Summary
Beatrice explains the cosmic order of creation to Dante, revealing how God created angels and the universe not for His own benefit, but to manifest His glory. She describes how some angels fell through pride while others remained faithful through humility. This cosmic lesson becomes deeply personal as Beatrice shifts to condemn contemporary preachers who have abandoned the Gospel's simple truth for entertaining performances and personal gain. She contrasts Christ's straightforward message to his disciples with modern clergy who fill their sermons with jokes and fabricated stories to win applause. These corrupt preachers exploit people's spiritual hunger, offering empty spectacle instead of genuine nourishment. Beatrice's anger burns hottest not at philosophical errors, but at those who twist God's word for personal advancement, noting how much blood was shed to spread the true Gospel. The chapter reveals a pattern that transcends medieval Italy: leaders who should serve truth instead serve themselves, leaving their followers spiritually starved. Beatrice's teaching method itself demonstrates authentic leadership—she explains complex cosmic truths clearly and practically, always pointing beyond herself to the source of all light. Her final image of God's infinite light reflected in countless mirrors yet remaining whole shows how true authority works: it empowers others without diminishing itself, unlike the ego-driven performances of corrupt preachers.
Coming Up in Chapter 97
As the cosmic vision begins to fade like stars disappearing at dawn, Dante must prepare for the final, most overwhelming revelation of his journey through Paradise.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1134 words)
No longer than what time Latona’s twins Cover’d of Libra and the fleecy star, Together both, girding the’ horizon hang, In even balance from the zenith pois’d, Till from that verge, each, changing hemisphere, Part the nice level; e’en so brief a space Did Beatrice’s silence hold. A smile Bat painted on her cheek; and her fix’d gaze Bent on the point, at which my vision fail’d: When thus her words resuming she began: “I speak, nor what thou wouldst inquire demand; For I have mark’d it, where all time and place Are present. Not for increase to himself Of good, which may not be increas’d, but forth To manifest his glory by its beams, Inhabiting his own eternity, Beyond time’s limit or what bound soe’er To circumscribe his being, as he will’d, Into new natures, like unto himself, Eternal Love unfolded. Nor before, As if in dull inaction torpid lay. For not in process of before or aft Upon these waters mov’d the Spirit of God. Simple and mix’d, both form and substance, forth To perfect being started, like three darts Shot from a bow three-corded. And as ray In crystal, glass, and amber, shines entire, E’en at the moment of its issuing; thus Did, from th’ eternal Sovran, beam entire His threefold operation, at one act Produc’d coeval. Yet in order each Created his due station knew: those highest, Who pure intelligence were made: mere power The lowest: in the midst, bound with strict league, Intelligence and power, unsever’d bond. Long tract of ages by the angels past, Ere the creating of another world, Describ’d on Jerome’s pages thou hast seen. But that what I disclose to thee is true, Those penmen, whom the Holy Spirit mov’d In many a passage of their sacred book Attest; as thou by diligent search shalt find And reason in some sort discerns the same, Who scarce would grant the heav’nly ministers Of their perfection void, so long a space. Thus when and where these spirits of love were made, Thou know’st, and how: and knowing hast allay’d Thy thirst, which from the triple question rose. Ere one had reckon’d twenty, e’en so soon Part of the angels fell: and in their fall Confusion to your elements ensued. The others kept their station: and this task, Whereon thou lookst, began with such delight, That they surcease not ever, day nor night, Their circling. Of that fatal lapse the cause Was the curst pride of him, whom thou hast seen Pent with the world’s incumbrance. Those, whom here Thou seest, were lowly to confess themselves Of his free bounty, who had made them apt For ministries so high: therefore their views Were by enlight’ning grace and their own merit Exalted; so that in their will confirm’d They stand, nor feel to fall. For do not doubt, But to receive the grace, which heav’n vouchsafes, Is meritorious, even as the soul With prompt affection welcometh the guest. Now, without further help, if with good heed My words thy mind have treasur’d, thou henceforth This consistory round about mayst scan, And gaze thy fill. But since thou hast on earth Heard vain disputers, reasoners in the schools, Canvas the’ angelic nature, and dispute Its powers of apprehension, memory, choice; Therefore, ’tis well thou take from me the truth, Pure and without disguise, which they below, Equivocating, darken and perplex. “Know thou, that, from the first, these substances, Rejoicing in the countenance of God, Have held unceasingly their view, intent Upon the glorious vision, from the which Naught absent is nor hid: where then no change Of newness with succession interrupts, Remembrance there needs none to gather up Divided thought and images remote “So that men, thus at variance with the truth Dream, though their eyes be open; reckless some Of error; others well aware they err, To whom more guilt and shame are justly due. Each the known track of sage philosophy Deserts, and has a byway of his own: So much the restless eagerness to shine And love of singularity prevail. Yet this, offensive as it is, provokes Heav’n’s anger less, than when the book of God Is forc’d to yield to man’s authority, Or from its straightness warp’d: no reck’ning made What blood the sowing of it in the world Has cost; what favour for himself he wins, Who meekly clings to it. The aim of all Is how to shine: e’en they, whose office is To preach the Gospel, let the gospel sleep, And pass their own inventions off instead. One tells, how at Christ’s suffering the wan moon Bent back her steps, and shadow’d o’er the sun With intervenient disk, as she withdrew: Another, how the light shrouded itself Within its tabernacle, and left dark The Spaniard and the Indian, with the Jew. Such fables Florence in her pulpit hears, Bandied about more frequent, than the names Of Bindi and of Lapi in her streets. The sheep, meanwhile, poor witless ones, return From pasture, fed with wind: and what avails For their excuse, they do not see their harm? Christ said not to his first conventicle, ‘Go forth and preach impostures to the world,’ But gave them truth to build on; and the sound Was mighty on their lips; nor needed they, Beside the gospel, other spear or shield, To aid them in their warfare for the faith. The preacher now provides himself with store Of jests and gibes; and, so there be no lack Of laughter, while he vents them, his big cowl Distends, and he has won the meed he sought: Could but the vulgar catch a glimpse the while Of that dark bird which nestles in his hood, They scarce would wait to hear the blessing said. Which now the dotards hold in such esteem, That every counterfeit, who spreads abroad The hands of holy promise, finds a throng Of credulous fools beneath. Saint Anthony Fattens with this his swine, and others worse Than swine, who diet at his lazy board, Paying with unstamp’d metal for their fare. “But (for we far have wander’d) let us seek The forward path again; so as the way Be shorten’d with the time. No mortal tongue Nor thought of man hath ever reach’d so far, That of these natures he might count the tribes. What Daniel of their thousands hath reveal’d With finite number infinite conceals. The fountain at whose source these drink their beams, With light supplies them in as many modes, As there are splendours, that it shines on: each According to the virtue it conceives, Differing in love and sweet affection. Look then how lofty and how huge in breadth The’ eternal might, which, broken and dispers’d Over such countless mirrors, yet remains Whole in itself and one, as at the first.”
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Performance Over Purpose
Leaders abandon their true mission to chase applause and validation, gradually replacing authentic service with empty spectacle.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when leaders abandon their core mission to chase personal validation and applause.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone in authority seems more focused on looking important than actually helping—then ask yourself if you've fallen into the same trap.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Angelic Hierarchy
The medieval belief that angels exist in different levels of power and closeness to God, like a cosmic organizational chart. Dante presents this as the original template for all authority structures.
Modern Usage:
We still organize institutions in hierarchies, from corporate chains of command to military ranks to academic tenure systems.
Divine Glory
The idea that God creates not because He needs anything, but to share His perfection and make it visible. It's about abundance flowing outward, not scarcity hoarding inward.
Modern Usage:
Great leaders and teachers today share knowledge and power to lift others up, rather than hoarding it to stay on top.
Scholastic Theology
The medieval academic method of using reason and logic to understand religious truth. Dante shows how this can become overly complicated and lose sight of simple spiritual truths.
Modern Usage:
When experts use jargon and complexity to sound smart instead of actually helping people understand important topics.
Simony
The practice of buying or selling church positions and spiritual services for money. Named after Simon Magus, who tried to buy spiritual power from the apostles.
Modern Usage:
Any corruption where people exploit positions of trust for personal gain, like politicians selling influence or doctors overprescribing for profit.
Coeval Creation
The belief that angels, the heavens, and matter were all created at the exact same moment, showing God's perfect timing and order.
Modern Usage:
When we talk about things happening simultaneously or being perfectly coordinated, like a well-executed team project.
Threefold Operation
Dante's description of how God creates through a triple action - form, substance, and their combination - all happening at once like three arrows shot from one bow.
Modern Usage:
Any process that requires multiple elements working together perfectly, like a successful business needing good product, marketing, and customer service.
Characters in This Chapter
Beatrice
Divine teacher and guide
She explains cosmic creation and then shifts to condemning corrupt preachers who exploit people's spiritual hunger. Her teaching demonstrates authentic authority - she points beyond herself to truth.
Modern Equivalent:
The mentor who tells you hard truths and teaches you to think for yourself
Dante
Student and observer
He listens as Beatrice explains both cosmic order and earthly corruption. His role shows how we must be willing to learn uncomfortable truths about how power works.
Modern Equivalent:
The person trying to understand why their world seems so messed up
Corrupt Preachers
False spiritual leaders
Though not directly present, they are the target of Beatrice's anger. They represent those who twist truth for personal gain and entertainment rather than genuine service.
Modern Equivalent:
The influencer who exploits their followers' trust for clicks and money
The Apostles
Models of authentic teaching
Beatrice contrasts them with modern preachers, showing how they spread the Gospel simply and directly without seeking personal glory or profit.
Modern Equivalent:
The teacher who actually cares about students learning, not just looking good
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Not for increase to himself of good, which may not be increased, but forth to manifest his glory by its beams"
Context: Explaining why God created the universe
This reveals that true power creates abundance for others, not scarcity for personal gain. God doesn't create because He lacks something, but because He wants to share perfection.
In Today's Words:
Real leaders don't hoard power to feel important - they share it because they have more than enough.
"With jokes and gibes to preach the Gospel now"
Context: Condemning preachers who entertain rather than teach truth
This shows how spiritual authority gets corrupted when leaders prioritize popularity over genuine service. Entertainment becomes a substitute for transformation.
In Today's Words:
They turn serious stuff into comedy shows to get likes and applause.
"So much blood to sow the Gospel in the world was spilt"
Context: Contrasting the sacrifice of early Christians with modern corruption
This reminds us that truth often comes at great cost, making its exploitation for personal gain especially offensive. Real change requires real sacrifice.
In Today's Words:
People died for this truth, and now you're using it to make a quick buck.
Thematic Threads
Authority
In This Chapter
Beatrice models authentic authority by teaching clearly and pointing beyond herself, contrasting with corrupt preachers who exploit their platforms for personal gain
Development
Building from earlier examples of false vs. true guidance throughout the journey
In Your Life:
You see this when supervisors take credit for team success or when experts use jargon to sound important rather than help you understand
Class
In This Chapter
Corrupt preachers exploit the spiritual hunger of ordinary people, offering entertainment instead of the genuine nourishment they desperately need
Development
Continues the theme of elites failing to serve those who depend on them
In Your Life:
This appears when professionals in positions of trust—doctors, teachers, managers—prioritize their image over actually helping you
Identity
In This Chapter
Preachers lose their true identity as servants of truth and become performers seeking applause, corrupting their fundamental purpose
Development
Deepens the exploration of how roles can either authentic expression or hollow performance
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you find yourself changing who you are to get approval at work or in relationships
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
The pressure to entertain and win approval corrupts the sacred duty to teach truth, showing how social expectations can destroy authentic purpose
Development
Expands on how external pressures can corrupt internal mission
In Your Life:
This shows up when you feel pressure to be the 'fun' parent or 'cool' coworker instead of being genuinely helpful
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Beatrice demonstrates growth through service—she becomes more luminous by helping Dante understand, showing how authentic teaching elevates both teacher and student
Development
Contrasts with earlier examples of growth through suffering, showing growth through generous service
In Your Life:
You experience this when helping others genuinely makes you feel more fulfilled than getting recognition for yourself
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Beatrice reveal about why God created the universe and angels, and what happened to some of the angels?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Beatrice become angry with contemporary preachers, and how does their approach differ from Christ's original message?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see leaders today who have shifted from serving their mission to performing for applause?
application • medium - 4
How can you tell when you're genuinely helping others versus just trying to look impressive?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter suggest about the relationship between authentic authority and ego-driven performance?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Performance Check: Mission vs. Applause
Think of a role where you have influence over others - as a parent, trainer, team leader, or mentor. Write down three specific things you do in that role. For each one, honestly assess: Am I doing this to help them grow, or to make myself look good? Look for signs like whether you explain things clearly or use confusing jargon, whether you share credit or hog it, whether you focus on their success or your reputation.
Consider:
- •Notice when you feel tempted to show off your knowledge instead of helping someone understand
- •Pay attention to whether you're more excited about being seen as helpful than actually being helpful
- •Consider how your motivation affects the quality of your guidance and the other person's growth
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you caught yourself performing instead of genuinely serving. What triggered the shift, and how did you recognize it? What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 97: The River of Light
The coming pages reveal to recognize when you're approaching a life-changing moment of clarity, and teach us preparation and readiness are essential before receiving profound truths. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.
