Summary
Kutúzov faces the most devastating decision of his career: whether to defend Moscow or retreat. When his general Ermólov suggests retreat is necessary, Kutúzov refuses to accept it, checking the man's pulse as if the very idea were a fever. But reality closes in. On Poklónny Hill outside Moscow, generals gather in what becomes an impromptu war council. Everyone talks around the central question—some debate battle positions, others reference historical sieges, still others engage in pure speculation. Kutúzov listens with growing despair, realizing that beneath all the chatter, every single commander knows the truth: defending Moscow is physically impossible. The army would face certain defeat, and even discussing defense has become mere political theater. General Bennigsen pushes for a fight, but Kutúzov sees through the politics—if they lose, Bennigsen will blame Kutúzov; if they somehow win, Bennigsen will claim credit. Meanwhile, Kutúzov tortures himself with an agonizing question: when exactly did he allow Napoleon to reach Moscow? Was it yesterday's order, or some earlier decision? The weight of having to abandon Russia's sacred capital feels like surrendering his command entirely. Yet he knows he alone can lead the army through this crisis. The conversations around him grow too free, too undisciplined. Something must be decided. Kutúzov calls his key generals and declares his head, good or bad, must depend on itself. He rides to Filí, where the hardest decision of the war awaits.
Coming Up in Chapter 233
At Filí, Kutúzov must finally make the choice that will determine Russia's fate. The generals gather for a formal council where Moscow's destiny—and perhaps the war itself—will be decided once and for all.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
When Ermólov, having been sent by Kutúzov to inspect the position, told the field marshal that it was impossible to fight there before Moscow and that they must retreat, Kutúzov looked at him in silence. “Give me your hand,” said he and, turning it over so as to feel the pulse, added: “You are not well, my dear fellow. Think what you are saying!” Kutúzov could not yet admit the possibility of retreating beyond Moscow without a battle. On the Poklónny Hill, four miles from the Dorogomílov gate of Moscow, Kutúzov got out of his carriage and sat down on a bench by the roadside. A great crowd of generals gathered round him, and Count Rostopchín, who had come out from Moscow, joined them. This brilliant company separated into several groups who all discussed the advantages and disadvantages of the position, the state of the army, the plans suggested, the situation of Moscow, and military questions generally. Though they had not been summoned for the purpose, and though it was not so called, they all felt that this was really a council of war. The conversations all dealt with public questions. If anyone gave or asked for personal news, it was done in a whisper and they immediately reverted to general matters. No jokes, or laughter, or smiles even, were seen among all these men. They evidently all made an effort to hold themselves at the height the situation demanded. And all these groups, while talking among themselves, tried to keep near the commander in chief (whose bench formed the center of the gathering) and to speak so that he might overhear them. The commander in chief listened to what was being said and sometimes asked them to repeat their remarks, but did not himself take part in the conversations or express any opinion. After hearing what was being said by one or other of these groups he generally turned away with an air of disappointment, as though they were not speaking of anything he wished to hear. Some discussed the position that had been chosen, criticizing not the position itself so much as the mental capacity of those who had chosen it. Others argued that a mistake had been made earlier and that a battle should have been fought two days before. Others again spoke of the battle of Salamanca, which was described by Crosart, a newly arrived Frenchman in a Spanish uniform. (This Frenchman and one of the German princes serving with the Russian army were discussing the siege of Saragossa and considering the possibility of defending Moscow in a similar manner.) Count Rostopchín was telling a fourth group that he was prepared to die with the city train bands under the walls of the capital, but that he still could not help regretting having been left in ignorance of what was happening, and that had he known it sooner things would have been different.... A fifth group, displaying the profundity of their strategic perceptions, discussed the direction...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Impossible Choices
When external constraints create genuinely impossible situations, but social pressure demands we perform decision-making instead of acknowledging hard realities.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between real decision-making and performative discussions that avoid hard truths.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when meetings or family discussions circle around obvious conclusions—practice being the person who names the real constraints clearly.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Council of war
An emergency meeting where military leaders debate crucial decisions during crisis. Though not formally called, everyone recognizes the gravity when such gatherings happen naturally.
Modern Usage:
Like when a family crisis forces everyone to gather in the kitchen to figure out what to do next.
Strategic retreat
Withdrawing from a position not out of cowardice, but to preserve your forces for a better fight later. Often the hardest decision a leader can make because it looks like giving up.
Modern Usage:
When you quit a toxic job without another one lined up because staying would destroy you completely.
Sacred ground
Places that hold such deep cultural or spiritual meaning that defending them becomes about more than military strategy. Moscow represented the heart of Russian identity and Orthodox faith.
Modern Usage:
Like how some people will fight to keep the family home even when it makes no financial sense.
Political theater
When people engage in public discussions or debates not to solve problems, but to position themselves favorably regardless of the outcome.
Modern Usage:
Office meetings where everyone talks around the real issue because no one wants to be the bearer of bad news.
Command isolation
The loneliness of ultimate responsibility, where a leader must make decisions that others can debate but only they must own completely.
Modern Usage:
Being the single parent who has to decide whether to move for a job opportunity, knowing everyone will judge the outcome.
Impossible position
A situation where all available choices lead to negative consequences, forcing someone to choose the least damaging option rather than a good one.
Modern Usage:
When you have to choose between paying rent or buying groceries because there's not enough for both.
Characters in This Chapter
Kutúzov
Commander-in-chief under crushing pressure
Faces the agonizing decision to abandon Moscow without a fight. He knows it's the right military choice but struggles with the weight of seeming to surrender Russia's sacred capital.
Modern Equivalent:
The plant manager who has to announce layoffs to save the company
Ermólov
Realistic subordinate
The general who tells Kutúzov the hard truth that defending Moscow is impossible. Kutúzov's reaction of checking his pulse shows how unwelcome this reality is.
Modern Equivalent:
The employee who has to tell the boss the project is failing
Bennigsen
Political opportunist
Pushes for defending Moscow not because it's militarily sound, but because he can blame Kutúzov if they lose and claim credit if they somehow win.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who volunteers you for impossible tasks so they look good either way
Count Rostopchín
Moscow's civil administrator
Joins the impromptu war council as the representative of Moscow's civilian population, adding political pressure to an already impossible military situation.
Modern Equivalent:
The city council member who shows up when the factory might close
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Give me your hand. You are not well, my dear fellow. Think what you are saying!"
Context: When Ermólov suggests they must retreat from Moscow without fighting
Kutúzov's reaction shows how desperately he wants to reject this reality. Checking Ermólov's pulse suggests the very idea of retreat is like a sickness that needs to be cured.
In Today's Words:
You must be crazy to even suggest that!
"Though they had not been summoned for the purpose, and though it was not so called, they all felt that this was really a council of war"
Context: Describing the gathering of generals around Kutúzov on Poklónny Hill
Shows how crisis creates its own gravity, pulling people together even without formal organization. The weight of the moment makes everyone understand what's really happening.
In Today's Words:
Nobody called a meeting, but everyone knew this was where the big decision would be made.
"They evidently all made an effort to hold themselves at the height the situation demanded"
Context: Describing how the generals behaved during the impromptu council
Everyone understands the gravity of the moment and tries to rise to it, suppressing normal human reactions like jokes or casual conversation. The situation demands their best selves.
In Today's Words:
Everyone was trying to be as serious and professional as this terrible situation required.
Thematic Threads
Leadership
In This Chapter
Kutúzov must make a decision that will define his legacy while knowing any choice invites criticism
Development
Evolved from earlier battlefield tactics to existential command responsibility
In Your Life:
You might face this when managing a team through impossible corporate demands or family crises with no good options
Responsibility
In This Chapter
Kutúzov tortures himself over when exactly he allowed Napoleon to reach Moscow, searching for the moment of failure
Development
Deepened from personal duty to crushing weight of national consequences
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when replaying every decision that led to a major loss or failure in your life
Political Theater
In This Chapter
Generals debate positions and reference history while everyone knows defense is impossible
Development
Introduced here as avoidance mechanism during crisis
In Your Life:
You might see this in workplace meetings where everyone discusses solutions to problems they know are unfixable
Isolation
In This Chapter
Kutúzov realizes he alone can lead the army through this crisis, despite the crushing burden
Development
Expanded from social isolation to the ultimate loneliness of command
In Your Life:
You might feel this when facing a major family or work decision that ultimately only you can make
Sacred Loss
In This Chapter
Abandoning Moscow feels like surrendering not just territory but Russia's sacred heart
Development
Introduced here as the cost of survival versus meaning
In Your Life:
You might experience this when forced to give up something deeply meaningful to preserve something essential
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Kutúzov refuse to accept Ermólov's suggestion about retreat, even going so far as to check his pulse?
analysis • surface - 2
What's really happening when the generals debate battle positions and reference historical sieges instead of directly addressing whether Moscow can be defended?
analysis • medium - 3
Think of a time when everyone around a problem knew the truth but no one would say it directly. What made speaking honestly feel impossible?
application • medium - 4
When you face a situation where all your options feel like betrayal of something important, how do you decide what to sacrifice?
application • deep - 5
What does Kutúzov's isolation in this decision reveal about the burden of leadership when there are no good choices?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Name the Impossible Choice
Think of a current situation in your life, workplace, or family where everyone is talking around a problem instead of naming it directly. Write down what the real constraints are versus what people are pretending the options are. Then identify what decision actually needs to be made.
Consider:
- •What makes speaking the truth feel dangerous or disloyal in this situation?
- •Who benefits from keeping the real constraints unnamed?
- •What would change if someone said the quiet part out loud?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to make a decision that felt like betraying something important to you. How did you navigate choosing between competing loyalties or values?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 233: The Burden of Impossible Choices
What lies ahead teaches us leaders must sometimes make decisions that go against popular opinion, and shows us clear communication matters more than flowery rhetoric in crisis. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.