Summary
Lucy's recovery continues at the Brettons' home, where she observes the complex nature of Dr. John's character. While publicly modest and philanthropic in his medical work among the poor, privately he craves admiration and attention. Lucy appreciates his genuine kindness but refuses to idealize him, noting his vanity and need for praise. During art gallery visits, she discovers her own authentic responses to paintings, rejecting the pressure to admire what she's supposed to like. A confrontation occurs when Professor Emanuel finds Lucy viewing a provocative painting of Cleopatra. He's scandalized that an unmarried woman would look at such art, forcing her to sit before morally 'appropriate' paintings of women's life stages instead. Lucy finds these sanitized images far more offensive than the sensual Cleopatra. The incident reveals the hypocrisy of social conventions—men can freely view and discuss the same art that women are forbidden to see. When Dr. John arrives, his casual dismissal of the Cleopatra contrasts sharply with both Emanuel's moral outrage and other men's obvious fascination. Lucy learns to trust her own perceptions rather than accept others' judgments, whether about art or people. The chapter explores how society polices women's experiences while celebrating the very things it forbids them to acknowledge.
Coming Up in Chapter 20
A concert provides the perfect stage for observing Villette's social dynamics in action. Lucy will witness how performance—both musical and social—reveals the true nature of those around her, while she continues to navigate her own complex feelings.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
THE CLEOPATRA. My stay at La Terrasse was prolonged a fortnight beyond the close of the vacation. Mrs. Bretton’s kind management procured me this respite. Her son having one day delivered the dictum that “Lucy was not yet strong enough to go back to that den of a pensionnat,” she at once drove over to the Rue Fossette, had an interview with the directress, and procured the indulgence, on the plea of prolonged rest and change being necessary to perfect recovery. Hereupon, however, followed an attention I could very well have dispensed with, viz.—a polite call from Madame Beck. That lady—one fine day—actually came out in a fiacre as far as the château. I suppose she had resolved within herself to see what manner of place Dr. John inhabited. Apparently, the pleasant site and neat interior surpassed her expectations; she eulogized all she saw, pronounced the blue salon “une pièce magnifique,” profusely congratulated me on the acquisition of friends, “tellement dignes, aimables, et respectables,” turned also a neat compliment in my favour, and, upon Dr. John coming in, ran up to him with the utmost buoyancy, opening at the same time such a fire of rapid language, all sparkling with felicitations and protestations about his “château,”—“madame sa mère, la digne châtelaine:” also his looks; which, indeed, were very flourishing, and at the moment additionally embellished by the good-natured but amused smile with which he always listened to Madame’s fluent and florid French. In short, Madame shone in her very best phase that day, and came in and went out quite a living catherine-wheel of compliments, delight, and affability. Half purposely, and half to ask some question about school-business, I followed her to the carriage, and looked in after she was seated and the door closed. In that brief fraction of time what a change had been wrought! An instant ago, all sparkles and jests, she now sat sterner than a judge and graver than a sage. Strange little woman! I went back and teased Dr. John about Madame’s devotion to him. How he laughed! What fun shone in his eyes as he recalled some of her fine speeches, and repeated them, imitating her voluble delivery! He had an acute sense of humour, and was the finest company in the world—when he could forget Miss Fanshawe. To “sit in sunshine calm and sweet” is said to be excellent for weak people; it gives them vital force. When little Georgette Beck was recovering from her illness, I used to take her in my arms and walk with her in the garden by the hour together, beneath a certain wall hung with grapes, which the Southern sun was ripening: that sun cherished her little pale frame quite as effectually as it mellowed and swelled the clustering fruit. There are human tempers, bland, glowing, and genial, within whose influence it is as good for the poor in spirit to live, as it is for the feeble in frame to bask in the glow of...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Double Standards - How Society Polices What You're Allowed to See
Society creates moral restrictions that serve control rather than protection, policing who can access what experiences based on power dynamics, not actual harm.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between genuine ethical concerns and artificial boundaries designed to control access to information or experiences.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone expresses moral outrage about something you're doing, seeing, or knowing—ask yourself who benefits from the restriction and whether it protects or controls you.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Pensionnat
A French boarding school for girls, typically run by women and focused on 'accomplishments' like languages and arts rather than serious academics. These schools were designed to prepare middle-class girls for marriage, not careers.
Modern Usage:
Like expensive private schools today that focus more on social connections and 'refinement' than actual learning.
Fiacre
A horse-drawn cab for hire in 19th-century cities, the equivalent of calling a taxi. Using one showed you had money to spend on convenience rather than walking or taking cheaper transport.
Modern Usage:
Taking an Uber instead of the bus - it's about both convenience and showing you can afford it.
Châtelaine
The lady of a castle or manor house, responsible for managing the household. The term implies both authority and respectability - a woman with legitimate social power within her domestic sphere.
Modern Usage:
Like calling someone 'the queen of her domain' - recognizing a woman's authority in her own space.
Salon
A formal reception room in wealthy homes where guests were entertained. The quality of your salon reflected your social status and taste, making it crucial for maintaining reputation.
Modern Usage:
Your living room when company comes over - the space that shows who you are and what you can afford.
Moral propriety
The strict social rules about what was considered appropriate behavior, especially for women. These rules controlled everything from what you could look at to where you could go and with whom.
Modern Usage:
Like dress codes or social media policies that police women's behavior while men face fewer restrictions.
Philanthropic work
Charitable activities, especially medical care for the poor. For middle-class professionals, this work provided both genuine help to others and social respectability - proving you were morally worthy of your status.
Modern Usage:
Like volunteer work or pro bono services that help your community while also looking good on your resume.
Characters in This Chapter
Lucy Snowe
Protagonist and observer
Lucy continues recovering while developing her ability to see people clearly, without illusions. She refuses to idealize Dr. John despite his kindness and learns to trust her own judgment about art and social conventions.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who sees through everyone's act but keeps it mostly to herself
Dr. John
Complex romantic interest
Revealed as genuinely kind but also vain and needing constant admiration. He's philanthropic with the poor but craves praise from his social equals, showing the complexity of human motivation.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who volunteers at the shelter but posts about it constantly on social media
Madame Beck
Calculating authority figure
Makes a strategic visit to assess the Brettons' wealth and social status. Her flattery and charm mask her constant evaluation of people's usefulness to her own interests.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss who suddenly becomes your best friend when she finds out you have connections
Professor Emanuel
Moral enforcer
Becomes outraged at Lucy viewing the Cleopatra painting, forcing her to look at 'appropriate' art instead. His reaction reveals the hypocrisy of moral standards that police women's experiences.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who gets offended by women's choices while consuming the same content himself
Mrs. Bretton
Protective mother figure
Arranges Lucy's extended stay and manages the social situation diplomatically. She represents genuine care combined with social awareness and practical action.
Modern Equivalent:
The mom who actually follows through on helping instead of just offering thoughts and prayers
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Lucy was not yet strong enough to go back to that den of a pensionnat"
Context: Dr. John declaring Lucy needs more recovery time
His protective language reveals both genuine concern and a negative view of Lucy's workplace. The word 'den' suggests something dangerous or unwholesome, showing how he sees her environment.
In Today's Words:
She's not ready to go back to that toxic workplace yet
"It would not do for a woman to look at this picture"
Context: Emanuel's reaction to Lucy viewing the Cleopatra painting
This reveals the double standard that forbids women from seeing what men freely view and discuss. It shows how moral outrage is often used to control women's experiences and knowledge.
In Today's Words:
This isn't appropriate for ladies to see
"I found it more offensive than the Cleopatra"
Context: Lucy's reaction to the 'morally appropriate' paintings Emanuel forces her to view
Lucy recognizes the hypocrisy in sanitized images that reduce women to moral stereotypes. Her authentic response challenges social expectations about what should offend her.
In Today's Words:
The supposedly wholesome stuff was actually more insulting
Thematic Threads
Authentic Judgment
In This Chapter
Lucy trusts her own response to art over social expectations, finding the 'moral' paintings more offensive than the sensual one
Development
Building from earlier chapters where Lucy learned to see through social performances
In Your Life:
You might find yourself preferring the 'wrong' books, movies, or music that others dismiss as inappropriate for someone like you
Male Hypocrisy
In This Chapter
Men freely view and discuss the same art they declare inappropriate for women to see
Development
Expanding the theme of how men's public virtue masks private contradictions
In Your Life:
You might notice male colleagues discussing topics they claim women shouldn't handle or understand
Social Control
In This Chapter
Emanuel forces Lucy to view 'appropriate' art that reinforces women's limited social roles
Development
New thread showing how society actively shapes what people are allowed to experience
In Your Life:
You might feel pressure to consume media, books, or activities deemed 'suitable' for your demographic rather than your interests
Class Visibility
In This Chapter
Dr. John's casual dismissal of the painting reveals his different relationship to social rules than Emanuel's rigid enforcement
Development
Continuing exploration of how class position affects moral policing
In Your Life:
You might notice how people with more social power can break rules that others get punished for breaking
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Lucy develops confidence in her own perceptions rather than accepting others' judgments about art and people
Development
Advancing Lucy's journey toward intellectual independence from earlier passive observation
In Your Life:
You might find yourself questioning why you're supposed to like or dislike certain things based on what others expect
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Professor Emanuel get so upset about Lucy looking at the Cleopatra painting, while Dr. John just dismisses it casually?
analysis • surface - 2
What's the real difference between the 'scandalous' Cleopatra painting and the 'appropriate' paintings of women's life stages that Emanuel forces Lucy to view?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this same pattern today - where the same content or behavior is treated differently depending on who's accessing it?
application • medium - 4
When someone tells you something is 'inappropriate' for you to see or know, how do you decide whether they're protecting you or controlling you?
application • deep - 5
What does Lucy's ability to form her own opinions about art teach us about developing authentic judgment in a world full of other people's rules?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Double Standard
Think of a situation where you've been told something was 'not for you' or inappropriate for your age, gender, role, or background. Write down who made this rule, what they claimed to be protecting you from, and who had access to this same information or experience. Then analyze: what was really being controlled here?
Consider:
- •Consider whether the person making the rule followed it themselves
- •Look at who benefited from maintaining this boundary
- •Think about whether you were actually protected or just kept uninformed
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you trusted your own judgment over someone else's 'protective' rules. What did you learn about yourself and about how these boundaries really work?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 20: The Concert and the Pink Dress
In the next chapter, you'll discover forced social situations can reveal hidden truths about ourselves and others, and learn the power of small acts of cruelty to shatter romantic illusions. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.
