An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1042 words)
Freely the sage, though wrapt in musings high, Assum’d the teacher’s part, and mild began: “The wound, that Mary clos’d, she open’d first, Who sits so beautiful at Mary’s feet. The third in order, underneath her, lo! Rachel with Beatrice. Sarah next, Judith, Rebecca, and the gleaner maid, Meek ancestress of him, who sang the songs Of sore repentance in his sorrowful mood. All, as I name them, down from deaf to leaf, Are in gradation throned on the rose. And from the seventh step, successively, Adown the breathing tresses of the flow’r Still doth the file of Hebrew dames proceed. For these are a partition wall, whereby The sacred stairs are sever’d, as the faith In Christ divides them. On this part, where blooms Each leaf in full maturity, are set Such as in Christ, or ere he came, believ’d. On th’ other, where an intersected space Yet shows the semicircle void, abide All they, who look’d to Christ already come. And as our Lady on her glorious stool, And they who on their stools beneath her sit, This way distinction make: e’en so on his, The mighty Baptist that way marks the line (He who endur’d the desert and the pains Of martyrdom, and for two years of hell, Yet still continued holy), and beneath, Augustin, Francis, Benedict, and the rest, Thus far from round to round. So heav’n’s decree Forecasts, this garden equally to fill. With faith in either view, past or to come, Learn too, that downward from the step, which cleaves Midway the twain compartments, none there are Who place obtain for merit of their own, But have through others’ merit been advanc’d, On set conditions: spirits all releas’d, Ere for themselves they had the power to choose. And, if thou mark and listen to them well, Their childish looks and voice declare as much. “Here, silent as thou art, I know thy doubt; And gladly will I loose the knot, wherein Thy subtle thoughts have bound thee. From this realm Excluded, chalice no entrance here may find, No more shall hunger, thirst, or sorrow can. A law immutable hath establish’d all; Nor is there aught thou seest, that doth not fit, Exactly, as the finger to the ring. It is not therefore without cause, that these, O’erspeedy comers to immortal life, Are different in their shares of excellence. Our Sovran Lord—that settleth this estate In love and in delight so absolute, That wish can dare no further—every soul, Created in his joyous sight to dwell, With grace at pleasure variously endows. And for a proof th’ effect may well suffice. And ’tis moreover most expressly mark’d In holy scripture, where the twins are said To, have struggled in the womb. Therefore, as grace Inweaves the coronet, so every brow Weareth its proper hue of orient light. And merely in respect to his prime gift, Not in reward of meritorious deed, Hath each his several degree assign’d. In early times with their own innocence More was not wanting, than the parents’ faith, To save them: those first ages past, behoov’d That circumcision in the males should imp The flight of innocent wings: but since the day Of grace hath come, without baptismal rites In Christ accomplish’d, innocence herself Must linger yet below. Now raise thy view Unto the visage most resembling Christ: For, in her splendour only, shalt thou win The pow’r to look on him.” Forthwith I saw Such floods of gladness on her visage shower’d, From holy spirits, winging that profound; That, whatsoever I had yet beheld, Had not so much suspended me with wonder, Or shown me such similitude of God. And he, who had to her descended, once, On earth, now hail’d in heav’n; and on pois’d wing. “Ave, Maria, Gratia Plena,” sang: To whose sweet anthem all the blissful court, From all parts answ’ring, rang: that holier joy Brooded the deep serene. “Father rever’d: Who deign’st, for me, to quit the pleasant place, Wherein thou sittest, by eternal lot! Say, who that angel is, that with such glee Beholds our queen, and so enamour’d glows Of her high beauty, that all fire he seems.” So I again resorted to the lore Of my wise teacher, he, whom Mary’s charms Embellish’d, as the sun the morning star; Who thus in answer spake: “In him are summ’d, Whatever of buxomness and free delight May be in Spirit, or in angel, met: And so beseems: for that he bare the palm Down unto Mary, when the Son of God Vouchsaf’d to clothe him in terrestrial weeds. Now let thine eyes wait heedful on my words, And note thou of this just and pious realm The chiefest nobles. Those, highest in bliss, The twain, on each hand next our empress thron’d, Are as it were two roots unto this rose. He to the left, the parent, whose rash taste Proves bitter to his seed; and, on the right, That ancient father of the holy church, Into whose keeping Christ did give the keys Of this sweet flow’r: near whom behold the seer, That, ere he died, saw all the grievous times Of the fair bride, who with the lance and nails Was won. And, near unto the other, rests The leader, under whom on manna fed Th’ ungrateful nation, fickle and perverse. On th’ other part, facing to Peter, lo! Where Anna sits, so well content to look On her lov’d daughter, that with moveless eye She chants the loud hosanna: while, oppos’d To the first father of your mortal kind, Is Lucia, at whose hest thy lady sped, When on the edge of ruin clos’d thine eye. “But (for the vision hasteneth so an end) Here break we off, as the good workman doth, That shapes the cloak according to the cloth: And to the primal love our ken shall rise; That thou mayst penetrate the brightness, far As sight can bear thee. Yet, alas! in sooth Beating thy pennons, thinking to advance, Thou backward fall’st. Grace then must first be gain’d; Her grace, whose might can help thee. Thou in prayer Seek her: and, with affection, whilst I sue, Attend, and yield me all thy heart.” He said, And thus the saintly orison began.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Some receive extraordinary benefits not through merit or effort, but through forces beyond human concepts of fairness.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when benefits flow to people for reasons beyond merit, helping you respond strategically rather than emotionally.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone receives something good they didn't necessarily earn—and practice responding with curiosity about the system rather than judgment about the person.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The wound, that Mary clos'd, she open'd first"
Context: Beatrice explains how Eve (who opened the wound of sin) and Mary (who closed it through Christ's birth) are connected in God's plan
This shows how God can use even our mistakes as part of a bigger redemption story. Eve's disobedience led to humanity's fall, but it also led to the need for salvation that Mary helped provide.
In Today's Words:
The person who caused the problem is also part of the solution - it's all connected in ways we don't always see
"So heav'n's decree forecasts, this garden equally to fill, with faith in either view, past or to come"
Context: She explains how heaven is perfectly balanced between those who believed before Christ and those who believed after
This reveals God's perfect planning - the same number of souls believed before Christ came as after. It shows divine justice operates on a scale beyond human understanding.
In Today's Words:
Everything works out perfectly in the end, even though we can't see the big picture while we're living through it
"Learn too, that downward from the grade, which cleaves midway the twain divisions, none there are who of their proper merit hold their seats"
Context: She explains that the children in the lower sections aren't there because they earned less, but because they were saved by grace alone
This challenges our normal ideas about fairness and earning our place. These souls are blessed not through their own actions but through God's free gift of grace.
In Today's Words:
Some people get good things in life not because they earned them, but because someone decided to bless them - and that's okay
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Divine hierarchy places souls based on grace rather than earthly merit or social status
Development
Evolved from earlier class critiques to show even divine realms have structure, but based on different principles
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone from a wealthy family gets opportunities you're more qualified for.
Identity
In This Chapter
Dante must abandon his reliance on reason and accept his need for Mary's intercession
Development
Culmination of his journey from proud intellectual to humble seeker
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you can't solve everything through willpower and planning alone.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Children receive salvation without meeting adult expectations of earning it through good works
Development
Challenges earlier assumptions about merit-based rewards throughout the journey
In Your Life:
You might see this when watching how differently society treats people based on circumstances beyond their control.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Dante prepares for ultimate vision by accepting the limits of human understanding
Development
Final stage of growth from relying on human reason to embracing divine mystery
In Your Life:
You might experience this when you stop trying to control everything and learn to work with uncertainty.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Beatrice points Dante toward Mary, showing how relationships mediate divine experience
Development
Continues theme of needing others for spiritual and personal advancement
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize the most important changes come through connection with others, not solo effort.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Dante discover about how souls are arranged in Paradise's highest realm, and why does this surprise him?
analysis • surface - 2
Why are innocent children placed in Paradise's highest sections while adults who struggled for their faith are positioned differently?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see the 'Unearned Grace Pattern' in your workplace, school, or community - situations where benefits go to people who didn't necessarily earn them through effort?
application • medium - 4
How would you handle receiving an unearned advantage versus being passed over despite merit? What strategies help you navigate both situations?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between fairness as humans understand it and how larger systems actually operate?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Grace and Effort
Create two lists: advantages you received without earning them (birth circumstances, lucky breaks, helpful connections) and achievements you genuinely worked for. Then identify one current frustration where you're applying 'earned' thinking to an 'unearned grace' situation. How might recognizing this pattern change your approach?
Consider:
- •Be honest about unearned advantages without minimizing your real efforts
- •Notice where you're expecting fairness in systems that don't operate that way
- •Consider how this awareness might reduce both entitlement and resentment
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you received something you didn't earn, or when you were passed over despite deserving it. How did you handle it then, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 100: The Vision of Divine Love
In the final canto, Saint Bernard leads Dante in a prayer to the Virgin Mary, seeking her intercession for the ultimate vision. Dante's eyes are finally opened to see the very essence of God - the source of all love that moves the sun and stars.




