Summary
Princess Mary faces a crisis that reveals how good intentions can go terribly wrong. When her peasants gather at the barn, she assumes they want to discuss her generous offer of grain and safe passage to Moscow. But the peasants have heard something entirely different—they think she's trying to bribe them into staying behind while she escapes to safety, leaving them to face Napoleon's army alone. Mary tries desperately to clarify her true intentions, offering them everything she owns and promising food and shelter on her Moscow estate. But the damage is done. The peasants refuse her grain and reject her protection, convinced she's trying to trick them into slavery. Their faces show not gratitude but suspicion and anger. The scene captures a painful truth about leadership and communication: sometimes the very act of trying to help can backfire when trust has been broken or when cultural misunderstandings run deep. Mary's shock at their rejection shows how leaders often live in a bubble, unaware of how their actions are perceived by those they're trying to serve. The peasants' refusal isn't just stubbornness—it's self-protection based on generations of experience with broken promises from the nobility. This moment reveals the complex power dynamics that exist even in relationships where one person genuinely wants to help another. Mary learns that good intentions aren't enough when communication breaks down and trust is absent.
Coming Up in Chapter 202
With her peasants refusing her help and Napoleon's army drawing closer, Princess Mary must make difficult decisions about her own escape. The breakdown in trust will have consequences that extend far beyond this single conversation.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
An hour later Dunyásha came to tell the princess that Dron had come, and all the peasants had assembled at the barn by the princess’ order and wished to have word with their mistress. “But I never told them to come,” said Princess Mary. “I only told Dron to let them have the grain.” “Only, for God’s sake, Princess dear, have them sent away and don’t go out to them. It’s all a trick,” said Dunyásha, “and when Yákov Alpátych returns let us get away... and please don’t...” “What is a trick?” asked Princess Mary in surprise. “I know it is, only listen to me for God’s sake! Ask nurse too. They say they don’t agree to leave Boguchárovo as you ordered.” “You’re making some mistake. I never ordered them to go away,” said Princess Mary. “Call Drónushka.” Dron came and confirmed Dunyásha’s words; the peasants had come by the princess’ order. “But I never sent for them,” declared the princess. “You must have given my message wrong. I only said that you were to give them the grain.” Dron only sighed in reply. “If you order it they will go away,” said he. “No, no. I’ll go out to them,” said Princess Mary, and in spite of the nurse’s and Dunyásha’s protests she went out into the porch; Dron, Dunyásha, the nurse, and Michael Ivánovich following her. “They probably think I am offering them the grain to bribe them to remain here, while I myself go away leaving them to the mercy of the French,” thought Princess Mary. “I will offer them monthly rations and housing at our Moscow estate. I am sure Andrew would do even more in my place,” she thought as she went out in the twilight toward the crowd standing on the pasture by the barn. The men crowded closer together, stirred, and rapidly took off their hats. Princess Mary lowered her eyes and, tripping over her skirt, came close up to them. So many different eyes, old and young, were fixed on her, and there were so many different faces, that she could not distinguish any of them and, feeling that she must speak to them all at once, did not know how to do it. But again the sense that she represented her father and her brother gave her courage, and she boldly began her speech. “I am very glad you have come,” she said without raising her eyes, and feeling her heart beating quickly and violently. “Drónushka tells me that the war has ruined you. That is our common misfortune, and I shall grudge nothing to help you. I am myself going away because it is dangerous here... the enemy is near... because... I am giving you everything, my friends, and I beg you to take everything, all our grain, so that you may not suffer want! And if you have been told that I am giving you the grain to keep you here—that is not true. On the contrary, I ask...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Good Intentions Gone Wrong
When good intentions create resistance because the helper fails to see how their offer looks from the recipient's perspective.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when differences in resources or status create invisible barriers to communication.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone rejects help or seems suspicious of your offers—ask yourself what they might be seeing that you're missing.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Serf
A peasant bound to work their master's land, essentially owned by the nobility. They couldn't leave without permission and had no legal rights. Different from American slavery because they weren't bought and sold individually, but they weren't free either.
Modern Usage:
We see similar power imbalances today between employers and workers who can't afford to quit, or between landlords and tenants with no other housing options.
Paternalism
When someone in power makes decisions 'for your own good' without asking what you actually want. The person thinks they're being kind and protective, but they're still controlling your choices.
Modern Usage:
This happens when managers don't consult employees about changes that affect them, or when politicians pass laws 'to help' communities without asking those communities what they need.
Class consciousness
When people become aware of the power differences between social classes and start to distrust the motives of those above them. It's realizing that your interests and the boss's interests aren't the same.
Modern Usage:
We see this when workers organize unions, or when communities become skeptical of corporate promises about 'helping' their neighborhoods.
Communication breakdown
When the same message gets interpreted completely differently by different people, usually because of different backgrounds, experiences, or power positions. What sounds generous to one person sounds threatening to another.
Modern Usage:
This happens constantly in workplaces when management announces 'exciting changes' that employees hear as 'layoffs coming.'
Noblesse oblige
The idea that people with privilege have a duty to help those beneath them. Sounds nice, but it assumes the privileged person knows what's best and keeps the power structure intact.
Modern Usage:
We see this when wealthy people or companies do charity work while maintaining systems that create the problems they're trying to solve.
Mutual mistrust
When two groups can't communicate because each assumes the worst about the other's motives. Past betrayals make it impossible to hear good intentions, even when they're genuine.
Modern Usage:
This happens between management and workers after layoffs, or between communities and police after repeated negative encounters.
Characters in This Chapter
Princess Mary
Well-meaning but naive leader
She genuinely wants to help her peasants escape Napoleon's army and offers them grain, money, and shelter. But she's shocked when they reject her help and suspect her motives, revealing how disconnected she is from their reality.
Modern Equivalent:
The well-intentioned manager who can't understand why employees don't trust her 'generous' restructuring plan
Dron
Reluctant messenger
The estate manager caught between Princess Mary's orders and the peasants' suspicions. He tries to navigate both sides but can't fix the fundamental communication problem between them.
Modern Equivalent:
The middle manager who has to deliver bad news from corporate while trying to maintain relationships with their team
Dunyásha
Protective advisor
Mary's maid who sees danger in the peasants' gathering and begs her not to go out to them. She understands the tension better than Mary does and fears for her safety.
Modern Equivalent:
The assistant who tries to warn their boss that the staff meeting is going to be hostile
The peasants
Suspicious collective
They refuse Mary's grain and help because they believe she's trying to trick them into staying behind while she escapes. Their reaction shows how past betrayals have made them distrust any offer from the nobility.
Modern Equivalent:
Employees who reject company benefits because they assume there are hidden strings attached
Key Quotes & Analysis
"They probably think I am offering them the grain to bribe them to remain here, while I myself go away"
Context: Mary realizes the peasants have misunderstood her generous offer
This shows Mary's dawning awareness that her good intentions have been completely misinterpreted. She's beginning to understand how her actions look from the peasants' perspective, but it may be too late to fix the damage.
In Today's Words:
They think I'm trying to buy them off so I can save myself while leaving them behind
"It's all a trick"
Context: Warning Mary not to meet with the peasants
Dunyásha, coming from a lower social class herself, understands the peasants' mindset better than Mary does. She recognizes the danger in the situation that Mary, in her privileged bubble, cannot see.
In Today's Words:
This is a setup - don't fall for it
"But I never sent for them"
Context: When told the peasants came by her order
Mary's confusion reveals how messages get distorted as they pass through layers of hierarchy. What she intended as a generous offer has become something threatening by the time it reaches the peasants.
In Today's Words:
I never called this meeting - something got lost in translation
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
The deep mistrust between nobility and peasants prevents genuine communication despite Mary's sincere intentions
Development
This continues the book's exploration of how class barriers create misunderstanding even in moments of crisis
In Your Life:
You might see this when trying to help someone from a different background and not understanding why they seem ungrateful or suspicious
Communication
In This Chapter
Mary and her peasants are speaking different languages—she hears generosity, they hear manipulation
Development
Builds on earlier scenes where characters fail to understand each other across social divides
In Your Life:
This appears when your words land completely differently than you intended, especially with people who have different life experiences
Power
In This Chapter
Mary's position of privilege blinds her to how her offers of help might be perceived as control or manipulation
Development
Continues examining how power dynamics complicate even well-intentioned relationships
In Your Life:
You see this when you have more resources or authority than someone and don't realize how that affects your interactions
Trust
In This Chapter
Years of broken promises from the nobility have created a wall of suspicion that Mary's good intentions cannot penetrate
Development
Shows how historical patterns of betrayal affect present relationships
In Your Life:
This happens when past experiences make someone resistant to help, even when you genuinely want to assist them
Identity
In This Chapter
Mary's identity as a caring noble clashes with the peasants' identity as self-protecting survivors
Development
Explores how different identities create different interpretations of the same situation
In Your Life:
You experience this when your self-image as helpful conflicts with how others actually receive your help
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why do the peasants reject Princess Mary's offer of grain and safe passage to Moscow?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Princess Mary's position of privilege blind her to how her offer actually sounds to the peasants?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about a time when someone offered to help you but it felt uncomfortable or suspicious. What made you hesitant to accept their help?
application • medium - 4
When you're trying to help someone who seems resistant, what questions could you ask to understand their perspective better?
application • deep - 5
What does this scene reveal about how past experiences shape our ability to trust, even when someone genuinely wants to help us?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Flip the Script: Rewrite from the Peasants' Perspective
Rewrite this scene from the peasants' point of view. What do they see when Princess Mary approaches? What are they thinking when she makes her offer? Focus on their fears, their past experiences with nobility, and why her generosity feels like a trap. This exercise helps you practice seeing situations through other people's eyes—a crucial skill for effective helping.
Consider:
- •What past experiences with nobles might make them suspicious of sudden generosity?
- •How might their economic desperation make them more cautious, not less?
- •What would it feel like to have someone with power suddenly offer you everything, knowing you can't reciprocate?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you offered help and were surprised by someone's reaction. Looking back, what might you have missed about their perspective? How could you approach similar situations differently in the future?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 202: The Weight of Unspoken Words
The coming pages reveal regret over missed conversations can haunt us after loss, and teach us grief comes in waves, triggered by quiet moments of reflection. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.