Summary
The loyalists make their desperate dash to the stockade as the mutineers close in, and the first real battle erupts. Dr. Livesey shows how quickly people adapt in crisis—weapons get redistributed based on skill, not rank, and everyone finds their role. The fight goes well at first: they drop one enemy and reach safety. But victory turns bitter when Tom Redruth, the quiet gamekeeper, takes a fatal shot. His death scene reveals something profound about loyalty and class. This working man, who never complained or questioned orders, dies asking forgiveness from his social superior—showing how deeply ingrained hierarchy runs, even at death's door. Captain Smollett responds by raising the British flag, a powerful symbolic act. When the enemy starts firing cannons at it, the squire suggests taking it down for safety. Smollett refuses, and everyone immediately understands why: the flag isn't about patriotism, it's about defiance. It tells the mutineers they're not broken. The chapter ends with a supply crisis—they're running low on food and the enemy is stealing their stores. Just when things look darkest, Jim Hawkins reappears, climbing over the stockade wall. His return offers hope, but also raises questions about where he's been and what he's learned. The chapter shows how leadership works under pressure: through symbols, through honoring the dead, and through refusing to show weakness even when you're outgunned.
Coming Up in Chapter 19
Jim's back, but where has he been while his friends fought for their lives? His story promises to reveal new dangers and perhaps new opportunities in their desperate situation.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Narrative Continued by the Doctor: End of the First Day’s Fighting We made our best speed across the strip of wood that now divided us from the stockade, and at every step we took the voices of the buccaneers rang nearer. Soon we could hear their footfalls as they ran and the cracking of the branches as they breasted across a bit of thicket. I began to see we should have a brush for it in earnest and looked to my priming. “Captain,” said I, “Trelawney is the dead shot. Give him your gun; his own is useless.” They exchanged guns, and Trelawney, silent and cool as he had been since the beginning of the bustle, hung a moment on his heel to see that all was fit for service. At the same time, observing Gray to be unarmed, I handed him my cutlass. It did all our hearts good to see him spit in his hand, knit his brows, and make the blade sing through the air. It was plain from every line of his body that our new hand was worth his salt. Forty paces farther we came to the edge of the wood and saw the stockade in front of us. We struck the enclosure about the middle of the south side, and almost at the same time, seven mutineers--Job Anderson, the boatswain, at their head--appeared in full cry at the southwestern corner. They paused as if taken aback, and before they recovered, not only the squire and I, but Hunter and Joyce from the block house, had time to fire. The four shots came in rather a scattering volley, but they did the business: one of the enemy actually fell, and the rest, without hesitation, turned and plunged into the trees. After reloading, we walked down the outside of the palisade to see to the fallen enemy. He was stone dead--shot through the heart. We began to rejoice over our good success when just at that moment a pistol cracked in the bush, a ball whistled close past my ear, and poor Tom Redruth stumbled and fell his length on the ground. Both the squire and I returned the shot, but as we had nothing to aim at, it is probable we only wasted powder. Then we reloaded and turned our attention to poor Tom. The captain and Gray were already examining him, and I saw with half an eye that all was over. I believe the readiness of our return volley had scattered the mutineers once more, for we were suffered without further molestation to get the poor old gamekeeper hoisted over the stockade and carried, groaning and bleeding, into the log-house. Poor old fellow, he had not uttered one word of surprise, complaint, fear, or even acquiescence from the very beginning of our troubles till now, when we had laid him down in the log-house to die. He had lain like a Trojan behind his mattress in the gallery; he had followed every order...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Crisis Leadership - When Everything Falls Apart, Symbols Matter Most
In crisis, controlling symbols of meaning and identity becomes more important than controlling resources.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how leaders use symbols to maintain morale and group identity when material resources fail.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone keeps up appearances during tough times—the teacher who decorates their classroom despite budget cuts, the coach who insists on team traditions despite losing seasons—and recognize the strategic purpose behind these gestures.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Stockade
A defensive barrier made of wooden posts driven into the ground, creating a fort-like enclosure. In this chapter, it's the loyalists' safe haven - their last stand against the mutineers. The stockade represents the thin line between order and chaos.
Modern Usage:
We still talk about 'circling the wagons' or creating safe spaces when under attack - whether it's a gated community, a support group, or even just blocking toxic people on social media.
Mutineers
Sailors who rebel against their captain and officers, refusing to follow orders and taking control by force. These aren't just troublemakers - they're people who've decided the existing power structure doesn't serve them. They're willing to risk everything to change their situation.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this in workplace uprisings, union strikes, or even when employees mass-quit bad jobs - people collectively deciding they won't accept unfair treatment anymore.
Dead shot
Someone with exceptional accuracy with firearms, able to hit targets with deadly precision. In crisis situations, skills matter more than rank - the doctor recognizes Trelawney's superior marksmanship and adjusts the plan accordingly.
Modern Usage:
We use this for anyone with exceptional skill - 'She's a dead shot at closing deals' or 'He's a dead shot at diagnosing problems' - meaning they rarely miss their target.
Priming
Preparing a flintlock gun to fire by putting gunpowder in the pan. This was a crucial step that could mean life or death in battle. The doctor checking his priming shows he's preparing for the worst while hoping for the best.
Modern Usage:
We still 'prime' ourselves for important moments - prepping for job interviews, getting ready for difficult conversations, or loading up on coffee before a long shift.
Worth his salt
Proving your value and competence, especially under pressure. The phrase comes from when Roman soldiers were paid partly in salt. Gray shows he's reliable and skilled when it matters most.
Modern Usage:
We still say someone is 'worth their salt' when they prove they can handle responsibility and deliver results when the pressure is on.
Colors/Flag
The national flag flown as a symbol of identity and defiance. Captain Smollett raises the British flag not from patriotism, but as psychological warfare - showing the enemy they haven't surrendered and won't be intimidated.
Modern Usage:
Today this shows up as profile pictures during causes, wearing team colors during rivalry, or any symbol that says 'we're still here and we're not backing down.'
Characters in This Chapter
Dr. Livesey
Narrator and strategist
Takes over the storytelling and shows practical leadership by redistributing weapons based on skill, not social rank. He makes quick tactical decisions and recognizes people's strengths under pressure. His medical training makes him calm in crisis.
Modern Equivalent:
The ER doctor who stays cool during emergencies and knows how to organize people when everything's falling apart
Captain Smollett
Military leader
Demonstrates symbolic leadership by raising the British flag and refusing to take it down despite cannon fire. He understands that showing strength matters as much as actual strength. His response to Tom's death shows he values his men.
Modern Equivalent:
The supervisor who won't let the team look weak in front of corporate, even when things are going badly
Squire Trelawney
Skilled marksman
Proves his worth as 'the dead shot' and handles weapon exchange professionally. Despite his earlier bumbling, he stays cool and competent in actual combat. Shows that people can surprise you when tested.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who seems scattered in meetings but becomes laser-focused when there's a real crisis to handle
Tom Redruth
Loyal servant
The gamekeeper who dies in the battle, asking forgiveness from his social superior even as he's dying. His death scene reveals how deeply class hierarchy is ingrained - he's more worried about disappointing his 'betters' than his own life.
Modern Equivalent:
The long-term employee who always puts the company first, even when it doesn't serve their own interests
Gray
Converted ally
Former mutineer who proves his loyalty by fighting skillfully for the loyalists. When given a cutlass, he shows he's 'worth his salt' - demonstrating that people can change sides and prove themselves through actions.
Modern Equivalent:
The reformed troublemaker who becomes your most reliable team member once they're on your side
Key Quotes & Analysis
"It did all our hearts good to see him spit in his hand, knit his brows, and make the blade sing through the air."
Context: Describing Gray's reaction when handed a cutlass for the coming fight
This shows how people reveal their true character under pressure. Gray's physical preparation - spitting in his hand for grip, focusing his expression, testing his weapon - demonstrates he's committed and competent. The doctor recognizes that actions speak louder than words.
In Today's Words:
We could all see he was ready to get down to business and knew what he was doing.
"Forgive me, sir, but I think I'm done for."
Context: Tom's dying words to Squire Trelawney after being shot
This reveals the tragic depth of class conditioning - even while dying, Tom apologizes to his social superior for the inconvenience of his death. It shows how working-class loyalty often goes unrecognized and unrewarded, yet remains absolute.
In Today's Words:
Sorry boss, but I think this is it for me.
"Strike my colors! No, sir, not I!"
Context: Refusing the squire's suggestion to lower the flag when pirates start firing cannons at it
This shows understanding of psychological warfare. The flag isn't about patriotism - it's about refusing to show weakness. Smollett knows that symbols matter in maintaining morale and intimidating enemies. Taking down the flag would signal defeat.
In Today's Words:
Take down our flag? Hell no! We're not showing any sign of giving up.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Tom Redruth dies asking forgiveness from his social superior, showing how deeply hierarchy is internalized even at death
Development
Deepened from earlier hints - now we see how class loyalty persists even when the system is literally under attack
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself apologizing to authority figures even when they've failed you or put you at risk
Leadership
In This Chapter
Smollett leads through symbols (the flag) and meaning-making rather than just tactical commands
Development
Evolved from his earlier rule-following to adaptive crisis management that understands psychology
In Your Life:
You might need to be the person who maintains hope and standards when everyone around you is panicking
Identity
In This Chapter
The flag becomes a symbol of who they are versus who the mutineers are - legitimate versus illegitimate
Development
Building on Jim's earlier identity struggles - now the group's collective identity is at stake
In Your Life:
You might find that what you display or maintain during tough times defines how others see you and how you see yourself
Loyalty
In This Chapter
Tom's deathbed loyalty to his social superiors despite their failures shows both nobility and tragedy of working-class devotion
Development
Intensified from earlier character loyalty - now we see its ultimate cost and complexity
In Your Life:
You might struggle with staying loyal to people or institutions that don't fully value or protect you
Adaptation
In This Chapter
Dr. Livesey quickly redistributes weapons based on skill rather than social rank when survival is at stake
Development
New development showing how crisis forces practical over social considerations
In Your Life:
You might find that emergencies reveal who actually has useful skills versus who just has titles or status
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Captain Smollett refuse to take down the British flag even when the pirates are shooting cannons at it?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Tom Redruth's death scene reveal about how people behave when they're dying - why does he ask forgiveness from the squire instead of expressing anger or fear?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about workplaces, families, or communities you know - where have you seen someone use symbols or rituals to keep people's spirits up during tough times?
application • medium - 4
If you were facing a crisis where people were losing hope, what would be your 'flag' - what symbol or action would you use to remind everyone you're still fighting?
application • deep - 5
Why do humans need symbols and rituals when facing uncertainty, and how can recognizing this help you navigate difficult situations in your own life?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Design Your Crisis Symbol
Think of a challenging situation you're currently facing or might face in the future - job stress, family conflict, financial pressure, health concerns. Design a simple, concrete symbol or ritual that would remind you and others that you're still in control and still fighting. It should be something you can actually do or display, not just think about.
Consider:
- •Your symbol should be something you can control completely, regardless of what others do
- •It should be visible or noticeable to the people who matter in your situation
- •It should genuinely represent your values or identity, not just look impressive to others
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's refusal to give up - shown through their actions, not just words - helped you keep going during a difficult period. What did they do that made the difference?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 19: Finding Sanctuary in the Stockade
Moving forward, we'll examine to recognize when someone has valuable information but needs to feel in control of sharing it, and understand good leaders keep people busy during crisis to prevent despair from taking hold. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.