Summary
Lucy faces her worst nightmare when M. Paul drags her before two sneering professors who accuse him of forging her essays. The public examination becomes a disaster—Lucy freezes up, can't answer basic questions, and breaks down in tears, humiliating both herself and M. Paul. But this crisis becomes a turning point. Later, when they talk privately, Lucy reveals she knows about his secret life: his modest living quarters, his care for elderly dependents, and his twenty-year devotion to a deceased woman named Justine Marie. Instead of being angry at her discovery, M. Paul opens up completely. He describes his lonely, austere life—living in a single room, doing his own housework, caring for the poor and forgotten. Most importantly, he asks Lucy to be his friend—not romantic, but something deeper: chosen family. He wants her as a sister, someone who knows his whole story and accepts him anyway. Lucy, who has spent her life feeling invisible and unwanted, finds herself genuinely needed by someone she respects. The chapter transforms their relationship from teacher-student antagonism to mutual understanding and support. Lucy realizes that real friendship isn't about perfection or performance—it's about seeing someone's full humanity and choosing to stand by them. M. Paul's request for sisterhood offers her something she's never had: a place where she belongs completely.
Coming Up in Chapter 36
But their newfound closeness faces an immediate test when family obligations and old rivalries threaten to tear them apart. Lucy must navigate the treacherous waters of Madame Beck's disapproval and discover whether their bond can survive external pressures.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
FRATERNITY. “Oubliez les Professeurs.” So said Madame Beck. Madame Beck was a wise woman, but she should not have uttered those words. To do so was a mistake. That night she should have left me calm—not excited, indifferent, not interested, isolated in my own estimation and that of others—not connected, even in idea, with this second person whom I was to forget. Forget him? Ah! they took a sage plan to make me forget him—the wiseheads! They showed me how good he was; they made of my dear little man a stainless little hero. And then they had prated about his manner of loving. What means had I, before this day, of being certain whether he could love at all or not? I had known him jealous, suspicious; I had seen about him certain tendernesses, fitfulnesses—a softness which came like a warm air, and a ruth which passed like early dew, dried in the heat of his irritabilities: _this_ was all I had seen. And they, Père Silas and Modeste Maria Beck (that these two wrought in concert I could not doubt) opened up the adytum of his heart—showed me one grand love, the child of this southern nature’s youth, born so strong and perfect, that it had laughed at Death himself, despised his mean rape of matter, clung to immortal spirit, and in victory and faith, had watched beside a tomb twenty years. This had been done—not idly: this was not a mere hollow indulgence of sentiment; he had proven his fidelity by the consecration of his best energies to an unselfish purpose, and attested it by limitless personal sacrifices: for those once dear to her he prized—he had laid down vengeance, and taken up a cross. Now, as for Justine Marie, I knew what she was as well as if I had seen her. I knew she was well enough; there were girls like her in Madame Beck’s school—phlegmatics—pale, slow, inert, but kind-natured, neutral of evil, undistinguished for good. If she wore angels’ wings, I knew whose poet-fancy conferred them. If her forehead shone luminous with the reflex of a halo, I knew in the fire of whose irids that circlet of holy flame had generation. Was I, then, to be frightened by Justine Marie? Was the picture of a pale dead nun to rise, an eternal barrier? And what of the charities which absorbed his worldly goods? What of his heart sworn to virginity? Madame Beck—Père Silas—you should not have suggested these questions. They were at once the deepest puzzle, the strongest obstruction, and the keenest stimulus, I had ever felt. For a week of nights and days I fell asleep—I dreamt, and I woke upon these two questions. In the whole world there was no answer to them, except where one dark little man stood, sat, walked, lectured, under the head-piece of a bandit bonnet-grec, and within the girth of a sorry paletôt, much be-inked, and no little adust. After that visit to the Rue des...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Authentic Connection - When Vulnerability Becomes Strength
Authentic relationships form only when people risk being fully known and choose to stay anyway.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when someone is offering genuine partnership versus transactional relationship.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when people share struggles rather than just successes—they might be testing for real connection rather than surface-level networking.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Adytum
The innermost sanctuary of a temple, the most sacred and private space. In this chapter, Lucy uses it to describe the secret depths of M. Paul's heart that others have revealed to her.
Modern Usage:
We still talk about someone's 'inner sanctum' or getting access to their most private thoughts and feelings.
Fraternity
Brotherhood or deep friendship between people who aren't blood relatives. M. Paul offers Lucy this kind of chosen family bond - deeper than romance, based on mutual understanding and loyalty.
Modern Usage:
Today we call this 'chosen family' - the people who become your real support system regardless of blood relations.
Public examination
A formal test conducted in front of an audience, designed to prove or disprove someone's abilities. Lucy's examination becomes a humiliating spectacle when she can't perform under pressure.
Modern Usage:
Like being put on the spot at work meetings or having to prove yourself publicly when you're already stressed.
Southern nature
Refers to M. Paul's passionate, emotional temperament, which Victorians associated with people from warmer climates like France or Spain, as opposed to cooler English reserve.
Modern Usage:
We still stereotype people by region - thinking of Southerners as more emotional or Northerners as more reserved.
Ruth
An old word for compassion or pity, especially the tender kind that moves you to help someone. Lucy notices these brief moments of softness in M. Paul's usually harsh demeanor.
Modern Usage:
We'd say someone shows their 'soft side' or has moments where their guard comes down.
Sage plan
What Lucy sarcastically calls the 'wise' strategy others use to make her forget M. Paul - by showing her how good and loveable he really is, which backfires completely.
Modern Usage:
Like when people try reverse psychology or think they're being clever with their manipulation tactics.
Characters in This Chapter
Lucy Snowe
Protagonist
Faces public humiliation during the examination but gains something more valuable - genuine friendship and belonging. She discovers M. Paul's secret life and accepts his offer of chosen family.
Modern Equivalent:
The quiet coworker who struggles with public speaking but forms deep, meaningful friendships
M. Paul Emanuel
Love interest/mentor
Defends Lucy during her examination disaster, then opens up completely about his austere life and devotion to a dead woman. Offers Lucy sisterhood instead of romance.
Modern Equivalent:
The intense colleague who lives simply, supports elderly relatives, and values deep friendship over casual relationships
Madame Beck
Antagonist
Conspires with Père Silas to manipulate Lucy's feelings by revealing M. Paul's good qualities, thinking this will make her forget him. Her plan completely backfires.
Modern Equivalent:
The meddling boss who thinks she knows what's best for everyone's personal life
Père Silas
Antagonist
Works with Madame Beck to reveal M. Paul's secret devotion to Justine Marie, hoping to discourage Lucy. Instead, this revelation brings Lucy and M. Paul closer together.
Modern Equivalent:
The gossipy priest or counselor who shares confidential information thinking it will help
The two professors
Minor antagonists
Publicly humiliate Lucy by accusing M. Paul of writing her essays and forcing her to take an examination she's unprepared for. They represent institutional cruelty.
Modern Equivalent:
The condescending academics or supervisors who enjoy making others look stupid in meetings
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Forget him? Ah! they took a sage plan to make me forget him—the wiseheads!"
Context: Lucy's sarcastic response to Madame Beck's advice to forget M. Paul
Shows Lucy's growing self-awareness and ability to see through manipulation. She recognizes that showing her M. Paul's good qualities will only make her care more, not less.
In Today's Words:
Forget him? Yeah right! These geniuses really thought they had it all figured out!
"They showed me how good he was; they made of my dear little man a stainless little hero."
Context: Lucy realizes how Madame Beck and Père Silas revealed M. Paul's virtues
The phrase 'my dear little man' shows Lucy's growing affection and protective feelings. She sees through their strategy while acknowledging M. Paul's genuine goodness.
In Today's Words:
They proved to me what a good guy he really was; they turned him into this perfect little saint in my eyes.
"This had been done—not idly: this was not a mere hollow indulgence of sentiment"
Context: Lucy reflecting on M. Paul's twenty-year devotion to Justine Marie's memory
Lucy respects that M. Paul's mourning isn't performative or self-indulgent - it's genuine, purposeful devotion. This reveals her mature understanding of different kinds of love.
In Today's Words:
This wasn't just for show - he wasn't just wallowing in his feelings for attention.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Lucy discovers she can be valued for who she truly is, not who she pretends to be
Development
Evolved from Lucy's constant self-hiding to acceptance of her authentic self
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone appreciates your real personality instead of your professional mask.
Class
In This Chapter
M. Paul's hidden poverty and service to others reveals true nobility versus social status
Development
Continued exploration of how real worth differs from social position
In Your Life:
You see this when someone with little money shows more generosity than wealthy acquaintances.
Belonging
In This Chapter
M. Paul offers Lucy chosen family—a place where she's needed and wanted
Development
Progression from Lucy's complete isolation to finding her tribe
In Your Life:
You experience this when someone invites you into their inner circle based on who you really are.
Expectations
In This Chapter
The public examination shows how performance anxiety can sabotage us when we try to meet others' standards
Development
Continued theme of how external pressures can undermine authentic self-expression
In Your Life:
You feel this when you freeze up in job interviews or family gatherings where you feel judged.
Growth
In This Chapter
Both characters grow by accepting their limitations and choosing connection over pride
Development
Shift from individual struggle to mutual support as path to development
In Your Life:
You see this when admitting you need help actually makes you stronger and more capable.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What triggers Lucy's breakdown during the examination, and how does M. Paul respond to her failure?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does M. Paul choose to reveal his secret life to Lucy after she discovers it, rather than becoming defensive or angry?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people in your life wearing masks to hide their struggles, and what happens when someone finally drops the pretense?
application • medium - 4
When someone offers you authentic friendship based on seeing your flaws, how do you typically respond, and what does this reveal about your comfort with being truly known?
application • deep - 5
What does M. Paul's request for sisterhood rather than romance teach us about different types of meaningful connection?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Mask Moments
Think of three different relationships in your life—work, family, and friendship. For each, identify one 'mask' you typically wear (the competent employee, the strong family member, the supportive friend). Then consider: what would happen if you let that mask slip just once? What are you afraid would happen, and what might actually happen instead?
Consider:
- •Notice the difference between what you fear and what's likely to actually occur
- •Consider which relationships could handle more honesty and which ones might not be ready
- •Think about someone who has dropped their mask with you—how did you respond?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone saw you at your worst or most vulnerable and chose to stay anyway. How did that change your relationship with them?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 36: The Apple of Discord
As the story unfolds, you'll explore religious and cultural differences can create invisible barriers in relationships, while uncovering understanding someone's motivations requires looking beyond surface behavior. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.
