Summary
Marguerite endures the most excruciating kind of waiting—not knowing if her betrayal has succeeded or failed. While she sits in the conservatory, her mind races between hope and terror. Has the Scarlet Pimpernel been caught, or has he escaped Chauvelin's trap? Either outcome brings devastating consequences: if he's caught, she's responsible for a hero's death; if he's escaped, her brother Armand will pay the price. When Chauvelin finally appears, he's maddeningly cryptic, refusing to give her straight answers about what happened in the dining-room. He confirms that no one came to the meeting—the trap appears to have failed—but speaks only in riddles about Armand's fate hanging 'on a thread.' His cruel ambiguity is deliberate torture, keeping Marguerite in agonizing suspense. She realizes she's completely at his mercy, having burned her bridges with both sides. The chapter captures the psychological torment of someone who has made an impossible choice and must now live with the consequences. Marguerite's desperation shows how love can drive us to betray our principles, and how the aftermath of such choices can be worse than the original dilemma. Her final plea to Chauvelin—'Give me some hope, my little Chauvelin'—reveals how completely powerless she has become.
Coming Up in Chapter 16
The coach ride home to Richmond brings no relief from Marguerite's torment. As she and Percy travel through the night, the weight of her secrets grows heavier, and she must face the man she has potentially betrayed—not knowing if he suspects anything about her role in the evening's events.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
DOUBT Marguerite Blakeney had watched the slight sable-clad figure of Chauvelin, as he worked his way through the ball-room. Then perforce she had had to wait, while her nerves tingled with excitement. Listlessly she sat in the small, still deserted boudoir, looking out through the curtained doorway on the dancing couples beyond: looking at them, yet seeing nothing, hearing the music, yet conscious of naught save a feeling of expectancy, of anxious, weary waiting. Her mind conjured up before her the vision of what was, perhaps at this very moment, passing downstairs. The half-deserted dining-room, the fateful hour—Chauvelin on the watch!—then, precise to the moment, the entrance of a man, he, the Scarlet Pimpernel, the mysterious leader, who to Marguerite had become almost unreal, so strange, so weird was this hidden identity. She wished she were in the supper-room, too, at this moment, watching him as he entered; she knew that her woman’s penetration would at once recognise in the stranger’s face—whoever he might be—that strong individuality which belongs to a leader of men—to a hero: to the mighty, high-soaring eagle, whose daring wings were becoming entangled in the ferret’s trap. Woman-like, she thought of him with unmixed sadness; the irony of that fate seemed so cruel which allowed the fearless lion to succumb to the gnawing of a rat! Ah! had Armand’s life not been at stake! . . . “Faith! your ladyship must have thought me very remiss,” said a voice suddenly, close to her elbow. “I had a deal of difficulty in delivering your message, for I could not find Blakeney anywhere at first . . .” Marguerite had forgotten all about her husband and her message to him; his very name, as spoken by Lord Fancourt, sounded strange and unfamiliar to her, so completely had she in the last five minutes lived her old life in the Rue de Richelieu again, with Armand always near her to love and protect her, to guard her from the many subtle intrigues which were forever raging in Paris in those days. “I did find him at last,” continued Lord Fancourt, “and gave him your message. He said that he would give orders at once for the horses to be put to.” “Ah!” she said, still very absently, “you found my husband, and gave him my message?” “Yes; he was in the dining-room fast asleep. I could not manage to wake him up at first.” “Thank you very much,” she said mechanically, trying to collect her thoughts. “Will your ladyship honour me with the _contredanse_ until your coach is ready?” asked Lord Fancourt. “No, I thank you, my lord, but—and you will forgive me—I really am too tired, and the heat in the ball-room has become oppressive.” “The conservatory is deliciously cool; let me take you there, and then get you something. You seem ailing, Lady Blakeney.” “I am only very tired,” she repeated wearily, as she allowed Lord Fancourt to lead her, where subdued lights and green plants lent...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Impossible Choices
When someone with power forces you to choose between two unacceptable options, often to serve their own agenda.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how withholding information is used as a deliberate torture technique to maintain control over someone who has already been compromised.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone keeps you waiting for important information that affects your life—and ask yourself who benefits from your uncertainty.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Boudoir
A woman's private sitting room or bedroom, typically elegant and intimate. In aristocratic homes, this was where ladies could retreat from public social spaces. It represents a sanctuary where one's true feelings could emerge.
Modern Usage:
Like having a private space in your home where you can finally drop the act and be yourself - your bedroom, a home office, or even your car during lunch break.
Woman's penetration
The belief that women possessed special intuitive abilities to read people and situations. This was considered both a strength and a limitation in this era. It suggests insight beyond surface appearances.
Modern Usage:
We still talk about women's intuition or having a good read on people - that ability to sense when something's off even when you can't prove it.
Psychological torture
Deliberately keeping someone in mental anguish through uncertainty and ambiguous information. More cruel than physical pain because it attacks the mind's need for resolution. The victim becomes their own torturer.
Modern Usage:
Like when someone gives you the silent treatment, sends mixed signals in a relationship, or keeps you waiting for important news without updates.
Burning bridges
Destroying relationships or options behind you so there's no way back to your former position. Once done, you're committed to your new path regardless of consequences. It's a point of no return.
Modern Usage:
Like quitting your job in anger, telling off your boss, or betraying a friend's trust - actions that make it impossible to go back to how things were.
Impossible choice
A dilemma where every option leads to devastating consequences, forcing you to choose between competing loyalties or values. No matter what you decide, someone you care about gets hurt.
Modern Usage:
Like choosing between caring for an aging parent or advancing your career, or having to pick sides when friends divorce.
At someone's mercy
Being completely powerless and dependent on another person's goodwill or whims. You have no leverage, no options, and must accept whatever they decide to do to you.
Modern Usage:
Like being dependent on your ex for child support, waiting for a boss to decide on your promotion, or relying on someone else's insurance after an accident.
Characters in This Chapter
Marguerite Blakeney
Tormented protagonist
She endures the agony of waiting to learn if her betrayal succeeded or failed. Her mental anguish reveals how impossible choices can trap us between competing loyalties. She's powerless and at Chauvelin's mercy.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who had to choose between family and principles, now living with the consequences and uncertainty
Chauvelin
Manipulative antagonist
He deliberately tortures Marguerite with ambiguous answers and cryptic responses about the trap's outcome. His refusal to give straight answers is calculated cruelty designed to maximize her psychological suffering.
Modern Equivalent:
The toxic person who withholds information to maintain power and keep you anxious
The Scarlet Pimpernel
Absent hero
Though not physically present, he dominates Marguerite's thoughts as she imagines him walking into Chauvelin's trap. She sees him as a noble eagle being ensnared by a rat, highlighting the tragedy of the situation.
Modern Equivalent:
The good person you had to betray to protect someone else - haunting your thoughts even when they're not around
Armand
Absent catalyst
Though not in the scene, his life hangs in the balance and drives all of Marguerite's anguish. Chauvelin uses his fate as leverage, keeping Marguerite trapped in uncertainty about his survival.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member whose safety forces you to make terrible compromises with people you despise
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Woman-like, she thought of him with unmixed sadness; the irony of that fate seemed so cruel which allowed the fearless lion to succumb to the gnawing of a rat!"
Context: Marguerite imagines the Scarlet Pimpernel walking into Chauvelin's trap
This reveals Marguerite's anguish over betraying someone she sees as noble and heroic. The animal metaphors emphasize the injustice - a magnificent lion destroyed by something small and contemptible. It shows her growing respect for the man she's betrayed.
In Today's Words:
She felt sick thinking about how someone so brave and good could be brought down by such a sneaky, worthless person.
"Ah! had Armand's life not been at stake!"
Context: As she tortures herself over the betrayal she's committed
This captures the heart of impossible choices - how love for one person can force us to betray our principles and hurt others. It's both an excuse and an expression of genuine anguish over what she's been forced to do.
In Today's Words:
If only my brother's life wasn't on the line, I never would have done this!
"Give me some hope, my little Chauvelin"
Context: Her final desperate plea to Chauvelin for information about Armand
The diminutive 'little Chauvelin' shows how desperate she's become - trying to appeal to whatever humanity he might have left. Her begging reveals how completely powerless she now is, reduced to pleading with her tormentor.
In Today's Words:
Please, just tell me there's a chance my brother might be okay.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Chauvelin wields psychological power through information control, keeping Marguerite in deliberate suspense
Development
Evolved from his earlier subtle manipulation to open psychological torture
In Your Life:
You see this when bosses give vague performance feedback to keep you anxious and compliant
Identity
In This Chapter
Marguerite's identity fragments as she becomes neither hero nor villain, but something in between
Development
Her earlier confident social identity has completely dissolved under moral pressure
In Your Life:
You experience this when forced to act against your values to protect someone you love
Class
In This Chapter
Her aristocratic background provides no protection against Chauvelin's middle-class cunning and revolutionary power
Development
The traditional class advantages continue to prove useless in this new political reality
In Your Life:
You see this when educational credentials mean nothing against someone with street smarts and connections
Betrayal
In This Chapter
The aftermath of betrayal proves worse than the act itself—living with uncertainty about the consequences
Development
Moved from contemplating betrayal to executing it to suffering its psychological aftermath
In Your Life:
You feel this when you break confidence to help someone and then agonize over whether you did the right thing
Isolation
In This Chapter
Marguerite realizes she's burned bridges with both sides and has no allies left
Development
Her earlier social connections have systematically dissolved throughout the story
In Your Life:
You experience this when taking a stand at work leaves you isolated from both management and coworkers
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Chauvelin refuse to give Marguerite straight answers about what happened in the dining room?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Chauvelin use uncertainty as a weapon against Marguerite?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of impossible choices in modern workplaces or family situations?
application • medium - 4
When someone puts you in a lose-lose situation, how can you tell if it's deliberate manipulation?
application • deep - 5
What does Marguerite's powerlessness reveal about how love can be weaponized against us?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Manipulation
Think of a time when someone kept you waiting for important information or gave you vague, unhelpful answers. Draw a simple diagram showing who had the power, what they gained by keeping you uncertain, and how the situation made you feel. Then identify what you could have done differently to protect yourself.
Consider:
- •Notice how uncertainty often serves the other person's interests, not yours
- •Consider whether the vagueness was accidental or strategic
- •Think about what information you needed and why they withheld it
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you were caught between two bad choices. How did you handle it? Looking back, was there a third option you didn't see at the time?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 16: A Marriage Unraveling at Dawn
As the story unfolds, you'll explore pride can destroy love even when both people still care deeply, while uncovering timing matters in relationships—sometimes we're ready to forgive when the other person isn't. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.