
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone saw through your performed indifference and responded to who you really are. How did that change the relationship, and what did it teach you about the risks and rewards of being genuine?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 47: Harvest Time: Jo's Dream Fulfilled
The coming pages reveal to turn personal struggles into purposeful work that helps others, and teach us building something meaningful matters more than accumulating wealth. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.