Summary
Joe's Uncomfortable Visit to Miss Havisham
Great Expectations by Charles Dickens
Approaching his fourteenth birthday means Pip must finally become Joe's apprentice, formalizing his future as a blacksmith—a fate he once would have accepted but now views as a trap. Miss Havisham summons them both to Satis House to formalize the apprenticeship, giving Joe twenty-five guineas as Pip's premium. The meeting is excruciating, as Joe refuses to speak directly to Miss Havisham or Pip, addressing all his comments to his hat, demonstrating how class difference can render even a good man inarticulate. Miss Havisham seems amused by Joe's awkwardness, turning the business transaction into another of her psychological entertainments. For Pip, the visit confirms his worst fears: Miss Havisham has no special plans for him, no intention of lifting him from his social position. The fantasy he'd been nurturing—that somehow his connection to Satis House would save him from being 'common'—collapses. The apprenticeship that should represent a secure future instead feels like a prison sentence, and the money that should be generous feels like payment for Pip's dismissal from the genteel world. Estella is away at school, receiving the education and refinement that Pip longs for but has no path to achieve, further emphasizing the unbridgeable gap between their stations.
Coming Up in Chapter 14
Pip's feelings about his humble home and Joe's trade have permanently changed. The shame of his background begins to eat away at him, creating a rift that will have lasting consequences for his most important relationship.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
T was a trial to my feelings, on the next day but one, to see Joe arraying himself in his Sunday clothes to accompany me to Miss Havisham’s. However, as he thought his court-suit necessary to the occasion, it was not for me to tell him that he looked far better in his working-dress; the rather, because I knew he made himself so dreadfully uncomfortable, entirely on my account, and that it was for me he pulled up his shirt-collar so very high behind, that it made the hair on the crown of his head stand up like a tuft of feathers. At breakfast-time my sister declared her intention of going to town with us, and being left at Uncle Pumblechook’s and called for “when we had done with our fine ladies”—a way of putting the case, from which Joe appeared inclined to augur the worst. The forge was shut up for the day, and Joe inscribed in chalk upon the door (as it was his custom to do on the very rare occasions when he was not at work) the monosyllable HOUT, accompanied by a sketch of an arrow supposed to be flying in the direction he had taken. We walked to town, my sister leading the way in a very large beaver bonnet, and carrying a basket like the Great Seal of England in plaited Straw, a pair of pattens, a spare shawl, and an umbrella, though it was a fine bright day. I am not quite clear whether these articles were carried penitentially or ostentatiously; but I rather think they were displayed as articles of property,—much as Cleopatra or any other sovereign lady on the Rampage might exhibit her wealth in a pageant or procession. When we came to Pumblechook’s, my sister bounced in and left us. As it was almost noon, Joe and I held straight on to Miss Havisham’s house. Estella opened the gate as usual, and, the moment she appeared, Joe took his hat off and stood weighing it by the brim in both his hands; as if he had some urgent reason in his mind for being particular to half a quarter of an ounce. Estella took no notice of either of us, but led us the way that I knew so well. I followed next to her, and Joe came last. When I looked back at Joe in the long passage, he was still weighing his hat with the greatest care, and was coming after us in long strides on the tips of his toes. Estella told me we were both to go in, so I took Joe by the coat-cuff and conducted him into Miss Havisham’s presence. She was seated at her dressing-table, and looked round at us immediately. “Oh!” said she to Joe. “You are the husband of the sister of this boy?” I could hardly have imagined dear old Joe looking so unlike himself or so like some extraordinary bird; standing as he did speechless, with his tuft of...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Shame Spiral - When Exposure Changes Everything
When exposure to a different social level makes us ashamed of our origins, even when those origins represent genuine love and goodness.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when exposure to 'higher' social circles triggers shame about your background rather than genuine growth.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel embarrassed by family or old friends around new people—ask yourself if the shame is about something actually harmful or just different social codes.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
premium
Money paid to a master craftsman to take on an apprentice for training. In Pip's case, Miss Havisham pays Joe twenty-five guineas - a substantial sum - to formally train Pip as a blacksmith.
Modern Usage:
Like paying tuition for trade school or a certification program today.
court-suit
Joe's formal Sunday clothes, which he wears to show respect for the important occasion. He's deeply uncomfortable in them but believes proper dress is necessary when dealing with upper-class people.
Modern Usage:
Like wearing your best interview outfit to meet your partner's wealthy parents.
beaver bonnet
An expensive hat made from beaver fur, showing Mrs. Joe's attempt to appear fashionable and respectable when going to town. It's her version of dressing up for important occasions.
Modern Usage:
Like wearing designer accessories to signal status at social events.
pattens
Wooden overshoes worn to protect regular shoes from mud and dirt. Mrs. Joe brings them as practical preparation, showing her methodical nature.
Modern Usage:
Like bringing rain boots or shoe covers when you know conditions might be messy.
indenture
The legal contract binding Pip as Joe's apprentice for seven years. This ceremony at the Town Hall makes it official, though it feels like a prison sentence to Pip.
Modern Usage:
Like signing a long-term employment contract or commitment that you can't easily break.
social mortification
The deep shame Pip feels when Joe's awkward behavior embarrasses him in front of Miss Havisham and Estella. This marks the beginning of Pip's shame about his background.
Modern Usage:
Like when your family embarrasses you in front of people you're trying to impress.
Characters in This Chapter
Joe Gargery
loving father figure
Joe's genuine goodness shines through his awkwardness at Miss Havisham's. He's so nervous he can only speak to Pip, not directly to Miss Havisham, but he cleverly presents the premium money as a gift to make Mrs. Joe happy.
Modern Equivalent:
The working-class dad trying his best at his kid's fancy school meeting
Pip
conflicted protagonist
Pip is mortified by Joe's behavior and realizes he no longer wants to be a blacksmith. This moment marks his first real rejection of his humble origins and the beginning of his alienation from Joe.
Modern Equivalent:
The scholarship kid who starts feeling ashamed of where they came from
Miss Havisham
wealthy benefactor
She observes Joe's discomfort with apparent amusement and pays the premium without much ceremony. Her presence represents the upper-class world that now makes Pip ashamed of his own.
Modern Equivalent:
The wealthy donor who enjoys watching regular people squirm in fancy settings
Mrs. Joe
status-conscious sister
She's thrilled by the twenty-five guineas and the attention it brings. Her excitement about the money and social recognition shows her materialistic values.
Modern Equivalent:
The relative who gets way too excited about any connection to money or status
Uncle Pumblechook
opportunistic relative
He immediately takes credit for arranging everything and insists on celebrating with Pip's premium money. He represents people who claim success they didn't earn.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who takes credit for your achievements and spends your money
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am not quite clear whether these articles were carried penitentially or ostentatiously; but, I rather think they were displayed as articles of property—much as clowns in the circus display theirs."
Context: Pip describes his sister's elaborate preparations for the trip to town
This reveals Pip's growing critical eye toward his family's behavior. He's starting to see them as performing respectability rather than naturally possessing it, which shows his changing perspective.
In Today's Words:
I couldn't tell if she was showing off or just being extra, but it felt like she was putting on a show.
"Which I meantersay, Pip, as I heerd her say, and which I meantersay, as I stand or fall by, as there warn't no objections on her part, and Pip it were the great wish of your hart!"
Context: Joe nervously trying to explain the apprenticeship arrangement to Miss Havisham
Joe's garbled speech shows his extreme nervousness around upper-class people. His genuine love for Pip shines through despite his awkwardness, making Pip's embarrassment more painful.
In Today's Words:
What I'm trying to say is, she agreed to it, and Pip, this is what you really wanted!
"I had believed in the forge as the glowing road to manhood and independence. Within a single year all this was changed. Now, it was all coarse and common."
Context: Pip reflecting on how his perspective has changed after exposure to Satis House
This captures the devastating moment when exposure to wealth makes someone ashamed of their origins. Pip's former dreams now seem beneath him, marking a fundamental shift in his values.
In Today's Words:
I used to think working with my hands was the path to success. Now it just seemed low-class and embarrassing.
Thematic Threads
Class Consciousness
In This Chapter
Pip becomes painfully aware of class differences through Joe's discomfort at Satis House and his own embarrassment
Development
Evolved from mere curiosity about wealth to active shame about his own social position
In Your Life:
You might feel this when you're the first in your family to enter a professional environment and suddenly notice how differently your relatives speak or dress.
Identity Shift
In This Chapter
Pip realizes he no longer wants to be a blacksmith, marking his rejection of his predetermined path
Development
Built from his initial fascination with Estella and Satis House to this decisive moment of wanting something different
In Your Life:
This happens when you realize the life everyone expected for you no longer fits who you're becoming.
Ingratitude
In This Chapter
Pip feels burdened by the celebration dinner held in his honor, unable to appreciate others' joy for his future
Development
Growing from his initial dissatisfaction with his circumstances to active resentment of his benefactors
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you feel annoyed by family members celebrating your achievements because their excitement feels 'beneath' your new aspirations.
Social Performance
In This Chapter
Joe's painful inability to speak directly to Miss Havisham, only addressing Pip, shows how class anxiety affects behavior
Development
Introduced here as a new dimension of how social hierarchies create artificial barriers
In Your Life:
This shows up when you find yourself or others acting differently around people perceived as 'higher status,' losing natural authenticity.
Alienation
In This Chapter
Pip ends the chapter alone in his room, psychologically separated from Joe and his former life despite physical proximity
Development
The culmination of growing distance from his origins, now crystallized into conscious rejection
In Your Life:
You experience this when success or new opportunities make you feel like a stranger in your own family or community.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Joe become so awkward when speaking to Miss Havisham, and how does this affect Pip?
analysis • surface - 2
What causes Pip's sudden shift from loving Joe to feeling ashamed of him?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today becoming embarrassed by family or friends after exposure to a 'higher' social class?
application • medium - 4
How could Pip have handled his conflicted feelings without rejecting Joe and his background?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how exposure to different worlds can change our relationships with the people who love us?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Rewrite the Scene from Joe's Perspective
Imagine you're Joe walking into Miss Havisham's grand house. Write a short paragraph describing what you see, feel, and think during this awkward visit. Focus on Joe's genuine emotions and his love for Pip, even as he struggles with the unfamiliar social situation.
Consider:
- •Joe knows he's out of his element but goes anyway for Pip's sake
- •His nervousness comes from love and wanting to do right by Pip
- •He sees Pip's embarrassment but doesn't fully understand why
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt caught between two different worlds or social groups. How did you handle the tension? What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 14: The Shame of Home
Moving forward, we'll examine exposure to different social classes can poison your view of your own life, and understand the way shame can transform familiar places into sources of embarrassment. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.