Summary
Death, Grief, and Empty Promises
Great Expectations by Charles Dickens
Mrs. Joe's death brings Pip back to the marshes, confronting him with the relationships he's neglected and the person he's become. The funeral is somber, with Joe grieving simply and sincerely for the difficult woman he married. Despite Mrs. Joe's harshness, Joe remembers her better qualities and mourns genuinely. Biddy has stayed on to manage the household, her quiet competence and kindness more evident than ever in contrast to Pip's London sophistication. During this visit, Pip promises to return often and maintain his connection to Joe. Biddy's response—gentle skepticism about whether he'll actually follow through—stings precisely because it's accurate. Pip resents her doubt even as he recognizes its foundation; his behavior has earned her skepticism. The visit is filled with good intentions that Pip half-knows he won't fulfill. He's sincere in the moment about wanting to stay connected to Joe, but his life in London and his shame about his origins make regular visits unlikely. The funeral marks not just Mrs. Joe's end but the effective end of Pip's childhood home. Joe and Biddy will eventually create something new, but Pip won't really be part of it. His great expectations have required leaving these people behind, and while he feels guilty about it, he's not prepared to change course. The chapter captures the permanent cost of social climbing—broken ties that can't be repaired.
Coming Up in Chapter 36
Time moves forward whether we're ready or not, and Pip comes of age while his debts mount higher. Herbert's prediction about Pip's majority proves accurate, but will adulthood bring the wisdom and responsibility that Pip still lacks?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
T was the first time that a grave had opened in my road of life, and the gap it made in the smooth ground was wonderful. The figure of my sister in her chair by the kitchen fire, haunted me night and day. That the place could possibly be, without her, was something my mind seemed unable to compass; and whereas she had seldom or never been in my thoughts of late, I had now the strangest ideas that she was coming towards me in the street, or that she would presently knock at the door. In my rooms too, with which she had never been at all associated, there was at once the blankness of death and a perpetual suggestion of the sound of her voice or the turn of her face or figure, as if she were still alive and had been often there. Whatever my fortunes might have been, I could scarcely have recalled my sister with much tenderness. But I suppose there is a shock of regret which may exist without much tenderness. Under its influence (and perhaps to make up for the want of the softer feeling) I was seized with a violent indignation against the assailant from whom she had suffered so much; and I felt that on sufficient proof I could have revengefully pursued Orlick, or any one else, to the last extremity. Having written to Joe, to offer him consolation, and to assure him that I would come to the funeral, I passed the intermediate days in the curious state of mind I have glanced at. I went down early in the morning, and alighted at the Blue Boar in good time to walk over to the forge. It was fine summer weather again, and, as I walked along, the times when I was a little helpless creature, and my sister did not spare me, vividly returned. But they returned with a gentle tone upon them that softened even the edge of Tickler. For now, the very breath of the beans and clover whispered to my heart that the day must come when it would be well for my memory that others walking in the sunshine should be softened as they thought of me. At last I came within sight of the house, and saw that Trabb and Co. had put in a funereal execution and taken possession. Two dismally absurd persons, each ostentatiously exhibiting a crutch done up in a black bandage,—as if that instrument could possibly communicate any comfort to anybody,—were posted at the front door; and in one of them I recognised a postboy discharged from the Boar for turning a young couple into a sawpit on their bridal morning, in consequence of intoxication rendering it necessary for him to ride his horse clasped round the neck with both arms. All the children of the village, and most of the women, were admiring these sable warders and the closed windows of the house and forge; and as I came...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Hollow Promises - When Good Intentions Meet Bad Habits
We make sincere commitments during emotional highs that we quietly abandon when normal life resumes.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between genuine commitments and emotional promises that won't survive normal life pressures.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you or others make promises during intense moments - ask 'Will I still want to do this in three months?' and build systems immediately if yes.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Victorian funeral customs
Elaborate, expensive funeral rituals that became a public display of social status and respectability. Undertakers like Trabb created theatrical spectacles with hired mourners, specific mourning dress, and rigid ceremony protocols.
Modern Usage:
We still see this in expensive funeral packages that prey on grief and guilt, making families feel they must spend beyond their means to 'properly' honor the dead.
Mourning dress
Specific black clothing worn for designated periods after a death, with strict rules about fabric, style, and duration. It was a visible social signal of loss and respectability.
Modern Usage:
Today we might wear black to funerals but don't have formal mourning periods - though we still judge people who seem to 'move on too quickly' after loss.
Hired mourners
Professional mourners paid to attend funerals and display grief, making the ceremony appear more important and well-attended. This was common among the Victorian middle class.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how we might hire people to fill seats at events or pad social media engagement - creating artificial importance through purchased participation.
Complicated grief
The confusing mix of emotions when someone difficult dies - feeling sad, guilty, angry, and relieved all at once. Pip experiences this because his relationship with his sister was troubled.
Modern Usage:
This happens when toxic family members die - we grieve not just the person, but the relationship we never had and now never will.
Social obligation vs genuine feeling
The gap between what society expects you to feel or do and what you actually experience. Pip feels he should be more tender about his sister's death than he actually is.
Modern Usage:
Like posting condolences on social media or attending funerals out of duty rather than genuine emotion - performing grief rather than feeling it.
Deathbed reconciliation
The Victorian belief that people made peace and found clarity in their final moments. Mrs. Joe calls for Joe and asks for pardon before dying.
Modern Usage:
We still hope difficult family members will have deathbed revelations or apologies, though real life rarely provides such neat closure.
Characters in This Chapter
Pip
Protagonist experiencing first major loss
Confronts his first real death and discovers his feelings about his sister are more complicated than expected. His promise to visit Joe regularly reveals his tendency toward self-deception.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who shows up for funerals making promises they won't keep
Biddy
Truth-telling voice of reason
Cares for Mrs. Joe in her final days and gently but firmly challenges Pip's hollow promises. Her skeptical silence cuts through his self-deception.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who calls you out on your BS with uncomfortable accuracy
Joe
Genuine mourner and steady presence
Shows real grief for his wife despite her harsh treatment of him. His renewed vitality after her death suggests relief mixed with sorrow.
Modern Equivalent:
The spouse who stayed loyal through an abusive relationship and quietly rebuilds after it ends
Mr. Trabb
Opportunistic funeral director
Transforms the funeral into an elaborate, expensive spectacle that serves his business interests more than genuine mourning.
Modern Equivalent:
The funeral director who upsells grieving families on expensive packages they can't afford
Pumblechook
Self-promoting social climber
Uses the funeral as another opportunity to remind everyone of his supposed role in Pip's good fortune, showing his shameless self-interest.
Modern Equivalent:
The relative who makes every family gathering about their own accomplishments or connections
Key Quotes & Analysis
"It was the first time that a grave had opened in my road of life, and the gap it made in the smooth ground was wonderful."
Context: Pip reflects on experiencing death for the first time
This metaphor reveals how death disrupts our sense that life will continue smoothly. The word 'wonderful' means amazing rather than good - Pip is struck by how dramatically death changes everything.
In Today's Words:
I'd never lost anyone close before, and I was shocked by how much it messed with my head.
"I suppose there is a shock of regret which may exist without much tenderness."
Context: Pip trying to understand his complex feelings about his sister's death
This captures the guilt we feel when someone difficult dies - we regret the relationship more than we miss the person. It's honest about how grief isn't always pure or simple.
In Today's Words:
You can feel bad about someone dying without actually missing them that much.
"Are you quite sure, then, that you WILL come to see him often?"
Context: Questioning Pip's promise to visit Joe regularly after the funeral
Biddy's emphasis on 'WILL' shows she sees through Pip's easy promises. Her question forces him to confront his own insincerity, which is why it stings so much.
In Today's Words:
Yeah right, like you're actually going to follow through on that.
"Joe, dear Joe, you never complain. Pardon, and be thankful."
Context: Mrs. Joe's final words before dying
These deathbed words suggest Mrs. Joe finally recognized Joe's goodness and her own harshness. The plea for pardon acknowledges the pain she caused.
In Today's Words:
Joe, you're a good man and I'm sorry for how I treated you. Forgive me and try to be happy.
Thematic Threads
Self-Deception
In This Chapter
Pip genuinely believes he'll visit Joe regularly, despite his track record suggesting otherwise
Development
Evolved from earlier chapters where Pip deceived himself about his motivations for wealth
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you promise yourself you'll call family more often after a funeral, then gradually stop.
Class Shame
In This Chapter
Pip's discomfort with Joe's simple grief and his need to leave quickly reveals ongoing class anxiety
Development
Deepened from his initial embarrassment about Joe's manners to now feeling trapped by his humble origins
In Your Life:
You might feel this when visiting your hometown after moving up professionally, feeling caught between two worlds.
Authentic vs. Performative Grief
In This Chapter
The contrast between Joe's simple sorrow and the undertaker's theatrical funeral spectacle
Development
New theme introduced here through the funeral setting
In Your Life:
You see this at funerals where some people genuinely mourn while others perform grief for social expectations.
Truth-Telling
In This Chapter
Biddy's honest skepticism about Pip's promises cuts through his self-deception
Development
Continues Biddy's role as truth-teller, established in earlier chapters
In Your Life:
You might be the Biddy in someone's life, or need to listen when others question your commitments.
Guilt and Redemption
In This Chapter
Pip's complex feelings about his sister's death and his desire to make amends through future visits
Development
Builds on his growing awareness of how his ambitions have damaged relationships
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when trying to fix damaged relationships through future promises rather than present actions.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Pip feel both grief and guilt about his sister's death, even though their relationship was difficult?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Biddy's skeptical silence reveal about the promises we make during emotional moments?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about promises made during family crises, job changes, or health scares. How often do these emotional commitments actually stick?
application • medium - 4
When someone questions your sincere promise like Biddy questions Pip's, how should you respond to make the promise more likely to succeed?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about the difference between feeling genuine remorse and actually changing our behavior patterns?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Promise Reality Check
Think of a sincere promise you made during an emotional moment - maybe after a fight, during a health scare, or when someone was leaving. Write down what you promised, why you meant it at the time, and what actually happened. Then design one specific system that could have helped you keep that promise.
Consider:
- •Consider the gap between your emotional state when making the promise versus your normal daily routine
- •Think about what external pressures or habits pulled you away from the commitment
- •Focus on concrete systems (calendar reminders, accountability partners) rather than willpower alone
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone made you an emotional promise they didn't keep. How did their broken promise affect your relationship, and how do you handle similar promises now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 36: Coming of Age and Hard Truths
As the story unfolds, you'll explore financial independence often comes with uncomfortable realities, while uncovering mixing money and friendship requires careful boundaries. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.