Summary
This chapter reveals the complex power dynamics of Middlemarch through the lens of a chaplaincy appointment debate. Mr. Bulstrode, the town's banker, wields influence not just through money but through strategic charity—helping people while keeping them dependent. At a dinner party, Lydgate naively argues that appointments should be based on merit rather than popularity, earning him the label of 'prig' from the established social order. Meanwhile, Lydgate becomes enchanted with Rosamond Vincy during an evening of music and conversation. She represents everything he thinks he wants in a woman—refined, accomplished, beautiful—yet Eliot hints at the danger of such surface attractions. The chapter masterfully contrasts Lydgate's scientific precision with his romantic blindness. While he can analyze fever with disciplined imagination, he completely misreads Rosamond's calculated performance of femininity. She, meanwhile, sees him not as an individual but as a ticket to higher social status. The evening ends with both characters living in separate fantasy worlds about each other. Eliot also introduces Mr. Farebrother, the current chaplain who seems genuinely kind but struggles financially, highlighting how good people often lose to those with better political connections. The chapter demonstrates how social power really works—through networks of obligation, careful image management, and the human tendency to choose the agreeable over the competent.
Coming Up in Chapter 17
As Lydgate settles into Middlemarch society, his professional ideals will clash more directly with local politics. Meanwhile, the chaplaincy debate intensifies, forcing him to choose sides in a conflict that will define his place in the community.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
A“ll that in woman is adored In thy fair self I find— For the whole sex can but afford The handsome and the kind.” —SIR CHARLES SEDLEY. The question whether Mr. Tyke should be appointed as salaried chaplain to the hospital was an exciting topic to the Middlemarchers; and Lydgate heard it discussed in a way that threw much light on the power exercised in the town by Mr. Bulstrode. The banker was evidently a ruler, but there was an opposition party, and even among his supporters there were some who allowed it to be seen that their support was a compromise, and who frankly stated their impression that the general scheme of things, and especially the casualties of trade, required you to hold a candle to the devil. Mr. Bulstrode’s power was not due simply to his being a country banker, who knew the financial secrets of most traders in the town and could touch the springs of their credit; it was fortified by a beneficence that was at once ready and severe—ready to confer obligations, and severe in watching the result. He had gathered, as an industrious man always at his post, a chief share in administering the town charities, and his private charities were both minute and abundant. He would take a great deal of pains about apprenticing Tegg the shoemaker’s son, and he would watch over Tegg’s church-going; he would defend Mrs. Strype the washerwoman against Stubbs’s unjust exaction on the score of her drying-ground, and he would himself scrutinize a calumny against Mrs. Strype. His private minor loans were numerous, but he would inquire strictly into the circumstances both before and after. In this way a man gathers a domain in his neighbors’ hope and fear as well as gratitude; and power, when once it has got into that subtle region, propagates itself, spreading out of all proportion to its external means. It was a principle with Mr. Bulstrode to gain as much power as possible, that he might use it for the glory of God. He went through a great deal of spiritual conflict and inward argument in order to adjust his motives, and make clear to himself what God’s glory required. But, as we have seen, his motives were not always rightly appreciated. There were many crass minds in Middlemarch whose reflective scales could only weigh things in the lump; and they had a strong suspicion that since Mr. Bulstrode could not enjoy life in their fashion, eating and drinking so little as he did, and worreting himself about everything, he must have a sort of vampire’s feast in the sense of mastery. The subject of the chaplaincy came up at Mr. Vincy’s table when Lydgate was dining there, and the family connection with Mr. Bulstrode did not, he observed, prevent some freedom of remark even on the part of the host himself, though his reasons against the proposed arrangement turned entirely on his objection to Mr. Tyke’s sermons, which were all doctrine,...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Strategic Charity - How Power Disguises Itself as Kindness
People in power maintain control by helping others just enough to create gratitude and dependence, then leveraging that obligation to suppress opposition.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when decisions are really about maintaining control networks rather than stated objectives.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone in authority frames their agenda as moral duty while quietly punishing those who offer alternatives based on merit or effectiveness.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Beneficence
Strategic charity that creates power and obligation rather than genuine kindness. Bulstrode uses his generous donations to control people and maintain his reputation. It's charity with strings attached.
Modern Usage:
Like a boss who pays for the office holiday party but expects you to work late without complaint, or a wealthy donor whose name goes on the building.
Patronage system
A way of distributing jobs and positions based on personal connections and loyalty rather than qualifications. The chaplaincy debate shows how appointments worked through influence, not merit.
Modern Usage:
Still happens today when jobs go to the boss's nephew or when political appointments reward campaign supporters over qualified candidates.
Accomplished woman
A Victorian ideal of femininity focused on surface skills like music, languages, and drawing rather than intelligence or character. These accomplishments were designed to attract a husband, not develop the mind.
Modern Usage:
Like Instagram influencers who curate perfect images, or the pressure on women to be effortlessly beautiful while managing career and family.
Country banker
In small towns, the banker knew everyone's financial secrets and could make or break local businesses. This gave them enormous social and political power beyond just money.
Modern Usage:
Like how tech companies today know our data and can influence our choices, or how small-town business owners often run the city council.
Prig
Someone who acts morally superior or shows off their principles in an annoying way. Lydgate gets called this for suggesting merit should matter more than popularity.
Modern Usage:
That coworker who always points out when others bend the rules, or someone who lectures about organic food while others struggle to afford groceries.
Drawing room performance
The social ritual where young women displayed their accomplishments (piano, singing) to attract suitors. It was carefully choreographed to seem natural while being completely calculated.
Modern Usage:
Like dating app profiles or social media posts designed to look spontaneous but actually crafted to present the perfect image.
Characters in This Chapter
Mr. Bulstrode
Power broker
The town's banker who controls people through strategic charity and financial leverage. He helps people but always in ways that increase his own influence and moral authority.
Modern Equivalent:
The wealthy donor who expects their name on everything
Lydgate
Naive idealist
Believes appointments should be based on merit, not politics, earning him the label of 'prig.' He's scientifically brilliant but completely blind to social manipulation and romantic calculation.
Modern Equivalent:
The smart new employee who doesn't understand office politics
Rosamond Vincy
Strategic romantic
Performs the perfect accomplished woman act to attract Lydgate, seeing him as her ticket to higher social status. She's calculating while appearing innocent and charming.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who dates for the lifestyle upgrade
Mr. Farebrother
Deserving underdog
The current chaplain who actually seems good at his job and genuinely kind, but lacks the political connections to secure the paid position he desperately needs.
Modern Equivalent:
The qualified candidate who loses out to networking
Mr. Tyke
Political appointee
Bulstrode's preferred candidate for chaplain, chosen not for his abilities but for his loyalty and alignment with Bulstrode's religious views.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss's favorite who gets promoted despite better candidates
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He would take a great deal of pains about apprenticing Tegg the shoemaker's son, and he would watch over Tegg's church-going"
Context: Describing how Bulstrode's charity always comes with surveillance and control
This reveals how Bulstrode's generosity is really about power. He doesn't just help people - he monitors them afterward to ensure they meet his moral standards. His charity creates dependence, not freedom.
In Today's Words:
He'd help you get your kid into a good program, then keep tabs on whether you're living up to his expectations.
"The general scheme of things, and especially the casualties of trade, required you to hold a candle to the devil"
Context: Explaining why even Bulstrode's opponents sometimes support him
This shows the pragmatic reality of small-town politics. People may dislike Bulstrode but they need his financial support to survive. Sometimes you have to work with people you don't respect.
In Today's Words:
Business is business - sometimes you have to play nice with people you can't stand because you need what they can do for you.
"What is the use of being exquisite if you are not seen by the best judges?"
Context: Describing Rosamond's calculations about attracting the right kind of man
This exposes how Rosamond views her own beauty and accomplishments as investments. She's not interested in self-improvement for its own sake - she wants the right audience to appreciate her assets.
In Today's Words:
Why put in all this effort to look perfect if the right people aren't going to notice?
"He was not going to have his vanities provoked by contact with the showy worldly successes of the capital, but would find a good provincial life quite worth living"
Context: Lydgate's thoughts about settling in Middlemarch rather than pursuing London ambitions
This shows Lydgate's dangerous overconfidence. He thinks he can avoid temptation and stay focused on his noble goals, but he's already falling for exactly the kind of surface attraction he claims to despise.
In Today's Words:
He figured small-town life would keep him grounded and away from shallow distractions - famous last words.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Bulstrode uses strategic charity and moral positioning to control town decisions while appearing virtuous
Development
Expanding from earlier hints about his influence to show the specific mechanisms of control
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone helps you but expects unspoken loyalty or compliance in return
Blindness
In This Chapter
Lydgate can analyze disease precisely but completely misreads Rosamond's calculated performance
Development
Building on his earlier confidence, now showing how expertise in one area creates dangerous overconfidence in others
In Your Life:
You might excel at work but be terrible at reading romantic partners or family dynamics
Performance
In This Chapter
Rosamond carefully crafts her femininity to attract the right kind of husband, while Lydgate performs intellectual superiority
Development
Introduced here as a key dynamic between characters
In Your Life:
You might find yourself performing a version of yourself that you think others want to see
Merit
In This Chapter
Lydgate argues for merit-based appointments but gets labeled a troublemaker for challenging the social order
Development
Introduced here as conflict between idealism and political reality
In Your Life:
You might discover that doing good work isn't enough if you don't understand workplace politics
Fantasy
In This Chapter
Both Lydgate and Rosamond create elaborate fantasies about each other based on surface attractions
Development
Introduced here as dangerous foundation for their relationship
In Your Life:
You might fall for the idea of someone rather than who they actually are
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How does Bulstrode use charity and favors to maintain control over people in Middlemarch?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Lydgate's argument for merit-based appointments threaten the existing social order?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people using strategic generosity to create obligation in your workplace or community?
application • medium - 4
How would you maintain your independence when someone offers help that might come with strings attached?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between true generosity and calculated kindness?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Obligation Network
Draw a simple map of the favors and help you've received in the past year. For each one, write whether it came with spoken or unspoken expectations. Then identify which relationships feel genuinely supportive versus those that create pressure or guilt. This exercise helps you recognize patterns of strategic charity in your own life.
Consider:
- •Some obligations are healthy and mutual - focus on the unbalanced ones
- •Consider both financial help and emotional support or time given
- •Notice whether the helper reminds you of their generosity when they want something
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's help came with unexpected strings attached. How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 17: The Vicar's Honest Compromises
The coming pages reveal good people navigate imperfect circumstances without losing their integrity, and teach us understanding workplace politics matters even when you want to stay above it. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.