An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1141 words)
he Town
Almost on the margin of the lake, in the midst of meadows and
paddy-fields, lies the town of San Diego. [50] From it sugar, rice,
coffee, and fruits are either exported or sold for a small part of
their value to the Chinese, who exploit the simplicity and vices of
the native farmers.
When on a clear day the boys ascend to the upper part of the church
tower, which is beautified by moss and creeping plants, they break
out into joyful exclamations at the beauty of the scene spread out
before them. In the midst of the clustering roofs of nipa, tiles,
corrugated iron, and palm leaves, separated by groves and gardens,
each one is able to discover his own home, his little nest. Everything
serves as a mark: a tree, that tamarind with its light foliage,
that coco palm laden with nuts, like the Astarte Genetrix, or the
Diana of Ephesus with her numerous breasts, a bending bamboo, an
areca palm, or a cross. Yonder is the river, a huge glassy serpent
sleeping on a green carpet, with rocks, scattered here and there
along its sandy channel, that break its current into ripples. There,
the bed is narrowed between high banks to which the gnarled trees
cling with bared roots; here, it becomes a gentle slope where the
stream widens and eddies about. Farther away, a small hut built on the
edge of the high bank seems to defy the winds, the heights and the
depths, presenting with its slender posts the appearance of a huge,
long-legged bird watching for a reptile to seize upon. Trunks of palm
or other trees with their bark still on them unite the banks by a
shaky and infirm foot-bridge which, if not a very secure crossing,
is nevertheless a wonderful contrivance for gymnastic exercises in
preserving one's balance, a thing not to be despised. The boys bathing
in the river are amused by the difficulties of the old woman crossing
with a basket on her head or by the antics of the old man who moves
tremblingly and loses his staff in the water.
But that which always attracts particular notice is what might be
called a peninsula of forest in the sea of cultivated fields. There
in that wood are century-old trees with hollow trunks, which die only
when their high tops are struck and set on fire by the lightning--and
it is said that the fire always checks itself and dies out in the same
spot. There are huge points of rock which time and nature are clothing
with velvet garments of moss. Layer after layer of dust settles in
the hollows, the rains beat it down, and the birds bring seeds. The
tropical vegetation spreads out luxuriantly in thickets and underbrush,
while curtains of interwoven vines hang from the branches of the trees
and twine about their roots or spread along the ground, as if Flora
were not yet satisfied but must place plant above plant. Mosses and
fungi live upon the cracked trunks, and orchids--graceful guests--twine
in loving embrace with the foliage of the hospitable trees.
Strange legends exist concerning this wood, which is held in awe by
the country folk. The most credible account, and therefore the one
least known and believed, seems to be this. When the town was still
a collection of miserable huts with the grass growing abundantly in
the so-called streets, at the time when the wild boar and deer roamed
about during the nights, there arrived in the place one day an old,
hollow-eyed Spaniard, who spoke Tagalog rather well. After looking
about and inspecting the land, he finally inquired for the owners of
this wood, in which there were hot springs. Some persons who claimed to
be such presented themselves, and the old man acquired it in exchange
for clothes, jewels, and a sum of money. Soon afterward he disappeared
mysteriously. The people thought that he had been spirited away,
when a bad odor from the neighboring wood attracted the attention of
some herdsmen. Tracing this, they found the decaying corpse of the
old Spaniard hanging from the branch of a balete tree. [51] In life
he had inspired fear by his deep, hollow voice, his sunken eyes, and
his mirthless laugh, but now, dead by his own act, he disturbed the
sleep of the women. Some threw the jewels into the river and burned the
clothes, and from the time that the corpse was buried at the foot of
the balete itself, no one willingly ventured near the spot. A belated
herdsman looking for some of his strayed charges told of lights that
he had seen there, and when some venturesome youths went to the place
they heard mournful cries. To win the smiles of his disdainful lady,
a forlorn lover agreed to spend the night there and in proof to wrap
around the trunk a long piece of rattan, but he died of a quick fever
that seized him the very next day. Stories and legends still cluster
about the place.
A few months after the finding of the old Spaniard's body there
appeared a youth, apparently a Spanish mestizo, who said that
he was the son of the deceased. He established himself in the
place and devoted his attention to agriculture, especially the
raising of indigo. Don Saturnino was a silent young man with a
violent disposition, even cruel at times, yet he was energetic and
industrious. He surrounded the grave of his father with a wall,
but visited it only at rare intervals. When he was along in years,
he married a young woman from Manila, and she became the mother of
Don Rafael, the father of Crisostomo. From his youth Don Rafael was a
favorite with the country people. The agricultural methods introduced
and encouraged by his father spread rapidly, new settlers poured in,
the Chinese came, and the settlement became a village with a native
priest. Later the village grew into a town, the priest died, and Fray
Damaso came.
All this time the tomb and the land around it remained
unmolested. Sometimes a crowd of boys armed with clubs and stones would
become bold enough to wander into the place to gather guavas, papayas,
lomboy, and other fruits, but it frequently happened that when their
sport was at its height, or while they gazed in awed silence at the
rotting piece of rope which still swung from the branch, stones would
fall, coming from they knew not where. Then with cries of "The old
man! The old man!" they would throw away fruit and clubs, jump from
the trees, and hurry between the rocks and through the thickets;
nor would they stop running until they were well out of the wood,
some pale and breathless, others weeping, and only a few laughing.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
The Beautiful Lie - How Communities Hide Their Foundations
Communities and organizations showcase their successes while burying the uncomfortable truths about how their prosperity was actually built.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to look past surface prosperity to identify the buried exploitation that often underlies community success stories.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when institutions or communities celebrate their achievements - ask yourself what story might be getting buried, and who might be paying the real cost of that success.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Everything serves as a mark: a tree, that tamarind with its light foliage, that coco palm laden with nuts"
Context: Describing how townspeople identify their homes from the church tower view
This shows how people create meaning and belonging through small, personal landmarks. Each family has their own way of recognizing home, suggesting both community connection and individual identity within the larger social fabric.
In Today's Words:
Everyone knows their own house by the little things - that big oak tree, the fence that needs fixing, the garden their mom planted.
"The Chinese, who exploit the simplicity and vices of the native farmers"
Context: Explaining the economic relationship in the town's agricultural trade
Rizal directly calls out the exploitative economic system where middlemen profit from farmers' desperation and lack of alternatives. This sets up the theme of how colonialism creates systems that benefit outsiders at locals' expense.
In Today's Words:
The middlemen who take advantage of farmers who don't know better or have no other choice.
"The forest remains haunted in the townspeople's minds"
Context: Describing the community's relationship with the mysterious forest and its dark history
The forest represents how unresolved trauma and buried secrets continue to influence a community's psyche. Even though the events happened decades ago, they still shape how people think and behave.
In Today's Words:
That place still gives everyone the creeps because of what happened there years ago.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
The town's prosperity depends on exploiting farmers through Chinese middlemen who profit from local desperation
Development
Builds on earlier class tensions, now showing the economic machinery that maintains inequality
In Your Life:
You might notice how your workplace celebrates teamwork while certain people always get the worst assignments.
Identity
In This Chapter
The Ibarra family identity as respectable landowners masks their origins in mystery and possible violence
Development
Deepens Crisostomo's character by revealing his family's buried history
In Your Life:
You might discover your own family's success stories leave out important details about who paid the price.
Hidden Power
In This Chapter
Real economic control lies with middlemen who remain invisible while farmers and landowners get the credit or blame
Development
Introduced here as a new layer of colonial exploitation
In Your Life:
You might realize the people making decisions about your life often aren't the ones with official titles.
Collective Memory
In This Chapter
The town remembers the forest as haunted but forgets the economic exploitation that continues daily
Development
Introduced here - communities choose what to remember and what to forget
In Your Life:
You might notice how your community talks endlessly about certain problems while completely ignoring others.
Inherited Guilt
In This Chapter
Crisostomo inherits not just wealth but the moral weight of how that wealth was created
Development
Sets up future moral conflicts for the protagonist
In Your Life:
You might struggle with benefits you've received that came at someone else's expense.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What two different pictures of San Diego does Rizal show us - the view from the church tower versus the reality on the ground?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do you think the townspeople choose to focus on San Diego's beautiful appearance while ignoring the exploitation happening in their economy?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this 'Beautiful Lie' pattern in your own community - places that look successful on the surface but have buried uncomfortable truths?
application • medium - 4
When you encounter a community or organization that seems too good to be true, what questions would you ask to understand the full picture?
application • deep - 5
What does the haunted forest tell us about how communities deal with their dark histories, and why some stories get buried while others get celebrated?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Community's Hidden Story
Choose a place you know well - your workplace, neighborhood, school, or hometown. First, write down the 'beautiful story' this place tells about itself (mission statements, welcome signs, promotional materials). Then dig deeper: what uncomfortable questions never get asked? Who really benefits from how things are set up? What would someone from 50 years ago recognize that's been forgotten or rewritten?
Consider:
- •Look for patterns in who gets hired, promoted, or heard in decision-making
- •Notice which problems persist despite repeated promises to fix them
- •Pay attention to whose stories get celebrated and whose get ignored
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you discovered that a place or organization you trusted wasn't quite what it seemed on the surface. How did this change how you navigate similar situations now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 11: The Real Powers Behind the Throne
Now that we understand the town's dark foundations, we'll meet the people who currently hold power in San Diego. The rulers who control this community will reveal how colonial authority actually operates at the local level.




