An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 2314 words)
s I had grown accustomed to my expectations, I had insensibly begun to
notice their effect upon myself and those around me. Their influence on
my own character I disguised from my recognition as much as possible,
but I knew very well that it was not all good. I lived in a state of
chronic uneasiness respecting my behaviour to Joe. My conscience was
not by any means comfortable about Biddy. When I woke up in the
night,—like Camilla,—I used to think, with a weariness on my spirits,
that I should have been happier and better if I had never seen Miss
Havisham’s face, and had risen to manhood content to be partners with
Joe in the honest old forge. Many a time of an evening, when I sat
alone looking at the fire, I thought, after all there was no fire like
the forge fire and the kitchen fire at home.
Yet Estella was so inseparable from all my restlessness and disquiet of
mind, that I really fell into confusion as to the limits of my own part
in its production. That is to say, supposing I had had no expectations,
and yet had had Estella to think of, I could not make out to my
satisfaction that I should have done much better. Now, concerning the
influence of my position on others, I was in no such difficulty, and so
I perceived—though dimly enough perhaps—that it was not beneficial to
anybody, and, above all, that it was not beneficial to Herbert. My
lavish habits led his easy nature into expenses that he could not
afford, corrupted the simplicity of his life, and disturbed his peace
with anxieties and regrets. I was not at all remorseful for having
unwittingly set those other branches of the Pocket family to the poor
arts they practised; because such littlenesses were their natural bent,
and would have been evoked by anybody else, if I had left them
slumbering. But Herbert’s was a very different case, and it often
caused me a twinge to think that I had done him evil service in
crowding his sparely furnished chambers with incongruous upholstery
work, and placing the Canary-breasted Avenger at his disposal.
So now, as an infallible way of making little ease great ease, I began
to contract a quantity of debt. I could hardly begin but Herbert must
begin too, so he soon followed. At Startop’s suggestion, we put
ourselves down for election into a club called The Finches of the
Grove: the object of which institution I have never divined, if it were
not that the members should dine expensively once a fortnight, to
quarrel among themselves as much as possible after dinner, and to cause
six waiters to get drunk on the stairs. I know that these gratifying
social ends were so invariably accomplished, that Herbert and I
understood nothing else to be referred to in the first standing toast
of the society: which ran “Gentlemen, may the present promotion of good
feeling ever reign predominant among the Finches of the Grove.”
The Finches spent their money foolishly (the Hotel we dined at was in
Covent Garden), and the first Finch I saw when I had the honour of
joining the Grove was Bentley Drummle, at that time floundering about
town in a cab of his own, and doing a great deal of damage to the posts
at the street corners. Occasionally, he shot himself out of his
equipage headforemost over the apron; and I saw him on one occasion
deliver himself at the door of the Grove in this unintentional way—like
coals. But here I anticipate a little, for I was not a Finch, and could
not be, according to the sacred laws of the society, until I came of
age.
In my confidence in my own resources, I would willingly have taken
Herbert’s expenses on myself; but Herbert was proud, and I could make
no such proposal to him. So he got into difficulties in every
direction, and continued to look about him. When we gradually fell into
keeping late hours and late company, I noticed that he looked about him
with a desponding eye at breakfast-time; that he began to look about
him more hopefully about midday; that he drooped when he came into
dinner; that he seemed to descry Capital in the distance, rather
clearly, after dinner; that he all but realised Capital towards
midnight; and that at about two o’clock in the morning, he became so
deeply despondent again as to talk of buying a rifle and going to
America, with a general purpose of compelling buffaloes to make his
fortune.
I was usually at Hammersmith about half the week, and when I was at
Hammersmith I haunted Richmond, whereof separately by and by. Herbert
would often come to Hammersmith when I was there, and I think at those
seasons his father would occasionally have some passing perception that
the opening he was looking for, had not appeared yet. But in the
general tumbling up of the family, his tumbling out in life somewhere,
was a thing to transact itself somehow. In the meantime Mr. Pocket grew
greyer, and tried oftener to lift himself out of his perplexities by
the hair. While Mrs. Pocket tripped up the family with her footstool,
read her book of dignities, lost her pocket-handkerchief, told us about
her grandpapa, and taught the young idea how to shoot, by shooting it
into bed whenever it attracted her notice.
As I am now generalising a period of my life with the object of
clearing my way before me, I can scarcely do so better than by at once
completing the description of our usual manners and customs at
Barnard’s Inn.
We spent as much money as we could, and got as little for it as people
could make up their minds to give us. We were always more or less
miserable, and most of our acquaintance were in the same condition.
There was a gay fiction among us that we were constantly enjoying
ourselves, and a skeleton truth that we never did. To the best of my
belief, our case was in the last aspect a rather common one.
Every morning, with an air ever new, Herbert went into the City to look
about him. I often paid him a visit in the dark back-room in which he
consorted with an ink-jar, a hat-peg, a coal-box, a string-box, an
almanac, a desk and stool, and a ruler; and I do not remember that I
ever saw him do anything else but look about him. If we all did what we
undertake to do, as faithfully as Herbert did, we might live in a
Republic of the Virtues. He had nothing else to do, poor fellow, except
at a certain hour of every afternoon to “go to Lloyd’s”—in observance
of a ceremony of seeing his principal, I think. He never did anything
else in connection with Lloyd’s that I could find out, except come back
again. When he felt his case unusually serious, and that he positively
must find an opening, he would go on ’Change at a busy time, and walk
in and out, in a kind of gloomy country dance figure, among the
assembled magnates. “For,” says Herbert to me, coming home to dinner on
one of those special occasions, “I find the truth to be, Handel, that
an opening won’t come to one, but one must go to it,—so I have been.”
If we had been less attached to one another, I think we must have hated
one another regularly every morning. I detested the chambers beyond
expression at that period of repentance, and could not endure the sight
of the Avenger’s livery; which had a more expensive and a less
remunerative appearance then than at any other time in the
four-and-twenty hours. As we got more and more into debt, breakfast
became a hollower and hollower form, and, being on one occasion at
breakfast-time threatened (by letter) with legal proceedings, “not
unwholly unconnected,” as my local paper might put it, “with jewelery,”
I went so far as to seize the Avenger by his blue collar and shake him
off his feet,—so that he was actually in the air, like a booted
Cupid,—for presuming to suppose that we wanted a roll.
At certain times—meaning at uncertain times, for they depended on our
humour—I would say to Herbert, as if it were a remarkable discovery,—
“My dear Herbert, we are getting on badly.”
“My dear Handel,” Herbert would say to me, in all sincerity, “if you
will believe me, those very words were on my lips, by a strange
coincidence.”
“Then, Herbert,” I would respond, “let us look into our affairs.”
We always derived profound satisfaction from making an appointment for
this purpose. I always thought this was business, this was the way to
confront the thing, this was the way to take the foe by the throat. And
I know Herbert thought so too.
We ordered something rather special for dinner, with a bottle of
something similarly out of the common way, in order that our minds
might be fortified for the occasion, and we might come well up to the
mark. Dinner over, we produced a bundle of pens, a copious supply of
ink, and a goodly show of writing and blotting paper. For there was
something very comfortable in having plenty of stationery.
I would then take a sheet of paper, and write across the top of it, in
a neat hand, the heading, “Memorandum of Pip’s debts”; with Barnard’s
Inn and the date very carefully added. Herbert would also take a sheet
of paper, and write across it with similar formalities, “Memorandum of
Herbert’s debts.”
Each of us would then refer to a confused heap of papers at his side,
which had been thrown into drawers, worn into holes in pockets, half
burnt in lighting candles, stuck for weeks into the looking-glass, and
otherwise damaged. The sound of our pens going refreshed us
exceedingly, insomuch that I sometimes found it difficult to
distinguish between this edifying business proceeding and actually
paying the money. In point of meritorious character, the two things
seemed about equal.
When we had written a little while, I would ask Herbert how he got on?
Herbert probably would have been scratching his head in a most rueful
manner at the sight of his accumulating figures.
“They are mounting up, Handel,” Herbert would say; “upon my life, they
are mounting up.”
“Be firm, Herbert,” I would retort, plying my own pen with great
assiduity. “Look the thing in the face. Look into your affairs. Stare
them out of countenance.”
“So I would, Handel, only they are staring me out of countenance.”
However, my determined manner would have its effect, and Herbert would
fall to work again. After a time he would give up once more, on the
plea that he had not got Cobbs’s bill, or Lobbs’s, or Nobbs’s, as the
case might be.
“Then, Herbert, estimate; estimate it in round numbers, and put it
down.”
“What a fellow of resource you are!” my friend would reply, with
admiration. “Really your business powers are very remarkable.”
I thought so too. I established with myself, on these occasions, the
reputation of a first-rate man of business,—prompt, decisive,
energetic, clear, cool-headed. When I had got all my responsibilities
down upon my list, I compared each with the bill, and ticked it off. My
self-approval when I ticked an entry was quite a luxurious sensation.
When I had no more ticks to make, I folded all my bills up uniformly,
docketed each on the back, and tied the whole into a symmetrical
bundle. Then I did the same for Herbert (who modestly said he had not
my administrative genius), and felt that I had brought his affairs into
a focus for him.
My business habits had one other bright feature, which I called
“leaving a Margin.” For example; supposing Herbert’s debts to be one
hundred and sixty-four pounds four-and-twopence, I would say, “Leave a
margin, and put them down at two hundred.” Or, supposing my own to be
four times as much, I would leave a margin, and put them down at seven
hundred. I had the highest opinion of the wisdom of this same Margin,
but I am bound to acknowledge that on looking back, I deem it to have
been an expensive device. For, we always ran into new debt immediately,
to the full extent of the margin, and sometimes, in the sense of
freedom and solvency it imparted, got pretty far on into another
margin.
But there was a calm, a rest, a virtuous hush, consequent on these
examinations of our affairs that gave me, for the time, an admirable
opinion of myself. Soothed by my exertions, my method, and Herbert’s
compliments, I would sit with his symmetrical bundle and my own on the
table before me among the stationery, and feel like a Bank of some
sort, rather than a private individual.
We shut our outer door on these solemn occasions, in order that we
might not be interrupted. I had fallen into my serene state one
evening, when we heard a letter dropped through the slit in the said
door, and fall on the ground. “It’s for you, Handel,” said Herbert,
going out and coming back with it, “and I hope there is nothing the
matter.” This was in allusion to its heavy black seal and border.
The letter was signed Trabb & Co., and its contents were simply, that I
was an honoured sir, and that they begged to inform me that Mrs. J.
Gargery had departed this life on Monday last at twenty minutes past
six in the evening, and that my attendance was requested at the
interment on Monday next at three o’clock in the afternoon.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
When status anxiety drives unsustainable behavior, we create elaborate systems to justify and organize our self-destruction rather than address it.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between managing money problems and solving them by recognizing when elaborate systems mask deeper dysfunction.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when your solutions involve better organization rather than actual reduction—if you're making your overspending more sophisticated, you're probably not solving it.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I lived in a state of chronic uneasiness respecting my behaviour to Joe."
Context: Pip reflecting on how his expectations have changed him
This shows Pip's growing self-awareness about how success has made him treat good people badly. The word 'chronic' suggests this guilt is constant and eating away at him.
In Today's Words:
I constantly felt bad about how I was treating the people who really cared about me.
"We spent as much money as we could, and got as little for it as people could make up their minds to give us."
Context: Describing his and Herbert's wasteful lifestyle
This perfectly captures how people throw money at status symbols that provide no real value. They're being taken advantage of because they're trying so hard to look wealthy.
In Today's Words:
We wasted money on overpriced stuff just to look like we belonged.
"We were always more or less miserable, and most of our acquaintance were in the same condition."
Context: Describing their social circle at the gentlemen's club
This reveals that their entire social world is built on shared misery disguised as sophistication. Everyone is pretending to enjoy a lifestyle that's actually making them unhappy.
In Today's Words:
Everyone in our crowd was basically miserable but nobody wanted to admit it.
"We made a gay fiction of such a day, and a skeleton truth of such another day."
Context: Explaining how they alternated between fake happiness and facing reality
This shows how exhausting it is to maintain a false image. They have to schedule when to be fake-happy and when to acknowledge how bad things really are.
In Today's Words:
Some days we pretended everything was great, other days we couldn't hide how awful things really were.
Thematic Threads
False Friendship
In This Chapter
Pip and Herbert's relationship becomes based on shared financial pretense and mutual enabling rather than genuine care
Development
Evolution from Pip's earlier authentic relationships with Joe and Biddy to these performative social connections
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in friendships that revolve around expensive activities neither of you can really afford.
Self-Deception
In This Chapter
Creating beautiful debt ledgers with margins and fancy stationery to make financial destruction feel organized and responsible
Development
Deepening from Pip's earlier simple lies to himself into elaborate systems of self-justification
In Your Life:
You might see this when you use apps or systems to organize problems instead of solving them.
Class Performance
In This Chapter
Joining 'The Finches of the Grove' club purely for status, despite finding it pointless and expensive
Development
Escalation of Pip's earlier discomfort with his origins into active participation in meaningless upper-class rituals
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in maintaining memberships, subscriptions, or social obligations that drain your resources for appearance's sake.
Guilt Recognition
In This Chapter
Pip finally acknowledges how his transformation has hurt Joe and Biddy, and how he's dragging Herbert down with him
Development
First clear moment of self-awareness about the damage his expectations have caused to genuine relationships
In Your Life:
You might feel this when you realize your pursuit of something 'better' is actually hurting the people who truly care about you.
Financial Anxiety
In This Chapter
Herbert desperately searches for business opportunities while maintaining expensive appearances, creating a cycle of stress and spending
Development
Introduction of how financial pressure affects even well-meaning people when trapped in unsustainable social expectations
In Your Life:
You might see this in the stress of trying to maintain a lifestyle that requires constant hustle just to break even.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific behaviors show that Pip and Herbert are living beyond their means, and how do they justify it to themselves?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do Pip and Herbert create elaborate debt-tracking systems instead of actually reducing their spending?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today creating 'gay fictions' to hide financial or personal struggles? What modern versions of expensive gentlemen's clubs exist?
application • medium - 4
If you were Herbert's true friend, how would you help him break this cycle without destroying your relationship or embarrassing him?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how shame and pride can trap us in destructive patterns, and why is it so hard to choose authenticity over performance?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Audit Your Own 'Gay Fictions'
Look at your own life for areas where you might be organizing problems instead of solving them. This could be financial (budgeting apps while overspending), health (tracking calories while eating poorly), or social (managing drama instead of setting boundaries). Write down one area where you're creating sophisticated systems to manage unsustainable behavior.
Consider:
- •Ask yourself: 'Am I managing this problem or solving it?'
- •Notice if your 'solution' involves better organization rather than difficult changes
- •Consider whether shame is preventing you from admitting the real scope of the issue
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you realized you were pretending something was under control when it really wasn't. What finally made you stop organizing the chaos and start eliminating it? Or if you haven't reached that point yet, what would it take?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 35: Death, Grief, and Empty Promises
The death of Pip's sister forces him to return home and face the people he's been avoiding. This homecoming will test whether he's learned anything from his self-reflection, or if he'll continue hiding behind his gentleman's facade when confronted with real grief and the simple dignity of those he left behind.




