An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 2934 words)
eptember 24th.—In the morning I rose, light and cheerful—nay,
intensely happy. The hovering cloud cast over me by my aunt’s views,
and by the fear of not obtaining her consent, was lost in the bright
effulgence of my own hopes, and the too delightful consciousness of
requited love. It was a splendid morning; and I went out to enjoy it,
in a quiet ramble, in company with my own blissful thoughts. The dew
was on the grass, and ten thousand gossamers were waving in the breeze;
the happy red-breast was pouring out its little soul in song, and my
heart overflowed with silent hymns of gratitude and praise to heaven.
But I had not wandered far before my solitude was interrupted by the
only person that could have disturbed my musings, at that moment,
without being looked upon as an unwelcome intruder: Mr. Huntingdon came
suddenly upon me. So unexpected was the apparition, that I might have
thought it the creation of an over-excited imagination, had the sense
of sight alone borne witness to his presence; but immediately I felt
his strong arm round my waist and his warm kiss on my cheek, while his
keen and gleeful salutation, “My own Helen!” was ringing in my ear.
“Not yours yet!” said I, hastily swerving aside from this too
presumptuous greeting. “Remember my guardians. You will not easily
obtain my aunt’s consent. Don’t you see she is prejudiced against you?”
“I do, dearest; and you must tell me why, that I may best know how to
combat her objections. I suppose she thinks I am a prodigal,” pursued
he, observing that I was unwilling to reply, “and concludes that I
shall have but little worldly goods wherewith to endow my better half?
If so, you must tell her that my property is mostly entailed, and I
cannot get rid of it. There may be a few mortgages on the rest—a few
trifling debts and incumbrances here and there, but nothing to speak
of; and though I acknowledge I am not so rich as I might be—or have
been—still, I think, we could manage pretty comfortably on what’s left.
My father, you know, was something of a miser, and in his latter days
especially saw no pleasure in life but to amass riches; and so it is no
wonder that his son should make it his chief delight to spend them,
which was accordingly the case, until my acquaintance with you, dear
Helen, taught me other views and nobler aims. And the very idea of
having you to care for under my roof would force me to moderate my
expenses and live like a Christian—not to speak of all the prudence and
virtue you would instil into my mind by your wise counsels and sweet,
attractive goodness.”
“But it is not that,” said I; “it is not money my aunt thinks about.
She knows better than to value worldly wealth above its price.”
“What is it, then?”
“She wishes me to—to marry none but a really good man.”
“What, a man of ‘decided piety’?—ahem!—Well, come, I’ll manage that
too! It’s Sunday to-day, isn’t it? I’ll go to church morning,
afternoon, and evening, and comport myself in such a godly sort that
she shall regard me with admiration and sisterly love, as a brand
plucked from the burning. I’ll come home sighing like a furnace, and
full of the savour and unction of dear Mr. Blatant’s discourse—”
“Mr. Leighton,” said I, dryly.
“Is Mr. Leighton a ‘sweet preacher,’ Helen—a ‘dear, delightful,
heavenly-minded man’?”
“He is a good man, Mr. Huntingdon. I wish I could say half as much
for you.”
“Oh, I forgot, you are a saint, too. I crave your pardon, dearest—but
don’t call me Mr. Huntingdon; my name is Arthur.”
“I’ll call you nothing—for I’ll have nothing at all to do with you if
you talk in that way any more. If you really mean to deceive my aunt as
you say, you are very wicked; and if not, you are very wrong to jest on
such a subject.”
“I stand corrected,” said he, concluding his laugh with a sorrowful
sigh. “Now,” resumed he, after a momentary pause, “let us talk about
something else. And come nearer to me, Helen, and take my arm; and then
I’ll let you alone. I can’t be quiet while I see you walking there.”
I complied; but said we must soon return to the house.
“No one will be down to breakfast yet, for long enough,” he answered.
“You spoke of your guardians just now, Helen, but is not your father
still living?”
“Yes, but I always look upon my uncle and aunt as my guardians, for
they are so in deed, though not in name. My father has entirely given
me up to their care. I have never seen him since dear mamma died, when
I was a very little girl, and my aunt, at her request, offered to take
charge of me, and took me away to Staningley, where I have remained
ever since; and I don’t think he would object to anything for me that
she thought proper to sanction.”
“But would he sanction anything to which she thought proper to object?”
“No, I don’t think he cares enough about me.”
“He is very much to blame—but he doesn’t know what an angel he has for
his daughter—which is all the better for me, as, if he did, he would
not be willing to part with such a treasure.”
“And Mr. Huntingdon,” said I, “I suppose you know I am not an
heiress?”
He protested he had never given it a thought, and begged I would not
disturb his present enjoyment by the mention of such uninteresting
subjects. I was glad of this proof of disinterested affection; for
Annabella Wilmot is the probable heiress to all her uncle’s wealth, in
addition to her late father’s property, which she has already in
possession.
I now insisted upon retracing our steps to the house; but we walked
slowly, and went on talking as we proceeded. I need not repeat all we
said: let me rather refer to what passed between my aunt and me, after
breakfast, when Mr. Huntingdon called my uncle aside, no doubt to make
his proposals, and she beckoned me into another room, where she once
more commenced a solemn remonstrance, which, however, entirely failed
to convince me that her view of the case was preferable to my own.
“You judge him uncharitably, aunt, I know,” said I. “His very friends
are not half so bad as you represent them. There is Walter Hargrave,
Milicent’s brother, for one: he is but a little lower than the angels,
if half she says of him is true. She is continually talking to me about
him, and lauding his many virtues to the skies.”
“You will form a very inadequate estimate of a man’s character,”
replied she, “if you judge by what a fond sister says of him. The worst
of them generally know how to hide their misdeeds from their sisters’
eyes, and their mother’s, too.”
“And there is Lord Lowborough,” continued I, “quite a decent man.”
“Who told you so? Lord Lowborough is a desperate man. He has
dissipated his fortune in gambling and other things, and is now seeking
an heiress to retrieve it. I told Miss Wilmot so; but you’re all alike:
she haughtily answered she was very much obliged to me, but she
believed she knew when a man was seeking her for her fortune, and
when for herself; she flattered herself she had had experience enough
in those matters to be justified in trusting to her own judgment—and as
for his lordship’s lack of fortune, she cared nothing about that, as
she hoped her own would suffice for both; and as for his wildness, she
supposed he was no worse than others—besides, he was reformed now. Yes,
they can all play the hypocrite when they want to take in a fond,
misguided woman!”
“Well, I think he’s about as good as she is,” said I. “But when Mr.
Huntingdon is married, he won’t have many opportunities of consorting
with his bachelor friends;—and the worse they are, the more I long to
deliver him from them.”
“To be sure, my dear; and the worse he is, I suppose, the more you
long to deliver him from himself.”
“Yes, provided he is not incorrigible—that is, the more I long to
deliver him from his faults—to give him an opportunity of shaking off
the adventitious evil got from contact with others worse than himself,
and shining out in the unclouded light of his own genuine goodness—to
do my utmost to help his better self against his worse, and make him
what he would have been if he had not, from the beginning, had a bad,
selfish, miserly father, who, to gratify his own sordid passions,
restricted him in the most innocent enjoyments of childhood and youth,
and so disgusted him with every kind of restraint;—and a foolish mother
who indulged him to the top of his bent, deceiving her husband for him,
and doing her utmost to encourage those germs of folly and vice it was
her duty to suppress,—and then, such a set of companions as you
represent his friends to be—”
“Poor man!” said she, sarcastically, “his kind have greatly wronged
him!”
“They have!” cried I—“and they shall wrong him no more—his wife shall
undo what his mother did!”
“Well,” said she, after a short pause, “I must say, Helen, I thought
better of your judgment than this—and your taste too. How you can love
such a man I cannot tell, or what pleasure you can find in his company;
for ‘what fellowship hath light with darkness; or he that believeth
with an infidel?’”
“He is not an infidel;—and I am not light, and he is not darkness; his
worst and only vice is thoughtlessness.”
“And thoughtlessness,” pursued my aunt, “may lead to every crime, and
will but poorly excuse our errors in the sight of God. Mr. Huntingdon,
I suppose, is not without the common faculties of men: he is not so
light-headed as to be irresponsible: his Maker has endowed him with
reason and conscience as well as the rest of us; the Scriptures are
open to him as well as to others;—and ‘if he hear not them, neither
will he hear though one rose from the dead.’ And remember, Helen,”
continued she, solemnly, “‘the wicked shall be turned into hell, and
they that forget God!’” And suppose, even, that he should continue to
love you, and you him, and that you should pass through life together
with tolerable comfort—how will it be in the end, when you see
yourselves parted for ever; you, perhaps, taken into eternal bliss, and
he cast into the lake that burneth with unquenchable fire—there for
ever to—”
“Not for ever,” I exclaimed, “‘only till he has paid the uttermost
farthing;’ for ‘if any man’s work abide not the fire, he shall suffer
loss, yet himself shall be saved, but so as by fire;’ and He that ‘is
able to subdue all things to Himself will have all men to be saved,’
and ‘will, in the fulness of time, gather together in one all things in
Christ Jesus, who tasted death for every man, and in whom God will
reconcile all things to Himself, whether they be things in earth or
things in heaven.’”
“Oh, Helen! where did you learn all this?”
“In the Bible, aunt. I have searched it through, and found nearly
thirty passages, all tending to support the same theory.”
“And is that the use you make of your Bible? And did you find no
passages tending to prove the danger and the falsity of such a belief?”
“No: I found, indeed, some passages that, taken by themselves, might
seem to contradict that opinion; but they will all bear a different
construction to that which is commonly given, and in most the only
difficulty is in the word which we translate ‘everlasting’ or
‘eternal.’ I don’t know the Greek, but I believe it strictly means for
ages, and might signify either endless or long-enduring. And as for the
danger of the belief, I would not publish it abroad if I thought any
poor wretch would be likely to presume upon it to his own destruction,
but it is a glorious thought to cherish in one’s own heart, and I would
not part with it for all the world can give!”
Here our conference ended, for it was now high time to prepare for
church. Every one attended the morning service, except my uncle, who
hardly ever goes, and Mr. Wilmot, who stayed at home with him to enjoy
a quiet game of cribbage. In the afternoon Miss Wilmot and Lord
Lowborough likewise excused themselves from attending; but Mr.
Huntingdon vouchsafed to accompany us again. Whether it was to
ingratiate himself with my aunt I cannot tell, but, if so, he certainly
should have behaved better. I must confess, I did not like his conduct
during service at all. Holding his prayer-book upside down, or open at
any place but the right, he did nothing but stare about him, unless he
happened to catch my aunt’s eye or mine, and then he would drop his own
on his book, with a puritanical air of mock solemnity that would have
been ludicrous, if it had not been too provoking. Once, during the
sermon, after attentively regarding Mr. Leighton for a few minutes, he
suddenly produced his gold pencil-case and snatched up a Bible.
Perceiving that I observed the movement, he whispered that he was going
to make a note of the sermon; but instead of that, as I sat next him, I
could not help seeing that he was making a caricature of the preacher,
giving to the respectable, pious, elderly gentleman, the air and aspect
of a most absurd old hypocrite. And yet, upon his return, he talked to
my aunt about the sermon with a degree of modest, serious
discrimination that tempted me to believe he had really attended to and
profited by the discourse.
Just before dinner my uncle called me into the library for the
discussion of a very important matter, which was dismissed in few
words.
“Now, Nell,” said he, “this young Huntingdon has been asking for you:
what must I say about it? Your aunt would answer ‘no’—but what say
you?”
“I say yes, uncle,” replied I, without a moment’s hesitation; for I had
thoroughly made up my mind on the subject.
“Very good!” cried he. “Now that’s a good honest answer—wonderful for a
girl!—Well, I’ll write to your father to-morrow. He’s sure to give his
consent; so you may look on the matter as settled. You’d have done a
deal better if you’d taken Wilmot, I can tell you; but that you won’t
believe. At your time of life, it’s love that rules the roast: at mine,
it’s solid, serviceable gold. I suppose now, you’d never dream of
looking into the state of your husband’s finances, or troubling your
head about settlements, or anything of that sort?”
“I don’t think I should.”
“Well, be thankful, then, that you’ve wiser heads to think for you. I
haven’t had time, yet, to examine thoroughly into this young rascal’s
affairs, but I see that a great part of his father’s fine property has
been squandered away;—but still, I think, there’s a pretty fair share
of it left, and a little careful nursing may make a handsome thing of
it yet; and then we must persuade your father to give you a decent
fortune, as he has only one besides yourself to care for;—and, if you
behave well, who knows but what I may be induced to remember you in my
will!” continued he, putting his fingers to his nose, with a knowing
wink.
“Thanks, uncle, for that and all your kindness,” replied I.
“Well, and I questioned this young spark on the matter of settlements,”
continued he; “and he seemed disposed to be generous enough on that
point—”
“I knew he would!” said I. “But pray don’t trouble your head—or his, or
mine about that; for all I have will be his, and all he has will be
mine; and what more could either of us require?” And I was about to
make my exit, but he called me back.
“Stop, stop!” cried he; “we haven’t mentioned the time yet. When must
it be? Your aunt would put it off till the Lord knows when, but he is
anxious to be bound as soon as may be: he won’t hear of waiting beyond
next month; and you, I guess, will be of the same mind, so—”
“Not at all, uncle; on the contrary, I should like to wait till after
Christmas, at least.”
“Oh! pooh, pooh! never tell me that tale—I know better,” cried he; and
he persisted in his incredulity. Nevertheless, it is quite true. I am
in no hurry at all. How can I be, when I think of the momentous change
that awaits me, and of all I have to leave? It is happiness enough to
know that we are to be united; and that he really loves me, and I may
love him as devotedly, and think of him as often as I please.
However, I insisted upon consulting my aunt about the time of the
wedding, for I determined her counsels should not be utterly
disregarded; and no conclusions on that particular are come to yet.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
The tendency to rationalize away clear warning signs when emotionally invested in a person or situation.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how emotional investment clouds judgment, making us defend what we should question.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you find yourself building elaborate explanations for someone's concerning behavior—then ask what you'd tell a friend in the same situation.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Not yours yet! Remember my guardians. You will not easily obtain my aunt's consent."
Context: When Huntingdon presumptuously greets her with physical affection
This shows Helen still has some boundaries and awareness of proper procedure, but she's already emotionally committed. The phrase 'not yet' implies she expects it to happen eventually.
In Today's Words:
Slow down there, cowboy - you haven't met my family yet and they're not going to make this easy.
"I'll endeavour to appear a good Christian for a few weeks, and then, when I've secured my prize, I may throw off the mask."
Context: Suggesting he'll fake being religious to win the aunt's approval
This reveals his manipulative nature and complete lack of genuine faith or character. He sees Helen as a 'prize' to be won through deception rather than a person deserving honesty.
In Today's Words:
I'll just pretend to be what they want until I get what I want, then I can go back to being myself.
"He is not a wicked man - only thoughtless."
Context: Defending Huntingdon to her aunt
Helen minimizes serious character flaws as mere thoughtlessness. This is classic denial - she can't admit the man she loves might actually be morally deficient.
In Today's Words:
He's not a bad guy, he just doesn't think before he acts.
Thematic Threads
Self-Deception
In This Chapter
Helen transforms Huntingdon's obvious character flaws into minor quirks she can fix
Development
Deepening from earlier romantic idealization
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself making excuses for someone whose behavior consistently makes you uncomfortable.
Religious Authority
In This Chapter
Huntingdon mocks church service while Helen defends his irreverence as harmless
Development
Expanding from earlier class tensions to spiritual conflicts
In Your Life:
You might find yourself caught between family values and partner's dismissive attitudes toward what matters to you.
Family Wisdom
In This Chapter
Helen's aunt warns against Huntingdon's character while Helen dismisses these concerns
Development
Continuing pattern of generational conflict over life choices
In Your Life:
You might struggle when family members voice concerns about your relationship or career decisions.
Reform Fantasy
In This Chapter
Helen believes her love will transform Huntingdon into a better man
Development
Introduced here as core relationship dynamic
In Your Life:
You might find yourself dating someone's potential rather than their current reality.
Male Privilege
In This Chapter
Huntingdon faces no real consequences for his behavior while being rewarded with engagement
Development
Continuing theme of men's actions having fewer social costs
In Your Life:
You might notice how certain people in your life get away with behavior that would be unacceptable from others.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific behaviors does Huntingdon display at church, and how does Helen interpret them versus how her aunt sees them?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Helen defend Huntingdon as 'thoughtless' rather than wicked, and what does this reveal about how love affects our judgment?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of making excuses for someone's concerning behavior in modern relationships, workplaces, or family dynamics?
application • medium - 4
If you were Helen's friend, what specific strategies would you use to help her see the situation more clearly without pushing her away?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about the difference between accepting someone's flaws and enabling their destructive behavior?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Red Flag Reality Check
Think of a situation where you or someone close to you made excuses for concerning behavior. Create two columns: 'What I Told Myself' and 'What the Facts Actually Were.' Then write what you would tell a friend facing the same situation. This exercise helps you recognize the difference between emotional interpretation and objective reality.
Consider:
- •Focus on patterns of behavior, not isolated incidents
- •Consider what you would advise a friend in the same situation
- •Notice how emotional investment changes your interpretation of facts
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you ignored your gut instincts about someone because you wanted the relationship to work. What warning signs did you rationalize away, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 21: Friends Who Warn You
The engagement is officially settled with her father's consent, and Christmas is set as the wedding date. Helen must choose her bridesmaids, including the wealthy Annabella Wilmot, setting up new social dynamics as the wedding approaches.




