Summary
Victor watches in horror as Justine Moritz, the family's beloved servant, stands trial for William's murder. Despite her innocence, the evidence seems damning - William's locket was found in her pocket, placed there by the creature as Victor realizes with growing dread. The trial reveals the ugly prejudices of the justice system: Justine's lower social status works against her, and the court seems determined to find her guilty regardless of her character or the inconsistencies in the case. Elizabeth passionately defends Justine, praising her virtue and devotion to the family, but her testimony falls on deaf ears. Victor agonizes over whether to reveal the truth about his creature, but realizes no one would believe such an incredible story - and it might only make him appear mad. Justine herself, broken by the pressure and perhaps hoping for spiritual peace, eventually confesses to the crime she didn't commit. She's executed, becoming the creature's second victim. Victor is consumed by guilt, knowing he could have prevented both deaths. This chapter shows how injustice thrives when those in power refuse to look beyond surface appearances, and how the innocent often pay for others' sins. Victor's paralysis in the face of crisis - his inability to act decisively when lives hang in the balance - establishes a pattern that will haunt him throughout the story. The real monster here isn't just the creature, but a system that destroys the powerless.
Coming Up in Chapter 12
Devastated by two deaths he feels responsible for, Victor retreats to the mountains seeking solace in nature. But his peace is about to be shattered by an unexpected and terrifying encounter.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Clerval then put the following letter into my hands. It was from my own Elizabeth: “My dearest Cousin, “You have been ill, very ill, and even the constant letters of dear kind Henry are not sufficient to reassure me on your account. You are forbidden to write—to hold a pen; yet one word from you, dear Victor, is necessary to calm our apprehensions. For a long time I have thought that each post would bring this line, and my persuasions have restrained my uncle from undertaking a journey to Ingolstadt. I have prevented his encountering the inconveniences and perhaps dangers of so long a journey, yet how often have I regretted not being able to perform it myself! I figure to myself that the task of attending on your sickbed has devolved on some mercenary old nurse, who could never guess your wishes nor minister to them with the care and affection of your poor cousin. Yet that is over now: Clerval writes that indeed you are getting better. I eagerly hope that you will confirm this intelligence soon in your own handwriting. “Get well—and return to us. You will find a happy, cheerful home and friends who love you dearly. Your father’s health is vigorous, and he asks but to see you, but to be assured that you are well; and not a care will ever cloud his benevolent countenance. How pleased you would be to remark the improvement of our Ernest! He is now sixteen and full of activity and spirit. He is desirous to be a true Swiss and to enter into foreign service, but we cannot part with him, at least until his elder brother returns to us. My uncle is not pleased with the idea of a military career in a distant country, but Ernest never had your powers of application. He looks upon study as an odious fetter; his time is spent in the open air, climbing the hills or rowing on the lake. I fear that he will become an idler unless we yield the point and permit him to enter on the profession which he has selected. “Little alteration, except the growth of our dear children, has taken place since you left us. The blue lake and snow-clad mountains—they never change; and I think our placid home and our contented hearts are regulated by the same immutable laws. My trifling occupations take up my time and amuse me, and I am rewarded for any exertions by seeing none but happy, kind faces around me. Since you left us, but one change has taken place in our little household. Do you remember on what occasion Justine Moritz entered our family? Probably you do not; I will relate her history, therefore in a few words. Madame Moritz, her mother, was a widow with four children, of whom Justine was the third. This girl had always been the favourite of her father, but through a strange perversity, her mother could not endure her, and after...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Moral Paralysis
When fear of personal consequences convinces us we're powerless to prevent injustice, making us complicit through inaction.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when institutions sacrifice individuals to protect themselves from systemic problems.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when workplace problems get blamed on the newest or most vulnerable employee—ask yourself what systemic issue is being hidden.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Class prejudice
When people are judged and treated differently based on their social or economic status rather than their individual character. In Justine's case, being a servant made her an easy scapegoat for the wealthy family's tragedy.
Modern Usage:
We see this when poor defendants get harsher sentences than wealthy ones for the same crimes, or when service workers are automatically blamed when something goes wrong.
Scapegoating
Blaming an innocent person for problems they didn't cause, usually someone powerless who can't fight back effectively. The real culprit stays hidden while someone else takes the fall.
Modern Usage:
This happens in workplaces when management blames front-line workers for systemic failures, or when politicians blame immigrants for economic problems.
Circumstantial evidence
Evidence that suggests guilt but doesn't prove it directly - like finding someone's belongings at a crime scene. It can be misleading, especially when someone has been framed.
Modern Usage:
Courts still rely heavily on circumstantial evidence, which is why innocent people sometimes get convicted based on being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
Moral paralysis
When someone knows the right thing to do but can't bring themselves to act, often due to fear of consequences or disbelief from others. Victor experiences this when he can't bring himself to reveal the truth.
Modern Usage:
This happens when people witness workplace harassment but don't report it, or when they know someone is innocent but won't speak up because it might hurt their own reputation.
False confession
When an innocent person admits to a crime they didn't commit, usually due to psychological pressure, exhaustion, or hope for mercy. Justine confesses to save her soul, not because she's guilty.
Modern Usage:
Police interrogations still produce false confessions, especially from vulnerable people who think admitting guilt will lead to lighter punishment or end their suffering.
Systemic injustice
When unfairness is built into institutions like courts, schools, or workplaces, making it nearly impossible for certain groups to get fair treatment. The system works against people like Justine from the start.
Modern Usage:
We see this in how the justice system treats people differently based on race, class, or immigration status, regardless of individual circumstances.
Characters in This Chapter
Victor Frankenstein
Tormented protagonist
Victor knows Justine is innocent but stays silent, paralyzed by the impossibility of explaining his creature. His guilt and inaction make him complicit in her death, showing how knowledge without courage is useless.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who knows their coworker is being falsely blamed but won't speak up because the truth sounds too crazy
Justine Moritz
Innocent victim
A devoted servant framed for William's murder, she represents how the powerless become convenient targets. Her false confession shows how the system breaks people down until they give up fighting.
Modern Equivalent:
The minimum-wage worker who gets fired and blamed when corporate policies fail
Elizabeth Lavenza
Moral advocate
She courageously defends Justine's character in court, showing true loyalty and moral conviction. Her testimony fails not because it's wrong, but because the system doesn't value her perspective.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who writes character references and shows up to court, even when everyone else has given up
The Creature
Hidden manipulator
Though not physically present, the creature orchestrates Justine's downfall by planting evidence. He understands how to exploit human prejudices and weaknesses to destroy innocent lives.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who sets up others to take the fall for their mistakes, knowing exactly how to manipulate the situation
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I passed a night of unmingled wretchedness. In the morning I went to the court; my lips and throat were parched."
Context: Victor struggles with whether to reveal the truth about his creature during Justine's trial
This shows Victor's physical manifestation of guilt and moral conflict. He's literally sick with the knowledge that he could save Justine but won't risk the consequences to himself.
In Today's Words:
I couldn't sleep all night knowing I had information that could save her, and I felt physically sick walking into that courtroom.
"God knows how entirely I am innocent. But I do not pretend that my protestations should acquit me; I rest my innocence on a plain and simple explanation of the facts."
Context: Justine's defense during her trial for William's murder
Justine's dignity and straightforward honesty contrast sharply with the court's prejudice. She believes truth and character should matter more than social status, but she's wrong about how the world works.
In Today's Words:
I know I didn't do this, and I'm just going to tell you exactly what happened and hope that's enough.
"The ballots had been thrown; they were all black, and Justine was condemned."
Context: The verdict is announced in Justine's trial
The unanimous verdict shows this wasn't about evidence or justice - it was predetermined. The imagery of 'black' ballots emphasizes the darkness of this moment and the system's failure.
In Today's Words:
Every single person voted guilty - they had already made up their minds before hearing the evidence.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Justine's lower social status makes her an easy scapegoat—the court assumes guilt based on her position as a servant
Development
Builds on earlier hints about social hierarchy, now showing how class determines who gets believed and who gets sacrificed
In Your Life:
You might notice how your job title, neighborhood, or family background affects whether people take your word seriously in conflicts
Justice
In This Chapter
The trial reveals a system more interested in finding a convenient culprit than discovering truth
Development
Introduced here as a major theme that will echo throughout Victor's story
In Your Life:
You might see this when workplace investigations focus on easy targets rather than actual problems
Responsibility
In This Chapter
Victor's refusal to speak up makes him morally responsible for Justine's death, even though he didn't directly cause it
Development
Deepens from Victor's earlier abandonment of his creature—showing how avoiding responsibility compounds harm
In Your Life:
You might recognize times when staying silent about problems you could help solve made you part of the problem
Truth
In This Chapter
Victor possesses the truth that could save Justine but convinces himself it's unusable
Development
Continues the pattern of Victor hiding crucial information, now with deadly consequences
In Your Life:
You might notice how you sometimes withhold important information because you fear the messenger will be blamed
Powerlessness
In This Chapter
Both Victor and Justine feel trapped by circumstances, but their responses differ—she confesses falsely, he stays silent
Development
Introduced here as a theme about how perceived powerlessness shapes our choices
In Your Life:
You might see this when you feel stuck between bad options and have to choose which kind of damage to accept
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Victor convince himself he can't save Justine, even though he knows she's innocent?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Justine's social status as a servant affect her treatment in court, and what does this reveal about the justice system?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today staying silent when they have information that could help someone in trouble?
application • medium - 4
What would you do if you had crucial information that could save someone, but speaking up might make you look crazy or ruin your reputation?
application • deep - 5
What does Victor's paralysis teach us about the difference between being powerless and choosing powerlessness?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Moral Emergency Plan
Think of a situation where you might witness injustice but feel scared to speak up. Create a step-by-step action plan: Who would you tell first? What evidence would you gather? What allies could you find? Write out your personal protocol for breaking through moral paralysis when it matters most.
Consider:
- •Consider starting with the safest person who might listen and take action
- •Think about documentation - what proof could you gather before speaking up?
- •Remember that doing something imperfect is often better than doing nothing perfectly
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you stayed silent about something wrong because you were afraid of the consequences. What would you do differently now, knowing what you know about moral paralysis?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 12: Justine's Trial and Execution
The coming pages reveal circumstantial evidence can destroy innocent lives, and teach us the way guilt and secrets poison relationships. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.