Amplified ClassicsAmplified Classics
Literature MattersLife IndexEducators
Sign inSign up
Treasure Island - The Failed Negotiation

Robert Louis Stevenson

Treasure Island

The Failed Negotiation

Home›Books›Treasure Island›Chapter 20
Previous
20 of 34
Next

Summary

Long John Silver arrives at the stockade under a flag of truce, attempting to negotiate with Captain Smollett. The morning is cold and misty, creating an ominous atmosphere that mirrors the tension of the encounter. Silver, dressed in his finest clothes and addressing himself as 'Captain Silver,' tries to project authority and respectability despite his mutinous actions. He offers what seems like a reasonable deal: the treasure map in exchange for safe passage and the choice of either joining the pirates or being left safely on the island with supplies. However, Captain Smollett sees through Silver's manipulative tactics and responds with unwavering firmness. He refuses to negotiate with mutineers and instead offers only one option: surrender for a fair trial in England. When Silver threatens violence, Smollett doesn't flinch, making it clear that he'll shoot Silver on sight if they meet again. The negotiation ends with Silver's humiliating departure, crawling through the sand and spitting in their water supply as a final act of defiance. This confrontation reveals the fundamental difference between true leadership and mere charisma. Smollett's refusal to compromise with wrongdoers, even when outnumbered, demonstrates that some principles are non-negotiable. Silver's polished words and reasonable tone can't mask his essential dishonesty, and Smollett's moral clarity cuts through the deception.

Coming Up in Chapter 21

Silver's threats weren't empty bluster. The failed negotiation has sealed everyone's fate, and the pirates prepare to make good on their promise of violence.

Share it with friends

Previous ChapterNext Chapter
GO ADS FREE — JOIN US

An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1886 words)

S

ilver’s Embassy

Sure enough, there were two men just outside the stockade, one of them
waving a white cloth, the other, no less a person than Silver himself,
standing placidly by.

It was still quite early, and the coldest morning that I think I ever
was abroad in--a chill that pierced into the marrow. The sky was bright
and cloudless overhead, and the tops of the trees shone rosily in
the sun. But where Silver stood with his lieutenant, all was still in
shadow, and they waded knee-deep in a low white vapour that had crawled
during the night out of the morass. The chill and the vapour taken
together told a poor tale of the island. It was plainly a damp,
feverish, unhealthy spot.

“Keep indoors, men,” said the captain. “Ten to one this is a trick.”

Then he hailed the buccaneer.

“Who goes? Stand, or we fire.”

“Flag of truce,” cried Silver.

The captain was in the porch, keeping himself carefully out of the way
of a treacherous shot, should any be intended. He turned and spoke to
us, “Doctor’s watch on the lookout. Dr. Livesey take the north side,
if you please; Jim, the east; Gray, west. The watch below, all hands to
load muskets. Lively, men, and careful.”

And then he turned again to the mutineers.

“And what do you want with your flag of truce?” he cried.

This time it was the other man who replied.

“Cap’n Silver, sir, to come on board and make terms,” he shouted.

“Cap’n Silver! Don’t know him. Who’s he?” cried the captain. And we
could hear him adding to himself, “Cap’n, is it? My heart, and here’s
promotion!”

Long John answered for himself. “Me, sir. These poor lads have chosen me
cap’n, after your desertion, sir”--laying a particular emphasis upon the
word “desertion.” “We’re willing to submit, if we can come to terms,
and no bones about it. All I ask is your word, Cap’n Smollett, to let me
safe and sound out of this here stockade, and one minute to get out o’
shot before a gun is fired.”

“My man,” said Captain Smollett, “I have not the slightest desire to
talk to you. If you wish to talk to me, you can come, that’s all. If
there’s any treachery, it’ll be on your side, and the Lord help you.”

“That’s enough, Cap’n,” shouted Long John cheerily. “A word from you’s
enough. I know a gentleman, and you may lay to that.”

We could see the man who carried the flag of truce attempting to hold
Silver back. Nor was that wonderful, seeing how cavalier had been the
captain’s answer. But Silver laughed at him aloud and slapped him on the
back as if the idea of alarm had been absurd. Then he advanced to the
stockade, threw over his crutch, got a leg up, and with great vigour
and skill succeeded in surmounting the fence and dropping safely to the
other side.

I will confess that I was far too much taken up with what was going on
to be of the slightest use as sentry; indeed, I had already deserted
my eastern loophole and crept up behind the captain, who had now seated
himself on the threshold, with his elbows on his knees, his head in his
hands, and his eyes fixed on the water as it bubbled out of the old iron
kettle in the sand. He was whistling “Come, Lasses and Lads.”

Silver had terrible hard work getting up the knoll. What with the
steepness of the incline, the thick tree stumps, and the soft sand, he
and his crutch were as helpless as a ship in stays. But he stuck to it
like a man in silence, and at last arrived before the captain, whom
he saluted in the handsomest style. He was tricked out in his best;
an immense blue coat, thick with brass buttons, hung as low as to his
knees, and a fine laced hat was set on the back of his head.

“Here you are, my man,” said the captain, raising his head. “You had
better sit down.”

“You ain’t a-going to let me inside, Cap’n?” complained Long John. “It’s
a main cold morning, to be sure, sir, to sit outside upon the sand.”

“Why, Silver,” said the captain, “if you had pleased to be an honest
man, you might have been sitting in your galley. It’s your own doing.
You’re either my ship’s cook--and then you were treated handsome--or
Cap’n Silver, a common mutineer and pirate, and then you can go hang!”

“Well, well, Cap’n,” returned the sea-cook, sitting down as he was
bidden on the sand, “you’ll have to give me a hand up again, that’s all.
A sweet pretty place you have of it here. Ah, there’s Jim! The top of
the morning to you, Jim. Doctor, here’s my service. Why, there you all
are together like a happy family, in a manner of speaking.”

“If you have anything to say, my man, better say it,” said the captain.

“Right you were, Cap’n Smollett,” replied Silver. “Dooty is dooty, to be
sure. Well now, you look here, that was a good lay of yours last
night. I don’t deny it was a good lay. Some of you pretty handy with a
handspike-end. And I’ll not deny neither but what some of my people was
shook--maybe all was shook; maybe I was shook myself; maybe that’s
why I’m here for terms. But you mark me, Cap’n, it won’t do twice, by
thunder! We’ll have to do sentry-go and ease off a point or so on the
rum. Maybe you think we were all a sheet in the wind’s eye. But I’ll
tell you I was sober; I was on’y dog tired; and if I’d awoke a second
sooner, I’d ’a caught you at the act, I would. He wasn’t dead when I got
round to him, not he.”

“Well?” says Captain Smollett as cool as can be.

All that Silver said was a riddle to him, but you would never have
guessed it from his tone. As for me, I began to have an inkling. Ben
Gunn’s last words came back to my mind. I began to suppose that he had
paid the buccaneers a visit while they all lay drunk together round
their fire, and I reckoned up with glee that we had only fourteen
enemies to deal with.

“Well, here it is,” said Silver. “We want that treasure, and we’ll have
it--that’s our point! You would just as soon save your lives, I reckon;
and that’s yours. You have a chart, haven’t you?”

“That’s as may be,” replied the captain.

“Oh, well, you have, I know that,” returned Long John. “You needn’t be
so husky with a man; there ain’t a particle of service in that, and you
may lay to it. What I mean is, we want your chart. Now, I never meant
you no harm, myself.”

“That won’t do with me, my man,” interrupted the captain. “We know
exactly what you meant to do, and we don’t care, for now, you see, you
can’t do it.”

And the captain looked at him calmly and proceeded to fill a pipe.

“If Abe Gray--” Silver broke out.

“Avast there!” cried Mr. Smollett. “Gray told me nothing, and I asked
him nothing; and what’s more, I would see you and him and this whole
island blown clean out of the water into blazes first. So there’s my
mind for you, my man, on that.”

This little whiff of temper seemed to cool Silver down. He had been
growing nettled before, but now he pulled himself together.

“Like enough,” said he. “I would set no limits to what gentlemen might
consider shipshape, or might not, as the case were. And seein’ as how
you are about to take a pipe, Cap’n, I’ll make so free as do likewise.”

And he filled a pipe and lighted it; and the two men sat silently
smoking for quite a while, now looking each other in the face, now
stopping their tobacco, now leaning forward to spit. It was as good as
the play to see them.

“Now,” resumed Silver, “here it is. You give us the chart to get the
treasure by, and drop shooting poor seamen and stoving of their heads in
while asleep. You do that, and we’ll offer you a choice. Either you come
aboard along of us, once the treasure shipped, and then I’ll give you my
affy-davy, upon my word of honour, to clap you somewhere safe ashore. Or
if that ain’t to your fancy, some of my hands being rough and having
old scores on account of hazing, then you can stay here, you can. We’ll
divide stores with you, man for man; and I’ll give my affy-davy, as
before to speak the first ship I sight, and send ’em here to pick you
up. Now, you’ll own that’s talking. Handsomer you couldn’t look to get,
now you. And I hope”--raising his voice--“that all hands in this here
block house will overhaul my words, for what is spoke to one is spoke to
all.”

Captain Smollett rose from his seat and knocked out the ashes of his
pipe in the palm of his left hand.

“Is that all?” he asked.

“Every last word, by thunder!” answered John. “Refuse that, and you’ve
seen the last of me but musket-balls.”

“Very good,” said the captain. “Now you’ll hear me. If you’ll come up
one by one, unarmed, I’ll engage to clap you all in irons and take you
home to a fair trial in England. If you won’t, my name is Alexander
Smollett, I’ve flown my sovereign’s colours, and I’ll see you all
to Davy Jones. You can’t find the treasure. You can’t sail the
ship--there’s not a man among you fit to sail the ship. You can’t fight
us--Gray, there, got away from five of you. Your ship’s in irons, Master
Silver; you’re on a lee shore, and so you’ll find. I stand here and tell
you so; and they’re the last good words you’ll get from me, for in the
name of heaven, I’ll put a bullet in your back when next I meet you.
Tramp, my lad. Bundle out of this, please, hand over hand, and double
quick.”

Silver’s face was a picture; his eyes started in his head with wrath. He
shook the fire out of his pipe.

“Give me a hand up!” he cried.

“Not I,” returned the captain.

“Who’ll give me a hand up?” he roared.

Not a man among us moved. Growling the foulest imprecations, he crawled
along the sand till he got hold of the porch and could hoist himself
again upon his crutch. Then he spat into the spring.

“There!” he cried. “That’s what I think of ye. Before an hour’s out,
I’ll stove in your old block house like a rum puncheon. Laugh, by
thunder, laugh! Before an hour’s out, ye’ll laugh upon the other side.
Them that die’ll be the lucky ones.”

And with a dreadful oath he stumbled off, ploughed down the sand, was
helped across the stockade, after four or five failures, by the man with
the flag of truce, and disappeared in an instant afterwards among the
trees.

Master this chapter. Complete your experience

Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature

Read Free on GutenbergBuy at Powell'sBuy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.

Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats

GO ADS FREE — JOIN US

Let's Analyse the Pattern

Pattern: False Authority Collapse
This chapter reveals a crucial pattern: when someone's authority comes from manipulation rather than merit, they'll eventually face someone who won't be fooled. Silver arrives dressed up, speaking formally, calling himself 'Captain'—but underneath the performance, he's still a mutineer trying to steal what isn't his. The pattern shows how false authority crumbles when it meets genuine leadership. The mechanism works like this: manipulative people rely on others playing along with their performance. They need you to accept their version of reality. Silver needs Smollett to treat him as an equal, to negotiate as if his demands have legitimacy. But Smollett refuses to participate in the charade. He sees past the costume and formal language to the core truth: Silver is a thief and a traitor. When someone won't validate false authority, the manipulator has no power. This exact pattern plays out constantly in modern workplaces. The coworker who takes credit for your ideas, then acts wounded when you call them out. The supervisor who uses friendship language ('we're all family here') while exploiting workers, then gets defensive when boundaries are set. In healthcare, it's the doctor who talks down to nurses, expecting deference based on title rather than earning respect through competence. In families, it's the relative who uses guilt and manipulation to control others, then throws tantrums when someone finally says no. When you recognize this pattern, your navigation strategy is simple but powerful: refuse to validate false authority. Don't argue with their logic or try to prove they're wrong—that gives them the debate they want. Instead, like Smollett, state your position clearly and hold your ground. 'I don't negotiate with people who steal from their coworkers.' 'I won't pretend this behavior is acceptable.' The manipulator will escalate (Silver spits in their water), but that's just proof you've identified them correctly. When you can name the pattern of false authority, predict how it crumbles under moral clarity, and navigate it by refusing to participate in the performance—that's amplified intelligence working for you.

When manipulative people encounter someone who won't validate their performance of authority, their power evaporates and they resort to petty retaliation.

Why This Matters

Connect literature to life

Skill: Detecting False Authority

This chapter teaches how to distinguish between legitimate leadership and manipulative performance disguised as authority.

Practice This Today

This week, notice when someone uses titles, formal language, or dress to demand respect they haven't earned through their actions.

GO ADS FREE — JOIN US

Now let's explore the literary elements.

Key Quotes & Analysis

"Ten to one this is a trick."

— Captain Smollett

Context: When Silver arrives under a flag of truce, Smollett immediately suspects deception

This shows Smollett's wisdom and experience. He doesn't let the formal rules of warfare blind him to the reality that he's dealing with untrustworthy people. Good leaders stay alert even during 'peaceful' negotiations.

In Today's Words:

This is probably a setup.

"Cap'n Silver, sir, to come on board and make terms."

— Silver's lieutenant

Context: Silver has his subordinate announce him with a fancy title he's given himself

Silver is trying to project authority and legitimacy he doesn't actually have. By calling himself 'Captain' and having someone else announce him, he's putting on a show of respectability to strengthen his negotiating position.

In Today's Words:

The boss wants to meet and make a deal.

"I'll give you a piece of my mind. I've always done my duty by seamen, and I'll do it now."

— Captain Smollett

Context: Smollett's response to Silver's attempts at negotiation

Smollett refuses to be drawn into Silver's game. He makes it clear that his principles don't change based on circumstances - he'll do what's right whether it's convenient or not.

In Today's Words:

Let me tell you exactly what I think. I've always done right by my people, and I'm not stopping now.

Thematic Threads

Authority

In This Chapter

Silver performs authority through costume and titles while Smollett embodies it through moral clarity

Development

Contrasts with earlier chapters where Silver's charisma seemed genuinely powerful

In Your Life:

You might recognize this when someone demands respect they haven't earned through their actions.

Deception

In This Chapter

Silver's reasonable tone and formal dress attempt to mask his criminal intentions

Development

Shows how Silver's earlier charm was always manipulation, now fully exposed

In Your Life:

You might see this when someone uses polite language to make unreasonable demands seem normal.

Class

In This Chapter

Silver tries to claim gentleman status through appearance while Smollett shows true nobility through principles

Development

Deepens the theme that real class comes from character, not performance

In Your Life:

You might notice this when people use expensive clothes or fancy words to hide their lack of integrity.

Negotiation

In This Chapter

Smollett refuses to negotiate with criminals, understanding that some things aren't up for debate

Development

Introduced here as a crucial leadership skill

In Your Life:

You might apply this when someone tries to bargain over basic respect or ethical behavior.

Consequences

In This Chapter

Silver's humiliating retreat and petty water-spitting show how manipulation backfires

Development

Builds on earlier hints that Silver's choices would eventually catch up with him

In Your Life:

You might see this when someone's manipulative behavior finally stops working and they lash out.

GO ADS FREE — JOIN US

You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.

Discussion Questions

  1. 1

    What tactics does Silver use to try to appear legitimate and authoritative when he arrives at the stockade?

    analysis • surface
  2. 2

    Why does Captain Smollett refuse to negotiate with Silver, even though Silver's offer might seem reasonable?

    analysis • medium
  3. 3

    Where have you seen someone dress up their demands in fancy language or formal presentation to make wrongdoing seem acceptable?

    application • medium
  4. 4

    How do you respond when someone expects you to treat their bad behavior as if it's legitimate just because they present it politely?

    application • deep
  5. 5

    What does this confrontation reveal about the difference between real authority and performed authority?

    reflection • deep

Critical Thinking Exercise

10 minutes

Spot the Performance vs. the Person

Think of someone in your life who uses impressive presentation to mask questionable behavior - maybe they dress professionally while cutting corners, speak formally while being dishonest, or use titles and credentials to avoid accountability. Write down what their 'performance' looks like versus what their actual actions reveal about their character.

Consider:

  • •Notice the gap between how they present themselves and how they actually behave
  • •Consider whether their authority comes from their position or from earning respect through actions
  • •Think about how they react when someone doesn't play along with their performance

Journaling Prompt

Write about a time when you had to choose between going along with someone's false authority to keep the peace, or standing your ground like Captain Smollett. What did you learn from that situation?

GO ADS FREE — JOIN US

Coming Up Next...

Chapter 21: The Pirates Strike Back

Silver's threats weren't empty bluster. The failed negotiation has sealed everyone's fate, and the pirates prepare to make good on their promise of violence.

Continue to Chapter 21
Previous
Finding Sanctuary in the Stockade
Contents
Next
The Pirates Strike Back

Continue Exploring

Treasure Island Study GuideTeaching ResourcesEssential Life IndexBrowse by ThemeAll Books

You Might Also Like

The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde cover

The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde

Robert Louis Stevenson

Also by Robert Louis Stevenson

Jane Eyre cover

Jane Eyre

Charlotte Brontë

Explores personal growth

Great Expectations cover

Great Expectations

Charles Dickens

Explores personal growth

Don Quixote cover

Don Quixote

Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra

Explores personal growth

Browse all 47+ books

Share This Chapter

Know someone who'd enjoy this? Spread the wisdom!

TwitterFacebookLinkedInEmail

Read ad-free with Prestige

Get rid of ads, unlock study guides and downloads, and support free access for everyone.

Subscribe to PrestigeCreate free account
Intelligence Amplifier
Intelligence Amplifier™Powering Amplified Classics

Exploring human-AI collaboration through books, essays, and philosophical dialogues. Classic literature transformed into navigational maps for modern life.

2025 Books

→ The Amplified Human Spirit→ The Alarming Rise of Stupidity Amplified→ San Francisco: The AI Capital of the World
Visit intelligenceamplifier.org
hello@amplifiedclassics.com

AC Originals

→ The Last Chapter First→ You Are Not Lost→ The Lit of Love→ The Wealth Paradox
Arvintech
arvintechAmplify your Mind
Visit at arvintech.com

Navigate

  • Home
  • Library
  • Essential Life Index
  • How It Works
  • Subscribe
  • Account
  • About
  • Contact
  • Authors
  • Suggest a Book
  • Landings

Made For You

  • Students
  • Educators
  • Families
  • Readers
  • Literary Analysis
  • Finding Purpose
  • Letting Go
  • Recovering from a Breakup
  • Corruption
  • Gaslighting in the Classics

Newsletter

Weekly insights from the classics. Amplify Your Mind.

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility

Why Public Domain?

We focus on public domain classics because these timeless works belong to everyone. No paywalls, no restrictions—just wisdom that has stood the test of centuries, freely accessible to all readers.

Public domain books have shaped humanity's understanding of love, justice, ambition, and the human condition. By amplifying these works, we help preserve and share literature that truly belongs to the world.

© 2025 Amplified Classics™. All Rights Reserved.

Intelligence Amplifier™ and Amplified Classics™ are proprietary trademarks of Arvin Lioanag.

Copyright Protection: All original content, analyses, discussion questions, pedagogical frameworks, and methodology are protected by U.S. and international copyright law. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, web scraping, or use for AI training is strictly prohibited. See our Copyright Notice for details.

Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute professional, legal, financial, or technical advice. While we strive to ensure accuracy and relevance, we make no warranties regarding completeness, reliability, or suitability. Any reliance on such information is at your own risk. We are not liable for any losses or damages arising from use of this site. By using this site, you agree to these terms.