Summary
Crusoe's discovery of cannibals on his island transforms him from a cautious survivor into a paranoid fortress-dweller. The horrifying sight of human bones and evidence of ritualistic feasting sends him into a two-year spiral of fear-driven planning. He arms himself heavily, stops using his gun to avoid detection, and obsessively plots elaborate revenge schemes against the cannibals. But as months pass without any encounters, Crusoe begins questioning his bloodthirsty fantasies. He realizes these people aren't evil by their own standards—they're following their cultural norms, just as Europeans follow theirs. This moral awakening stops him from becoming a murderer himself. Meanwhile, his practical needs continue: he discovers a magnificent hidden cave that becomes his secret arsenal and refuge. The chapter shows how trauma can warp our thinking, turning us into the very thing we fear. Crusoe's journey from victim mentality to moral reasoning demonstrates that our first emotional response to threat isn't always our wisest. His ability to step back and examine his own motivations saves him from becoming the monster he imagined his enemies to be. The cave discovery also reinforces a key theme: sometimes our greatest security comes not from attacking our fears, but from finding better ways to hide from them.
Coming Up in Chapter 12
A shipwreck brings new hope and new dangers to Crusoe's island. The discovery of a Spanish vessel will force him to confront whether his years of isolation have prepared him for human contact—or made it impossible.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
A CAVE RETREAT While this was doing, I was not altogether careless of my other affairs; for I had a great concern upon me for my little herd of goats: they were not only a ready supply to me on every occasion, and began to be sufficient for me, without the expense of powder and shot, but also without the fatigue of hunting after the wild ones; and I was loath to lose the advantage of them, and to have them all to nurse up over again. For this purpose, after long consideration, I could think of but two ways to preserve them: one was, to find another convenient place to dig a cave underground, and to drive them into it every night; and the other was to enclose two or three little bits of land, remote from one another, and as much concealed as I could, where I might keep about half-a-dozen young goats in each place; so that if any disaster happened to the flock in general, I might be able to raise them again with little trouble and time: and this though it would require a good deal of time and labour, I thought was the most rational design. Accordingly, I spent some time to find out the most retired parts of the island; and I pitched upon one, which was as private, indeed, as my heart could wish: it was a little damp piece of ground in the middle of the hollow and thick woods, where, as is observed, I almost lost myself once before, endeavouring to come back that way from the eastern part of the island. Here I found a clear piece of land, near three acres, so surrounded with woods that it was almost an enclosure by nature; at least, it did not want near so much labour to make it so as the other piece of ground I had worked so hard at. I immediately went to work with this piece of ground; and in less than a month’s time I had so fenced it round that my flock, or herd, call it which you please, which were not so wild now as at first they might be supposed to be, were well enough secured in it: so, without any further delay, I removed ten young she-goats and two he-goats to this piece, and when they were there I continued to perfect the fence till I had made it as secure as the other; which, however, I did at more leisure, and it took me up more time by a great deal. All this labour I was at the expense of, purely from my apprehensions on account of the print of a man’s foot; for as yet I had never seen any human creature come near the island; and I had now lived two years under this uneasiness, which, indeed, made my life much less comfortable than it was before, as may be well imagined by any who know what it is...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Fear-Driven Extremism
Trauma creates narratives that justify increasingly extreme responses, transforming victims into the very threats they fear.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how fear and violation can gradually normalize thoughts and actions we'd normally find abhorrent.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you catch yourself rehearsing revenge scenarios or when anger makes extreme responses feel reasonable—that's the pattern activating.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Paranoid fortification
The psychological response of building excessive defenses when we feel threatened. Crusoe creates multiple hiding places and weapons caches after discovering the cannibals. This shows how fear can make us over-prepare and isolate ourselves.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who installs five security cameras and three deadbolts after one break-in attempt in their neighborhood.
Cultural relativism
The idea that what's considered right or wrong depends on your culture's standards. Crusoe realizes the cannibals aren't evil by their own cultural norms, just as Europeans aren't evil by theirs. This prevents him from becoming a murderer.
Modern Usage:
Understanding that different families have different rules about money, relationships, or child-rearing - not better or worse, just different.
Moral awakening
The moment when someone stops reacting emotionally and starts thinking ethically about their choices. Crusoe moves from wanting revenge to questioning whether he has the right to judge others by his standards.
Modern Usage:
Like realizing you were wrong to gossip about a coworker's personal problems, even if you disapproved of their choices.
Victim mentality spiral
When feeling threatened turns someone into an aggressor. Crusoe goes from being afraid of the cannibals to plotting elaborate ways to kill them. Fear transforms him into what he fears.
Modern Usage:
When someone who's been hurt starts hurting others first, thinking 'I'll get them before they get me.'
Strategic retreat
Choosing to hide or avoid conflict rather than confronting it directly. Crusoe builds secret caves and changes his habits to stay invisible rather than fight the cannibals.
Modern Usage:
Taking a different route to work to avoid a difficult coworker instead of having a confrontation.
Resource diversification
Spreading your valuable things across multiple locations so you don't lose everything at once. Crusoe splits his goat herd and creates multiple hideouts to protect against disaster.
Modern Usage:
Like keeping some money in different banks or having backup plans for childcare with several different people.
Characters in This Chapter
Robinson Crusoe
Paranoid survivor
Discovers evidence of cannibals and spends two years in fearful isolation, heavily armed and plotting revenge. Eventually realizes his murderous fantasies are wrong and finds peace through moral reasoning instead of violence.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who becomes obsessed with home security after a neighborhood crime
The Cannibals
Unseen threat
Never actually appear in this chapter, but their presence through leftover bones and fire sites drives Crusoe to paranoia. They represent the unknown danger that can consume our thoughts and change our behavior.
Modern Equivalent:
The anonymous online trolls who make someone afraid to post anything
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I was a perfect agent for all the misery I endured, and all I should yet endure; and that my present condition was but the consequence of my original sin."
Context: Crusoe reflecting on how his choices led to his current fearful state
This shows Crusoe taking responsibility for his situation rather than just blaming external threats. He recognizes that his own decisions created his problems, which is the first step toward making better choices.
In Today's Words:
I brought this on myself, and I'm the only one who can fix it.
"How do I know what God himself judges in this particular case? It is certain these people do not commit this as a crime; it is not against their own consciences reproving, or their light reproaching them."
Context: Crusoe questioning whether he has the right to judge the cannibals by his standards
This is Crusoe's moral breakthrough - realizing that different people have different moral frameworks. This stops him from becoming a murderer and shows real wisdom about human nature.
In Today's Words:
Who am I to judge them? They're not doing anything they think is wrong.
"I had been now thirteen years in this place, and was so naturalized to the place, and to the manner of living, that could I have but enjoyed the certainty that no savages would come to the place to disturb me, I could have been content to have capitulated for spending the rest of my time there, even to the last moment."
Context: Crusoe realizing he's actually grown to love his island life, except for the fear
This reveals that fear is the only thing preventing Crusoe from being truly happy. He's built a good life, but anxiety about potential threats is poisoning his contentment.
In Today's Words:
I'd actually be happy here if I could just stop worrying about what might happen.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Crusoe nearly loses his moral identity by convincing himself that planned murder would be justified self-defense
Development
Evolution from earlier chapters where Crusoe maintained his civilized identity despite isolation
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you catch yourself justifying behavior that normally goes against your values
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Crusoe realizes his horror at cannibalism reflects his cultural conditioning, not universal moral truth
Development
Builds on earlier themes of European superiority and civilized behavior
In Your Life:
You see this when judging others' choices without understanding their circumstances or background
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Crusoe's ability to question his own bloodthirsty fantasies represents significant moral development
Development
Major advancement from earlier impulsive decision-making and self-centered thinking
In Your Life:
This appears when you catch yourself in destructive thought patterns and choose to examine them honestly
Class
In This Chapter
Crusoe's assumption that he has the right to judge and execute 'savages' reflects colonial class superiority
Development
Continuation of themes about European cultural supremacy from earlier chapters
In Your Life:
You might notice this when assuming your way of doing things is obviously better than others'
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Crusoe's isolation has warped his ability to see other humans as complex beings rather than threats
Development
Shows how prolonged isolation affects his capacity for empathy and understanding
In Your Life:
This happens when fear or past hurt makes you view entire groups of people as enemies rather than individuals
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What evidence of cannibals does Crusoe find, and how does it change his daily behavior on the island?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Crusoe spend two years planning violent revenge against people he's never met, and what finally stops him?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this same pattern today—people discovering something frightening and then planning extreme responses they'd normally consider wrong?
application • medium - 4
When you've been scared or hurt by someone, how do you tell the difference between reasonable caution and revenge fantasies that could change who you are?
application • deep - 5
What does Crusoe's ability to step back and question his own murderous plans teach us about how trauma can warp our thinking?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Fear Response Pattern
Think of a time when you felt threatened or deeply upset by someone's actions. Write down your immediate emotional response, then trace how your thoughts escalated from there. What revenge fantasies or extreme solutions did you consider? Now step outside yourself: what would you tell a friend having the same experience?
Consider:
- •Notice how fear makes extreme responses feel reasonable and justified
- •Consider whether your planned response would solve the actual problem or just feed the anger
- •Ask yourself what someone with no emotional investment would advise
Journaling Prompt
Write about a situation where you caught yourself planning revenge or an extreme response to being hurt. How did you recognize the pattern and what helped you step back from it?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 12: The Spanish Shipwreck Discovery
The coming pages reveal isolation affects decision-making and risk assessment, and teach us material wealth means nothing without human connection. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.