Summary
Isolation and Defiance
Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë
Following her illness and confinement in the red room, Jane finds herself even more isolated at Gateshead Hall. Mrs. Reed has increased the separation between Jane and her cousins, forcing her to sleep alone in a closet, eat meals by herself, and spend time only in the nursery while the Reed children enjoy the drawing room. Despite this harsh treatment, Jane maintains hope that she will be sent to school, sensing Mrs. Reed's growing aversion to her presence. The chapter reveals Jane's developing strength of character when she stands up to John Reed's bullying, physically defending herself and declaring that the Reed children are 'not fit to associate with' her. This bold statement leads to a confrontation with Mrs. Reed, during which Jane invokes her deceased Uncle Reed, suggesting he can see Mrs. Reed's cruel treatment from heaven. This reference clearly disturbs Mrs. Reed, hinting at promises made to her late husband regarding Jane's care. Throughout the winter months, Jane experiences complete exclusion from the family's Christmas celebrations and social gatherings. She finds solace only in her relationship with her doll, which represents her deep need for affection and companionship. The chapter also explores her complex relationship with Bessie, the servant who shows her occasional kindness but remains inconsistent in her treatment. The chapter concludes with detailed observations of the Reed children's characters, particularly Eliza's mercenary nature and love of profit, establishing the moral contrasts that will run throughout the novel. Jane's isolation becomes both a source of suffering and a crucible for developing her independent spirit and moral compass.
Coming Up in Chapter 5
Five o'clock had hardly struck on the morning of the 19th of January, when Bessie brought a candle into my closet and found me already up and nearly dressed. I had risen half-an-hour before her entran
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~352 words)
From my discourse with Mr. Lloyd, and from the above reported conference between Bessie and Abbot, I gathered enough of hope to suffice as a motive for wishing to get well: a change seemed near,—I desired and waited it in silence. It tarried, however: days and weeks passed: I had regained my normal state of health, but no new allusion was made to the subject over which I brooded. Mrs. Reed surveyed me at times with a severe eye, but seldom addressed me: since my illness, she had drawn a more mar Following her illness and confinement in the red room, Jane finds herself even more isolated at Gateshead Hall. Mrs. Reed has increased the separation between Jane and her cousins, forcing her to sleep alone in a closet, eat meals by herself, and spend time only in the nursery while the Reed children enjoy the drawing room. Despite this harsh treatment, Jane maintains hope that she will be sent to school, sensing Mrs. Reed's growing aversion to her presence. The chapter reveals Jane's developing strength of character when she stands up to John Reed's bullying, physically defending herself and declaring that the Reed children are 'not fit to associate with' her. This bold statement leads to a confrontation with Mrs. Reed, during which Jane invokes her deceased Uncle Reed, suggesting he can see Mrs. Reed's cruel treatment from heaven. This reference clearly disturbs Mrs. Reed, hinting at promises made to her late husband regarding Jane's care. Throughout the winter months, Jane experiences complete exclusion from the family's Christmas celebrations and social gatherings. She finds solace only in her relationship with her doll, which represents her deep need for affection and companionship. The chapter also explores her complex relationship with Bessie, the servant who shows her occasional kindness but remains inconsistent in her treatment. The chapter concludes with detailed observations of the Reed children's characters, particularly Eliza's mercenary nature and love of profit, establishing the moral contrasts that will run throughout the novel. Jane's isolation becomes both a source of suffering and a crucible for developing her independent spirit and moral compass.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
Literary Insight
This chapter demonstrates how literature can illuminate the psychological resilience required to maintain dignity in the face of systematic oppression and emotional abuse.
Today's Relevance
Jane's experience speaks to anyone who has felt excluded, bullied, or diminished by those in power, showing how inner strength and moral conviction can sustain us through difficult circumstances
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Insuperable
Impossible to overcome; insurmountable
Execrations
Curses or expressions of hatred and condemnation
Hiatus
A pause or gap in continuity; an interruption
Homily
A religious discourse or moralizing lecture
Apparelling
The act of dressing or clothing someone
Parterre
A formal garden with paths between beds of flowers
Characters in This Chapter
Jane Eyre
Protagonist/Orphaned child
Shows increasing defiance and moral strength despite continued isolation and abuse
Mrs. Reed
Jane's aunt and guardian
Becomes more openly hostile toward Jane, clearly disturbed by mentions of her late husband
John Reed
Jane's cousin and tormentor
Continues his bullying but now fears Jane's retaliation after she fights back
Eliza Reed
Jane's cousin
Revealed as mercenary and profit-minded, caring for poultry to earn and hoard money
Georgiana Reed
Jane's cousin
Participates in Jane's social exclusion but remains a background figure
Bessie Lee
Servant/nursemaid
Shows Jane occasional kindness but remains inconsistent, described as pretty but capricious
Key Quotes & Analysis
"They are not fit to associate with me."
Context: Jane's bold declaration of moral superiority over the Reed children, marking her growing self-respect
"My Uncle Reed is in heaven, and can see all you do and think; and so can papa and mama: they know how you shut me up all day long, and how you wish me dead."
Context: Jane invokes divine justice and her deceased relatives, disturbing Mrs. Reed with implications of broken promises
"Human beings must love something, and, in the dearth of worthier objects of affection, I contrived to find a pleasure in loving and cherishing a faded graven image, shabby as a miniature scarecrow."
Context: Jane's poignant reflection on her need for love and her attachment to her doll as a substitute for human affection
Thematic Threads
Independence
In This Chapter
Development
In Your Life:
When have you had to choose between financial security and your personal values, and what did that decision reveal about what truly matters to you?
Social class
In This Chapter
Development
In Your Life:
How do you navigate situations where you feel judged or excluded because of your background, income, or social status?
Self-respect
In This Chapter
Development
In Your Life:
What does it mean to you to maintain your dignity when others try to make you feel small or unworthy?
Morality
In This Chapter
Development
In Your Life:
When faced with a situation where everyone else is doing something you believe is wrong, how do you find the courage to stand alone?
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How does Jane's physical retaliation against John Reed represent a turning point in her character development?
- 2
What role does Jane's attachment to her doll play in her emotional survival, and what does this reveal about human nature?
- 3
Why does Mrs. Reed react so strongly when Jane mentions Uncle Reed, and what might this suggest about promises made to the dying?
- 4
How does Brontë use the contrast between Jane's isolation and the Reed family's social activities to highlight themes of belonging and exclusion?
Critical Thinking Exercise
Analyze how Brontë uses physical spaces (the closet, nursery, drawing room) to represent social hierarchies and emotional states. Consider how Jane's confinement to certain areas reflects her position in the household and her internal psychological state.
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 5: Departure from Gateshead
In the next chapter, you'll discover uses the journey motif as a symbol of personal transformation and escape from oppression, and learn jane's refusal to bid farewell to mrs. reed as an act of moral independence. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.