Summary
Philip finally confesses his love to Maggie during one of their secret meetings in the Red Deeps. What starts as playful banter about books and dark-haired heroines becomes intensely personal when Philip reveals he's been in love with her all along. Maggie is genuinely surprised—she never saw herself as someone who could have a lover, viewing romance as something that happened to other people in stories. Her reaction shows both her innocence and her deep-seated belief that she doesn't deserve happiness. Philip's confession is vulnerable and desperate; he describes himself as someone 'marked from childhood for suffering' who sees Maggie as his only source of joy. Maggie responds with genuine affection, admitting she could 'hardly love anyone better,' but immediately pulls back, worried about the practical impossibilities. She knows their families' feud makes any relationship dangerous, and she's haunted by guilt over their secret friendship. The chapter captures that moment when a relationship shifts from friendship to something deeper—both thrilling and terrifying. Maggie kisses Philip, remembering a childhood promise, but insists they can never be more than secret 'brother and sister.' Philip refuses to give up hope, and Maggie admits she's never been happier than when with him. The scene ends with both clinging to a fragile hope while knowing the obstacles ahead are enormous. This moment marks a turning point where Maggie can no longer pretend their relationship is innocent—she must now navigate the dangerous territory between her heart and her duty.
Coming Up in Chapter 37
The title 'The Cloven Tree' suggests something split or broken lies ahead. Maggie's moment of happiness may be short-lived as the consequences of this confession begin to unfold, and the symbolic split tree Philip warned her not to look at may prove prophetic.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Another Love-Scene Early in the following April, nearly a year after that dubious parting you have just witnessed, you may, if you like, again see Maggie entering the Red Deeps through the group of Scotch firs. But it is early afternoon and not evening, and the edge of sharpness in the spring air makes her draw her large shawl close about her and trip along rather quickly; though she looks round, as usual, that she may take in the sight of her beloved trees. There is a more eager, inquiring look in her eyes than there was last June, and a smile is hovering about her lips, as if some playful speech were awaiting the right hearer. The hearer was not long in appearing. “Take back your _Corinne_,” said Maggie, drawing a book from under her shawl. “You were right in telling me she would do me no good; but you were wrong in thinking I should wish to be like her.” “Wouldn’t you really like to be a tenth Muse, then, Maggie?” said Philip looking up in her face as we look at a first parting in the clouds that promises us a bright heaven once more. “Not at all,” said Maggie, laughing. “The Muses were uncomfortable goddesses, I think,—obliged always to carry rolls and musical instruments about with them. If I carried a harp in this climate, you know, I must have a green baize cover for it; and I should be sure to leave it behind me by mistake.” “You agree with me in not liking Corinne, then?” “I didn’t finish the book,” said Maggie. “As soon as I came to the blond-haired young lady reading in the park, I shut it up, and determined to read no further. I foresaw that that light-complexioned girl would win away all the love from Corinne and make her miserable. I’m determined to read no more books where the blond-haired women carry away all the happiness. I should begin to have a prejudice against them. If you could give me some story, now, where the dark woman triumphs, it would restore the balance. I want to avenge Rebecca and Flora MacIvor and Minna, and all the rest of the dark unhappy ones. Since you are my tutor, you ought to preserve my mind from prejudices; you are always arguing against prejudices.” “Well, perhaps you will avenge the dark women in your own person, and carry away all the love from your cousin Lucy. She is sure to have some handsome young man of St Ogg’s at her feet now; and you have only to shine upon him—your fair little cousin will be quite quenched in your beams.” “Philip, that is not pretty of you, to apply my nonsense to anything real,” said Maggie, looking hurt. “As if I, with my old gowns and want of all accomplishments, could be a rival of dear little Lucy,—who knows and does all sorts of charming things, and is ten times prettier than I...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Dangerous Recognition - When Someone Sees Your Hidden Worth
When someone sees worth in us that contradicts our self-limiting beliefs, creating both opportunity and identity crisis.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify moments when someone's recognition of your value challenges your limiting beliefs about yourself.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone compliments a strength you don't think you have—pause before dismissing it and ask yourself what if they're seeing something real.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Secret courtship
When two people develop romantic feelings but must hide their relationship due to family disapproval, social class differences, or other barriers. In Victorian times, this was especially dangerous for women, who could be ruined socially if discovered.
Modern Usage:
We see this in workplace romances that violate company policy, or relationships parents disapprove of due to religion, race, or economic differences.
Family feud
Long-standing hatred between families, often over money, property, or old grievances. These feuds could last generations and make any friendship between the families scandalous or dangerous.
Modern Usage:
Think bitter divorces where kids can't see certain relatives, or business partnerships that ended badly and split extended families.
Romantic awakening
The moment when someone realizes they're capable of romantic love, often surprising themselves. For sheltered people like Maggie, this can feel overwhelming and confusing.
Modern Usage:
That moment when you realize your 'friend' feelings have turned into something deeper, or when someone who never thought about dating suddenly catches feelings.
Self-sacrifice
Giving up your own happiness for what you believe is right or to protect others. Victorian women were especially expected to sacrifice their desires for family duty.
Modern Usage:
Staying in a job you hate to support family, or ending a relationship because it would hurt too many other people.
Social impossibility
When a relationship or situation seems doomed because of external circumstances like class, family expectations, or social rules rather than personal compatibility.
Modern Usage:
Dating someone from a very different economic background, or loving someone your family would disown you for being with.
Forbidden love
Romantic feelings that society, family, or circumstances make dangerous or wrong to pursue. The prohibition often makes the feelings stronger.
Modern Usage:
Office romances with power imbalances, dating your best friend's ex, or any relationship that could cost you your job or family.
Characters in This Chapter
Maggie Tulliver
Protagonist experiencing romantic awakening
She's genuinely shocked to discover someone could love her romantically, showing her low self-esteem and inexperience. Her immediate worry about family consequences reveals how duty-bound she feels.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who never thinks they're 'relationship material' until someone proves them wrong
Philip Wakem
Vulnerable lover making desperate confession
He finally reveals his love after months of secret meetings, describing himself as marked for suffering. His confession is both hopeful and desperate, knowing the odds are against them.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who's been secretly in love for years and finally takes the terrifying leap
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I had never thought of your being my lover. It seemed so far off—like a dream—only like one of the stories one imagines—that I should ever have a lover."
Context: Her response when Philip confesses his love
This reveals Maggie's deep insecurity and how she's never seen herself as worthy of romantic love. She's lived so much in books that real romance feels impossible for her personally.
In Today's Words:
I never imagined someone could actually want to be with me like that. That stuff only happens to other people, not me.
"I am waiting for something that will never come."
Context: Describing his hopeless love before his confession
Philip's words capture the agony of loving someone when you believe it's impossible. He's been torturing himself with hope while expecting disappointment.
In Today's Words:
I keep hoping for something I know will never happen.
"We can only be friends—brother and sister in secret, as we have been hitherto."
Context: Her attempt to maintain boundaries after Philip's confession
Even after admitting her feelings, Maggie immediately tries to put the relationship back in a 'safe' category. She's terrified of the consequences but can't bear to lose him entirely.
In Today's Words:
We have to keep this platonic. We can't let it go anywhere, but I can't lose you either.
Thematic Threads
Self-Worth
In This Chapter
Maggie genuinely shocked that someone could love her, revealing deep-seated belief in her own unworthiness
Development
Evolution from childhood sense of being 'wrong' to adult conviction she's unlovable
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when compliments feel impossible to believe or when good treatment feels suspicious.
Secret Relationships
In This Chapter
Their friendship becomes dangerous the moment it turns romantic, requiring more elaborate deception
Development
Escalation from innocent secret meetings to emotionally charged hidden romance
In Your Life:
You see this when any relationship that started innocently begins requiring lies to maintain.
Class Barriers
In This Chapter
Family feud makes their love practically impossible despite mutual affection
Development
Class differences now personally painful rather than abstract social fact
In Your Life:
You experience this when loving someone your family or community would never accept.
Duty vs Desire
In This Chapter
Maggie torn between genuine happiness with Philip and loyalty to family expectations
Development
First major test of whether she'll choose personal fulfillment over family duty
In Your Life:
You face this when what makes you happy conflicts with what others expect from you.
Vulnerability
In This Chapter
Philip's confession requires enormous emotional risk, describing himself as 'marked for suffering'
Development
His childhood isolation now becomes adult desperation for connection
In Your Life:
You know this feeling when you have to risk rejection to tell someone how much they mean to you.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why is Maggie so shocked by Philip's confession of love? What does her reaction tell us about how she sees herself?
analysis • surface - 2
Philip describes himself as 'marked from childhood for suffering' while seeing Maggie as his source of joy. What makes this dynamic both powerful and potentially dangerous?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about a time when someone saw potential or worth in you that you couldn't see in yourself. How did that recognition change your behavior or self-perception?
application • medium - 4
Maggie feels torn between her happiness with Philip and her sense of duty to family loyalty. When someone's recognition of your worth conflicts with other obligations, how do you decide what to prioritize?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between being loved for who you are versus being needed as someone's only source of happiness?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Recognition Reality Check
Think of someone whose opinion you value who has told you something positive about yourself that you dismissed or couldn't accept. Write down what they said, then list three specific examples from your life that might support their view. Finally, consider what you'd lose and what you'd gain if you actually believed them.
Consider:
- •Notice whether you're quicker to believe criticism than praise about yourself
- •Consider how your self-limiting beliefs might be protecting you from risk or disappointment
- •Think about whether accepting this recognition would require you to change your behavior or take on new responsibilities
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's belief in you pushed you to attempt something you thought was beyond your abilities. What happened, and how did it change your relationship with your own potential?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 37: When Secrets Explode
The coming pages reveal family loyalty and personal desires create impossible choices, and teach us shame often reveals more about the accuser than the accused. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.