Summary
Meg struggles with the overwhelming demands of motherhood, becoming so absorbed in her babies that she neglects her husband John and their home. John feels displaced and lonely, eventually seeking companionship at the neighbors' house. When Meg notices his absence and feels hurt, her mother Marmee provides crucial wisdom: marriage requires balance, and children should bring couples together, not drive them apart. Marmee explains that both parents have roles in childcare, and that Meg needs to maintain her own interests and identity beyond motherhood. When Meg attempts to implement this advice, she faces resistance from her spoiled son Demi, but John steps in with firm but loving discipline. The chapter shows how the couple learns to share parenting duties—John bringing structure and boundaries while Meg provides nurturing care. Through honest communication and mutual effort, they restore harmony to their home. The chapter illustrates the common challenge many new parents face: losing themselves and each other in the intensity of caring for children. Alcott presents a progressive view for the 1860s, showing that successful marriages require both partners to be engaged parents and interesting companions to each other. The resolution demonstrates that happiness comes not from sacrifice and martyrdom, but from balance, communication, and shared responsibility.
Coming Up in Chapter 39
The focus shifts to Laurie, who despite his privileged position, struggles with his own challenges of purpose and direction. His laid-back attitude begins to concern those who care about him most.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
CHAPTER THIRTY-EIGHT ON THE SHELF In France the young girls have a dull time of it till they are married, when ‘Vive la liberte!’ becomes their motto. In America, as everyone knows, girls early sign the declaration of independence, and enjoy their freedom with republican zest, but the young matrons usually abdicate with the first heir to the throne and go into a seclusion almost as close as a French nunnery, though by no means as quiet. Whether they like it or not, they are virtually put upon the shelf as soon as the wedding excitement is over, and most of them might exclaim, as did a very pretty woman the other day, “I’m as handsome as ever, but no one takes any notice of me because I’m married.” Not being a belle or even a fashionable lady, Meg did not experience this affliction till her babies were a year old, for in her little world primitive customs prevailed, and she found herself more admired and beloved than ever. As she was a womanly little woman, the maternal instinct was very strong, and she was entirely absorbed in her children, to the utter exclusion of everything and everybody else. Day and night she brooded over them with tireless devotion and anxiety, leaving John to the tender mercies of the help, for an Irish lady now presided over the kitchen department. Being a domestic man, John decidedly missed the wifely attentions he had been accustomed to receive, but as he adored his babies, he cheerfully relinquished his comfort for a time, supposing with masculine ignorance that peace would soon be restored. But three months passed, and there was no return of repose. Meg looked worn and nervous, the babies absorbed every minute of her time, the house was neglected, and Kitty, the cook, who took life ‘aisy’, kept him on short commons. When he went out in the morning he was bewildered by small commissions for the captive mamma, if he came gaily in at night, eager to embrace his family, he was quenched by a “Hush! They are just asleep after worrying all day.” If he proposed a little amusement at home, “No, it would disturb the babies.” If he hinted at a lecture or a concert, he was answered with a reproachful look, and a decided—“Leave my children for pleasure, never!” His sleep was broken by infant wails and visions of a phantom figure pacing noiselessly to and fro in the watches of the night. His meals were interrupted by the frequent flight of the presiding genius, who deserted him, half-helped, if a muffled chirp sounded from the nest above. And when he read his paper of an evening, Demi’s colic got into the shipping list and Daisy’s fall affected the price of stocks, for Mrs. Brooke was only interested in domestic news. The poor man was very uncomfortable, for the children had bereft him of his wife, home was merely a nursery and the perpetual ‘hushing’ made him...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Lost Partnership - When Good Intentions Create Distance
When complete devotion to one responsibility inadvertently destroys the relationships we're trying to protect.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to spot when we're using self-sacrifice to avoid asking for what we actually need.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel overwhelmed but refuse help—ask yourself what you're really afraid of losing if you share the responsibility.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
On the shelf
A Victorian phrase meaning a woman was considered past her prime or no longer socially relevant, typically applied to married women who were expected to retreat from social life. Once married, women were supposed to focus entirely on home and children, becoming invisible in society.
Modern Usage:
We still use this phrase today when someone feels overlooked or sidelined, like when older workers worry about being 'put on the shelf' for younger employees.
Republican zest
Alcott refers to the American ideal that young women could enjoy more freedom and independence than their European counterparts, reflecting the democratic values of the new nation. American girls were expected to be more spirited and self-reliant.
Modern Usage:
This captures the ongoing American belief in individual freedom and self-determination, especially the idea that American women have more opportunities than women in other cultures.
Maternal instinct
The Victorian belief that women had a natural, overwhelming drive to care for children that would consume all other interests. This was used to justify why women should focus solely on motherhood and domestic duties.
Modern Usage:
We still debate whether maternal instinct is natural or learned, and many new mothers struggle with the pressure to be naturally nurturing while maintaining their own identity.
Domestic man
A husband who preferred home life and family time over outside social activities or work pursuits. This was somewhat unusual for Victorian men, who were expected to focus on business and public life.
Modern Usage:
Today we call these 'family men' or 'homebodies' - partners who prioritize family time and want to be actively involved in home life.
Wifely attentions
The constant care and service Victorian wives were expected to provide their husbands - managing the household, preparing meals, and attending to their comfort and needs. This was considered a woman's primary duty.
Modern Usage:
This reflects ongoing tensions about domestic labor division and emotional labor in relationships, though today we expect more equality in household responsibilities.
Primitive customs
Alcott's way of describing simpler, more traditional ways of living where community values and family relationships mattered more than fashionable society rules. In Meg's world, being a good wife and mother was more important than being stylish.
Modern Usage:
We use 'old-fashioned values' or 'traditional ways' to describe communities that prioritize family and relationships over material success or social status.
Characters in This Chapter
Meg
Overwhelmed new mother
She becomes so consumed with caring for her babies that she neglects everything else, including her husband and herself. Her transformation from balanced wife to anxious, obsessive mother creates problems in her marriage that require intervention from her wise mother.
Modern Equivalent:
The helicopter parent who loses herself completely in her children's needs
John
Neglected husband
He feels displaced in his own home as Meg focuses entirely on the babies. Rather than communicate directly, he starts spending time at the neighbors' house, which hurts Meg's feelings and creates tension in their marriage.
Modern Equivalent:
The partner who feels pushed out when the baby comes and doesn't know how to ask for attention
Marmee
Wise mentor
Meg's mother provides crucial guidance about balancing marriage and motherhood. She explains that healthy families require both parents to be involved and that wives shouldn't sacrifice their entire identity to child-rearing.
Modern Equivalent:
The experienced mom friend who gives you the real talk about maintaining your relationship after kids
Demi
Spoiled child
Meg's overindulgence has made him demanding and difficult. When John finally steps in with firm discipline, Demi learns boundaries while still feeling loved, showing how both parents' approaches are needed.
Modern Equivalent:
The kid who rules the house because one parent won't set limits
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I'm as handsome as ever, but no one takes any notice of me because I'm married."
Context: The narrator uses this quote to illustrate how married women become socially invisible
This captures the frustration many women felt about losing their individual identity once they became wives and mothers. Marriage was supposed to be fulfilling, but it often meant disappearing from public life and social recognition.
In Today's Words:
I'm still the same person I was before, but now that I'm married, people treat me like I don't exist.
"Children should draw you nearer together, not separate you."
Context: Marmee is counseling Meg about her marriage problems
This wisdom challenges the Victorian assumption that women must choose between being good wives or good mothers. Marmee argues that healthy parenting requires both partners working together, not the mother sacrificing everything.
In Today's Words:
Kids should bring you closer as a team, not drive a wedge between you.
"Don't shut him out of the nursery, but teach him how to help."
Context: Advising Meg on how to include John in parenting
Revolutionary advice for the 1860s, suggesting fathers should be active participants in childcare rather than distant providers. This challenges traditional gender roles and promotes partnership in parenting.
In Today's Words:
Don't push him away from the baby stuff - show him how to be helpful instead.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Meg loses herself completely in the mother role, forgetting she's also a wife and individual person
Development
Evolution from earlier themes of finding identity - now showing how identity can become too narrow
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you can only talk about work, your kids, or your problems
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Marriage requires active maintenance and balance between different roles and responsibilities
Development
Builds on earlier relationship themes, showing how good relationships require ongoing effort
In Your Life:
You see this when your closest relationships feel strained because you've been taking them for granted
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Meg tries to meet impossible standards of perfect motherhood that actually harm her family
Development
Continues the theme of how social pressure can lead us astray from what actually works
In Your Life:
You feel this pressure when you're exhausted trying to meet everyone else's definition of success
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Both Meg and John must learn new skills - sharing responsibilities and honest communication
Development
Shows growth as an ongoing process that requires adapting to new life phases
In Your Life:
You experience this when major life changes force you to develop new ways of being in relationships
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What changes in Meg's behavior after she becomes a mother, and how does John react to these changes?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Meg's complete devotion to her children actually harm her family instead of helping it?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern today - people becoming so absorbed in one responsibility that they neglect important relationships?
application • medium - 4
When you're overwhelmed by competing demands, how do you decide what gets your attention and what gets put on hold?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between sacrifice and balance in relationships?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Attention Patterns
Think about the past month and identify one area where you've been intensely focused - work project, family crisis, health issue, or personal goal. Draw a simple chart showing how much time and mental energy you've given to this focus versus other important relationships and responsibilities. Then mark which relationships might be feeling neglected.
Consider:
- •Notice where good intentions might be creating unintended consequences
- •Look for relationships that have been 'on hold' longer than you realized
- •Consider whether your current balance is sustainable long-term
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you became so absorbed in doing something good that you accidentally hurt the people you cared about. What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 39: Amy's Wake-Up Call for Laurie
Moving forward, we'll examine honest feedback from someone who cares can break through self-pity, and understand wallowing in rejection often becomes more damaging than the original hurt. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.