Summary
Montaigne reflects on his kidney stones, inherited from his father who never showed symptoms until age 67. This leads him to marvel at heredity's mysterious workings—how can a drop of seed carry not just physical traits but thoughts and inclinations across generations? He uses this wonder to launch a devastating critique of physicians, whom he sees as profiteers exploiting human fear of death. Drawing on family history (his ancestors lived long lives without doctors), Montaigne argues that medicine often does more harm than good. He mocks physicians' contradictory advice, their tendency to blame patients for failures, and their use of incomprehensible jargon to mask ignorance. Yet he's not entirely dogmatic—he acknowledges medicine might help in some cases and admits he might turn to doctors if desperate enough. The essay reveals Montaigne's core philosophy: embrace life's uncertainties rather than surrendering to false authorities. He advocates for natural healing, personal observation over expert opinion, and maintaining authentic dignity even in pain. His skepticism extends beyond medicine to any system that promises certainty in an uncertain world. Through personal anecdotes and classical references, he demonstrates how to think critically about those who claim to have answers to life's fundamental mysteries.
Coming Up in Chapter 94
Having examined the false promises of medicine, Montaigne turns to examine another realm where we often compromise our integrity—the tension between profit and honesty in our daily dealings with others.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
F THE RESEMBLANCE OF CHILDREN TO THEIR FATHERS This faggoting up of so many divers pieces is so done that I never set pen to paper but when I have too much idle time, and never anywhere but at home; so that it is compiled after divers interruptions and intervals, occasions keeping me sometimes many months elsewhere. As to the rest, I never correct my first by any second conceptions; I, peradventure, may alter a word or so, but ‘tis only to vary the phrase, and not to destroy my former meaning. I have a mind to represent the progress of my humours, and that every one may see each piece as it came from the forge. I could wish I had begun sooner, and had taken more notice of the course of my mutations. A servant of mine whom I employed to transcribe for me, thought he had got a prize by stealing several pieces from me, wherewith he was best pleased; but it is my comfort that he will be no greater a gainer than I shall be a loser by the theft. I am grown older by seven or eight years since I began; nor has it been without same new acquisition: I have, in that time, by the liberality of years, been acquainted with the stone: their commerce and long converse do not well pass away without some such inconvenience. I could have been glad that of other infirmities age has to present long-lived men withal, it had chosen some one that would have been more welcome to me, for it could not possibly have laid upon me a disease for which, even from my infancy, I have had so great a horror; and it is, in truth, of all the accidents of old age, that of which I have ever been most afraid. I have often thought with myself that I went on too far, and that in so long a voyage I should at last run myself into some disadvantage; I perceived, and have often enough declared, that it was time to depart, and that life should be cut off in the sound and living part, according to the surgeon’s rule in amputations; and that nature made him pay very strict usury who did not in due time pay the principal. And yet I was so far from being ready, that in the eighteen months’ time or thereabout that I have been in this uneasy condition, I have so inured myself to it as to be content to live on in it; and have found wherein to comfort myself, and to hope: so much are men enslaved to their miserable being, that there is no condition so wretched they will not accept, provided they may live! Hear Maecenas: “Debilem facito manu, Debilem pede, coxa, Lubricos quate dentes; Vita dum superest, bene est.” [“Cripple my hand, foot, hip; shake out my loose teeth: while there’s life, ‘tis well.”--Apud Seneca, Ep., 101.] And Tamerlane, with a...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Expert Intimidation
People exploiting others' fears by claiming exclusive expertise while using complexity to mask their own ignorance.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between genuine knowledge and intimidation tactics disguised as expertise.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone uses jargon you can't understand to explain something that affects you—ask them to explain it in plain language and watch their reaction.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Heredity
The passing down of traits from parents to children through biological inheritance. Montaigne marvels at how his father's kidney stones appeared in him at the exact same age, wondering how such specific conditions can be transmitted through generations.
Modern Usage:
We see this in discussions about genetic predispositions to diseases, addiction, or even personality traits that 'run in families.'
Physician's Authority
The unquestioned power doctors held in Montaigne's time to diagnose and prescribe treatments. Montaigne challenges this authority, arguing that doctors often profit from fear while providing contradictory or harmful advice.
Modern Usage:
This appears today when we question medical second opinions, research our own symptoms online, or debate whether doctors overprescribe medications.
Natural Philosophy
The belief that nature has its own wisdom for healing and that human intervention often disrupts natural processes. Montaigne advocates trusting the body's own healing abilities over artificial medical treatments.
Modern Usage:
We see this in alternative medicine movements, people choosing natural remedies over pharmaceuticals, or trusting immune systems over antibiotics.
Skepticism
The practice of questioning accepted truths and authorities rather than blindly accepting expert opinions. Montaigne applies this to medicine, challenging doctors' claims to certainty about uncertain conditions.
Modern Usage:
This shows up when people question government health advice, research their own treatments, or seek multiple opinions before major medical decisions.
Stoic Acceptance
The philosophical approach of accepting pain and mortality as natural parts of life rather than fighting them desperately. Montaigne suggests enduring his kidney stones with dignity rather than seeking desperate cures.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who choose quality of life over aggressive treatments, or who accept aging gracefully instead of fighting it with extreme measures.
Medical Jargon
The complex, often incomprehensible language doctors use that can mask ignorance or uncertainty behind impressive-sounding terms. Montaigne argues this confuses patients and hides medical failures.
Modern Usage:
This appears when doctors use technical terms patients don't understand, or when medical bills contain mysterious codes and procedures.
Characters in This Chapter
Montaigne
Reflective narrator
The author examining his own experience with inherited kidney stones and his growing distrust of medical authority. He uses personal pain as a lens to question broader systems of supposed expertise.
Modern Equivalent:
The patient who researches their own condition and questions their doctor's recommendations
Montaigne's Father
Inherited influence
Though deceased, his father's genetic legacy shapes Montaigne's current suffering. The father lived to 74 without kidney stones until age 67, providing a template for Montaigne's expectations about his own condition.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent whose health issues predict what their adult children might face
The Physicians
Antagonistic authorities
Medical doctors whom Montaigne portrays as profit-driven charlatans who exploit human fear of death. They provide contradictory advice, blame patients for treatment failures, and hide behind complex terminology.
Modern Equivalent:
The specialist who orders expensive tests but can't give straight answers
The Servant
Minor betrayer
A household employee who stole some of Montaigne's writings, thinking they were valuable. Montaigne uses this anecdote to show his casual attitude toward his own work and possessions.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who takes credit for your ideas or steals office supplies
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am grown older by seven or eight years since I began; nor has it been without some new acquisition: I have, in that time, by the liberality of years, been acquainted with the stone."
Context: He's reflecting on how age has brought him kidney stones as an unwelcome gift.
Montaigne uses ironic language, calling his painful condition an 'acquisition' and stones a gift from the 'liberality of years.' This shows his attempt to maintain dignity and even humor in the face of physical suffering.
In Today's Words:
I've gotten older while writing this, and age has given me the lovely present of kidney stones.
"How can a drop of seed, from which we are produced, carry in it the impressions not only of the bodily form, but of the thoughts and inclinations of our fathers?"
Context: He's marveling at how heredity works, wondering how traits pass from parent to child.
This quote reveals Montaigne's scientific curiosity about inheritance, centuries before genetics was understood. He's amazed that physical traits, diseases, and even personality can be transmitted through reproduction.
In Today's Words:
How does something as tiny as sperm carry not just how we look, but how we think and what we're drawn to?
"The art of medicine is not so fixed that we need be without authority for whatever we do."
Context: He's criticizing how doctors claim certainty in an uncertain field.
Montaigne exposes the contradiction in medical practice: doctors act with absolute authority while practicing an art full of uncertainty. This challenges readers to question any expert who claims perfect knowledge in imperfect circumstances.
In Today's Words:
Medicine isn't an exact science, so doctors can basically justify whatever they want to do.
Thematic Threads
Authority
In This Chapter
Montaigne questions medical authority by observing that his family lived long lives without doctors, challenging the assumption that experts always know best
Development
Building on earlier skepticism of social conventions, now extending to professional authority
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when a professional uses jargon you don't understand instead of explaining their reasoning clearly
Class
In This Chapter
Physicians use Latin terminology and complex theories to maintain social distance from patients, creating artificial barriers to understanding
Development
Continues theme of how social hierarchies are maintained through exclusion and mystery
In Your Life:
You see this when service providers make you feel ignorant for asking basic questions about their work
Identity
In This Chapter
Montaigne defines himself against medical orthodoxy, choosing natural observation over expert opinion as core to his character
Development
Deepens his commitment to authentic self-knowledge over external validation
In Your Life:
You face this choice when deciding whether to trust your instincts or defer to someone else's supposed expertise
Fear
In This Chapter
Fear of death makes people vulnerable to medical charlatans who promise control over the uncontrollable
Development
Introduced here as a driving force behind false expertise
In Your Life:
You might notice how your deepest fears make you susceptible to anyone claiming they can protect you from them
Heredity
In This Chapter
Montaigne marvels at inheriting his father's kidney stones, seeing mystery in how traits pass between generations
Development
Introduced here as wonder at life's fundamental mysteries
In Your Life:
You might recognize patterns in your family—both gifts and challenges—that seem to skip generations or appear unexpectedly
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Montaigne distrust doctors, and what evidence does he use from his own family history?
analysis • surface - 2
What pattern does Montaigne identify in how physicians respond when their treatments don't work?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this same pattern today - experts using complex language and blaming clients when results don't come?
application • medium - 4
How would you apply Montaigne's three questions when dealing with someone claiming special expertise in your life?
application • deep - 5
What does Montaigne's approach reveal about the difference between healthy skepticism and cynical rejection of all help?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Expert
Think of someone who recently tried to sell you something or convince you of their expertise - a mechanic, salesperson, consultant, or advisor. Write down exactly what they said and how they said it. Then analyze their language and behavior using Montaigne's framework for spotting false expertise.
Consider:
- •Did they explain things in plain language you could understand and repeat to someone else?
- •When you asked questions, did they welcome them or deflect with more jargon?
- •If previous clients had problems, how did they explain those failures?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you trusted your own judgment over expert advice. What happened, and what did you learn about when to listen to experts versus when to trust yourself?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 94: The Price of Compromise
Having examined the false promises of medicine, Montaigne turns to examine another realm where we often compromise our integrity—the tension between profit and honesty in our daily dealings with others.
