An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 5926 words)
HE PLAYMATES.
Mr. Home stayed two days. During his visit he could not be prevailed on
to go out: he sat all day long by the fireside, sometimes silent,
sometimes receiving and answering Mrs. Bretton’s chat, which was just
of the proper sort for a man in his morbid mood—not over-sympathetic,
yet not too uncongenial, sensible; and even with a touch of the
motherly—she was sufficiently his senior to be permitted this touch.
As to Paulina, the child was at once happy and mute, busy and watchful.
Her father frequently lifted her to his knee; she would sit there till
she felt or fancied he grew restless; then it was—“Papa, put me down; I
shall tire you with my weight.”
And the mighty burden slid to the rug, and establishing itself on
carpet or stool just at “papa’s“ feet, the white work-box and the
scarlet-speckled handkerchief came into play. This handkerchief, it
seems, was intended as a keepsake for “papa,” and must be finished
before his departure; consequently the demand on the sempstress’s
industry (she accomplished about a score of stitches in half-an-hour)
was stringent.
The evening, by restoring Graham to the maternal roof (his days were
passed at school), brought us an accession of animation—a quality not
diminished by the nature of the scenes pretty sure to be enacted
between him and Miss Paulina.
A distant and haughty demeanour had been the result of the indignity
put upon her the first evening of his arrival: her usual answer, when
he addressed her, was—“I can’t attend to you; I have other things to
think about.” Being implored to state what things:
“Business.”
Graham would endeavour to seduce her attention by opening his desk and
displaying its multifarious contents: seals, bright sticks of wax,
pen-knives, with a miscellany of engravings—some of them gaily
coloured—which he had amassed from time to time. Nor was this powerful
temptation wholly unavailing: her eyes, furtively raised from her work,
cast many a peep towards the writing-table, rich in scattered pictures.
An etching of a child playing with a Blenheim spaniel happened to
flutter to the floor.
“Pretty little dog!” said she, delighted.
Graham prudently took no notice. Ere long, stealing from her corner,
she approached to examine the treasure more closely. The dog’s great
eyes and long ears, and the child’s hat and feathers, were
irresistible.
“Nice picture!” was her favourable criticism.
“Well—you may have it,” said Graham.
She seemed to hesitate. The wish to possess was strong, but to accept
would be a compromise of dignity. No. She put it down and turned away.
“You won’t have it, then, Polly?”
“I would rather not, thank you.”
“Shall I tell you what I will do with the picture if you refuse it?”
She half turned to listen.
“Cut it into strips for lighting the taper.”
“No!”
“But I shall.”
“Please—don’t.”
Graham waxed inexorable on hearing the pleading tone; he took the
scissors from his mother’s work-basket.
“Here goes!” said he, making a menacing flourish. “Right through Fido’s
head, and splitting little Harry’s nose.”
“No! No! NO!”
“Then come to me. Come quickly, or it is done.”
She hesitated, lingered, but complied.
“Now, will you have it?” he asked, as she stood before him.
“Please.”
“But I shall want payment.”
“How much?”
“A kiss.”
“Give the picture first into my hand.”
Polly, as she said this, looked rather faithless in her turn. Graham
gave it. She absconded a debtor, darted to her father, and took refuge
on his knee. Graham rose in mimic wrath and followed. She buried her
face in Mr. Home’s waistcoat.
“Papa—papa—send him away!”
“I’ll not be sent away,” said Graham.
With face still averted, she held out her hand to keep him off.
“Then, I shall kiss the hand,” said he; but that moment it became a
miniature fist, and dealt him payment in a small coin that was not
kisses.
Graham—not failing in his way to be as wily as his little
playmate—retreated apparently quite discomfited; he flung himself on a
sofa, and resting his head against the cushion, lay like one in pain.
Polly, finding him silent, presently peeped at him. His eyes and face
were covered with his hands. She turned on her father’s knee, and gazed
at her foe anxiously and long. Graham groaned.
“Papa, what is the matter?” she whispered.
“You had better ask him, Polly.”
“Is he hurt?” (groan second.)
“He makes a noise as if he were,” said Mr. Home.
“Mother,” suggested Graham, feebly, “I think you had better send for
the doctor. Oh my eye!” (renewed silence, broken only by sighs from
Graham.)
“If I were to become blind——?” suggested this last.
His chastiser could not bear the suggestion. She was beside him
directly.
“Let me see your eye: I did not mean to touch it, only your mouth; and
I did not think I hit so very hard.”
Silence answered her. Her features worked,—“I am sorry; I am sorry!”
Then succeeded emotion, faltering; weeping.
“Have done trying that child, Graham,” said Mrs. Bretton.
“It is all nonsense, my pet,” cried Mr. Home.
And Graham once more snatched her aloft, and she again punished him;
and while she pulled his lion’s locks, termed him—“The naughtiest,
rudest, worst, untruest person that ever was.”
On the morning of Mr. Home’s departure, he and his daughter had some
conversation in a window-recess by themselves; I heard part of it.
“Couldn’t I pack my box and go with you, papa?” she whispered
earnestly.
He shook his head.
“Should I be a trouble to you?”
“Yes, Polly.”
“Because I am little?”
“Because you are little and tender. It is only great, strong people
that should travel. But don’t look sad, my little girl; it breaks my
heart. Papa, will soon come back to his Polly.”
“Indeed, indeed, I am not sad, scarcely at all.”
“Polly would be sorry to give papa pain; would she not?”
“Sorrier than sorry.”
“Then Polly must be cheerful: not cry at parting; not fret afterwards.
She must look forward to meeting again, and try to be happy meanwhile.
Can she do this?”
“She will try.”
“I see she will. Farewell, then. It is time to go.”
“Now?—just now?
“Just now.”
She held up quivering lips. Her father sobbed, but she, I remarked, did
not. Having put her down, he shook hands with the rest present, and
departed.
When the street-door closed, she dropped on her knees at a chair with a
cry—“Papa!”
It was low and long; a sort of “Why hast thou forsaken me?” During an
ensuing space of some minutes, I perceived she endured agony. She went
through, in that brief interval of her infant life, emotions such as
some never feel; it was in her constitution: she would have more of
such instants if she lived. Nobody spoke. Mrs. Bretton, being a mother,
shed a tear or two. Graham, who was writing, lifted up his eyes and
gazed at her. I, Lucy Snowe, was calm.
The little creature, thus left unharassed, did for herself what none
other could do—contended with an intolerable feeling; and, ere long, in
some degree, repressed it. That day she would accept solace from none;
nor the next day: she grew more passive afterwards.
On the third evening, as she sat on the floor, worn and quiet, Graham,
coming in, took her up gently, without a word. She did not resist: she
rather nestled in his arms, as if weary. When he sat down, she laid her
head against him; in a few minutes she slept; he carried her upstairs
to bed. I was not surprised that, the next morning, the first thing she
demanded was, “Where is Mr. Graham?”
It happened that Graham was not coming to the breakfast-table; he had
some exercises to write for that morning’s class, and had requested his
mother to send a cup of tea into the study. Polly volunteered to carry
it: she must be busy about something, look after somebody. The cup was
entrusted to her; for, if restless, she was also careful. As the study
was opposite the breakfast-room, the doors facing across the passage,
my eye followed her.
“What are you doing?” she asked, pausing on the threshold.
“Writing,” said Graham.
“Why don’t you come to take breakfast with your mamma?”
“Too busy.”
“Do you want any breakfast?”
“Of course.”
“There, then.”
And she deposited the cup on the carpet, like a jailor putting a
prisoner’s pitcher of water through his cell-door, and retreated.
Presently she returned.
“What will you have besides tea—what to eat?”
“Anything good. Bring me something particularly nice; that’s a kind
little woman.”
She came back to Mrs. Bretton.
“Please, ma’am, send your boy something good.”
“You shall choose for him, Polly; what shall my boy have?”
She selected a portion of whatever was best on the table; and, ere
long, came back with a whispered request for some marmalade, which was
not there. Having got it, however, (for Mrs. Bretton refused the pair
nothing), Graham was shortly after heard lauding her to the skies;
promising that, when he had a house of his own, she should be his
housekeeper, and perhaps—if she showed any culinary genius—his cook;
and, as she did not return, and I went to look after her, I found
Graham and her breakfasting tête-à-tête—she standing at his elbow,
and sharing his fare: excepting the marmalade, which she delicately
refused to touch, lest, I suppose, it should appear that she had
procured it as much on her own account as his. She constantly evinced
these nice perceptions and delicate instincts.
The league of acquaintanceship thus struck up was not hastily
dissolved; on the contrary, it appeared that time and circumstances
served rather to cement than loosen it. Ill-assimilated as the two were
in age, sex, pursuits, &c., they somehow found a great deal to say to
each other. As to Paulina, I observed that her little character never
properly came out, except with young Bretton. As she got settled, and
accustomed to the house, she proved tractable enough with Mrs. Bretton;
but she would sit on a stool at that lady’s feet all day long, learning
her task, or sewing, or drawing figures with a pencil on a slate, and
never kindling once to originality, or showing a single gleam of the
peculiarities of her nature. I ceased to watch her under such
circumstances: she was not interesting. But the moment Graham’s knock
sounded of an evening, a change occurred; she was instantly at the head
of the staircase. Usually her welcome was a reprimand or a threat.
“You have not wiped your shoes properly on the mat. I shall tell your
mamma.”
“Little busybody! Are you there?”
“Yes—and you can’t reach me: I am higher up than you“ (peeping between
the rails of the banister; she could not look over them).
“Polly!”
“My dear boy!” (such was one of her terms for him, adopted in imitation
of his mother.)
“I am fit to faint with fatigue,” declared Graham, leaning against the
passage-wall in seeming exhaustion. “Dr. Digby“ (the headmaster) “has
quite knocked me up with overwork. Just come down and help me to carry
up my books.”
“Ah! you’re cunning!”
“Not at all, Polly—it is positive fact. I’m as weak as a rush. Come
down.”
“Your eyes are quiet like the cat’s, but you’ll spring.”
“Spring? Nothing of the kind: it isn’t in me. Come down.”
“Perhaps I may—if you’ll promise not to touch—not to snatch me up, and
not to whirl me round.”
“I? I couldn’t do it!” (sinking into a chair.)
“Then put the books down on the first step, and go three yards off.“
This being done, she descended warily, and not taking her eyes from the
feeble Graham. Of course her approach always galvanized him to new and
spasmodic life: the game of romps was sure to be exacted. Sometimes she
would be angry; sometimes the matter was allowed to pass smoothly, and
we could hear her say as she led him up-stairs: “Now, my dear boy, come
and take your tea—I am sure you must want something.”
It was sufficiently comical to observe her as she sat beside Graham,
while he took that meal. In his absence she was a still personage, but
with him the most officious, fidgety little body possible. I often
wished she would mind herself and be tranquil; but no—herself was
forgotten in him: he could not be sufficiently well waited on, nor
carefully enough looked after; he was more than the Grand Turk in her
estimation. She would gradually assemble the various plates before him,
and, when one would suppose all he could possibly desire was within his
reach, she would find out something else: “Ma’am,” she would whisper to
Mrs. Bretton,—“perhaps your son would like a little cake—sweet cake,
you know—there is some in there“ (pointing to the sideboard cupboard).
Mrs. Bretton, as a rule, disapproved of sweet cake at tea, but still
the request was urged,—“One little piece—only for him—as he goes to
school: girls—such as me and Miss Snowe—don’t need treats, but he
would like it.”
Graham did like it very well, and almost always got it. To do him
justice, he would have shared his prize with her to whom he owed it;
but that was never allowed: to insist, was to ruffle her for the
evening. To stand by his knee, and monopolize his talk and notice, was
the reward she wanted—not a share of the cake.
With curious readiness did she adapt herself to such themes as
interested him. One would have thought the child had no mind or life of
her own, but must necessarily live, move, and have her being in
another: now that her father was taken from her, she nestled to Graham,
and seemed to feel by his feelings: to exist in his existence. She
learned the names of all his schoolfellows in a trice: she got by heart
their characters as given from his lips: a single description of an
individual seemed to suffice. She never forgot, or confused identities:
she would talk with him the whole evening about people she had never
seen, and appear completely to realise their aspect, manners, and
dispositions. Some she learned to mimic: an under-master, who was an
aversion of young Bretton’s, had, it seems, some peculiarities, which
she caught up in a moment from Graham’s representation, and rehearsed
for his amusement; this, however, Mrs. Bretton disapproved and forbade.
The pair seldom quarrelled; yet once a rupture occurred, in which her
feelings received a severe shock.
One day Graham, on the occasion of his birthday, had some friends—lads
of his own age—to dine with him. Paulina took much interest in the
coming of these friends; she had frequently heard of them; they were
amongst those of whom Graham oftenest spoke. After dinner, the young
gentlemen were left by themselves in the dining-room, where they soon
became very merry and made a good deal of noise. Chancing to pass
through the hall, I found Paulina sitting alone on the lowest step of
the staircase, her eyes fixed on the glossy panels of the dining-room
door, where the reflection of the hall-lamp was shining; her little
brow knit in anxious meditation.
“What are you thinking about, Polly?”
“Nothing particular; only I wish that door was clear glass—that I might
see through it. The boys seem very cheerful, and I want to go to them:
I want to be with Graham, and watch his friends.”
“What hinders you from going?”
“I feel afraid: but may I try, do you think? May I knock at the door,
and ask to be let in?”
I thought perhaps they might not object to have her as a playmate, and
therefore encouraged the attempt.
She knocked—too faintly at first to be heard, but on a second essay the
door unclosed; Graham’s head appeared; he looked in high spirits, but
impatient.
“What do you want, you little monkey?”
“To come to you.”
“Do you indeed? As if I would be troubled with you! Away to mamma and
Mistress Snowe, and tell them to put you to bed.” The auburn head and
bright flushed face vanished,—the door shut peremptorily. She was
stunned.
“Why does he speak so? He never spoke so before,” she said in
consternation. “What have I done?”
“Nothing, Polly; but Graham is busy with his school-friends.”
“And he likes them better than me! He turns me away now they are here!”
I had some thoughts of consoling her, and of improving the occasion by
inculcating some of those maxims of philosophy whereof I had ever a
tolerable stock ready for application. She stopped me, however, by
putting her fingers in her ears at the first words I uttered, and then
lying down on the mat with her face against the flags; nor could either
Warren or the cook root her from that position: she was allowed to lie,
therefore, till she chose to rise of her own accord.
Graham forgot his impatience the same evening, and would have accosted
her as usual when his friends were gone, but she wrenched herself from
his hand; her eye quite flashed; she would not bid him good-night; she
would not look in his face. The next day he treated her with
indifference, and she grew like a bit of marble. The day after, he
teased her to know what was the matter; her lips would not unclose. Of
course he could not feel real anger on his side: the match was too
unequal in every way; he tried soothing and coaxing. “Why was she so
angry? What had he done?” By-and-by tears answered him; he petted her,
and they were friends. But she was one on whom such incidents were not
lost: I remarked that never after this rebuff did she seek him, or
follow him, or in any way solicit his notice. I told her once to carry
a book or some other article to Graham when he was shut up in his
study.
“I shall wait till he comes out,” said she, proudly; “I don’t choose to
give him the trouble of rising to open the door.”
Young Bretton had a favourite pony on which he often rode out; from the
window she always watched his departure and return. It was her ambition
to be permitted to have a ride round the courtyard on this pony; but
far be it from her to ask such a favour. One day she descended to the
yard to watch him dismount; as she leaned against the gate, the longing
wish for the indulgence of a ride glittered in her eye.
“Come, Polly, will you have a canter?” asked Graham, half carelessly.
I suppose she thought he was too careless.
“No, thank you,” said she, turning away with the utmost coolness.
“You’d better,” pursued he. “You will like it, I am sure.”
“Don’t think I should care a fig about it,” was the response.
“That is not true. You told Lucy Snowe you longed to have a ride.”
“Lucy Snowe is a tatter-box,” I heard her say (her imperfect
articulation was the least precocious thing she had about her); and
with this; she walked into the house.
Graham, coming in soon after, observed to his mother,—“Mamma, I believe
that creature is a changeling: she is a perfect cabinet of oddities;
but I should be dull without her: she amuses me a great deal more than
you or Lucy Snowe.”
“Miss Snowe,” said Paulina to me (she had now got into the habit of
occasionally chatting with me when we were alone in our room at night),
“do you know on what day in the week I like Graham best?”
“How can I possibly know anything so strange? Is there one day out of
the seven when he is otherwise than on the other six?”
“To be sure! Can’t you see? Don’t you know? I find him the most
excellent on a Sunday; then we have him the whole day, and he is quiet,
and, in the evening, so kind.”
This observation was not altogether groundless: going to church, &c.,
kept Graham quiet on the Sunday, and the evening he generally dedicated
to a serene, though rather indolent sort of enjoyment by the parlour
fireside. He would take possession of the couch, and then he would call
Polly.
Graham was a boy not quite as other boys are; all his delight did not
lie in action: he was capable of some intervals of contemplation; he
could take a pleasure too in reading, nor was his selection of books
wholly indiscriminate: there were glimmerings of characteristic
preference, and even of instinctive taste in the choice. He rarely, it
is true, remarked on what he read, but I have seen him sit and think of
it.
Polly, being near him, kneeling on a little cushion or the carpet, a
conversation would begin in murmurs, not inaudible, though subdued. I
caught a snatch of their tenor now and then; and, in truth, some
influence better and finer than that of every day, seemed to soothe
Graham at such times into no ungentle mood.
“Have you learned any hymns this week, Polly?”
“I have learned a very pretty one, four verses long. Shall I say it?”
“Speak nicely, then: don’t be in a hurry.”
The hymn being rehearsed, or rather half-chanted, in a little singing
voice, Graham would take exceptions at the manner, and proceed to give
a lesson in recitation. She was quick in learning, apt in imitating;
and, besides, her pleasure was to please Graham: she proved a ready
scholar. To the hymn would succeed some reading—perhaps a chapter in
the Bible; correction was seldom required here, for the child could
read any simple narrative chapter very well; and, when the subject was
such as she could understand and take an interest in, her expression
and emphasis were something remarkable. Joseph cast into the pit; the
calling of Samuel; Daniel in the lions’ den;—these were favourite
passages: of the first especially she seemed perfectly to feel the
pathos.
“Poor Jacob!” she would sometimes say, with quivering lips. “How he
loved his son Joseph! As much,” she once added—“as much, Graham, as I
love you: if you were to die“ (and she re-opened the book, sought the
verse, and read), “I should refuse to be comforted, and go down into
the grave to you mourning.”
With these words she gathered Graham in her little arms, drawing his
long-tressed head towards her. The action, I remember, struck me as
strangely rash; exciting the feeling one might experience on seeing an
animal dangerous by nature, and but half-tamed by art, too heedlessly
fondled. Not that I feared Graham would hurt, or very roughly check
her; but I thought she ran risk of incurring such a careless, impatient
repulse, as would be worse almost to her than a blow. On the whole,
however, these demonstrations were borne passively: sometimes even a
sort of complacent wonder at her earnest partiality would smile not
unkindly in his eyes. Once he said:—“You like me almost as well as if
you were my little sister, Polly.”
“Oh! I do like you,” said she; “I do like you very much.”
I was not long allowed the amusement of this study of character. She
had scarcely been at Bretton two months, when a letter came from Mr.
Home, signifying that he was now settled amongst his maternal kinsfolk
on the Continent; that, as England was become wholly distasteful to
him, he had no thoughts of returning hither, perhaps, for years; and
that he wished his little girl to join him immediately.
“I wonder how she will take this news?” said Mrs. Bretton, when she had
read the letter. I wondered, too, and I took upon myself to
communicate it.
Repairing to the drawing-room—in which calm and decorated apartment she
was fond of being alone, and where she could be implicitly trusted, for
she fingered nothing, or rather soiled nothing she fingered—I found her
seated, like a little Odalisque, on a couch, half shaded by the
drooping draperies of the window near. She seemed happy; all her
appliances for occupation were about her; the white wood workbox, a
shred or two of muslin, an end or two of ribbon collected for
conversion into doll-millinery. The doll, duly night-capped and
night-gowned, lay in its cradle; she was rocking it to sleep, with an
air of the most perfect faith in its possession of sentient and
somnolent faculties; her eyes, at the same time, being engaged with a
picture-book, which lay open on her lap.
“Miss Snowe,” said she in a whisper, “this is a wonderful book.
Candace” (the doll, christened by Graham; for, indeed, its begrimed
complexion gave it much of an Ethiopian aspect)—“Candace is asleep now,
and I may tell you about it; only we must both speak low, lest she
should waken. This book was given me by Graham; it tells about distant
countries, a long, long way from England, which no traveller can reach
without sailing thousands of miles over the sea. Wild men live in these
countries, Miss Snowe, who wear clothes different from ours: indeed,
some of them wear scarcely any clothes, for the sake of being cool, you
know; for they have very hot weather. Here is a picture of thousands
gathered in a desolate place—a plain, spread with sand—round a man in
black,—a good, good Englishman—a missionary, who is preaching to them
under a palm-tree.” (She showed a little coloured cut to that effect.)
“And here are pictures” (she went on) “more stranger” (grammar was
occasionally forgotten) “than that. There is the wonderful Great Wall
of China; here is a Chinese lady, with a foot littler than mine. There
is a wild horse of Tartary; and here, most strange of all—is a land of
ice and snow, without green fields, woods, or gardens. In this land,
they found some mammoth bones: there are no mammoths now. You don’t
know what it was; but I can tell you, because Graham told me. A mighty,
goblin creature, as high as this room, and as long as the hall; but not
a fierce, flesh-eating thing, Graham thinks. He believes, if I met one
in a forest, it would not kill me, unless I came quite in its way; when
it would trample me down amongst the bushes, as I might tread on a
grasshopper in a hayfield without knowing it.”
Thus she rambled on.
“Polly,” I interrupted, “should you like to travel?”
“Not just yet,” was the prudent answer; “but perhaps in twenty years,
when I am grown a woman, as tall as Mrs. Bretton, I may travel with
Graham. We intend going to Switzerland, and climbing Mount Blanck; and
some day we shall sail over to South America, and walk to the top of
Kim-kim-borazo.”
“But how would you like to travel now, if your papa was with you?”
Her reply—not given till after a pause—evinced one of those unexpected
turns of temper peculiar to her.
“Where is the good of talking in that silly way?” said she. “Why do you
mention papa? What is papa to you? I was just beginning to be happy,
and not think about him so much; and there it will be all to do over
again!”
Her lip trembled. I hastened to disclose the fact of a letter having
been received, and to mention the directions given that she and Harriet
should immediately rejoin this dear papa. “Now, Polly, are you not
glad?” I added.
She made no answer. She dropped her book and ceased to rock her doll;
she gazed at me with gravity and earnestness.
“Shall not you like to go to papa?”
“Of course,” she said at last in that trenchant manner she usually
employed in speaking to me; and which was quite different from that she
used with Mrs. Bretton, and different again from the one dedicated to
Graham. I wished to ascertain more of what she thought but no: she
would converse no more. Hastening to Mrs. Bretton, she questioned her,
and received the confirmation of my news. The weight and importance of
these tidings kept her perfectly serious the whole day. In the evening,
at the moment Graham’s entrance was heard below, I found her at my
side. She began to arrange a locket-ribbon about my neck, she displaced
and replaced the comb in my hair; while thus busied, Graham entered.
“Tell him by-and-by,” she whispered; “tell him I am going.”
In the course of tea-time I made the desired communication. Graham, it
chanced, was at that time greatly preoccupied about some school-prize,
for which he was competing. The news had to be told twice before it
took proper hold of his attention, and even then he dwelt on it but
momently.
“Polly going? What a pity! Dear little Mousie, I shall be sorry to lose
her: she must come to us again, mamma.”
And hastily swallowing his tea, he took a candle and a small table to
himself and his books, and was soon buried in study.
“Little Mousie” crept to his side, and lay down on the carpet at his
feet, her face to the floor; mute and motionless she kept that post and
position till bed-time. Once I saw Graham—wholly unconscious of her
proximity—push her with his restless foot. She receded an inch or two.
A minute after one little hand stole out from beneath her face, to
which it had been pressed, and softly caressed the heedless foot. When
summoned by her nurse she rose and departed very obediently, having bid
us all a subdued good-night.
I will not say that I dreaded going to bed, an hour later; yet I
certainly went with an unquiet anticipation that I should find that
child in no peaceful sleep. The forewarning of my instinct was but
fulfilled, when I discovered her, all cold and vigilant, perched like a
white bird on the outside of the bed. I scarcely knew how to accost
her; she was not to be managed like another child. She, however,
accosted me. As I closed the door, and put the light on the
dressing-table, she turned to me with these words:—“I cannot—cannot
sleep; and in this way I cannot—cannot live!”
I asked what ailed her.
“Dedful miz-er-y!” said she, with her piteous lisp.
“Shall I call Mrs. Bretton?”
“That is downright silly,” was her impatient reply; and, indeed, I well
knew that if she had heard Mrs. Bretton’s foot approach, she would have
nestled quiet as a mouse under the bedclothes. Whilst lavishing her
eccentricities regardlessly before me—for whom she professed scarcely
the semblance of affection—she never showed my godmother one glimpse of
her inner self: for her, she was nothing but a docile, somewhat quaint
little maiden. I examined her; her cheek was crimson; her dilated eye
was both troubled and glowing, and painfully restless: in this state it
was obvious she must not be left till morning. I guessed how the case
stood.
“Would you like to bid Graham good-night again?” I asked. “He is not
gone to his room yet.”
She at once stretched out her little arms to be lifted. Folding a shawl
round her, I carried her back to the drawing-room. Graham was just
coming out.
“She cannot sleep without seeing and speaking to you once more,” I
said. “She does not like the thought of leaving you.”
“I’ve spoilt her,” said he, taking her from me with good humour, and
kissing her little hot face and burning lips. “Polly, you care for me
more than for papa, now—”
“I do care for you, but you care nothing for me,” was her whisper.
She was assured to the contrary, again kissed, restored to me, and I
carried her away; but, alas! not soothed.
When I thought she could listen to me, I said—“Paulina, you should not
grieve that Graham does not care for you so much as you care for him.
It must be so.”
Her lifted and questioning eyes asked why.
“Because he is a boy and you are a girl; he is sixteen and you are only
six; his nature is strong and gay, and yours is otherwise.”
“But I love him so much; he should love me a little.”
“He does. He is fond of you. You are his favourite.”
“Am I Graham’s favourite?”
“Yes, more than any little child I know.”
The assurance soothed her; she smiled in her anguish.
“But,” I continued, “don’t fret, and don’t expect too much of him, or
else he will feel you to be troublesome, and then it is all over.”
“All over!” she echoed softly; “then I’ll be good. I’ll try to be good,
Lucy Snowe.”
I put her to bed.
“Will he forgive me this one time?” she asked, as I undressed myself. I
assured her that he would; that as yet he was by no means alienated;
that she had only to be careful for the future.
“There is no future,” said she: “I am going. Shall I ever—ever—see him
again, after I leave England?”
I returned an encouraging response. The candle being extinguished, a
still half-hour elapsed. I thought her asleep, when the little white
shape once more lifted itself in the crib, and the small voice
asked—“Do you like Graham, Miss Snowe?”
“Like him! Yes, a little.”
“Only a little! Do you like him as I do?”
“I think not. No: not as you do.”
“Do you like him much?”
“I told you I liked him a little. Where is the use of caring for him so
very much: he is full of faults.”
“Is he?”
“All boys are.”
“More than girls?”
“Very likely. Wise people say it is folly to think anybody perfect; and
as to likes and dislikes, we should be friendly to all, and worship
none.”
“Are you a wise person?”
“I mean to try to be so. Go to sleep.”
“I cannot go to sleep. Have you no pain just here” (laying her elfish
hand on her elfish breast,) “when you think you shall have to leave
Graham; for your home is not here?”
“Surely, Polly,” said I, “you should not feel so much pain when you are
very soon going to rejoin your father. Have you forgotten him? Do you
no longer wish to be his little companion?”
Dead silence succeeded this question.
“Child, lie down and sleep,” I urged.
“My bed is cold,” said she. “I can’t warm it.”
I saw the little thing shiver. “Come to me,” I said, wishing, yet
scarcely hoping, that she would comply: for she was a most strange,
capricious, little creature, and especially whimsical with me. She
came, however, instantly, like a small ghost gliding over the carpet. I
took her in. She was chill: I warmed her in my arms. She trembled
nervously; I soothed her. Thus tranquillized and cherished she at last
slumbered.
“A very unique child,” thought I, as I viewed her sleeping countenance
by the fitful moonlight, and cautiously and softly wiped her glittering
eyelids and her wet cheeks with my handkerchief. “How will she get
through this world, or battle with this life? How will she bear the
shocks and repulses, the humiliations and desolations, which books, and
my own reason, tell me are prepared for all flesh?”
She departed the next day; trembling like a leaf when she took leave,
but exercising self-command.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
The tendency to abandon one's authentic self and become whatever others need in order to secure love and connection.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone (including yourself) is abandoning their authentic self to earn love and approval.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you find yourself changing your opinions, interests, or behavior to please someone—that anxious feeling when you're crafting responses based on what they want to hear.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Papa, put me down; I shall tire you with my weight."
Context: When she senses her father might be getting restless while she sits on his lap
This shows how hyperaware Paulina is of others' moods and needs. At six years old, she's already learned to anticipate rejection and protect herself by withdrawing first.
In Today's Words:
I don't want to be a burden, so I'll remove myself before you get annoyed with me.
"A distant and haughty demeanour had been the result of the indignity put upon her the first evening."
Context: Describing how Paulina reacted after Graham treated her poorly
Even as a small child, Paulina uses emotional withdrawal as protection. When hurt, she becomes cold and proud rather than showing vulnerability.
In Today's Words:
She gave him the cold shoulder after he disrespected her.
"The demand on the sempstress's industry was stringent."
Context: Describing Paulina's urgent need to finish the handkerchief for her father
This reveals Paulina's desperate need to create something meaningful for her father before he leaves. The handkerchief represents her love and fear of abandonment.
In Today's Words:
She was working frantically to finish this gift because it felt super important.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Paulina completely reshapes herself around Graham's preferences, losing her authentic self in the process of securing his attention
Development
Building from earlier hints about social performance, now showing how identity can be entirely sacrificed for connection
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you've changed your opinions, interests, or behavior dramatically to fit in with someone important to you.
Power Dynamics
In This Chapter
Graham holds all the power in their relationship, able to grant or withdraw affection at will while Paulina has none
Development
Expanding the theme to show how emotional power imbalances develop even in seemingly innocent relationships
In Your Life:
This appears when you find yourself constantly trying to please someone who gives you attention only when it suits them.
Emotional Labor
In This Chapter
Paulina does all the work of maintaining their relationship—studying his needs, managing his moods, making herself useful
Development
Introduced here as a central theme about who carries the burden of connection
In Your Life:
You see this when you're always the one reaching out, remembering important dates, or smoothing over conflicts in relationships.
Childhood Patterns
In This Chapter
Early attachment strategies formed in childhood that will likely persist into adulthood relationships
Development
New theme showing how adult relationship patterns are established early
In Your Life:
Your childhood coping mechanisms for getting love and attention probably still influence how you behave in important relationships today.
Observation
In This Chapter
Lucy watches this dynamic unfold with detachment, learning about human nature through careful observation
Development
Continuing Lucy's role as the perceptive outsider who sees patterns others miss
In Your Life:
Sometimes the most valuable skill is stepping back and observing relationship dynamics rather than getting caught up in them.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific strategies does Paulina use to win Graham's attention and approval?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Paulina completely reshape herself around Graham's interests instead of maintaining her own identity?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this 'emotional shapeshifter' pattern in modern workplaces, relationships, or social media?
application • medium - 4
How could Paulina maintain connection with Graham while still preserving her authentic self?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between earning love and receiving love?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Identity Audit: Performance vs. Authenticity
Think of a relationship where you find yourself constantly adapting to please the other person. List three ways you've changed your behavior, interests, or opinions in that relationship. Then identify one core value or preference you've never compromised, even in difficult relationships.
Consider:
- •Notice the difference between healthy compromise and complete self-erasure
- •Pay attention to relationships that energize you versus those that drain you
- •Consider whether the other person knows and accepts your authentic preferences
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you chose authenticity over approval. What happened? How did it feel different from your usual pattern of adapting to others?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 4: The Companion's Calling
Years pass, and Lucy finds herself in a very different situation—caring for an invalid woman whose bitter isolation offers a stark contrast to the warm chaos of the Bretton household. Miss Marchmont's story will reveal what happens when life's disappointments calcify into permanent withdrawal from human connection.




