Summary
Jim's quiet morning at the inn explodes into chaos when a mysterious stranger called Black Dog arrives looking for Captain Billy Bones. The visitor starts friendly enough, even claiming to have a son just like Jim, but his behavior quickly turns menacing. He forces Jim to help him ambush the captain, revealing the manipulative tactics people use when they want something from you. When Billy Bones returns, his reaction to seeing Black Dog tells us everything - this isn't a happy reunion between old friends. The captain's face goes white with terror, showing us that some people carry secrets so heavy they literally make them sick. The confrontation escalates into a violent sword fight that ends with Black Dog fleeing, wounded, and Billy Bones collapsing from what Dr. Livesey diagnoses as a stroke brought on by stress and drinking. The doctor's examination reveals Billy Bones' tattooed arms, including a prophetic image of a gallows, hinting at his dark past. This chapter shows us how unresolved conflicts from our past can literally kill us if we don't face them properly. It also demonstrates the power of having someone like Dr. Livesey in your corner - someone who sees through the drama to the real problem and takes practical action. Jim witnesses firsthand how quickly a normal day can turn dangerous when you're connected to people with complicated histories.
Coming Up in Chapter 3
Billy Bones has survived his stroke, but his terror of Black Dog suggests worse things are coming. The mysterious 'black spot' mentioned in the next chapter title hints at pirate justice catching up with the captain.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Black Dog Appears and Disappears It was not very long after this that there occurred the first of the mysterious events that rid us at last of the captain, though not, as you will see, of his affairs. It was a bitter cold winter, with long, hard frosts and heavy gales; and it was plain from the first that my poor father was little likely to see the spring. He sank daily, and my mother and I had all the inn upon our hands, and were kept busy enough without paying much regard to our unpleasant guest. It was one January morning, very early--a pinching, frosty morning--the cove all grey with hoar-frost, the ripple lapping softly on the stones, the sun still low and only touching the hilltops and shining far to seaward. The captain had risen earlier than usual and set out down the beach, his cutlass swinging under the broad skirts of the old blue coat, his brass telescope under his arm, his hat tilted back upon his head. I remember his breath hanging like smoke in his wake as he strode off, and the last sound I heard of him as he turned the big rock was a loud snort of indignation, as though his mind was still running upon Dr. Livesey. Well, mother was upstairs with father and I was laying the breakfast-table against the captain’s return when the parlour door opened and a man stepped in on whom I had never set my eyes before. He was a pale, tallowy creature, wanting two fingers of the left hand, and though he wore a cutlass, he did not look much like a fighter. I had always my eye open for seafaring men, with one leg or two, and I remember this one puzzled me. He was not sailorly, and yet he had a smack of the sea about him too. I asked him what was for his service, and he said he would take rum; but as I was going out of the room to fetch it, he sat down upon a table and motioned me to draw near. I paused where I was, with my napkin in my hand. “Come here, sonny,” says he. “Come nearer here.” I took a step nearer. “Is this here table for my mate Bill?” he asked with a kind of leer. I told him I did not know his mate Bill, and this was for a person who stayed in our house whom we called the captain. “Well,” said he, “my mate Bill would be called the captain, as like as not. He has a cut on one cheek and a mighty pleasant way with him, particularly in drink, has my mate Bill. We’ll put it, for argument like, that your captain has a cut on one cheek--and we’ll put it, if you like, that that cheek’s the right one. Ah, well! I told you. Now, is my mate Bill in this here house?” I told him he was...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Recognition Trap - When Your Past Shows Up Uninvited
When unresolved conflicts from your past create such stress that encountering reminders literally makes you sick.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how extreme physical reactions often reveal hidden conflicts and dangerous histories.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone has an outsized physical reaction to a person or situation—shaking hands, going pale, sudden illness—and ask yourself what story might be hiding underneath.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Cutlass
A short, curved sword used by sailors and pirates in the 18th-19th centuries. It was designed for close combat on ships where space was limited.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this pattern in any specialized tool that shows someone's profession or past - like how construction workers carry specific tools or how someone's tattoos might hint at their background.
Parlour
The main social room in an inn or house where guests would gather to eat, drink, and conduct business. This was the public face of any establishment.
Modern Usage:
Like the lobby of a hotel or the main dining area of a restaurant - the space where first impressions are made and deals are struck.
Hoar-frost
White frost that forms on surfaces during very cold mornings. Stevenson uses this detail to show how harsh the winter is and set a foreboding mood.
Modern Usage:
Writers still use weather details to signal mood - like how a story might start with rain when something bad is about to happen.
Apoplexy
An old medical term for what we now call a stroke - when blood flow to the brain is interrupted. In Stevenson's time, it was often blamed on strong emotions or drinking.
Modern Usage:
We still say someone is 'apoplectic with rage' when they're so angry it might affect their health.
Ambush tactics
Black Dog's strategy of using Jim to surprise Billy Bones shows classic manipulation - using an innocent person as bait or cover for confrontation.
Modern Usage:
This happens all the time when someone uses a mutual friend to approach someone who's avoiding them, or when debt collectors use family members to pressure someone.
Gallows tattoo
A tattoo showing a hangman's noose, which would mark someone as having been involved in piracy or other capital crimes. It's like wearing your criminal past on your skin.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how certain tattoos today immediately signal someone's background - gang affiliations, military service, or time in prison.
Characters in This Chapter
Black Dog
Antagonist/threat from the past
A manipulative stranger who uses Jim to ambush Billy Bones. He starts friendly but quickly reveals his true menacing nature when he doesn't get what he wants.
Modern Equivalent:
The ex who shows up at your workplace acting nice until they realize you won't talk to them
Billy Bones
Haunted man with dangerous secrets
His terror at seeing Black Dog reveals he's been running from his past. The confrontation literally makes him sick, showing how unresolved conflicts can destroy your health.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who's always looking over their shoulder, clearly hiding something that's eating them alive
Jim Hawkins
Innocent bystander/narrator
Gets manipulated by Black Dog into helping with the ambush, then witnesses the violent confrontation. He's learning how dangerous it is to be around people with complicated pasts.
Modern Equivalent:
The kid who gets caught in the middle when their parent's ex shows up causing drama
Dr. Livesey
Voice of reason/medical authority
Arrives after the chaos to diagnose Billy Bones' stroke and give practical medical advice. He sees through the drama to the real health crisis.
Modern Equivalent:
The EMT or nurse who cuts through family drama to focus on the actual medical emergency
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Come now, march up here and let me see him face to face."
Context: Black Dog is forcing Jim to help him surprise Billy Bones
This shows classic manipulation tactics - using an innocent person as cover while making demands. Black Dog knows Billy Bones might run if he sees him coming, so he uses Jim as bait.
In Today's Words:
Help me corner this guy so he can't avoid me.
"Bill, you old dog! You old sea-dog!"
Context: His fake-friendly greeting when Billy Bones enters
The forced familiarity masks real menace. This is how manipulative people operate - they act like everything's fine while setting up their real agenda.
In Today's Words:
Hey buddy, long time no see! (while planning something you won't like)
"I have only one thing to say to you, sir, and that is this: name of rum for you is death."
Context: His diagnosis after Billy Bones' stroke
Dr. Livesey cuts straight to the medical truth without sugarcoating it. He's the voice of practical reality in a situation full of drama and secrets.
In Today's Words:
Keep drinking like this and you'll die. It's that simple.
Thematic Threads
Secrets
In This Chapter
Billy Bones' terror at seeing Black Dog reveals he's been hiding something dangerous from his past
Development
Builds on the mysterious chest from Chapter 1—now we see the cost of carrying secrets
In Your Life:
Notice how keeping secrets affects your health and relationships over time
Class
In This Chapter
Dr. Livesey's educated authority contrasts sharply with the rough sailor's world of violence
Development
Continues from Chapter 1, showing how different social classes handle conflict
In Your Life:
Recognize how your background affects how you're perceived in crisis situations
Manipulation
In This Chapter
Black Dog uses friendly conversation and false concern to trap Jim into helping him ambush Billy Bones
Development
Introduced here as a new threat pattern
In Your Life:
Watch for people who start conversations with excessive friendliness when they want something
Physical Consequences
In This Chapter
Billy Bones' stroke shows how emotional stress manifests as real physical illness
Development
New theme showing the body-mind connection
In Your Life:
Pay attention to unexplained health issues during times of high stress or conflict
Support Systems
In This Chapter
Dr. Livesey provides calm, practical help when everyone else is panicking
Development
Introduced here as crucial life resource
In Your Life:
Identify who in your life can stay calm and practical during your emergencies
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What physical signs show us that Billy Bones is terrified when he sees Black Dog, and what does this tell us about their history?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Black Dog try to befriend Jim first before revealing what he really wants? What does this teach us about how manipulative people operate?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen someone have an extreme physical reaction to seeing a person from their past? What do you think they were trying to avoid?
application • medium - 4
Dr. Livesey immediately sees through the drama and focuses on Billy Bones' real health problem. Who in your life acts like Dr. Livesey when things get chaotic?
application • deep - 5
Billy Bones' body literally breaks down from carrying his secrets. What does this chapter suggest about the real cost of avoiding our problems?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Manipulation Playbook
Black Dog uses a classic manipulation sequence: befriend the vulnerable person (Jim), create false intimacy ('I have a son just like you'), then use them as a tool. Write down this three-step pattern, then identify two real-life situations where you've seen someone use similar tactics. What were the warning signs you could have spotted earlier?
Consider:
- •Notice how manipulators often start by finding common ground or complimenting you
- •Pay attention to when someone asks you to help them surprise or confront someone else
- •Trust your gut when someone's friendliness feels forced or too immediate
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone tried to use you to get to someone else, or when you felt pressured to help with something that didn't feel right. What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 3: When Desperation Makes Dangerous Deals
What lies ahead teaches us addiction and desperation make people vulnerable to manipulation, and shows us fear can override our better judgment in crisis moments. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.