An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1816 words)
ecollections
Ibarra's carriage was passing through a part of the busiest district
in Manila, the same which the night before had made him feel sad,
but which by daylight caused him to smile in spite of himself. The
movement in every part, so many carriages coming and going at full
speed, the carromatas and calesas, the Europeans, the Chinese,
the natives, each in his own peculiar costume, the fruit-venders,
the money-changers, the naked porters, the grocery stores, the lunch
stands and restaurants, the shops, and even the carts drawn by the
impassive and indifferent carabao, who seems to amuse himself in
carrying burdens while he patiently ruminates, all this noise and
confusion, the very sun itself, the distinctive odors and the motley
colors, awoke in the youth's mind a world of sleeping recollections.
Those streets had not yet been paved, and two successive days of
sunshine filled them with dust which covered everything and made the
passer-by cough while it nearly blinded him. A day of rain formed
pools of muddy water, which at night reflected the carriage lights and
splashed mud a distance of several yards away upon the pedestrians on
the narrow sidewalks. And how many women have left their embroidered
slippers in those waves of mud!
Then there might have been seen repairing those streets the lines of
convicts with their shaven heads, dressed in short-sleeved camisas
and pantaloons that reached only to their knees, each with his letter
and number in blue. On their legs were chains partly wrapped in dirty
rags to ease the chafing or perhaps the chill of the iron. Joined
two by two, scorched in the sun, worn out by the heat and fatigue,
they were lashed and goaded by a whip in the hands of one of their own
number, who perhaps consoled himself with this power of maltreating
others. They were tall men with somber faces, which he had never seen
brightened with the light of a smile. Yet their eyes gleamed when the
whistling lash fell upon their shoulders or when a passer-by threw
them the chewed and broken stub of a cigar, which the nearest would
snatch up and hide in his salakot, while the rest remained gazing at
the passers-by with strange looks.
The noise of the stones being crushed to fill the puddles and the
merry clank of the heavy fetters on the swollen ankles seemed to remain
with Ibarra. He shuddered as he recalled a scene that had made a deep
impression on his childish imagination. It was a hot afternoon, and the
burning rays of the sun fell perpendicularly upon a large cart by the
side of which was stretched out one of those unfortunates, lifeless,
yet with his eyes half opened. Two others were silently preparing
a bamboo bier, showing no signs of anger or sorrow or impatience,
for such is the character attributed to the natives: today it is you,
tomorrow it will be I, they say to themselves. The people moved rapidly
about without giving heed, women came up and after a look of curiosity
continued unconcerned on their way--it was such a common sight that
their hearts had become callous. Carriages passed, flashing back from
their varnished sides the rays of the sun that burned in a cloudless
sky. Only he, a child of eleven years and fresh from the country, was
moved, and to him alone it brought bad dreams on the following night.
There no longer existed the useful and honored Puente de Barcas, the
good Filipino pontoon bridge that had done its best to be of service
in spite of its natural imperfections and its rising and falling
at the caprice of the Pasig, which had more than once abused it and
finally destroyed it. The almond trees in the plaza of San Gabriel
[46] had not grown; they were still in the same feeble and stunted
condition. The Escolta appeared less beautiful in spite of the fact
that an imposing building with caryatids carved on its front now
occupied the place of the old row of shops. The new Bridge of Spain
caught his attention, while the houses on the right bank of the river
among the clumps of bamboo and trees where the Escolta ends and the
Isla de Romero begins, reminded him of the cool mornings when he used
to pass there in a boat on his way to the baths of Uli-Uli.
He met many carriages, drawn by beautiful pairs of dwarfish ponies,
within which were government clerks who seemed yet half asleep as they
made their way to their offices, or military officers, or Chinese in
foolish and ridiculous attitudes, or Gave friars and canons. In an
elegant victoria he thought he recognized Padre Damaso, grave and
frowning, but he had already passed. Now he was pleasantly greeted
by Capitan Tinong, who was passing in a carretela with his wife and
two daughters.
As they went down off the bridge the horses broke into a trot along the
Sabana Drive. [47] On the left the Arroceros Cigar Factory resounded
with the noise of the cigar-makers pounding the tobacco leaves, and
Ibarra was unable to restrain a smile as he thought of the strong odor
which about five o'clock in the afternoon used to float all over the
Puente de Barcas and which had made him sick when he was a child. The
lively conversations and the repartee of the crowds from the cigar
factories carried him back to the district of Lavapiés in Madrid,
with its riots of cigar-makers, so fatal for the unfortunate policemen.
The Botanical Garden drove away these agreeable recollections; the
demon of comparison brought before his mind the Botanical Gardens
of Europe, in countries where great, labor and much money are needed
to make a single leaf grow or one flower open its calyx; he recalled
those of the colonies, where they are well supplied and tended, and
all open to the public. Ibarra turned away his gaze toward the old
Manila surrounded still by its walls and moats like a sickly girl
wrapped in the garments of her grandmother's better days.
Then the sight of the sea losing itself in the distance! "On
the other shore lies Europe," thought the young man,--"Europe,
with its attractive peoples in constant movement in the search for
happiness, weaving their dreams in the morning and disillusioning
themselves at the setting of the sun, happy even in the midst of
their calamities. Yes, on the farther shore of the boundless sea
are the really spiritual nations, those who, even though they put
no restraints on material development, are still more spiritual than
those who pride themselves on adoring only the spirit!"
But these musings were in turn banished from his mind as he came in
sight of the little mound in Bagumbayan Field. [48] This isolated
knoll at the side of the Luneta now caught his attention and made him
reminiscent. He thought of the man who had awakened his intellect and
made him understand goodness and justice. The ideas which that man
had impressed upon him were not many, to be sure, but they were not
meaningless repetitions, they were convictions which had not paled
in the light of the most brilliant foci of progress. That man was an
old priest whose words of farewell still resounded in his ears: "Do
not forget that if knowledge is the heritage of mankind, it is only
the courageous who inherit it," he had reminded him. "I have tried to
pass on to you what I got from my teachers, the sum of which I have
endeavored to increase and transmit to the coming generation as far
as in me lay. You will now do the same for those who come after you,
and you can treble it, since you are going to rich countries." Then he
had added with a smile, "They come here seeking wealth, go you to their
country to seek also that other wealth which we lack! But remember
that all that glitters is not gold." The old man had died on that spot.
At these recollections the youth murmured audibly: "No, in spite of
everything, the fatherland first, first the Philippines, the child
of Spain, first the Spanish fatherland! No, that which is decreed by
fate does not tarnish the honor of the fatherland, no!"
He gave little heed to Ermita, the phenix of nipa that had rearisen
from its ashes under the form of blue and white houses with red-painted
roofs of corrugated iron. Nor was his attention caught by Malate,
neither by the cavalry barracks with the spreading trees in front,
nor by the inhabitants or their little nipa huts, pyramidal or
prismatic in shape, hidden away among the banana plants and areca
palms, constructed like nests by each father of a family.
The carriage continued on its way, meeting now and then carromatas
drawn by one or two ponies whose abaka harness indicated that they
were from the country. The drivers would try to catch a glimpse of the
occupant of the fine carriage, but would pass on without exchanging a
word, without a single salute. At times a heavy cart drawn by a slow
and indifferent carabao would appear on the dusty road over which beat
the brilliant sunlight of the tropics. The mournful and monotonous song
of the driver mounted on the back of the carabao would be mingled at
one time with the screechings of a dry wheel on the huge axle of the
heavy vehicle or at another time with the dull scraping of worn-out
runners on a sledge which was dragged heavily through the dust, and
over the ruts in the road. In the fields and wide meadows the herds
were grazing, attended ever by the white buffalo-birds which roosted
peacefully on the backs of the animals while these chewed their cuds
or browsed in lazy contentment upon the rich grass. In the distance
ponies frisked, jumping and running about, pursued by the lively colts
with long tails and abundant manes who whinnied and pawed the ground
with their hard hoofs.
Let us leave the youth dreaming or dozing, since neither the sad
nor the animated poetry of the open country held his attention. For
him there was no charm in the sun that gleamed upon the tops of the
trees and caused the rustics, with feet burned by the hot ground in
spite of their callousness, to hurry along, or that made the villager
pause beneath the shade of an almond tree or a bamboo brake while he
pondered upon vague and inexplicable things. While the youth's carriage
sways along like a drunken thing on account of the inequalities in
the surface of the road when passing over a bamboo bridge or going
up an incline or descending a steep slope, let us return to Manila.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
The Educated Eye - How Knowledge Changes What You Can't Unsee
Once you gain broader perspective through experience or education, you see problems others miss and feel responsible for change, creating both opportunity and isolation.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between individual problems and systemic issues that require different approaches.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you see problems that others seem to ignore—ask yourself whether this is an individual issue or part of a larger pattern that needs strategic, not emotional, responses.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The courageous inherit knowledge"
Context: Advice given to young Ibarra before he left for Europe to study
This quote reveals that seeking education and truth requires bravery, especially in an oppressive system. The priest knows that knowledge comes with risks but believes it's worth pursuing.
In Today's Words:
You have to be brave to really learn and grow - it's not always safe to seek the truth
"All that glitters is not gold"
Context: Warning Ibarra about what he might encounter in Europe
The priest reminds Ibarra to think critically even about European 'progress' and 'civilization.' Not everything that looks advanced or beautiful is actually good.
In Today's Words:
Don't believe everything you see on social media - what looks perfect often isn't
"Those streets had not yet been paved, and two successive days of sunshine filled them with dust"
Context: Describing Manila's poor infrastructure during Ibarra's childhood
This shows how colonial authorities neglected basic public works that would benefit ordinary people. The contrast between European cities and Manila reveals colonial priorities.
In Today's Words:
The city was basically falling apart - dusty when dry, muddy when wet
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Ibarra struggles with his dual identity—European-educated but Filipino-hearted, able to see his homeland's flaws while still declaring his loyalty to it
Development
Building on his earlier discomfort with Manila's poverty, now showing the internal conflict of loving a place while seeing its problems clearly
In Your Life:
You might feel this tension when you outgrow your family's expectations but still love them, or when you see your workplace's problems but need the job.
Class
In This Chapter
The stark contrast between the chain gang convicts and the indifferent passersby reveals how class differences create emotional distance and moral numbness
Development
Continues the exploration of social hierarchies, now focusing on how privilege shields people from seeing suffering
In Your Life:
You see this when people in comfortable positions dismiss others' struggles as 'just how things are' rather than recognizing systemic problems.
Memory
In This Chapter
Childhood memories flood back as Ibarra revisits familiar places, showing how physical spaces trigger emotional recollections and shape identity
Development
Introduced here as a key element in how the past influences present perspective
In Your Life:
You experience this when returning to your hometown or childhood neighborhood triggers memories that reshape how you see your current life.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Ibarra was marked as 'different' from childhood for feeling compassion where others showed indifference, highlighting how society pressures people to conform emotionally
Development
Expands on earlier themes of conformity, showing how emotional responses are policed from an early age
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you're told you're 'too sensitive' for caring about issues others ignore, or when your empathy is seen as weakness.
Progress
In This Chapter
Ibarra observes physical improvements in Manila while recognizing deeper social problems remain unchanged, showing the complexity of genuine progress
Development
Introduced here as the tension between surface improvements and systemic issues
In Your Life:
You see this when your workplace gets new equipment but keeps toxic management, or when your community builds fancy developments while ignoring poverty.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific memories does Ibarra experience as he rides through Manila in daylight, and how do they differ from his nighttime impressions?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does the memory of the dead convict affect eleven-year-old Ibarra so differently than it affects the other people who simply walk past?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'educated sight' today—people who gain new perspective and then can't ignore problems others accept as normal?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Ibarra's position, seeing problems clearly but feeling isolated by your perspective, how would you balance loyalty to home with the responsibility to push for change?
application • deep - 5
What does Ibarra's experience teach us about the relationship between knowledge and belonging—can you gain wisdom without losing your sense of home?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Educated Sight
Think of a time when you gained new knowledge or experience that changed how you see a familiar situation—maybe through training, travel, a new job, or education. Write down what you noticed that you couldn't see before, and how this new perspective affected your relationships with people who hadn't had the same experience.
Consider:
- •Notice whether your new perspective made you feel superior, isolated, or responsible for change
- •Consider how you handled the gap between what you now knew and what others around you accepted
- •Reflect on whether you found ways to share your insights without alienating people you care about
Journaling Prompt
Write about a situation where you currently have 'educated sight'—you can see problems or possibilities that others around you don't recognize. How are you choosing to navigate this knowledge? What would courage look like in this situation?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 9: Power Plays Behind Closed Doors
Ibarra's journey continues as he encounters the local affairs and personalities that will shape his attempts to bring progress to his hometown. The tension between his idealistic plans and the reality of local politics begins to emerge.




